CAT 2. Subjects of international law, territory and immunities

 

  • – Presentation
  • Objectives and Competencies
  • Test
  • Practical case
  • Formal issues
  • Marking criteria

 

Presentation

 

CAT 2 has two parts. Part I consists of a test that has 15 questions. You have to answer if the statements are true or false (T or F) and provide a brief reasoned justification. Part II consists of two practical cases. In this section, you must take into account different aspects that have been covered in teaching modules 4, 5 and 6.

 

Objectives and competencies

  • Identify the subjects of international law.

 

  • Analyse the nature and scope of their legal personality.

 

  • Determine the competences of States, which are known as the main subjects of international law.

 

Test (True/False and maximum five lines of reasoning)

  1. ( ) Article 1 of the Montevideo Convention highlights that a state will be considered as such only if the following requirements are fully complied: permanent population; a defined territory; government and capacity to enter into relation with other states.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) The mandate system established after the First World War evolved to the Trusteeship system included in the United Nations Charter.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) The Holy See is nowadays an undeniable subject of international law.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) The international legal personality of individuals is exclusively linked with the fact that they can be responsible for committing international crimes.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) State X, a new State that was before part of the territory of State Y, has to comply with all the obligations subscribed by the latter a State since it was bound by the content of them in the past.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) In the Reparation for Injuries Suffered in the Service of the United Nations case, the International Court of Justice declared that the UN had international legal personality derived from the functions exercised at the international level.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) Ports are subjected to the sovereignty of coastal States although they must allow the “innocent passage” to merchant ships.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) The right to self-determination can only be applied, in international law, to cases that refer to a decolonization process.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) Nowadays, territory cannot be gained by a State through the use of force unless this is a consequence of the exercise of the right of self-defence.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) After World War II, it has been clearly recognized that States have full sovereignty over their airspace located above their land and their exclusive economic zone.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) Imagine that there is a French merchant located in an Italian port. Immediately after their arrival, the captain -a Spanish national- realizes that an illicit has been committed by the crew. The captain concludes that the only competent court to judge the events that have occurred on board are the Italian ones.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

 

  1. ( ) Low-tide elevations located in the territorial sea of an island will create territorial sea of their own.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) A State, in its contiguous zone, is automatically able to exercise its rights in the mentioned area.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) The 1982 Convention highlights that the high seas are open to all States. Thus, if a crime is committed in a vessel located in the high seas, all States will be able to judge according to the general rule applicable to the mentioned area.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. ( ) The diplomatic and consular bag are always inviolable.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Practical case 1

In the South China sea, China has been filling sand over coral reefs during these last years. This has resulted in the creation of new islands; many of those are known as the Spratly islands and they are currently being used as naval military bases. The location of those is very relevant because there are many rich natural resources in the area and, at the same time, massive ships are constantly passing.

Bearing the above in mind, it must be highlighted that China is claiming sovereignty over the entire South China sea, including all the Spratly islands. Likewise, other countries consider that they have certain rights over the area, such as: Taiwan, Vietnam, Philippines and Malaysia.

Taking into account the above, please answer to the following questions. Remember to duly justify all your answers.

I hereby provide you a link where you can check how this project started:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZgvqE89KvQ

 

  • Being aware that the Spratly islands are a disputed archipelago composed of islands, islets, cays and more than one hundred reefs, it must be mentioned that they were discovered by the British captain, Richard Spratly, in the nineteenth century. According to which title do you think that the United Kingdom could have been able to claim, in the past, the sovereignty of those islands in which no State exercised any kind of control before the arrival of the British captain? Are there any particular requirements that should have been fulfilled in order to validly bring out the title which you deem more appropriate to strongly support that the British government validly acquired the Spratly islands?

 

When answering this question take into account what was said, inter alia, by the ICJ in the Occidental Sahara case of 1975 or in the Land, Island and Maritime Frontier Dispute (El Salvador/Honduras) in 1992.

 

  • Imagine that a few years after the discovery of the Spratly islands, the United Kingdom engaged in a war with the United States of America. Immediately after, a peace treaty was signed stating that the sovereignty of a few cays and islets of the cited area were transferred to the latter. According to which title do you think that the American administration could have been able to claim its own sovereignty? Do you think that third countries could bring, at that time, strong legal arguments against the way in which certain islets and cays were finally acquired by the United States of America?

 

  • Imagine that a few years after the peace treaty was signed, the American administration decides to leave the islands due to a lack of interest in the area. In the light of that, China acquires all the cays, islets and reefs that conform the Spratly island until nowadays. What can China argue in order to duly demonstrate that it has rights over those? In other words, which would be a valid title when claiming the acquisition of the area? Which requirements have to be duly fulfilled by China to justify that its acquisition has taken place validly according to the title that you deem most appropriate?

 

  • Taking into account what was said in question 3, imagine that Malaysia is suddenly willing to claim rights over the mentioned area. At this stage, China argues that Malaysia accepted, during long decades, the control deployed by the Chinese government over the islands and that no reaction nor opposition has been expressed by Malaysia. According to what was decided in the Temple of Preah Vihear case of 1962, could this argument succeed?

 

 

Practical case 2

Taking into account the facts that have been previously mentioned, you must answer the following questions (when doing this the content of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea might be useful):

 

  • According to China, Spratly islands are located in its exclusive economic zone. From its own point of view, this enables China to build man-made islands. Is this a valid argument taking into account what has been established in the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea?

 

  • The North American Administration has stepped into the conflict arguing that all countries should be able to exercise the freedom of navigation in the exclusive economic zone of China where Spratly islands are allegedly located. Is this a valid argument? Imagine that a vessel from a third country is willing to carry out marine scientific research in that specific area; would that be possible?

 

  • The Philippines is claiming that an area of the South China sea is located in its exclusive economic zone. Huge hostilities have appeared between The Philippines and China. How can this conflict be solved according to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea?

 

  • Fiery Cross island is located in South China sea; in 2014, it was only an underwater reef and now it is a man-made island. What has the ICJ declared regarding low tide elevations in the sentence issued the 19th of November of 2012 regarding the conflict that existed between Nicaragua and Colombia? If the case would have been judged in 2014, do you think that China would have been able to create those artificial islands?

Formal Issues

The estimated time that the student has to devote to this CAT is 25 hours. It includes reading the required materials, consulting international treaties and case law, solving the test questions and practical cases. It is an estimate since the actual hours of dedication may vary depending on the previous knowledge, skills and circumstances of each student.

Maximum length, without counting the test questions, is four pages keeping this  format (type of letters, size, paragraph, etc.)

The delivered document only has to contain the statements and the answers. Eliminate the rest of the sections (Presentation, Objectives, Marking criteria, etc.)

In addition, you must include your name and surnames in the upper part of the resolution document to facilitate the identification of the exercise in case it is printed.

 

Marking criteria

Following Appendix A of the ‘Student Handbook’ we will evaluate

  • Task fulfilment: fulfilment of the requirements of the task.
  • Knowledge and understanding: student demonstration of understanding of topics
  • Analysis and development of an argument: Student capacity for analysis, coherence of ideas and critical judgement.
  • Structure and presentation: order and structure in the argumentation Correct writing. Clear style.
  • Use of sources and data collection: range of sources. referencing consistent and appropriate (see Appendix B of the ‘Student Handbook’)
Get 20% Discount on This Paper
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Try it now!

Get 20% Discount on This Paper

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Ace Writing Center has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.

Essays

Essay Writing Services

At Ace Writing Center, Nowadays, students normally have extremely busy schedules. You will note that some of them have to take on some evening or weekend jobs in order to get some income that can help them to sustain in college or in the university. This can deny them a chance to write all the essays given. Others usually get bombarded with a lot of work by their lecturers. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. However, some of them usually try to work on all these essays but end up delivering their work late. This can prevent them from graduating since most lecturers are strict on deadlines. If you want to write a business essay, the wise way is to hire an outstanding essay writing service like us, so that you can get the best results. If you are keen, you will note that many companies usually overcharge their customers. Some of them are there only to make money. And in reality, they really don’t care to build a long term commitment with students. You should not choose such companies. You should take your time and choose a reliable company to work with. Ace Writing Center is the ultimate solution for you. We have been offering our writing service for more than 7 years. This is a clear indication that you will get quality essay writing service. We have a wide range of writers who can work on any business essay that you might have. We believe in doing extensive research so that we can provide quality work to all our clients. .

Admissions

Admission and Business Papers

Have you ever had to write an admission essay for college? The majority of students face the same issues when applying to a university or college and many in such situations decide they need professional help to cope with this matter. They get in a situation when the deadline keeps coming closer but lack motivation to start because they are just not sure if their writing skills are strong enough. We have a solution for you! Ace Writing Center is the best admission essay writing service with a large professional team and years of experience in providing high-quality papers to students of all levels and faculties. The mission of our team is to help students make their dreams of entering a good college come true and that’s what we offer!.

Editing

Editing and Proofreading

Sometimes all the words for your paper just flow out of your mind and into your fingers. You type quickly at your keyboard and there they are, your beautiful words right there on the screen. But you have no idea how to polish it up. You may be wishing there was a paper writing service that offered this type of writing service. Look no more! Here at Ace Writing Center, we offer you an editing and proofreading option that you can't find anywhere else..

Coursework

College Essay Writing

In case you are familiar Ace Writing Center, you know the way to distinguish a better company from a cheap one exactly. First of all, poor service website does not have a sufficient support. We think support team is an essential part of success; it has to answer all clients’ questions and be a connecting link between clients and their writers. On our web-service you will get answers about anything you need and your writer will receive all your instructions, assignments and requirements exactly and swiftly. A writing service that we run has got a flexible pricing system that will save you from senseless wastes and many bonus systems that let you sparing money for something important for you.