Engl 1301, Essay 1, Summary/Response Essay
Length: pages or 650 to 850 words
Choose one of the assigned reading. Choose a reading that has intrigued you or for which you had a
strong response either agreeing or disagreeing with the author. The purpose of the assignment is to
help you further investigate an idea for a research project.
A summary/ response first summarizes what you’ve read and then gives your reaction to the text.
Keep in mind the directions from Everyone’s an Author (EA) “A summary uses just enough
information to record the main points you wish to summarize” and “captures the main ideas in your
own words” (Lunsford 191).
The main ideas in a longer text are the ones to which you plan to respond. Keep in mind also that in a
summary you should identify the key points in the text, find the essential evidence supporting those
points, and explain the contents concisely and fairly. Leave out your opinions when summarizing
concisely and fairly and use neutral verbs, such as states, asserts, or concludes. You should include
the name of the work and the author, but you should state the summary of the work in your own
words. The summary should probably be no more than 100 to 200 words.
Your response, then should be at least three-fourths of the essay. Your response should be focused
and have a thesis, topic sentences, and a central argument.
Your reaction may include one or more of the following:
A response to what a text says, in which case you might consider these questions:
What does the writer claim?
What reasons or evidence does he or she provide to support the claim?
What parts of the text do you agree with? Is there anything you disagree with—and if so, why?
Does the writer represent any views other than his or her own? If not, what other perspectives should
be considered?
Are there any aspects of the topic that the writer overlooks or ignores?
A response on the way a text is written, in which case you might consider these questions:
What is the writer’s message? Is there an explicit statement of that message?
How well has the writer communicated the message?
How does the writer support what he or she says: by citing facts or statistics? By quoting experts? By
noting person experiences? Are you persuaded?
Are there any words, phrases, or sentences that you find notable, and that contribute to the text’s
overall effect?
How does the text’s design affect your response to it?
A reflection on your own reaction to the text, in which case you might consider these questions:
How did the text affect you personally?
Is there anything in the text that really got your attention? If so, what?
Do any parts of the text provoke an emotional reaction—make you laugh or cry, make you uneasy?
What prompted that response?
Does the text bring to mind any memories or past experiences? Can you see anything related to you
and your life in the text?
Does the text remind you of any other texts?
Does the text support (or challenge) any of your beliefs? How?
Has the reading of this text given you any new ideas or insights?
You should have a works cited page for the article to which you are responding.
Select ONE of the following articles for your reader response paper:
How Nutritional Food Policy Could Save Millions (only 6 pages–so maybe this would a good starter
article?)
OR
How Junk Food Can End Obesity (Maybe give an option–this one is longer, but looks interesting)
OR
Why MacDonald’s Fries Taste so Good
You do not need to consult other sources, and please do not use any additional sources for this
assignment.
To assist you in writing Essay 1 review the following pages in Everyone’s an Author. :
pages 520 to 526 “Quoting, Paraphrasing, Summarizing”
pages 527 to 534 “Giving Credit, Avoiding Plagiarism
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
How Junk Food Can End Obesity
DAVID H. FREEDMAN
DAVID H. FREEDMAN is a journalist specializing in business and technology and is the
author of Wrong: Why Experts Keep Failing Us—And How to Know When Not to Trust Them
(2010). His work has appeared in Forbes, the New York Times, and Wired, among other
publications. This July 2013 essay is from the Atlantic. You can follow him on Twitter
@dhfreedman.
L
ATE LAST YEAR, in a small health-food eatery called Cafe Sprouts in Oberlin, Ohio,
I had what may well have been the most wholesome beverage of my life. The
friendly server patiently guided me to an apple-blueberry-kale-carrot smoothiejuice combination, which she spent the next several minutes preparing, mostly by
shepherding farm-fresh produce into machinery. The result was tasty, but at 300 calories
(by my rough calculation) in a 16-ounce cup, it was more than my diet could regularly
absorb without consequences, nor was I about to make a habit of $9 shakes, healthy or
not.
Inspired by the experience nonetheless, I tried again two months later at L.A.’s Real
Food Daily, a popular vegan restaurant near Hollywood. I was initially wary of a lowcalorie juice made almost entirely from green vegetables, but the server assured me it was
a popular treat. I like to brag that I can eat anything, and I scarf down all sorts of raw
vegetables like candy, but I could stomach only about a third of this oddly foamy, bitter
concoction. It smelled like lawn clippings and tasted like liquid celery. It goes for $7.95,
and I waited 10 minutes for it.
I finally hit the sweet spot just a few weeks later, in Chicago, with a delicious
blueberry-pomegranate smoothie that rang in at a relatively modest 220 calories. It cost
$3 and took only seconds to make. Best of all, I’ll be able to get this concoction just about
anywhere. Thanks, McDonald’s!
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
1/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
5
If only the McDonald’s smoothie weren’t, unlike the first two, so fattening and
unhealthy. Or at least that’s what the most-prominent voices in our food culture today
would have you believe.
An enormous amount of media space has been dedicated to promoting the notion that
all processed food, and only processed food, is making us sickly and overweight. In this
narrative, the food-industrial complex—particularly the fast-food industry—has turned
all the powers of food-processing science loose on engineering its offerings to addict us to
fat, sugar, and salt, causing or at least heavily contributing to the obesity crisis. The wares
of these pimps and pushers, we are told, are to be universally shunned.
Consider The New York Times. Earlier this year, The Times Magazine gave its cover to a
long piece based on Michael Moss’s about-to-be-best-selling book, Salt Sugar Fat: How the
Food Giants Hooked Us. Hitting bookshelves at about the same time was the former Times
reporter Melanie Warner’s Pandora’s Lunchbox: How Processed Food Took Over the
American Meal, which addresses more or less the same theme. Two years ago The Times
Magazine featured the journalist Gary Taubes’s “Is Sugar Toxic?,” a cover story on the evils
of refined sugar and high-fructose corn syrup. And most significant of all has been the
considerable space the magazine has devoted over the years to Michael Pollan, a
journalism professor at the University of California at Berkeley, and his broad indictment
of food processing as a source of society’s health problems.
How much—and how many calories—will a smoothie cost you?
“The food they’re cooking is making people sick,” Pollan has said of big food companies.
“It is one of the reasons that we have the obesity and diabetes epidemics that we do. . . . If
you’re going to let industries decide how much salt, sugar and fat is in your food, they’re
going to put [in] as much as they possibly can. . . . They will push those buttons until we
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
2/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
10
scream or die.” The solution, in his view, is to replace Big Food’s engineered, edible evil—
through public education and regulation—with fresh, unprocessed, local, seasonal, real
food.
Pollan’s worldview saturates the public conversation on healthy eating. You hear much
the same from many scientists, physicians, food activists, nutritionists, celebrity chefs,
and pundits. Foodlike substances, the derisive term Pollan uses to describe processed
foods, is now a solid part of the elite vernacular. Thousands of restaurants and grocery
stores, most notably the Whole Foods chain, have thrived by answering the call to reject
industrialized foods in favor of a return to natural, simple, nonindustrialized—let’s call
them “wholesome”—foods. The two newest restaurants in my smallish Massachusetts
town both prominently tout wholesome ingredients; one of them is called the
Farmhouse, and it’s usually packed.
A new generation of business, social, and policy entrepreneurs is rising to further cater
to these tastes, and to challenge Big Food. Silicon Valley, where tomorrow’s
entrepreneurial and social trends are forged, has spawned a small ecosystem of
wholesome-friendly venture-capital firms (Physic Ventures, for example), business
accelerators (Local Food Lab), and Web sites (Edible Startups) to fund, nurture, and keep
tabs on young companies such as blissmo (a wholesome-food-of-the-month club), Mile
High Organics (online wholesome-food shopping), and Wholeshare (group wholesomefood purchasing), all designed to help reacquaint Americans with the simpler eating
habits of yesteryear.
In virtually every realm of human existence, we turn to technology to help us solve our
problems. But even in Silicon Valley, when it comes to food and obesity, technology—or at
least food-processing technology—is widely treated as if it is the problem. The solution,
from this viewpoint, necessarily involves turning our back on it.
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
3/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
The produce section at a Whole Foods Market.
If the most-influential voices in our food culture today get their way, we will achieve a
genuine food revolution. Too bad it would be one tailored to the dubious health fantasies
of a small, elite minority. And too bad it would largely exclude the obese masses, who
would continue to sicken and die early. Despite the best efforts of a small army of
wholesome-food heroes, there is no reasonable scenario under which these foods could
become cheap and plentiful enough to serve as the core diet for most of the obese
population—even in the unlikely case that your typical junk-food eater would be willing
and able to break lifelong habits to embrace kale and yellow beets. And many of the
dishes glorified by the wholesome-food movement are, in any case, as caloric and
obesogenic as anything served in a Burger King.
Through its growing sway over health-conscious consumers and policy makers, the
wholesome-food movement is impeding the progress of the one segment of the food
world that is actually positioned to take effective, near-term steps to reverse the obesity
trend: the processed-food industry. Popular food producers, fast-food chains among them,
are already applying various tricks and technologies to create less caloric and more
satiating versions of their junky fare that nonetheless retain much of the appeal of the
originals, and could be induced to go much further. In fact, these roundly demonized
companies could do far more for the public’s health in five years than the wholesomefood movement is likely to accomplish in the next 50. But will the wholesome-food
advocates let them? . . .
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
4/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
Let Them Eat Kale
15
I’m a fan of many of Mark Bittman’s recipes. I shop at Whole Foods all the time. And I eat
like many wholesome foodies, except I try to stay away from those many wholesome
ingredients and dishes that are high in fat and problem carbs. What’s left are vegetables,
fruits, legumes, whole grains, poultry, and fish (none of them fried, thank you), which are
often emphasized by many wholesome-food fans. In general, I find that the more-natural
versions of these ingredients taste at least a bit better, and occasionally much better, than
the industrialized versions. And despite the wholesome-food movement’s frequent and
inexcusable obliviousness to the obesogenicity of many of its own foods, it deserves credit
for paying more attention to those healthier ingredients than does Big Food.
Where the Pollanites get into real trouble—where their philosophy becomes so glib and
wrongheaded that it is actually immoral—is in the claim that their style of food shopping
and eating is the answer to the country’s weight problem. Helping me to indulge my taste
for genuinely healthy wholesome foods are the facts that I’m relatively affluent and well
educated, and that I’m surrounded by people who tend to take care with what they eat.
Not only am I within a few minutes’ drive of three Whole Foods and two Trader Joe’s, I’m
within walking distance of two other supermarkets and more than a dozen restaurants
that offer bountiful healthy-eating options.
I am, in short, not much like the average obese person in America, and neither are the
Pollanites. That person is relatively poor, does not read The Times or cookbook manifestos,
is surrounded by people who eat junk food and are themselves obese, and stands a good
chance of living in a food desert—an area where produce tends to be hard to find, of poor
quality, or expensive.
The wholesome foodies don’t argue that obesity and class are unrelated, but they
frequently argue that the obesity gap between the classes has been created by the
processed-food industry, which, in the past few decades, has preyed mostly on the less
affluent masses. Yet Lenard Lesser, a physician and an obesity researcher at the Palo Alto
Medical Foundation Research Institute, says that can’t be so, because the obesity gap
predates the fast-food industry and the dietary dominance of processed food. “The
difference in obesity rates in low- and high-income groups was evident as far back as we
have data, at least back through the 1960s,” he told me. One reason, some researchers have
argued, is that after having had to worry, over countless generations, about getting
enough food, poorer segments of society had little cultural bias against overindulging in
food, or putting on excess pounds, as industrialization raised incomes and made rich food
cheaply available.
The most obvious problem with the “let them eat kale” philosophy of affluent
wholesome-food advocates involves the price and availability of wholesome food. Even if
Whole Foods, Real Food Daily, or the Farmhouse weren’t three bus rides away for the
working poor, and even if three ounces of Vegan Cheesy Salad Booster, a Sea Cake
appetizer, and the vegetarian quiche weren’t laden with fat and problem carbs, few
among them would be likely to shell out $5.99, $9.95, or $16, respectively, for those pricey
treats.
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
5/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
20
A slew of start-ups are trying to find ways of producing fresh, local, unprocessed meals
quickly and at lower cost. But could this food eventually be sold as cheaply, conveniently,
and ubiquitously as today’s junky fast food? Not even according to Bittman, who
explored the question in a recent New York Times Magazine article. Even if wholesome
food caught on with the public at large, including the obese population, and even if poor
and working-class people were willing to pay a premium for it, how long would it take to
scale up from a handful of shops to the tens of thousands required to begin making a dent
in the obesity crisis? How long would it take to create the thousands of local farms we’d
need in order to provide these shops with fresh, unprocessed ingredients, even in cities?
Yet these hurdles can be waved away, if one only has the proper mind-set. Bittman
argued two years ago in The Times that there’s no excuse for anyone, food-desert-bound
or not, to eat fast food rather than wholesome food, because even if it’s not perfectly fresh
and locally grown, lower-end wholesome food—when purchased judiciously at the
supermarket and cooked at home—can be cheaper than fast food. Sure, there’s the matter
of all the time, effort, schedule coordination, and ability it takes to shop, cook, serve, and
clean up. But anyone who whines about that extra work, Bittman chided, just doesn’t
want to give up their excessive TV watching. (An “important benefit of paying more for
better-quality food is that you’re apt to eat less of it,” Pollan helpfully noted in his 2008
book, In Defense of Food.) It’s remarkable how easy it is to remake the disadvantaged in
one’s own image.
Let’s assume for a moment that somehow America, food deserts and all, becomes
absolutely lousy with highly affordable outlets for wholesome, locally sourced dishes that
are high in vegetables, fruits, legumes, poultry, fish, and whole grains, and low in fat and
problem carbs. What percentage of the junk-food-eating obese do we want to predict will
be ready to drop their Big Macs, fries, and Cokes for grilled salmon on chard? We can all
agree that many obese people find the former foods extremely enjoyable, and seem
unable to control their consumption of them. Is greater availability of healthier food that
pushes none of the same thrill buttons going to solve the problem?
Many Pollanites insist it will. “If the government came into these communities and
installed Brita filters under their sinks, they’d drink water instead of Coke,” Lisa Powell, a
professor of health policy and administration at the University of Illinois at Chicago’s
Institute for Health Research and Policy, told me. But experts who actually work with the
obese see a more difficult transition, especially when busy schedules are thrown into the
equation. “They won’t eat broccoli instead of french fries,” says Kelli Drenner, an obesity
researcher at Stephen F. Austin State University in Nacogdoches, Texas, which has about
four fast-food restaurants per block along most of its main drag. “You try to make even a
small change to school lunches, and parents and kids revolt.” . . .
People aren’t going to change their ingrained, neurobiologically supercharged junkeating habits just because someone dangles vegetables in front of them, farm-fresh or
otherwise. Mark Bittman sees signs of victory in “the stories parents tell me of their kids
booing as they drive by McDonald’s,” but it’s not hard to imagine which parents, which
kids, and which neighborhoods those stories might involve. One study found that
subsidizing the purchase of vegetables encouraged shoppers to buy more vegetables, but
also more junk food with the money they saved; on balance, their diets did not improve.
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
6/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recently found that the aughts saw a
significant drop in fruit intake, and no increase in vegetable consumption; Americans
continue to fall far short of eating the recommended amounts of either. “Everyone’s
mother and brother has been telling them to eat more fruit and vegetables forever, and
the numbers are only getting worse,” says Steven Nickolas, who runs the Healthy Food
Project in Scottsdale, Arizona. “We’re not going to solve this problem by telling people to
eat unprocessed food.”
Trim, affluent Americans of course have a right to view dietary questions from their
own perspective—that is, in terms of what they need to eat in order to add perhaps a few
months onto the already healthy courses of their lives. The pernicious sleight of hand is
in willfully confusing what might benefit them—small, elite minority that they are—with
what would help most of society. The conversations they have among themselves in The
Times, in best-selling books, and at Real Food Daily may not register with the workingclass obese. But these conversations unquestionably distort the views of those who are in
a position to influence what society does about the obesity problem.
The Food Revolution We Need
The one fast-food restaurant near a busy East L.A. intersection otherwise filled with
bodegas was a Carl’s Jr. I went in and saw that the biggest and most prominent posters in
the store were pushing a new grilled-cod sandwich. It actually looked pretty good, but it
wasn’t quite lunchtime, and I just wanted a cup of coffee. I went to the counter to order it,
but before I could say anything, the cashier greeted me and asked, “Would you like to try
our new Charbroiled Atlantic Cod Fish Sandwich today?” Oh, well, sure, why not? (I
asked her to hold the tartar sauce, which is mostly fat, but found out later that the
sandwich is normally served with about half as much tartar sauce as the notoriously
fatty Filet-O-Fish sandwich at McDonald’s, where the fish is battered and fried.) The
sandwich was delicious. It was less than half the cost of the Sea Cake appetizer at Real
Food Daily. It took less than a minute to prepare. In some ways, it was the best meal I had
in L.A., and it was probably the healthiest.
David Freedman contrasts the offerings of fast-food restaurants with similar menu
items at pricier places. Find out more about this strategy on pp. 424–27
(Chapter18.xhtml#page_424).
25
We know perfectly well who within our society has developed an extraordinary
facility for nudging the masses to eat certain foods, and for making those foods widely
available in cheap and convenient forms. The Pollanites have led us to conflate the
industrial processing of food with the adding of fat and sugar in order to hook customers,
even while pushing many faux-healthy foods of their own. But why couldn’t Big Food’s
processing and marketing genius be put to use on genuinely healthier foods, like grilled
fish? Putting aside the standard objection that the industry has no interest in doing so—
we’ll see later that in fact the industry has plenty of motivation for taking on this
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
7/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
challenge—wouldn’t that present a more plausible answer to America’s junk-food
problem than ordering up 50,000 new farmers’ markets featuring locally grown organic
squash blossoms?
The menu board at KFC shows larger-than-life images of fried food.
According to Lenard Lesser, of the Palo Alto Medical Foundation, the food industry has
mastered the art of using in-store and near-store promotions to shape what people eat. As
Lesser and I drove down storied Telegraph Avenue in Berkeley and into far less affluent
Oakland, leaving behind the Whole Foods Markets and sushi restaurants for gas-station
markets and barbecued-rib stands, he pointed out the changes in the billboards. Whereas
the last one we saw in Berkeley was for fruit juice, many in Oakland tout fast-food joints
and their wares, including several featuring the Hot Mess Burger at Jack in the Box.
Though Lesser noted that this forest of advertising may simply reflect Oakland residents’
preexisting preference for this type of food, he told me lab studies have indicated that the
more signs you show people for a particular food product or dish, the more likely they are
to choose it over others, all else being equal.
We went into a KFC and found ourselves traversing a maze of signage that put us faceto-face with garish images of various fried foods that presumably had some chicken
somewhere deep inside them. “The more they want you to buy something, the bigger
they make the image on the menu board,” Lesser explained. Here, what loomed largest
was the $19.98 fried-chicken-and-corn family meal, which included biscuits and cake. A
few days later, I noticed that McDonald’s places large placards showcasing desserts on the
trash bins, apparently calculating that the best time to entice diners with sweets is when
they think they’ve finished their meals.
Trying to get burger lovers to jump to grilled fish may already be a bit of a stretch—I
didn’t see any of a dozen other customers buy the cod sandwich when I was at Carl’s Jr.,
though the cashier said it was selling reasonably well. Still, given the food industry’s
power to tinker with and market food, we should not dismiss its ability to get unhealthy
eaters—slowly, incrementally—to buy better food.
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
8/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
30
That brings us to the crucial question: Just how much healthier could fast-food joints
and processed-food companies make their best-selling products without turning off
customers? I put that question to a team of McDonald’s executives, scientists, and chefs
who are involved in shaping the company’s future menus, during a February visit to
McDonald’s surprisingly bucolic campus west of Chicago. By way of a partial answer, the
team served me up a preview tasting of two major new menu items that had been under
development in their test kitchens and high-tech sensory-testing labs for the past year,
and which were rolled out to the public in April. The first was the Egg White Delight
McMuffin ($2.65), a lower-calorie, less fatty version of the Egg McMuffin, with some of the
refined flour in the original recipe replaced by whole-grain flour. The other was one of
three new Premium McWraps ($3.99), crammed with grilled chicken and spring mix, and
given a light coating of ranch dressing amped up with rice vinegar. Both items tasted
pretty good (as do the versions in stores, I’ve since confirmed, though some outlets go too
heavy on the dressing). And they were both lower in fat, sugar, and calories than not only
many McDonald’s staples, but also much of the food served in wholesome restaurants or
touted in wholesome cookbooks.
In fact, McDonald’s has quietly been making healthy changes for years, shrinking
portion sizes, reducing some fats, trimming average salt content by more than 10 percent
in the past couple of years alone, and adding fruits, vegetables, low-fat dairy, and oatmeal
to its menu. In May, the chain dropped its Angus third-pounders and announced a new
line of quarter-pound burgers, to be served on buns containing whole grains. Outside the
core fast-food customer base, Americans are becoming more health-conscious. Public
backlash against fast food could lead to regulatory efforts, and in any case, the fast-food
industry has every incentive to maintain broad appeal. “We think a lot about how we can
bring nutritionally balanced meals that include enough protein, along with the tastes and
satisfaction that have an appetite-tiding effect,” said Barbara Booth, the company’s
director of sensory science.
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
9/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
Fast-food restaurants like McDonald’s have been trying for years to promote healthier fare.
Such steps are enormously promising, says Jamy Ard, an epidemiology and preventivemedicine researcher at Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center in Winston-Salem, North
Carolina, and a co-director of the Weight Management Center there. “Processed food is a
key part of our environment, and it needs to be part of the equation,” he explains. “If you
can reduce fat and calories by only a small amount in a Big Mac, it still won’t be a health
food, but it wouldn’t be as bad, and that could have a huge impact on us.” Ard, who has
been working for more than a decade with the obese poor, has little patience with the
wholesome-food movement’s call to eliminate fast food in favor of farm-fresh goods. “It’s
really naive,” he says. “Fast food became popular because it’s tasty and convenient and
cheap. It makes a lot more sense to look for small, beneficial changes in that food than it
does to hold out for big changes in what people eat that have no realistic chance of
happening.”
According to a recent study, Americans get 11 percent of their calories, on average,
from fast food—a number that’s almost certainly much higher among the less affluent
overweight. As a result, the fast-food industry may be uniquely positioned to improve
our diets. Research suggests that calorie counts in a meal can be trimmed by as much as
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
10/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
35
30 percent without eaters noticing—by, for example, reducing portion sizes and swapping
in ingredients that contain more fiber and water. Over time, that could be much more
than enough to literally tip the scales for many obese people. “The difference between
losing weight and not losing weight,” says Robert Kushner, the obesity scientist and
clinical director at Northwestern, “is a few hundred calories a day.”
Which raises a question: If McDonald’s is taking these sorts of steps, albeit in a slow and
limited way, why isn’t it more loudly saying so to deflect criticism? While the company
has heavily plugged the debut of its new egg-white sandwich and chicken wraps, the ads
have left out even a mention of health, the reduced calories and fat, or the inclusion of
whole grains. McDonald’s has practically kept secret the fact that it has also begun
substituting whole-grain flour for some of the less healthy refined flour in its best-selling
Egg McMuffin.
The explanation can be summed up in two words that surely strike fear into the hearts
of all fast-food executives who hope to make their companies’ fare healthier: McLean
Deluxe.
Among those who gleefully rank such things, the McLean Deluxe reigns as McDonald’s
worst product failure of all time, eclipsing McPasta, the McHotdog, and the McAfrica
(don’t ask). When I brought up the McLean Deluxe to the innovation team at McDonald’s,
I faced the first and only uncomfortable silence of the day. Finally, Greg Watson, a senior
vice president, cleared his throat and told me that neither he nor anyone else in the room
was at the company at the time, and he didn’t know that much about it. “It sounds to me
like it was ahead of its time,” he added. “If we had something like that in the future, we
would never launch it like that again.”
Introduced in 1991, the McLean Deluxe was perhaps the boldest single effort the food
industry has ever undertaken to shift the masses to healthier eating. It was supposed to
be a healthier version of the Quarter Pounder, made with extra-lean beef infused with
seaweed extract. It reportedly did reasonably well in early taste tests—for what it’s worth,
my wife and I were big fans—and McDonald’s pumped the reduced-fat angle to the public
for all it was worth. The general reaction varied from lack of interest to mockery to
revulsion. The company gamely flogged the sandwich for five years before quietly
removing it from the menu.
The McLean Deluxe was a sharp lesson to the industry, even if in some ways it merely
confirmed what generations of parents have well known: if you want to turn off
otherwise eager eaters to a dish, tell them it’s good for them. Recent studies suggest that
calorie counts placed on menus have a negligible effect on food choices, and that the lesshealth-conscious might even use the information to steer clear of low-calorie fare—
perhaps assuming that it tastes worse and is less satisfying, and that it’s worse value for
their money. The result is a sense in the food industry that if it is going to sell healthier
versions of its foods to the general public—and not just to that minority already sold on
healthier eating—it is going to have to do it in a relatively sneaky way, emphasizing the
taste appeal and not the health benefits. “People expect something to taste worse if they
believe it’s healthy,” says Charles Spence, an Oxford University neuroscientist who
specializes in how the brain perceives food. “And that expectation affects how it tastes to
them, so it actually does taste worse.”
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
11/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
40
Thus McDonald’s silence on the nutritional profiles of its new menu items. “We’re not
making any health claims,” Watson said. “We’re just saying it’s new, it tastes great, come
on in and enjoy it. Maybe once the product is well seated with customers, we’ll change
that message.” If customers learn that they can eat healthier foods at McDonald’s without
even realizing it, he added, they’ll be more likely to try healthier foods there than at other
restaurants. The same reasoning presumably explains why the promotions and ads for
the Carl’s Jr. grilled-cod sandwich offer not a word related to healthfulness, and why
there wasn’t a whiff of health cheerleading surrounding the turkey burger brought out
earlier this year by Burger King (which is not yet calling the sandwich a permanent
addition).
If the food industry is to quietly sell healthier products to its mainstream, mostly nonhealth-conscious customers, it must find ways to deliver the eating experience that fat
and problem carbs provide in foods that have fewer of those ingredients. There is no way
to do that with farm-fresh produce and wholesome meat, other than reducing portion
size. But processing technology gives the food industry a potent tool for trimming
unwanted ingredients while preserving the sensations they deliver.
I visited Fona International, a flavor-engineering company also outside Chicago, and
learned that there are a battery of tricks for fooling and appeasing taste buds, which are
prone to notice a lack of fat or sugar, or the presence of any of the various bitter, metallic,
or otherwise unpleasant flavors that vegetables, fiber, complex carbs, and fat or sugar
substitutes can impart to a food intended to appeal to junk-food eaters. Some 5,000 FDAapproved chemical compounds—which represent the base components of all known
flavors—line the shelves that run alongside Fona’s huge labs. Armed with these
ingredients and an array of state-of-the-art chemical-analysis and testing tools, Fona’s
scientists and engineers can precisely control flavor perception. “When you reduce the
sugar, fat, and salt in foods, you change the personality of the product,” said Robert Sobel,
a chemist, who heads up research at the company. “We can restore it.”
For example, fat “cushions” the release of various flavors on the tongue, unveiling them
gradually and allowing them to linger. When fat is removed, flavors tend to immediately
inundate the tongue and then quickly flee, which we register as a much less satisfying
experience. Fona’s experts can reproduce the “temporal profile” of the flavors in fattier
foods by adding edible compounds derived from plants that slow the release of flavor
molecules; by replacing the flavors with similarly flavored compounds that come on and
leave more slowly; or by enlisting “phantom aromas” that create the sensation of certain
tastes even when those tastes are not present on the tongue. (For example, the smell of
vanilla can essentially mask reductions in sugar of up to 25 percent.) One triumph of this
sort of engineering is the modern protein drink, a staple of many successful weight-loss
programs and a favorite of those trying to build muscle. “Seven years ago they were
unpalatable,” Sobel said. “Today we can mask the astringent flavors and eggy aromas by
adding natural ingredients.” . . .
Fona . . ., like most companies in [the] industry, won’t identify customers or product
names on the record. But [the firm] showed me an array of foods and beverages that were
under construction, so to speak, in the name of reducing calories, fat, and sugar while
maintaining mass appeal. . . . Dozens of companies are doing similar work, as are the big
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
12/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
food-ingredient manufacturers, such as ConAgra, whose products are in 97 percent of
American homes, and whose whole-wheat flour is what McDonald’s is relying on for its
breakfast sandwiches. Domino Foods, the sugar manufacturer, now sells a low-calorie
combination of sugar and the nonsugar sweetener stevia that has been engineered by a
flavor company to mask the sort of nonsugary tastes driving many consumers away from
diet beverages and the like. “Stevia has a licorice note we were able to have taken out,”
explains Domino Foods CEO Brian O’Malley.
High-tech anti-obesity food engineering is just warming up. Oxford’s Charles Spence
notes that in addition to flavors and textures, companies are investigating ways to exploit
a stream of insights that have been coming out of scholarly research about the
neuroscience of eating. He notes, for example, that candy companies may be able to slip
healthier ingredients into candy bars without anyone noticing, simply by loading these
ingredients into the middle of the bar and leaving most of the fat and sugar at the ends of
the bar. “We tend to make up our minds about how something tastes from the first and
last bites, and don’t care as much what happens in between,” he explains. Some other
potentially useful gimmicks he points out: adding weight to food packaging such as
yogurt containers, which convinces eaters that the contents are rich with calories, even
when they’re not; using chewy textures that force consumers to spend more time
between bites, giving the brain a chance to register satiety; and using colors, smells,
sounds, and packaging information to create the belief that foods are fatty and sweet
even when they are not. Spence found, for example, that wine is perceived as 50 percent
sweeter when consumed under a red light.
Researchers are also tinkering with food ingredients to boost satiety. Cargill has
developed a starch derived from tapioca that gives dishes a refined-carb taste and
mouthfeel, but acts more like fiber in the body—a feature that could keep the appetite
from spiking later. “People usually think that processing leads to foods that digest too
quickly, but we’ve been able to use processing to slow the digestion rate,” says Bruce
McGoogan, who heads R&D for Cargill’s North American food-ingredient business. The
company has also developed ways to reduce fat in beef patties, and to make baked goods
using half the usual sugar and oil, all without heavily compromising taste and texture. . . .
The Implacable Enemies of Healthier Processed Food
45
What’s not to like about these developments? Plenty, if you’ve bought into the notion that
processing itself is the source of the unhealthfulness of our foods. The wholesome-food
movement is not only talking up dietary strategies that are unlikely to help most obese
Americans; it is, in various ways, getting in the way of strategies that could work better.
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
13/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
Mark Bittman demonstrates a recipe on the Today Show.
The Pollanites didn’t invent resistance to healthier popular foods, as the fate of the
McLean Deluxe . . . demonstrate[s], but they’ve greatly intensified it. Fast food and junk
food have their core customer base, and the wholesome-food gurus have theirs. In
between sit many millions of Americans—the more the idea that processed food should
be shunned no matter what takes hold in this group, the less incentive fast-food joints
will have to continue edging away from the fat- and problem-carb-laden fare beloved by
their most loyal customers to try to broaden their appeal.
Pollan has popularized contempt for “nutritionism,” the idea behind packing healthier
ingredients into processed foods. In his view, the quest to add healthier ingredients to
food isn’t a potential solution, it’s part of the problem. Food is healthy not when it
contains healthy ingredients, he argues, but when it can be traced simply and directly to
(preferably local) farms. As he resonantly put it in The Times in 2007: “If you’re concerned
about your health, you should probably avoid food products that make health claims.
Why? Because a health claim on a food product is a good indication that it’s not really
food, and food is what you want to eat.”
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
14/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
McDonald’s executive chef Dan Coudreaut at work in his corporate kitchen.
50
In this way, wholesome-food advocates have managed to pre-damn the very steps we
need the food industry to take, placing the industry in a no-win situation: If it maintains
the status quo, then we need to stay away because its food is loaded with fat and sugar.
But if it tries to moderate these ingredients, then it is deceiving us with nutritionism.
Pollan explicitly counsels avoiding foods containing more than five ingredients, or any
hard-to-pronounce or unfamiliar ingredients. This rule eliminates almost anything the
industry could do to produce healthier foods that retain mass appeal—most of us wouldn’t
get past xanthan gum—and that’s perfectly in keeping with his intention.
By placing wholesome eating directly at odds with healthier processed foods, the
Pollanites threaten to derail the reformation of fast food just as it’s starting to gain
traction. At McDonald’s, “Chef Dan”—that is, Dan Coudreaut, the executive chef and
director of culinary innovation—told me of the dilemma the movement has caused him as
he has tried to make the menu healthier. “Some want us to have healthier food, but others
want us to have minimally processed ingredients, which can mean more fat,” he
explained. “It’s becoming a balancing act for us.” That the chef with arguably the most
influence in the world over the diet of the obese would even consider adding fat to his
menu to placate wholesome foodies is a pretty good sign that something has gone terribly
wrong with our approach to the obesity crisis.
Many people insist that the steps the food industry has already taken to offer lessobesogenic fare are no more than cynical ploys to fool customers into eating the same old
crap under a healthy guise. In his 3,500-word New York Times Magazine article on the
prospects for healthier fast food, Mark Bittman lauded a new niche of vegan chain
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
15/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
restaurants while devoting just one line to the major “quick serve” restaurants’
contribution to better health: “I’m not talking about token gestures, like the McDonald’s
fruit-and-yogurt parfait, whose calories are more than 50 percent sugar.” Never mind that
80 percent of a farm-fresh apple’s calories come from sugar; that almost any obesity
expert would heartily approve of the yogurt parfait as a step in the right direction for
most fast-food-dessert eaters; and that many of the desserts Bittman glorifies in his own
writing make the parfait look like arugula, nutrition-wise. (His recipe for corn-andblueberry crisp, for example, calls for adding two-thirds of a cup of brown sugar to a lot of
other problem carbs, along with five tablespoons of butter.)
Bittman is hardly alone in his reflexive dismissals. No sooner had McDonald’s and
Burger King rolled out their egg-white sandwich and turkey burger, respectively, than a
spate of articles popped up hooting that the new dishes weren’t healthier because they
trimmed a mere 50 and 100 calories from their standard counterparts, the Egg McMuffin
and the Whopper. Apparently these writers didn’t understand, or chose to ignore, the fact
that a reduction of 50 or 100 calories in a single dish places an eater exactly on track to
eliminate a few hundred calories a day from his or her diet—the critical threshold needed
for long-term weight loss. Any bigger reduction would risk leaving someone too hungry
to stick to a diet program. It’s just the sort of small step in the right direction we should be
aiming for, because the obese are much more likely to take it than they are to make a big
leap to wholesome or very-low-calorie foods.
Many wholesome foodies insist that the food industry won’t make serious progress
toward healthier fare unless forced to by regulation. I, for one, believe regulation aimed at
speeding the replacement of obesogenic foods with appealing healthier foods would be a
great idea. But what a lot of foodies really want is to ban the food industry from selling
junk food altogether. And that is just a fantasy. The government never managed to keep
the tobacco companies from selling cigarettes, and banning booze (the third-most-deadly
consumable killer after cigarettes and food) didn’t turn out so well. The two most healthenlightened, regulation-friendly major cities in America, New York and San Francisco,
tried to halt sales of two of the most horrific fast-food assaults on health—giant servings
of sugared beverages and kids’ fast-food meals accompanied by toys, respectively—and
neither had much luck. Michelle Obama is excoriated by conservatives for asking schools
to throw more fruits and vegetables into the lunches they serve. Realistically, the most we
can hope for is a tax on some obesogenic foods. The research of Lisa Powell, the
University of Illinois professor, suggests that a 20 percent tax on sugary beverages would
reduce consumption by about 25 percent. (As for fatty foods, no serious tax proposal has
yet been made in the U.S., and if one comes along, the wholesome foodies might well join
the food industry and most consumers in opposing it. Denmark did manage to enact a
fatty-food tax, but it was deemed a failure when consumers went next door into
Germany and Sweden to stock up on their beloved treats.)
Continuing to call out Big Food on its unhealthy offerings, and loudly, is one of the best
levers we have for pushing it toward healthier products—but let’s call it out intelligently,
not reflexively. Executives of giant food companies may be many things, but they are not
stupid. Absent action, they risk a growing public-relations disaster, the loss of their more
affluent and increasingly health-conscious customers, and the threat of regulation, which
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
16/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
55
will be costly to fight, even if the new rules don’t stick. Those fears are surely what’s
driving much of the push toward moderately healthier fare within the industry today.
But if the Pollanites convince policy makers and the health-conscious public that these
foods are dangerous by virtue of not being farm-fresh, that will push Big Food in a
different direction (in part by limiting the profit potential it sees in lower-fat, lowerproblem-carb foods), and cause it to spend its resources in other ways.
Significant regulation of junk food may not go far, but we have other tools at our
disposal to prod Big Food to intensify and speed up its efforts to cut fat and problem carbs
in its offerings, particularly if we’re smart about it. Lenard Lesser points out that
government and advocacy groups could start singling out particular restaurants and food
products for praise or shaming—a more official version of “eat this, not that”—rather than
sticking to a steady drumbeat of “processed food must go away.” Academia could do a
much better job of producing and highlighting solid research into less obesogenic, highmass-appeal foods, and could curtail its evidence-light anti-food-processing bias, so that
the next generation of social and policy entrepreneurs might work to narrow the gap
between the poor obese and the well-resourced healthy instead of inadvertently
widening it. We can keep pushing our health-care system to provide more incentives and
support to the obese for losing weight by making small, painless, but helpful changes in
their behavior, such as switching from Whoppers to turkey burgers, from Egg McMuffins
to Egg White Delights, or from blueberry crisp to fruit-and-yogurt parfaits.
And we can ask the wholesome-food advocates, and those who give them voice, to
make it clearer that the advice they sling is relevant mostly to the privileged healthy—
and to start getting behind realistic solutions to the obesity crisis.
Thinking about the Text
1. Why is David Freedman so sure that fast-food outlets can significantly improve the diet
and health of the U.S. public? SUMMARIZE the main arguments in this proposal. What
does he see as the problem, and what is his solution?
2. Freedman seems to be genuinely concerned about the problems caused by obesity and
unhealthy diets, and he argues passionately for a solution. Still, his way of describing poor
people, obese people, and particularly people who are both, can seem disrespectful and
patronizing. What do you think his ATTITUDE is toward these people? Do you think he
assumes that his AUDIENCE includes such people? Point to specific examples in the text
to support your conclusions.
3. A good PROPOSAL presents evidence that the proposed course of action will address the
problem, and that it will do so better than other possible solutions. Identify two REASONS
and the corresponding EVIDENCE that Freedman presents to support his proposed
solution. How persuasive are they? Has he convinced you that his solution is the best fix
available and if not, why not?
4. Recent studies show that restaurant customers pay little attention to the calorie count
information on menus, and even that some diners may use the information in order to
avoid the lower-calorie items. Do you pay attention to the calorie counts or other
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
17/18
6/1/2020
Everyone’s An Author 2e, with Readings
nutritional information on menus or food packaging? Explain the reasoning behind your
practices.
5. In arguing for “the food revolution we need,” Freedman poses a rhetorical question:
“Wouldn’t [healthier fast-food options] present a more plausible answer to America’s
junk food problem than ordering up 50,000 new farmers’ markets featuring locally
grown organic squash blossoms?” The issue, of course, is much more complex than
Freedman’s either/or proposition—but think locally for a moment. Which option would
you rather find around the corner from where you live: a healthier menu at a fast-food
restaurant, or a new farmers’ market with a variety of local produce? Write an editorial
for your local newspaper ARGUING for your chosen establishment. List and describe the
benefits of the option you’ve chosen, providing solid evidence that will appeal to those
who read that paper.
https://ncia.wwnorton.com/ebooks/epub/everyone2r/OEBPS/Readings-13.xhtml
18/18
Purchase answer to see full
attachment