Georgia Institute of Technology the Dark Side of Growth Discussion

Description

I need 3 paragraphs ( 5-6 sentences each paragraph) answer to the following discussion board question:

In The Dark Side of Growth the authors look at growth as a roller coaster ride with periods of rapid growth interspersed with periods of failure. They suggest that successful CEOs are able to manage both the highs and the lows. As you read and analyze the Amazon case how does Jeff Bezos fit into the model the authors of The Dark Side of Growth propose?

.

.

.

I also need a 1 paragraph (5-6 sentences) response to the following post:

Johns post

In the article “The Dark Side of Growth” the authors bring up many valid points about what CEO’s must be willing to accept when in their roles. It is easy and fun when times are going well. On the other hand the CEO must be innovative and forward thinking in order to successfully survive the down times that any growing company will endure. Jeff Bezos is a good example of the “roller coaster” leader of Amazon. Amazon has had many successful launches and also has had some large failures. What makes Jeff Bezos different from other CEOs is the fact that he shows management within Amazon and the shareholders that while one item may be a “flop” there are ten other projects behind it that could be winners. This allows others to not become discouraged and seek a new leader or new employment. This is similar to the business case we saw in the article where the CEO was asked to find his replacement but did so good and managing to turn things around the board kept him. Jeff Bezos is an innovator and is always forward thinking and that is important because when you are a growing business what will likely allow you to get past that period is innovation and resources. Jeff Bezos commits whatever resources are needed to a project and allows people to make mistakes as that is how the company has come back stronger after each successful and unsuccessful product launch.

Unformatted Attachment Preview

For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
CMR518
Managing in Different
Growth Contexts
Julia Prats
Marc Sosna
S. Ramakrishna Velamuri
Existing frameworks on growth do not distinguish between the managerial challenges of different growth
contexts; they place considerable emphasis on the overall quality of companies’ portfolios of strategic units,
but less on how different units should be managed according to the growth context they are in. The managerial challenges of generating growth in low-growth contexts are very different from those of managing growth in
high-growth contexts. This article introduces a matrix framework that incorporates four growth scenarios, which
firm-units can map themselves on to, and then outlines the major barriers they face in each of these scenarios
as well as the actions needed to overcome them. The results are based on longitudinal research on crossnational samples of small, medium, and large organizations. (Keywords: Growth strategy, Strategic management, Entrepreneurship, Innovation)
A
n experienced German manager of a European multinational chemicals company takes up his new job in July 2006 as VP for Asia
Pacific based in Shanghai, China. His previous assignment has been
in the mature U.S. market (less than 5% annual growth), where his
priority has been to generate modest growth largely at the expense of competitors
and to improve profitability through operational efficiencies. The Asia Pacific
region is experiencing explosive growth in all the company’s product segments,
driven mainly by the 10% GDP growth rate of the Chinese economy. Revenues
in 1996 were €60 million and are estimated in 2006 to reach €600 million, a
CAGR over the ten-year period of 26%. The manager’s brief is to achieve annual
revenues of €1 billion over the next three years. During his first weeks in his new
position, his direct reports fill him in on the challenges they face: first, competitors, both local and foreign, are also growing aggressively; second, it is proving difficult to attract, train, and retain talent; third, the company’s internal resources,
including management staff, production plants, distribution infrastructure, and
systems and processes are stretched to the limit, resulting in frequent disruptions
in day-to-day operations and less than optimal service to customers. As he listens
to these challenges, the German manager begins to realize that although he still
118
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
deals with the same product categories as before, his managerial approach in this
new position needs to be very different from the one that has brought him success
in his previous assignment in the U.S.
Julia Prats is an Associate Professor of
Entrepreneurship at IESE Business School.
Introduction
Marc Sosna is a Research Fellow at the
Profitable growth remains a top-priority for
Entrepreneurship Department at IESE
Business School and a PhD Candidate at
most executives around the world. One category
Technical University Berlin.
of existing growth frameworks focuses primarily
on facilitating strategic choices on resource allocaS. Ramakrishna Velamuri is a Professor of
tions within a portfolio: whether to milk, invest
Entrepreneurship at the China Europe
International Business School (CEIBS).
into, or divest a unit. Another describes the typi
cal developmental stages of firms and the corresponding internal challenges. However, the
existing literature provides surprisingly little evidence-based advice on how to
actually manage firm-units in different growth contexts. How should leaders manage
units that trail the market and that cannot or will not be divested? Similarly,
how should they manage high-growth units operating in product-segments
undergoing explosive growth? Our longitudinal study provides empirical depth
and insights into four growth scenarios that present very different challenges, as
described in our Growth Challenges Matrix.
We propose that while firm growth has typically been studied at the firm
level, it is more appropriate to do so at the level of product-segment combinations.
Our framework shares the contingency characteristic with portfolio models, but
takes the portfolio of product-segments as given and focuses instead on the challenges of managing the individual product-segment combinations based on the
growth context they are in. It also introduces a dynamic perspective that helps
managers anticipate future challenges based on the growth trajectories they are
in. Executives need to posses different skills and apply different managerial
approaches in order to succeed in each of these scenarios.
We define a product-segment combination as a particular product (or family
of products) matched with a particular product-segment growth context. For example, a
family of chemical products used for bonding applications for the automobile
industry in the United States could be considered a product-segment combination.
This combination would be different from the same family of bonding chemicals
matched to the Chinese automobile market, if the growth scenario of this product
segment is substantially different from the U.S. one. A third and separate combination would be the same product family for the U.S. aircraft market, if this market shows very different growth characteristics from those of the U.S. automobile
market. A product family that faces similar growth scenarios across markets
(for example, bonding chemicals for automobiles in the U.S. and in Canada) can
be said to be operating under the same product-segment combination for the purposes of our framework.
A focus on product-segments is helpful for a number of reasons. First, it
avoids bundling together product-segment combinations under more traditional
classification schemes (such as geographic markets or business units), which
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
119
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
deprives them of a more tailored strategic treatment. There are often pockets of
high-growth in mature markets that can be exploited to their full potential, but
need very different treatment from the general market. Equally, there can be
pockets of low or negative growth even in high-growth markets, often due to
overcapacity in the client industry (such as ball bearings for wind turbines in
2011 in China). There is a danger of losing some of this nuance if a more-granular
unit of analysis is not used. This notion is well captured by the former CEO of
Danfoss, who stated that his company was happy with its 35% year-on-year
growth in China, until it conducted a detailed study in 2004 and realized that it
could grow sales 10-fold (78% CAGR) over four years in the Chinese industrial
control devices segment.1 As a result of focusing on a geographic market (China)
rather than on individual product segments (such as industrial control devices),
management had earlier not identified the opportunity sharply enough and had
not mobilized itself to capture it fully.
Second, applying this more-granular perspective not only helps define the
best growth management approach for the present, but more importantly for the
future, taking into account the entities’ growth trajectories and facilitating anticipation of future challenges. For instance, in our analysis of the chemicals company
referred to at the beginning, we found that in 2007, the U.S. unit’s overall sales
growth in bonding chemicals exceeded that of its key competitors. A closer look
revealed that while the company’s aircraft unit had a much higher absolute growth
rate than the automobile unit, it was in fact trailing the average growth rate of its
product-segment by a considerable margin. Conversely, growth in the automobile
segment was significantly higher than its corresponding segment growth. As the
aircraft unit studied its segment needs in greater detail, it realized that a major technological shift had started to take place in that the share of carbon-fiber materials in
airplane production was expected to significantly increase, resulting in huge growth
potential for bonding chemicals. Thus, considering its current laggard-status, this
unit would need to dramatically increase its growth rate in the short term to avoid
being in a weak position when the market started to experience explosive growth.
Even within the aircraft segment, there were differences in geographical areas as
well as in sub-segments, such as the commercial airplane segment, the military segment, and the maintenance and repair segment, creating a number of different
product-segment combinations. Thus, it was of critical importance to manage the
different product-segments in this complex market according to their specific
growth contexts and the growth trajectories they were on.
Our analysis and discussion are targeted at leaders responsible for managing single or multiple firm-units as well as corporate-level executives who need
to understand their organization’s overall mapping of product-segment combinations on our Growth Challenges Matrix.
Literature Review
Firm growth is a rich and difficult to grasp phenomenon. McKelvie and
Wiklund suggest a classification of prior research into the following three broad
streams: growth as an outcome;2 the outcome of growth;3 and the growth process. In a
120
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
recent review,4 they describe the myriad of problems5 associated with growth
research and conclude that it has failed to develop a cumulative body of knowledge.6 Coad goes so far as to say that the findings of empirical work indicate “that
growth is largely a random process,” and that “theoretical predictions have been
of limited use in understanding growth of firms, if not downright misleading.”7
This problem of inconsistent results alerts us to the need for more focused
and circumscribed research approaches that attempt to shed light on specific facets
of growth, rather than on the multifaceted phenomenon of growth as a whole.
Gilbert et al. conclude that the focus on why growth rates vary has been done “to
the exclusion of how and where [within the organization] that growth is occurring,” even though the best predictors may depend exactly on these dimensions.8
As an important need in future research, they point to the varying speeds of growth
in different industries and the different impacts this has on growth management
in firms.
One important category of growth frameworks are stage models, which deal
with the internal transformations a firm must undergo as it grows. They have gained
popularity through the seminal work of Greiner in organizational development and
change.9 A second category is represented by contingency frameworks, such as those of
Igor Ansoff (“Product-Mission Matrix”),10 the BCG Growth Share Matrix,11 the
McKinsey-GE Business Screen,12 or Shell’s Directional Policy Matrix.13 Contingency
perspectives by and large help managers make strategic choices. While they do combine an external dimension with an internal one, they are mainly focused on supporting resource allocation decisions based on the attractiveness of business units
within a portfolio and on the quality of the overall portfolio. They do not to prescribe
how to manage business units within a given context.
In summary, insights from the recent literature on growth emphasize two key
needs: applying more-granular units of analysis; and studying these units in different growth
contexts, which result from combining the internal firm-unit growth rate with the
external product-segment growth rate. Several authors14 have argued that studying
interactions at more-granular levels of analysis is the better approach to understand
any phenomenon. Innovation research experienced a significant advance when it
was explored at the product subsystem level, by avoiding the confusion that the
more general “product” level was producing in understanding the effect of innovation on internal capabilities and the nature of complementary assets.15 Our study
specifically addresses these needs.
Research Methods
We designed an in-depth research project that began in 2004 and focused
on small, medium, as well as large companies. Our goal was to explore the different challenges involved in generating and managing growth. Based on our review
of the literature, we set out to: understand growth at the more-granular level
of product-segment combinations by comparing firm-unit growth to productsegment growth; limit our inquiry to firms that had articulated a growth intent; focus
only on organic growth; and study firms over time, as suggested by McKelvie &
Wiklund.
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
121
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
On the empirical side, we foresee that in-depth longitudinal case studies of different
types of growth processes would be particularly valuable in order to further develop
growth process theory.16
Our data have come from three sources. First, since 2005, we have had
access to the CEOs of 62 European technology companies from 20 countries.
These CEOs met every four months in groups of 8-12 and made presentations
to their peers on their key challenges relating to strategy, business models, governance, internationalization, new product development, marketing and sales,
finance, strategic partnerships, and human resource management. They also outlined the actions they would take to overcome these challenges. All these data
were captured in writing. Four months later and every four months thereafter
until December 2010, we tracked the implementation of the actions and their
consequences. Further, we conducted annual performance surveys in which the
CEOs provided information regarding their growth in revenues, employees, and
profits as well as financing, potential acquisitions and divestments, customer pipeline metrics, internationalization, partnerships, board structure, and compensation data. With a sub-sample of 28 of these CEOs, we conducted in-depth
interviews that went beyond the discussions we had in our usual communications. We also conducted additional interviews with several other informants,
including employees of the firm, board members, investors, and industry experts.
Second, we also conducted a cross-sectional study where we studied the
characteristics, behaviors, and strategies of CEOs and senior managers (growth
leaders) of eleven firm-units in medium-sized companies and fourteen units in
large European corporations who had succeeded in generating and sustaining
organic growth far above the average growth rates of their respective industry
segments over extended time periods. We have also had access to the U.S. data
collected for this project by our U.S. partner. Interviews were conducted using a
semi-structured questionnaire. For reasons of data triangulation, we also interviewed co-workers of the growth leaders along the same dimensions. Some
examples from our European sample are General Electric, Samsung, OTIS Elevator, UBS, Continental, and Microsoft.
In total, we conducted 152 in-depth interviews that were distributed as follows across our different samples: 35 interviews with executives in firm-units of
large organizations, 48 interviews with CEOs and top-management team members of medium-sized companies, and 69 interviews with leaders in small firms.
Finally, with a group of 12 CEOs of small companies as well as with 35 executives
of a division of a European listed company that operates in multiple productsegments and has to deal with challenges in different types of growth contexts
at the same time, we have twice organized focus group sessions to discuss and
receive their input on the framework we present here.
Our research does not suffer from survivor (or success) bias as we have
tracked companies that performed differently in different growth contexts; some
firm-units went from high growth to low growth, some did the opposite, some
were able to hold their position as high-growth firms, and some never recovered
from their low-growth state. We also had firms in our sample that were forced out
of business. As an illustrative display of some of our findings, we also wrote twelve
122
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
cases that cover the four quadrants of our framework. Given the international variety of our sample and our focus on product-segment combinations (in a number of
different geographies and industries), we believe that the generalizibility of our inferences is high.
The Growth Challenges Matrix
We start by presenting our two-by-two framework with four growth scenarios (see Figure 1). Each of the four quadrants presents an overall main challenge
that managers must address:
§ low firm-unit/low product-segment growth, where the challenge is to generate
growth;
§ low firm-unit/high product-segment growth, where the challenge consists of
linking up to product-segment growth;
§ high firm-unit/low product-segment growth, where the challenge is to sustain
the growth rate differential with respect to other competitors in the productsegment; and
§ high firm-unit/high product-segment growth, where the challenge is to manage
rapid growth and ensure that firm growth keeps pace at the very least with
that of the product-segment.
Exploring growth patterns across our samples, we find that the fundamental challenges facing managers in each of the four quadrants are very different.
Although certain issues might apply across the various scenarios, we focus on
the most salient ones in each quadrant and provide some important considerations for executives who face these barriers.
One issue we had to resolve early in our research was how to classify our
sample of firms in the four quadrants. The author team made quantitative and
FIGURE 1. The Growth Challenges Matrix
Growth challenges matrix
Q4
Q3
High
Firm-unit
growth
Managing
growth
Sustaining
growth
Q2
Q1
Low
Generating
growth
Low
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
Linking up
to market
growth
Product-segment
High
growth
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
123
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
FIGURE 2. Mapping of Sample Companies in our Growth Challenges Matrix
Q3
Q4
High
Firm-unit
growth
Q2
Q1
= BUs of large corporations
= Medium-sized companies
= Small firms
Low
Low
Product-segment
High
growth
qualitative assessments of each firm-unit to determine its growth context. This
was based on survey and interview data for revenue growth for both the subject
company and the product-segment. Additionally, we looked at industry reports
and conducted complimentary market research for the purpose of data triangulation. An entity that grows consistently at 30 percent in a product-segment that
grows at less than 6 percent annually is clearly a Q3-candidate. However, a company that grows at 30 percent while the product-segment grows at 100 percent is
a Q2-case. Thus, our growth measures were not absolute but relative. In this way,
we could clearly classify them into one of our four growth scenarios at any given
point in time (see Figure 2).17
Following the stakeholder framework as an organizing principle, we address
challenges relating to the firm-unit, including the top-management team and
employees; customers; suppliers and strategic partners; and competitors.
The First Quadrant: The Challenge of Generating Growth
If growth in the product-segment as well as in the firm-unit is minimal, the
challenges are similar to trying to sail in a calm sea. This quadrant is a well-known
reality for firm-units in mature product-segments and with products that are in
the later stages of their life cycles. Exiting this quadrant often requires a significant
reconfiguration of the existing offerings and organizational set-up.
Our findings show that lock-ins—with old mental models, misaligned processes and incentive systems, excessive internal focus, dysfunctional ownership
structures, and non-performing partnerships—represent a common challenge.
One executive in a large corporation describes his early conditions in this
quadrant (later becoming a high-growth unit in a Q3-context):
When I entered this unit as its new head, it was a huge challenge for me in many
ways. For nearly ten years, this business area hadn’t realized any growth or made
124
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
profits. . . . A number of internal issues seemed wrong at first sight, but the true
problems were actually at a deeper layer. To make matters worse, the market was
flat and with not much hope for better developments soon.
We found clear indications in such firm-units that fear of failure and mistakes inhibits experimental and innovative behavior among the management
team and employees, even in times where current approaches are ineffective.
Top-level sponsorship of specific initiatives can mitigate these risks in some cases
but cannot substitute for a culture where failure is accepted. Companies that
had successfully overcome these problems stand out with regard to empowerment
of lower management levels as well as the anchoring and reinforcement of new
attitudes. However, two aspects are worth noting with regard to “empowerment.”
First, while employees at lower levels often expressed initial enthusiasm about
having more responsibility and freedom, they soon realized the full extent of
the additional pressure that came along with it. Expectation management and sufficient training and preparation time are crucial to avoid a negative backlash. Second, in order to convert fear into excitement for new initiatives, top executives
need to define the limits of “honest mistakes” and act consistently within them
(for example, by offering promotions to those who have failed within the boundaries set for experimentation). A subsequent quote from the above-cited CEO
illustrates the point very well:
You know, you want to do only the good movies, but you have to fail. And I think
that by figuring out how to fail in an attractive and professional way, that’s the
key. . . . People suffer—you build on people and you have to sort of take them down
again. . . . I think that pushing down the responsibility for the profit to the next lower
level and embracing failure, making failure part of the business cost, part of the company, those were maybe the two most important things I did in those years.
What managers point out as crucial in such change processes is that it is not
so much about changing people’s behavior, but about changing their assumptions
and shaping their views so that they start changing themselves.
After years of decline, everybody is extremely aware of what’s going on for quite
some time and still most of the old companies struggle with adjusting to the new
realities. One of the main problems was that people, who worked in this industry
when it was extremely successful, had really bad habits because they were making
money anyway. Thus, they had to sort of re-think and re-build their structures,
which didn’t come naturally to them.
At the same time, firms need to be careful that their internal focus does not
impede “market listening,” because when significant changes take place, and
managers worry about their positions and access to resources, the attention paid
to market-related issues can decrease and weak market cues that might develop
into important trends can be missed. Therefore, it is important to involve a few
trusted clients when defining the new organizational and market-facing set-up.
Successful change initiatives that we have seen included formal executive
training in open programs to learn from executives in different industries as well
as boundary-spanning projects that would force employees to interact with colleagues from different departments and divisions, leading them to question their
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
125
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
underlying assumptions. This was accompanied by changes in the planning processes and incentive systems rewarding new styles.
Other low-growth contexts are created by economic or cyclical downturns
or when markets change or certain segments disappear due to innovations. The
speed with which markets or segments decrease or even disappear is often underestimated. The main problem is usually not that executives fail to recognize problems in their segments, but that they underestimate the urgency of shifting their
firm-unit into a new market-segment as long as the old segment and the current
business model are still generating revenues and the deterioration is slow. While
counterintuitive at first, we have seen some successful executives (especially newly
arrived ones) accelerating the downward spiral in order to create a sufficient sense
of urgency and break blockages that would have been difficult to overcome before.
However, it is a risky move and a new viable growth path should be identified
before this is done.
While firm-units in large corporations had it easier to shelve declining technologies and reallocate people to alternative activities, it is complicated for small
firms to “hibernate” themselves in meaningful ways. If an entity could not establish revenue streams from related activities to bridge that time, we saw executives
redeploying their assets and people in alternative settings. However, in a surprisingly large number of cases, executives needed outside intervention to help identify viable options. Analysis of business models and market trends of related
industries was an important exercise to create an understanding for alternative
product-segments.
Other problems originate from external factors. It is difficult for low growth,
and especially for small players in nascent markets, when current or new suppliers
are not favorably disposed to make necessary investments because they fear that
the market growth potential appears unproven:
Weak players must have strong partners . . . but strong partners aren’t much interested in weak players. We were not yet a very visible company and not yet very
strong . . . at least we were not perceived to be.
In such cases, successful companies designed a “stepping stone strategy,” as
the example of a tiny device developer from a small city in Norway illustrates.
With less than ten employees, it was too small to attract any serious contract manufacturer in spite of having a very innovative technology. The manufacturing process was demanding and needed capabilities of the highest standards, especially
for the military segment, where the board decided to concentrate all the young
firm’s resources. They first leveraged the contacts and links of the research institute they came from to get the Norwegian military as a potential customer in
the development process, which led to a small order. They were then able to
use this contract to bring on board a top-notch contract manufacturer to work
with them and set up a production line, which they relied on to build credibility
and eventually break into the U.S.-military market, sparking enough interest to
receive a small initial order. With this tailwind, they were eventually able to
win a large multimillion-dollar deal for their devices with the U.S. Marine Corps.
This flagship client enabled them to secure further significant contracts from many
126
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
European armies, ultimately helping them become the leading product in this
product-segment worldwide.
Table 1 shows the barriers and actions most specific to Quadrant 1.
The Second Quadrant: The Challenge of Linking up to Market Growth
Firm-units in this quadrant face a number of challenges similar to those in
Quadrant 1, but the situation is more serious because competitors have started to
grow, leading to loss of market share. Our findings for the firm-unit’s inability to
exploit external growth opportunities can be classified into: purely internal matters at the personal, interpersonal, and infrastructural level; and the interface
between the firm-unit with its external environment, more specifically with strategic partners and customers. A common reason for entities to be in this situation
is a fundamental problem with their offerings, but we have also come across firms
that were caught unawares when a new market segment opened up and they
found themselves simply unprepared to respond to growth. Executives need to
investigate why their units are decoupled from market developments and act with
urgency, as any delay widens the gap.
Very typical issues for firms in this quadrant are inadequately articulated
value propositions and technical difficulties with new products, as illustrated by
a small French mobile technology company, whose early years were marked by
lackluster revenue performance that trailed the market, before becoming a highgrowth firm. The CEO remarked:
It was kind of shocking to see that our potential customers were not able to use or
even to understand the potential of our technology. We had wrongly assumed that
they could work with it, but we realized that they were simply not ‘tech-savvy’
enough to use our product. This misperception was delaying our forecasted revenue
inflows significantly and competitors that were technically less good outperformed
us for quite some time.
The delay in revenues forced the company to raise a second round of venture capital much earlier than expected.
Executives of firm-units that successfully left this quadrant oversaw significant improvements in customer intimacy. Firm-units took very concrete steps
towards getting closer to their customers and engaging with them at a much deeper
level. One solution was to set up customer advisory boards to help define the right
offering and prioritize actions, as illustrated by the CEO of a small UK-based firm:
Our customers came for a full day. We showed them some of the new things we
were working on and gave them a pile of our “company dollars.” Then they went
to the table where our technical people were stationed with various prototypes,
and they put their money down on the features they liked. We used this as a
way to get their advice on which direction to head on our roadmap.
However, we found that at times even when the value propositions were
adequate, firm-units suffered from insufficient investment in marketing, especially compared to financially better-equipped competitors:
Our problem was that despite having the best technological solution in the market,
we could not out-power our U.S. competitors, who had sufficient venture capital to
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
127
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
Important
considerations
Actions
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
Important
considerations
128
Barriers
Q1
When organizations empower lower
levels significantly, they often
underestimate the extent and necessary
time for preparation, turning employees’
initial enthusiasm about more
responsibility and freedom into
frustration.
Employees need to understand how far
their empowerment reaches. Failures
within those boundaries should not
prevent them from receiving promotions
or bonuses.
Taking client as organizing principle: Executives need to
evaluate if they can engage a few trusted customers in
the reconceptualization of their entity.
Danger: duing times of significant change, managers
tend to keep their attention on defending their internal
positions and resources, and might potentially miss
weak market cues that might develop into important
trends.
Rather than focus on behavioral changes, it is important to
change the underlying assumptions. Changes in planning
processes and incentive systems (including non-monetary
ones) should follow.
It often takes external people to help
teams see how their capabilities and
resources could be applied in different
segments.
Analyze your asset
redeployability
If market take-off gets delayed,
especially small firms struggle to
hibernate themselves in meaningful
ways, while larger organizations often
shelve the technologies.
Often there is an unwillingness to change deep-seated While executives usually recognize
behaviors despite evidence than they are no longer
problems in their segments, they often
effective.
underestimate the urgency of shifting
their firm-units into new segments as long
Long-tenure employees frequently believe that their
as the old business model and market still
seniority entitles them to privileges and protections
generate revenues.
when it comes to change.
Reshape erroneous underlying
assumptions & ensure that attention
Empowerment & defining
the limits of honest mistakes on internal issues does not diminish
market sensitivity
and failures
Behaviors are influenced by how failures
impact individuals’ careers. Top-level
sponsorship of specific initiatives can
mitigate these risks in some cases, but
cannot substitute for a culture where
failure is accepted.
Customers
Markets that disappear or
are yet to take off
Generating Growth
Fear of failures and mistakes
inhibits experimental and
Old mental models, old routines &
innovative behavior
cognitive limitations
Firm-unit
TABLE 1. Barriers and Actions Most Specific to Quadrant 1
Build up a minimum amount of
credibility to get the first
partner or client and then
leverage one side to ‘upgrade’
to a better level until firm is
considered important enough
to strike alliances with impactful
partners or get big clients.
Develop a “step-stone
strategy”
Additionally, small firms face a
liability-of-size problem, despite
often having promising
technologies.
Entities will find it difficult to
secure commitment from
external partners especially
when asking them for significant
one-sided investments in which
the risk is higher due to asset
specificity.
Lack of credibility if
no proof of growth
existing
Suppliers & Strategic
Partners
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
easily overshadow all of our modest marketing activities. It was frustrating to see
how their client list grew while knowing that our product was superior.
In particular, small firms should evaluate possibilities to set up collaborative
marketing initiatives with larger partners. We have also seen small firms taking
advantage of the possibility to use partners’ employees as sales people. Quality training as well as the right incentives were crucial in successfully executing this option.
Existing business models can also lock units into unfavorable positions.
Sometimes it is the full business model, but often it is only one element (e.g., the
revenue model) that is gridlocked, which hinders exploitation of growth opportunities. For example, as the wind turbine market matures, customers’ demand for
financial support is becoming the norm. Producers who are unable to offer financing packages will, in spite of being technologically competitive, lose against competitors that push for such financing.
On the other hand, the business model is a significant source for creating
and delivering value. Too many firms trailing the market tend to focus their innovation activities excessively on product development, with less attention being
paid to understanding how new business models work or how a fine-tuning of
its elements could help to unleash the growth potential of a unit. The leader of
a medium-sized company explains this challenge:
The growth stalled. We had to look for solutions beyond just the product that would
help keep the company afloat and make it grow in the future. I realized that we had
to change the whole model.
Executives engaging in such change initiatives often need to deal with
issues of being blocked internally in their efforts due to perceived conflicts of
interest with other units. This is true especially in cases where new business models threatened to cannibalize existing revenue streams. Other purely internal challenges obstructing growth are when headquarters of large corporations respond
too slowly to requests of business units that do not have the freedom and resources to pursue critical opportunities (this is a common problem that hampers the
ability of MNCs to respond to more nimble local rivals in China). Worse than slow
reaction is poor market intelligence that leaves management oblivious to the fact
that its own growth is trailing that of its market segment.
Our findings reveal that perhaps the single most important success factor
was getting the right team to lead the change—people who were credible and
respected members of the organization and had a good track record, as well as
the necessary internal networks, to achieve the delicate task of persuading other
managers to back the initiative and to build internal momentum. It is important
to understand who “owns” existing processes and who has the power to effectively slow-down, distract, or block the intended change so that positive aspects
for those affected by change can be highlighted. Related to that, we came across
many cases where incentive systems, which are deeply ingrained in a firm’s culture, had become misaligned with the new strategic objectives—in some instances
even opposing the desired action.
On the infrastructural level, lack of alignment between structures and processes as well as bottlenecks within individual processes were among the most
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
129
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
significant barriers to link with growing markets. We came across cases where
customers expressed strong demand for solutions rather than individual products,
but firms, in spite of being aware of these demands, were not adequately organized to exploit these opportunities, as expressed by a business unit head of a
large corporation:
There are significant changes happening in this market and this segment is growing
by more than 25% on a year by year basis. But the focus within our company has
always been on a different segment. We just would need to develop a few more
products to really make a good value offering to this high-growth segment, but only
now we start to reorganize, combine units, and hire people that can address this
segment in a better way.
Our findings show that when executives undertake major internal restructurings, their firm’s age and experience are “reset” and that they are in fact dealing with a much younger organization that may not be capable of delivering
performance as quickly and as smoothly as a more mature one. If units have no
way to link to growing segments immediately, executives should evaluate if collaborating with a strategic partner can help to obtain an entry option into the
growth opportunity that can be exploited once the restructuring is completed.
Other means we came across were to secure contractual rights (such as a “right
of first refusal” to acquire a firm in the growth market) or to carry out an acquisition that would help the company to enter the growing market.
In certain cases, the reasons for lagging behind lie not within one’s own
unit, but are caused by external stakeholders. Unsuitable suppliers or partners
can be a significant part of the problem and, at times, even having the right strategic partner can lead to unsatisfactory outcomes due to poor structuring of the
relationship, as the CEO of a Dutch software firm that ended up in Q2 reflected:
First, I wondered why this collaboration didn’t work, because the partner seemed to
fit very well and they had a good reputation in the market. Then it was by chance
that I got to know why none of the sales people in our partner’s company were
willing to push our product. We had missed considering some important aspects
and it had backfired that we didn’t spend more time in the initial set-up and design
of this partnership.
Eventually the company, unable to push through a new incentive scheme
in the partner organization, had to withdraw from the alliance and look for a
more appropriate partner. The resulting delay of more than eight months cost
the firm significant money and market share.
A very common problem, specifically with smaller firms, was to neglect the
consequences of asymmetry of size, when courting much larger partners, for
whom they were usually of limited importance.
For firms in this quadrant, it has proven successful to benchmark with the
top-performing competitors within their product-segment. However, it is important for leaders to enthuse their teams to go beyond the competition, as this quote
from a unit in a medium-sized company exemplifies:
Having seen what the other leading players did, I sensed that we could go even further. To me this was vital for us, because if we had sat on the idea that initially
130
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
seemed a major step forward, we would have limited ourselves to copying it and we
wouldn’t be where we are today. That’s crystal clear.
Table 2 shows the barriers and actions most specific to Quadrant 2.
The Third Quadrant: The Challenge of Sustaining the
Growth Differential
Firm-units in this quadrant are growing faster than their product segments,
and their major challenge is to sustain the high growth differential with respect to
competitors. This presents a different set of challenges compared to the first and
second quadrants. While some might say that these are “challenges of the privileged,” they can in fact be, as the following quote illustrates, the breeding ground
for significant problems later on:
It really came as a surprise, because it suddenly was as if we had hit a glass ceiling
and more and more problems appeared in a picture that until then seemed flawless.
It wasn’t that we had one single and obvious big issue, but the accumulation of
many small ones that started to reinforce themselves in a negative way leading to
an overall erosion of our competitiveness and growth. Despite the success wave
we had been surfing on until then, I needed to accept that we had to restructure
the whole company if we wanted to be successful in the long term. You can stretch
resources only so far, but beyond you start harming yourself.
Challenges in this quadrant are often marked by issues around scalability
(internally as well as with external partners), the need to sustain quality across
all functions, the monitoring of internal complexity levels and coordination costs,
as well as increased competitive pressure. Resistance to change during success is
also a common issue, as the business unit leader in a large organization illustrates:
I saw that competitors started to copy elements of our model and to narrow the gap.
However, all the lower management staff strongly opposed me when I really
wanted to initiate organizational change, because they didn’t understand why
I wanted to change an organization that actually was very successful and even considered a benchmark in the industry.
Executives know well that they must put in systems, hire people, and make
investments to accommodate and sustain the high growth of the firm. However,
the need for some slack managerial resources that can be dedicated to setting
up suitable systems and to reacting to unexpected crises, without being tied-up
with daily activities, is often forgotten.
Another successful strategy among companies in our sample that scaled
well was to move forward in a controlled manner by introducing novelty on only
one dimension (either a new product, market, or business model) and growing
into adjacencies that ideally reinforced their core product or service. In this way,
a venture could benefit from existing synergies and leverage its brand without distracting the organization with growth possibilities unrelated to the core.
A different scalability challenge for many firms was the unpleasant surprise
of realizing that suppliers or partners were not able to keep pace with their
growth. While during low-growth phases such problems usually did not surface,
they could disrupt the growing firm’s development significantly, opening the
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
131
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
Important considerations
Actions
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
Important considerations
132
Barriers
Q2
Conflicts arise when firmunits experiment with
business models that could
cannibalize revenue streams
of other units.
Understand who ‘owns’
existing processes and who
has the power to effectively
slow-down, distract, or block
the intended change so that
positive aspects for those
affected can be developed.
Make relevant internal
stakeholders part of the
initiative early. Sequence
coalition building by bringing
on board most supportive
individual in order to build
momentum.
Install a credible leader
to build momentum
and mitigate conflicts
early on
Other mechanisms: securing
contractual rights (such as
right of first refusal) or
carrying out acquisitions to
enter new segment/market.
Collaborating with a strategic
partner can help obtain an
entry option to growth
opportunity, which can be
exploited after restructuring
is completed.
Secure an ‘entry ticket’
into the growth
opportunity
After major restructuring,
firm’s age/experience is
“reset” and managers deal
with much ‘younger and less
capable entities.
New growth initiatives
are blocked due to
internal conflicts of
interest
Growth can also be inhibited
if headquarters of large
corporations respond slowly
to requests of distant
business units.
Bottlenecks within or
lack of alignment
between structures &
processes + current
restructuring efforts
hinder growth
Firm-unit
Insufficient marketing
Customers
To make this meaningful,
high-quality training as well
as adequate incentives needs
Provide direct exposure to be provided.
to customers on as
many levels as possible.
Set up customer
advisory boards and/or
user group meetings.
Set up cooperative
marketing with partners
Significantly
in ecosystem and
leverage their employees
improve customer
intimacy at all levels as sales people
Understand if problem
is only with marketing
or with fundamental
value proposition.
Understand implications of
business model changes, e.g.
sales people might need to be
retrained if your firm is moving
from component to solution
sales.
Study business models in
other industries and
evaluate their applicability
to firm-unit
Business model adaptation is
often more difficult (and feels
less tangible than product
developments or entry into new
market), but can have more
impact long term. Sometimes
full business model, but often
only one element (e.g. revenue
model), is gridlocked which
hinders exploitation of growth
opportunities.
Business model lock-in,
but many keep
overemphasis on product
development
Linking up to Market Growth
Frequently, small innovative
firms lose marketing battles
against financially better
equipped competitors
despite having better
Often, clients perceive
company’s differentiation technology.
differently from the firm. Many firms wrongly focus
solely on product/service
features, instead of value
created for customers.
Poorly articulated
value proposition
and lack of
customer intimacy
TABLE 2. Barriers and Actions most specific to Quadrant 2
Benchmark with
top-performers within
own product-market,
but try to go beyond
Evaluate strategies that are
difficult to imitate or attack
as a result of competitors
being locked into their
existing business models and
partnerships.
Often, it is difficult to
influence or incentivize the
employees in partner’s
organization directly
responsible for operational
aspects of collaboration, but
crucial for making this a
success.
Problematic if segment is
characterized by high
switching costs or network
effects.
Each day of trailing the
market makes it more
difficult to close the market
share gap.
Competitors quickly
widening gap
Competitors
Redesign incentives,
re-align strategies,
or change partners if
necessary
Entities in this quadrant find
it difficult to attract or keep
good partners aligned and
motivated if growth is not
realized or is delayed.
Weak, incorrectly
structured or wrong
strategic partnerships
Suppliers & Strategic
Partners
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
door for competitors to catch up. Consequently, our findings point to the need for
executives to carefully evaluate the ability and willingness to grow of their mission-critical suppliers and partners.
On the positive side, business heads used their strong market position to
win value-adding strategic partners that helped to cement their market dominance and triggered further growth.
We are not so big, but we are the front-runner in our industry. The package we sell
includes cutting-edge technologies and our business model has very innovative elements. But most importantly, we have chosen a completely different approach to
business than our competitors. . . . It looks like we took the right decision, because
it opened the door to become the exclusive worldwide partner for one of the largest
corporations in the world.
Maintaining quality across functions appeared to be a critical challenge to
sustain the firm’s competitive advantage. If key performance indicators focus on
pushing growth at all cost, customer satisfaction and retention might be negatively
impacted, leading to a slow renewal and high churn rate. Successful executives
from our sample did evaluate the types of clients they were losing and the financial
and strategic implications of customer acquisition vs. retention in order to strike the
right balance. Moreover, good monitoring allowed for greater flexibility in processing information and responding faster to customers’ needs, as the following quote
from a medium-sized firm shows:
In each and every market that we have been in, we drove at least at double the
speed of growth than the second best in the market—and that’s for a period of
ten years. We have done many changes since I became the CEO, but most important is that everyone in the group has passion for what we do and that is based
on and reinforced by empowerment and agility. This allows us to be closer to
our customers, to better understand them as well as the trends in the markets.
We have better service and better yields in everything we do. Furthermore, we
measure all important key performance indicators on a daily or weekly basis.
We can react to anything that happens in the market and quicker than our competitors.
Along the same theme, we found that it was generally very difficult for
firms to retain the same level of quality in the recruitment process. Too often,
heads of firms diverted their attention from this issue and believed that having
an excellent core was enough to sustain success, but even seemingly small erosions in the quality of talent had disproportionally large effects on the companies’
future performance.
For a long time we were able to hire really great talents despite our rapid growth,
but at some point this had changed—but we realized it only in hindsight and way
too late.
Top executives should remain involved to ensure the right level of quality
in the recruitment and retention process, especially as during high-growth phases
today’s middle managers will quickly become tomorrow’s senior managers.
Finally, a specific challenge in this quadrant is that success in a segment
will quickly attract competitors: both existing firms and new entrants. These new
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
133
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
competitors may come from unexpected directions and thus alter the business
landscape.
We are the “Rolls Royce” in our market and we have a very good reputation, but
we are losing our USPs [unique selling propositions] due to strong competitors that
are now entering our segment even from international markets. . . . Due to all these
changes in the competitive landscape, our negotiation position has become a lot
weaker . . . large customers can almost impose contractual conditions as they want.
Problems can arise quickly if the entry of new players leads to a price war that
has not been anticipated by the incumbents, leading to deviations in planned return
on investment. Fast-followers with lower cost structures can “piggyback” on a market leader who has paved the way with high investments and can enter the market
with cheaper products. An example of such challenges is the fast-moving consumer
goods sector, where we have seen products losing their unique selling propositions to
imitators and competitors that had adapted their cheaper products so they could be
used with the installed proprietary systems of the market leader. Further, educational value-added services for customers soon become a huge cost burden without
returns when clients, after learning what is important, switch to competitors with
lower product prices (and no such services).
Since competitors from the same industry did not provide appropriate
benchmarks, it was important for firms in this quadrant to use benchmarks from
top-performers in other industries that offered conceptually similar value propositions (e.g., products to the mass market) to articulate challenging aspirations and
bring on board people who could make these aspirations a reality.
Table 3 shows the barriers and actions most specific to Quadrant 3.
The Fourth Quadrant: The Challenge of Managing Growth
Firm-entities in this quadrant face a situation in which there are abundant
market-induced growth opportunities available, and managers are faced with the
challenge of exploiting them to the fullest. This scenario is characterized by a
series of trade-offs, of which we outline the most essential ones. In order to do
this, we depart from the format we have followed for the first three quadrants
(barriers and actions). See Table 4.
Performance Metrics: Short-Term vs. Long-Term
Decisions about the appropriate performance metrics at different stages of
growth will have a significant impact on the development of an organization.
One of the biggest challenges for managers was to balance short-term and longterm aspects and translate them into appropriate performance metrics. Executives
from Vodafone Spain (formerly Airtel) stated for example:
It wasn’t until about 1998-1999 that we really started to look at churn. It was all
about getting new customers and trying to get more market share or at least maintain market share in a growing market.
Focus at this stage should be on exploiting short-term growth opportunities
that help to maximize competitive advantage even if these are only temporary.
134
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
Important considerations
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
Actions
Important considerations
Barriers
Q3
Executives need to create slack
for building sustainable growth
infrastructure, but also to react
to unforseen developments and
growth crises.
Managerial slack to
build sustainable
growth engine
Frequently, the sum of many
small ‘invisible‘ problems, rather
than large single issues,
negatively reinforce themselves
to develop a critical
momentum, bringing the
growth spurt to an end.
Small ‘invisible’
problems accumulate
and disrupt the growth
spurt
Important for people affected to
understand reason and
advantages of change for their
entity and themselves.
Leaders need to provide
ambitious and motivating
projects – ideally by moving into
adjacencies that reinforce the
core and leverage synergies.
Ambitious projects and
controlled growth
moves
Creating urgency for singnificant
changes is difficult if the
organization has been successful
and is still growing.
Complacency,
over-confidence and
resistance to change a
successful organization
Firm-unit
Quality recruitment standards
should be established and
maintained at all levels.
This task should not be
completely delegated by
top-management teams – even
during high growth.
Maintain high recruiting
standards
Heads of firms divert their
attention during growth phases
from recruiting, but even small
erosions of quality have
disproportionate effects on future
performance if growth is high.
Declining quality of new
employees recruited
during high growth
Dependence on partners
(logistics, technology providers,
etc.) for growth is high. Evaluate
their capacity to scale on a
sustained basis.
Probability of this is high when
key performance indicators are
solely focused on ‘new growth’related measures, neglecting
customer retention.
To minimize churn & ensure
sustainable performance, KPIs
should be combined: churn is
subtracted from new sales to
incentivize the sales team to
balance “hunting” and “farming”
activities.
Control the level and quality of
clients lost.
Smaller companies that partner
with larger ones should evaluate
consequences of contractual
restrictions, to avoid being locked
into alliance with partner that has
changed priorities or is divesting
the unit you are currently
attached to.
Leverage market
position to strike deals
Understand strategic
with partners that can
implications of customer help to cement leading
acquisition vs. retention market position
Negative impact are usually seen
with lag only, making it so
dangerous.
Stragegic partners not
as scalable or do not
want to grow at same
speed
Suppliers & Strategic
Partners
Excessive focus on
growth can affect
customer satisfaction and
retention, leading to low
renewal and high churn
Customers
Sustaining Growth Differential
TABLE 3. Barriers and Actions Most Specific to Quadrant 3
Being a benchmark in one’s
industry, firm-units should look
for suitable reference points in
other sectors.
Increase entry barriers
and benchmark with
top-performers from
other industries
Challenges arise when
fast-followers with lower cost
structures and cheaper products
‘piggyback’ on market leader who
has paved way with high
investments.
Such situations attract
competition from unexpected
quarters, whose entry changes
competitive dynamics in
unanticipated ways.
Dealing with
aggressively entering
competitors
Competitors
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
135
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
Trade-offs
Important considerations
136
Q4
VOL. 54, NO. 4
For mission-critical positions, if
possible, hire experienced people
that can provide stability.
Culture is usually diluted
by large intakes of
employees. Emphasizing
(founder-driven) values
through clear signals &
simple symbolic stories
from the start can
provide reference points
& stability far beyond the
early days.
Appropriate quality
depends on quality of
competitors’ offerings.
Need to be a little
better and keep
improving, to avoid
delaying time-to-market,
and thus reduce field
experience and
customer intimacy.
Partnerships with tier-1 players
can help to grow quickly in
good times and boost brand,
but if partner withdraws from
alliance, it could send negative
signals to existing partnerecosystem and client pool,
leading to a severe crisis.
Small players that lack the
incentives to attract established
suppliers/partners and that
cannot overcome the power
asymmetry, are better off
working with committed tier 2
suppliers.
Early employees who have grown
with company and are in leadership
roles are often unwilling to step aside.
Forced changes might lead to
disruptions and loss of morale at
lower levels.
Focus should be on
exploiting shortterm growth
opportunities that
help to maximize
competitive
advantage.
Suppliers & Strategic
Partners
Best suppliers or
strategic partners vs.
Someone less good,
but committed
Customers
Managing Growth
Culture & values:
Performance Employees & recruitment: Investing in
culture from the Product: Quality
Keeping/training old
metrics:
start vs. Leaving vs. Speed to
employees vs. Hiring
Short-term
market
it for later
vs. Long-term experienced outsiders
Firm-unit
TABLE 4. Trade-Offs in Quadrant 4
Competitors should be
monitored to ensure
they are not capturing
higher share of new
customers. However ,
main focus should be on
exploiting the market
opportunities to the
fullest extent.
Focus:
Competitors vs.
Market
opportunities
Competitors
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
Leaders need to live with this less than perfect internal situation and keep a razor
sharp focus on the market to ensure that there is no loss of market share.
Employees and Recruitment: Keeping/Training Old Employees vs. Hiring
Experienced Outsiders
Companies that experience rapid growth in an explosive market will typically face the crucial decision of keeping or replacing the people that brought the
firm to this level of success (among them the founders of the business). The following quote from a middle manager illustrates the situation well:
Now, even the middle managers have to start running the company by numbers. . . .
I’ve never run a company like this and I’m here every day making mistakes—and so
does everybody else, despite the fact that they all have grown incredibly. But we need
to understand and accept that we are now at a stage where it’s just necessary to hire
five top-managers, because it is too much for the current middle managers. It’s not
any longer fair to push them so hard.
The decision for CEOs or firm-unit heads becomes difficult as the early
employees have successfully built the company to date and often represent a strong
part of the company’s culture. Even if the founders agree to step down and have
other people take over their jobs, they often find that they are unable to work under
a new head. For the new manager, founders are insiders with a lot of intangible
knowledge and contacts; at the same time, they could undermine their authority
as they have much closer links with the existing employee base. Firms that managed
this transition smoothly benefited from a combination of the founder-CEO’s humility and the new CEO’s conviction that the previous CEO was necessary for the
future.
A second issue is whether firm-units should hire talented people who can
grow into specific jobs or hire people with expertise for the bigger roles they will
inevitably have as a result of growth. Based on many interviews with high-growth
companies, mission-critical positions should, if possible, be filled with people who
have done the job before and are “bigger than the job” at the current stage of the
firm’s development. This helps to add much needed stability to the firm that is
facing ambiguity and destabilizing forces in a high-growth environment. However, in a high-growth market within a high-growth economy (such as the IT
industry in India), middle and senior managers might be hard to come by, and
there might be no alternative to exposing youngsters early to positions of greater
responsibility. This inevitably increases risks in the execution stages.
Culture and Values: Investing in Building a Culture from the Start vs.
Leaving It for Later
Early employees in rapidly growing firms tend to become nostalgic about the
start-up days and the great culture and atmosphere that existed when everyone
knew each other. Operating in this quadrant means that this period is over rather
quickly and companies have to digest employee intakes of immense magnitudes.
Infosys Technologies, a major Indian IT services company, is a good example, with
net employee growth of nearly 25,000 in the 2007-2008 financial year. This means
that new projects are constantly being undertaken and structures and processes are
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
137
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
being continuously revamped. Such an environment does not appeal to everybody
and the dramatic pressure and stress causes many employees to leave.
We have seen two kinds of organizational responses to this challenge. One
consists of managers resigning themselves to the fact that organizational culture in
periods of such high growth will be less than optimal. The other is the approach taken
by Infosys, which took great pains to proactively signal its values to its stakeholders
before the market started to experience high growth. These values—meritocracy,
fairness, transparency, and integrity—became institutionalized through pithy sentences and stories. “In God we trust, everybody else brings data to the table,” communicated a culture of decisions made based on data and facts. “Let the good news take
the stairs, and the bad news the elevator”—signaled a culture of proactively sharing
bad news with stakeholders. There were also stories of founder behaviors that
became institutionalized and served as powerful control mechanisms. As these values have become known, Infosys has found it easier than its rivals to attract employees who share Infosys’s values and retain them.
We started the company in July 1981 . . . even when we formed it, the foundation
for our values was so strong. . . . Values are something that you don’t articulate—
they are something that you live in and then you articulate that it is very important.
Product: Quality vs. Speed-to-Market
Companies operating in high-growth markets are pressured to have high
speed-to-market in order to capture as much of the market growth as possible. This
can lead to higher error rates and quality problems with the product or service.
Management teams should be aware that not everything will go right and that
absolute control is neither possible nor necessary. They should try to avoid the most
critical and damaging errors, but not strive for perfection during such periods of
high growth. The quality that needs to be delivered is relative. A firm’s value propositions only need to be a little better than competitors and keep improving.
Partnering with a Tier-1 vs. Tier-2 Player
While the potential benefits of partnering with large and well-known players are obvious, waiting for a big player to agree in a high-growth market is a risky
strategy. When it comes to negotiations with strategic partners, smaller size usually means less power in negotiations, with regard to such things as payment
terms and risk sharing. Therefore, an ambitious and fast-moving tier-2 player is
sometimes a better partner.
Your own ambitions always drive you to partner with the big names and of course
it also signals a certain credibility if you can say that your partner is HP or whatever.
However, if I really take a critical look at the input vs. output ratio from the partnerships we had with such large players, I doubt that our investments regarding time
and money were paying off—at least in our case. I believe if we had acted earlier
with a smaller partner instead of spending so much time in trying to get the big
guys, we’d be in a better situation today.
Partnerships with tier-1 players can be a double-edged sword: they can help
you grow quickly in good times and boost your brand, but if the partner withdraws
138
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
from the alliance, it could send negative signals to your existing partner-ecosystem
and client pool, setting in motion a negative domino-effect.
Focus: Competitors or Market Opportunities
Growth leaders have to choose between focusing on their own company
and resources and focusing on competitors and their strategic moves. As a general
rule, focusing on the moves of known competitors is less important than ensuring
that the new growth opportunities are being exploited to the optimal level.
You don’t even know who your competitors are, because even other players in this
space are still shooting around and trying to figure out what they should focus on.
The one caveat we would add to this norm is to keep an eye on new
entrants, who can fundamentally change the dynamics of the market.
Growth Trajectories
It is also important to realize the dynamic nature of the framework. Research
on high-growth firms has shown that rapid growth is most effectively managed
when the knowledge and resources needed to make a transition are developed
ahead of time, before the pressures of growth force a reactive response. Therefore,
we would like to encourage managers not only to react to the challenges of the
quadrant they are currently in, but to chart out their growth trajectory and prepare
for the challenges they will face in the future. There exist three different growth trajectories from each quadrant that have all been represented within our sample,
though some more often than others. Entities that transition unwillingly from Q1
into Q2, thus undergoing a market-induced change trajectory, will continue to
struggle with typical Q1-issues, but face additional challenges put upon them from
external players. At the same time they will need to quickly solve underlying internal issues that might not have been as apparent before. Units able to actively move
from Q1 to Q3 are encouraged to reap the benefits of growth and exploit this
momentum to the fullest, but need to be careful with opening up too many new
sources of growth at once and at the cost of underestimating the time and resources
it takes to keep their organization efficient in the long term. While these two
growth trajectories are the most probable ones, some nascent markets (e.g., certain
mobile technology segments) can go from no growth to explosive growth in a very
limited time span, thus describing a Q1-to-Q4 growth trajectory, which is very challenging as the management approaches in the two contexts are so radically different. Not only organizational infrastructure, but also mental models and activities
need to be quickly shifted from an efficiency and generating-growth focus to one
of managing-growth. Executives should focus on evaluating and strengthening
their most mission-critical processes to avoid an unexpected underperformance or
collapse once the market growth picks up.
Units in Q2 move—in the positive case—towards Q4 after overcoming
their growth barriers. With this trajectory, they enter a high-growth market.
The problem often is that newly established processes are not yet stress-tested.
If product-segment growth stalls before the firm-unit has been able to catch up
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
139
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
(Q2-to-Q1-trajectory), then the product-segment growth rate will again equal
that of the firm-unit, but the market share gap will be considerable, leaving future
growth possible only at the expense of the other incumbent players who will usually be in much stronger positions. Firms need to seriously consider if it still makes
sense to pursue this segment under such conditions. From our data, we have
found that going from Q2 to Q3 is extremely rare.
Entities in Q3 will—if other competitors catch up with them and the market starts to accelerate—be moved into a Q4-scenario. Despite coming from a
strong position, this is a “moment of truth.” Leaders need to transition their
organizations into a different mindset—while previously many things will have
been done proactively, now units also need to react and potentially compete with
very different types of players.
Finally, a direct Q4-to-Q1 trajectory, where the growth of the market and
its players tapers off unexpectedly fast, is the typical bust situation after a bubble
period. Otherwise, we seldom find this trajectory. More probable are transitions
through two routes, with some players going through Q2, and others through
Q3. Despite the latter ones being on a slightly more advantageous path, if this
dynamic takes place within a short time, all affected firm-units will struggle as
their staffing, processes, and mindset have been attuned for growth, whereas they
might quickly need to go into a retrench mode.
Conclusions
The existing literature has developed very good insights on how to make
resource allocation decisions within a portfolio of business units, but it does not
provide evidence-based prescriptions on how to manage entities within different
growth contexts. We have presented a framework that maps out four stylized
growth scenarios and illustrates the challenges and trade-offs firm-units face in
each of them, as well as the most appropriate actions needed to tackle them. Executives need to analyze growth at the more-granular level of product-segment
combinations (instead of other higher level classifications) that take into account
the growth of a unit relative to its product-segment. Further, we suggest that
managers take a dynamic perspective and understand that their entity’s growthtrajectory future situations might demand different managerial skills and behaviors. Such an approach will enable a better understanding of the specific barriers,
more-precise action plans, and more-effective strategic behavior.
This emphasis on a more-granular level of analysis will also avoid an erroneous reading of the competitive situation or a poor definition of strategic priorities. For example, while leaders need to respond with great urgency in a Q2
scenario (where product-segment growth is high) in order to prevent a widening
of the gap with respect to competitors who are already ahead, speed of response is
less of a critical issue in a Q1 scenario (where competitors are also experiencing
low growth). For this, good market intelligence is critical. True problems arise if
executives believe they are in either a Q1-context, a Q3-context, or a Q4-context,
whereas they are actually in a Q2-scenario, not realizing that their competitors
did in fact grow or grew faster than them. We came across the latter problem a
140
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
number of times when perceived high-growth in absolute terms (say 35%) gave
managers a feeling of satisfaction, but was in fact significantly below the productsegment growth (say 60%).
In summary, this approach of developing a more-nuanced understanding
of a firm-unit’s growth situation at the product-segment combination level allows
for a much more customized and sustainable strategic treatment.
Notes
1. W.E. Hoover Jr., “Making China your second home market: An interview with the CEO of
Danfoss,” The McKinsey Quarterly, 1 (2006): 85-93.
2. For example, see M.E. Raynor, The Innovator’s Solution: Creating and Sustaining Successful Growth
(Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press, 2003); R.G. McGrath and I.C. MacMillan, “MarketBusting: Strategies for Exceptional Business Growth,” Harvard Business Review, 83/3 (2002): 8089; J. Irvin, L. Pedro, and P. Gennaro, “Strategy from the Inside Out: Lessons in Creating Organic
Growth,” Journal of Business Strategy, 24/5 (2003): 10-14.
3. There exists a rich empirical literature, for example see: E.G. Flamholtz, Managing the Transition
from an Entrepreneurship to a Professionally Managed Firm (San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass,
1986); R.K. Kazanjian, “Relation of Dominant Problems to Stages of Growth in TechnologyBased New Ventures,” Academy of Management Journal, 31 (June 1988): 257-279.
4. On new venture growth, see: B.A. Gilbert, P.P. McDougall, and D.B. Audretsch, “New Venture
Growth: A Review and Extension,” Journal of Management, 32/6 (December 2006): 926-950.
On knowledge and learning in growth, see: A. Macpherson and R. Holt, “Knowledge, Learning and Small Firm Growth: A Systematic Review of the Evidence,” Research Policy, 36/2
(March 2007): 172-192; R. Phelps, R. Adams, and J. Bessant, “Life Cycles of Growing Organizations: A Review with Implications for Knowledge and Learning,” International Journal of
Management Reviews, 9/1 (March 2007): 1-30. On small business growth, see: M. Dobbs and
R.T. Hamilton, “Small Business Growth: Recent Evidence and New Directions,” International
Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research, 13/5 (2007): 296-322. On measure constructs
in growth, see: D. Shepherd and J. Wiklund, “Are We Comparing Apples with Apples or
Apples with Oranges? Appropriateness of Knowledge Accumulation across Growth Studies,”
Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 33/1 (January 2009): 105-123. On an economic-oriented
perspective on growth, see: A. Coad, “Firm Growth: A Survey,” Papers on Economics and Evolution 2007-03, Max Planck Institute of Economics, Evolutionary Economics Group, Jena,
Germany.
5. Among the most significant problems are: the unit of analysis and the resulting lack of granularity;
research approaches that have been unable to detect or factor in the changing nature of firms’
growth goals over time; temporal delays or temporal effects; applying analytic methods (such as
regressions) that assume linear growth paths; studies that do not distinguish between different
growth modes; measuring growth (employees vs. revenues vs. profits vs. mixed or other constructs); studies that do not account for companies in their sample that falsely were assumed to
have a high willingness to grow; and insufficient attention paid to characteristics of the external
environments, specifically the varying speeds of growth in different product-segments.
6. A. McKelvie and J. Wiklund, “Advancing Firm Growth Research: A Focus on Growth Mode
Instead of Growth Rate,” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 34/2 (March 2010): 261-288.
7. Coad, op. cit., p. 186.
8. Gilbert, McDougall, and Audretsch, op. cit.
9. L.E. Greiner, “Evolution and Revolution as Organizations Grow,” Harvard Business Review, 50/4
(July/August 1972): 37-46.
10. I. Ansoff, “Strategies for Diversification,” Harvard Business Review, 35/5 (September/October
1957): 113-124.
11. B. Henderson, “The Experience Curve Reviewed: The Growth-Share Matrix or the Product
Portfolio,” BCG Perspectives, No. 135 (1973).
12. This framework sought to address the perceived shortcomings of the BCG framework.
13. This framework was developed by Shell in the mid-1970s and incorporated sector attractiveness and the company’s competitive capabilities as the two dimensions.
14. See W.J. Abernathy and K.B. Clark, “Innovation: Mapping the Winds of Creative Destruction,”
Research Policy, 14/1 (February 1985): 3-22; L. Rosenkopf and M.L. Tushman, “Organizational
CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
141
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.
For the exclusive use of K. Hernandez, 2022.
Managing in Different Growth Contexts
Determinants of Technological Change: Towards a Sociology of Technological Evolution,”
Research in Organizational Behavior, 14 (1992): 311-347.
15. For example, see W. Mitchell, “Whether and When? Probability and Timing of Incumbents
Entry into Emerging Industrial Subfields,” Administrative Science Quarterly, 34/2 (June 1989):
208-230; H.W. Chesbrough, “The Organizational Impact of Technological Change: A Comparative Theory of National Institutional Factors,” Industrial and Corporate Change, 8/3 (September
1999): 447-485; M. Tripsas, “Unraveling the Process of Creative Destruction: Complementary
Assets and Incumbent Survival in the Typesetter Industry,” Strategic Management Journal, 18
(Summer 1997): 119-142.
16. McKelvie and Wiklund, op. cit., p. 280.
17. Each author classified the firm-units independently. At full consensus it was classified under
the respective quadrant. Otherwise, the specific case was discussed until a consensus was
reached. There were differences in less than 5% of all cases.
California Management Review, Vol. 54, No. 4, pp. 118–142. ISSN 0008-1256, eISSN 2162-8564. © 2012
by The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved. Request permission to photocopy or
reproduce article content at the University of California Press’s Rights and Permissions website at
http://www.ucpressjournals.com/reprintinfo.asp. DOI: 10.1525/cmr.2012.54.4.118.
142
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
VOL. 54, NO. 4
SUMMER 2012
CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
This document is authorized for use only by Korey Hernandez in MGMT 614 Entrepreneurship:Growth Strategies-1 taught by ELIZABETH SIKKENGA, Eastern Michigan University from Jan
2022 to Jul 2022.

Purchase answer to see full
attachment
Explanation & Answer:

6 Sentences

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool’s honor code & terms of service.

Get 20% Discount on This Paper
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Try it now!

Get 20% Discount on This Paper

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Ace Writing Center has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.

Essays

Essay Writing Services

At Ace Writing Center, Nowadays, students normally have extremely busy schedules. You will note that some of them have to take on some evening or weekend jobs in order to get some income that can help them to sustain in college or in the university. This can deny them a chance to write all the essays given. Others usually get bombarded with a lot of work by their lecturers. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. However, some of them usually try to work on all these essays but end up delivering their work late. This can prevent them from graduating since most lecturers are strict on deadlines. If you want to write a business essay, the wise way is to hire an outstanding essay writing service like us, so that you can get the best results. If you are keen, you will note that many companies usually overcharge their customers. Some of them are there only to make money. And in reality, they really don’t care to build a long term commitment with students. You should not choose such companies. You should take your time and choose a reliable company to work with. Ace Writing Center is the ultimate solution for you. We have been offering our writing service for more than 7 years. This is a clear indication that you will get quality essay writing service. We have a wide range of writers who can work on any business essay that you might have. We believe in doing extensive research so that we can provide quality work to all our clients. .

Admissions

Admission and Business Papers

Have you ever had to write an admission essay for college? The majority of students face the same issues when applying to a university or college and many in such situations decide they need professional help to cope with this matter. They get in a situation when the deadline keeps coming closer but lack motivation to start because they are just not sure if their writing skills are strong enough. We have a solution for you! Ace Writing Center is the best admission essay writing service with a large professional team and years of experience in providing high-quality papers to students of all levels and faculties. The mission of our team is to help students make their dreams of entering a good college come true and that’s what we offer!.

Editing

Editing and Proofreading

Sometimes all the words for your paper just flow out of your mind and into your fingers. You type quickly at your keyboard and there they are, your beautiful words right there on the screen. But you have no idea how to polish it up. You may be wishing there was a paper writing service that offered this type of writing service. Look no more! Here at Ace Writing Center, we offer you an editing and proofreading option that you can't find anywhere else..

Coursework

College Essay Writing

In case you are familiar Ace Writing Center, you know the way to distinguish a better company from a cheap one exactly. First of all, poor service website does not have a sufficient support. We think support team is an essential part of success; it has to answer all clients’ questions and be a connecting link between clients and their writers. On our web-service you will get answers about anything you need and your writer will receive all your instructions, assignments and requirements exactly and swiftly. A writing service that we run has got a flexible pricing system that will save you from senseless wastes and many bonus systems that let you sparing money for something important for you.