Alibaba and Global Supply Chains
This activity is important because, as a manager, you must be able to understand global
production and supply chain management as they relate to the firm’s overall strategy.
The goal of this exercise is to demonstrate your understanding of global production and
supply chain management—where production should be located, whether to outsource
production, and how to manage the process from raw materials to the end consumer.
Read the case and answer the questions that follow.
Alibaba Group Holding Limited (alibaba.com) was founded in 1999 by Jack Ma as an ecommerce company to facilitate sales among companies that provide consumer-toconsumer, business-to-consumer, and business-to-business products that are sold via
the Internet. As the world’s largest e-commerce platform, Alibaba is on a path to realizing
its vision of facilitating $1 trillion in product sales annually as it also pursues a goal of
reaching 2 billion consumers. The company is headquartered in Hangzhou, Zhejiang,
China, has a revenue of more than 23 billion U.S. dollars (primarily via advertisements on
its sites), and employs about 51,000 people.
Alibaba’s global supply chains are constrained tremendously on “Singles Day” or
Guanggun Jie, a Chinese holiday celebrated on November 11, the solitary ones of the
date—11.11—suggesting “bare branches,” the common slang for singles in China. On
this day alone, more than $20 billion in sales, or more than 300 million orders, takes place
on Alibaba’s Internet platforms (e.g., Tmall, Taobao). When global retailers think of megasales online, they generally think of Black Friday or Cyber Monday, but they ought to be
watching 11.11 closely as well, especially as 11.11 doubles the combined sales of those
U.S. e-commerce holidays.
Each year, Alibaba handles more than 80 percent of China’s e-commerce business. The
company now operates in 190 countries. Moving forward, the vision for Alibaba is simple:
Bring in non-Chinese brands to the Chinese market and expand products to customers
outside of China’s borders. So far, the impact is clear. Beyond its own employees, Jack
Ma claims that Alibaba has created more than 30 million jobs in China related to
companies that sell their products on the Alibaba e-commerce platforms. Ma has also
committed to create 1 million new jobs in the U.S. With such a large scope, the global
supply chains that Alibaba facilitates have to be top-notch, innovative, and always
pushing the boundaries for what can be done in delivering products from manufacturers
to consumers.
Alibaba does this by focusing on a differentiation strategy, partner connections, buyer
protection, mobile technology, and large-scale product selections. Alibaba’s
differentiation strategy entails operating as an intermediary, connecting buyers and
sellers while largely avoiding the need for maintaining capital-intensive warehouses and
depots. Partnering with Alibaba enables small manufacturers and suppliers to reach
thousands, and likely tens of thousands, of new customers. Importantly, in these buyer–
seller exchanges, Alibaba emphasizes buyer protection. That is, if a customer is not
satisfied for any reason, he or she can make a refund request. This consumer focus also
carries over to how customers interact with the company. Alibaba has seamlessly
adapted its e-commerce sites to mobile platforms, an important part of its strategy given
that more than 80 percent is done via mobile devices. The large-scale product selection
that can be found on the Alibaba platforms has resulted in some 15 billion products being
sold annually and 15 million packages being shipped daily (compared with 5 billion items
on Amazon and 3 million packages per day).
Sources: “How to Cut Supply Chain Costs: 6 Lessons From Alibaba,” UNA Purchasing
Solutions, March 26, 2017; Frank Lavin, “Alibaba’s Singles’ Day: What We Know about the
World’s Biggest Shopping Event,” Forbes, November 6, 2016; Bob Bryan, “Alibaba Just
Proved It’s More Than Just Some Chinese Company,” Business Insider, November 15, 2015;
Catherine Cadell, “Alibaba Posts Record Singles Day Sales, But Growth
Slows,” Technology News, November 11, 2016; Jake Novak, “Here’s the Really Brilliant Thing
about Trump’s Meeting with Alibaba’s Jack Ma,” CNBC, January 10, 2017; Brian Deagon,
“Alibaba’s Audacious Goal to Reach $1 Trillion in Merchandise Sales,” Investor’s Business
Daily, May 6, 2016; Catherine Clifford, “By the Numbers: Amazon vs. Alibaba,” Entrepreneur,
July 13, 2015; Nick Wells, “A Tale of Two Companies: Matching Up Alibaba vs.
Amazon,” CNBC, May 5, 2016.
Global Business Today 11e
by Charles W.L. Hill
and G. Tomas M. Hult
©VIPRESIONA/Shutterstock
©McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. Authorized only for instructor use in the classroom. No reproduction or further distribution permitted without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
©McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. Authorized only for instructor use in the classroom. No reproduction or further distribution permitted without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
Part 6: International Business Functions
Chapter 15: Global Production and
Supply Chain Management
©McGraw-Hill Education
Source: ©Wu changqing/ICHPL Imaginechina/AP Images
Learning Objectives
15-1
Explain why global production and supply-chain management
decisions are of central importance to many global companies.
15-2
Explain how country differences, production technology, and
production factors all affect the choice of where to locate production
activities.
15-3
Recognize how the role of foreign subsidiaries in production can be
enhanced over time as they accumulate knowledge.
15-4
Identify the factors that influence a firm’s decision of whether to
source supplies from within the company or from foreign suppliers.
15-5
Understand the functions of logistics and purchasing (sourcing)
within global supply chains.
15-6
Describe what is required to efficiently manage a global supply
chain.
©McGraw-Hill Education
Opening Case:
Procter & Gamble Remakes Its Global Supply Chains
P&G has been an MNC for more than a century
Consumer packaged goods are a highly competitive
industry
• More fragmentation and specialization in industry
allows smaller firms to compete with giants like P&G
P&G responded by redesigning distribution network
• Developing supply chains jointly with core suppliers
• Maximizing synergies in production
• Increasing transparency through the end-to-end supply
chain
©McGraw-Hill Education
Introduction
In today’s global economy, firms must decide
• Where to locate productive activities
• What the long-term strategic role of foreign production
sites should be
• Whether to own foreign production activities or outsource
those activities
• How to manage a globally dispersed supply chain and
what the role of Internet-based information technology
should be in the management of global logistics
• Whether to manage global logistics or outsource
©McGraw-Hill Education
Which Career Would You Choose in Global Supply
Chain Management?
With increased outsourcing and overseas production sites and customers,
supply chain management is a growing field. The Council of Supply Chain
Management Professionals (CSCMP), a professional association with more
than 8,500 members worldwide, says the industry offers a promising outlook.
What’s more, potential employers are everywhere: manufacturers and
distributors; government agencies; consulting firms; the transport industry;
universities and colleges; service firms such as banks, hospitals, and hotels;
and third-party logistics providers. The basic career options in global supply
chains include its main functions of logistics, purchasing (sourcing),
production and operations management, and marketing channels. Which
functional area would you choose if you decided to get a job in supply chain
management and why? For more information about the organization and
careers in this field, visit the CSCMP website at www.cscmp.org and its Career
Center, http://careers.cscmp.org.
©McGraw-Hill Education
Strategy, Production, and Supply Chain Management 1
Production: activities involved in creating a product or
service
Supply chain management: the procurement and
physical transmission of material through the supply
chain, from suppliers to customers
• Purchasing
• Logistics
©McGraw-Hill Education
Did You Know?
Did you know global
supply chains are not
just about
transportation?
Click to play video
©McGraw-Hill Education
Strategy, Production, and Supply Chain Management 2
The strategic objectives of the production and logistics
function are:
• To lower costs
• To increase product quality by eliminating defective
products from the upstream and downstream supply
chain and manufacturing process
• Quality refers to reliability
©McGraw-Hill Education
Figure 15.1 The Relationship Between Quality and Costs
Access the text alternative for these images.
©McGraw-Hill Education
Source: David A. Gandin, “What Does Product Quality Really Mean?,” MIT Sloan Management Review, Fall 1984, pp. 25-43.
Strategy, Production, and Supply Chain Management 3
The Six Sigma quality improvement program aims to
reduce defects, boost productivity, eliminate waste,
and cut costs throughout a company
• Six Sigma is a direct descendant of total quality
management (TQM)
• First adopted by Japanese companies
• In addition, some countries have also promoted specific
quality guidelines like the EU’s ISO 9000
©McGraw-Hill Education
Strategy, Production, and Supply Chain Management 4
Two other objectives are important for international
companies
1. Production and logistics functions must be able to
accommodate demands for local responsiveness
2. Production and supply chain management must be able
to respond quickly to shifts in customer demand
©McGraw-Hill Education
Where to Produce 1
Country Factors
• Location economies
• Location externalities
• Presence of global concentrations of activities
• Formal and informal trade barriers
• Transportation costs
• Regulations affecting FDI
• Expected future movements in exchange rates
©McGraw-Hill Education
Where to Produce 2
Technological Factors
• Fixed Costs
• If they are very high, a firm might serve the world market from a
single location or from very few locations
• Minimum Efficient Scale
• The larger the minimum efficient scale—the level of output at
which most plant-level scale economies are exhausted—of a plant,
the more likely centralized production makes sense
©McGraw-Hill Education
Where to Produce 3
Technological Factors continued
• Flexible Manufacturing and Mass Customization
• Enable firms to produce a wide variety of end products at a unit
cost that traditionally would require mass production of a
standardized output
• Also known as lean production
• Reduce set up times for complex equipment
• Increase the utilization of individual machines through better
scheduling
• Improve quality control at all stages of the manufacturing process
• Mass customization
©McGraw-Hill Education
Where to Produce 4
Technological Factors continued
• Flexible Manufacturing and Mass Customization continued
• Another common flexible manufacturing technology are the
flexible machine cells: grouping of various types of machinery, a
common materials handler, and a centralized cell controller
• Adopting flexible manufacturing technologies can help the firm to
customize products to meet the demands of small customer
groups in different national markets
©McGraw-Hill Education
Should Nestlé Continue to Invest Heavily in Turkey?
According to Nestlé Turkey’s CEO Hans Ulrich Mayer, Turkey has been a great
place to invest. “Turkey has been the recipient of several Nestlé investments
many times greater than we invest in other markets,” reported Mayer. Nestlé
has invested about $500 million in Turkey over the last four years, and
following its successful breakfast cereal investment, the company intends to
go on investing because of the strong Turkish economy compared to other
European economies. Nestlé products sold in Turkey, ranging from pet food to
chocolates, are manufactured in Turkey and also exported to North Africa and
the Middle East. Given the political situation in Turkey, should Nestlé
continue to establish increased production (i.e., expand its production
facility) in delivering to North Africa and the Middle East, or should it
establish production elsewhere?
Source: Invest in Turkey. www.spotblue.co.uk.
©McGraw-Hill Education
Where to Produce 5
Production Factors
• Product Features
• Value-to-weight ratio
• Universal needs
• Locating Production Facilities
• Centralized location
• Fixed costs are substantial
• The minimum efficient scale of production is high
• Flexible manufacturing technologies are available
• Decentralizing close to major markets
• Fixed costs and the minimum efficient scale of production are low
• Appropriate flexible manufacturing technologies are not available
©McGraw-Hill Education
Where to Produce 6
Production Factors continued
• Strategic Roles for Production Facilities
• Multinationals trying to capture gains that come with dispersed
global production system
• Global learning: valuable knowledge may also be found in a
company’s foreign subsidiaries
©McGraw-Hill Education
Where to Produce 7
Production Factors continued
• Strategic Roles for Production Facilities continued
• Offshore factory: produces component parts or finished goods at
a lower cost than producing them at home or in any other market
• Source factory: primary purpose is also to drive down costs in the
global supply chain
• Server factory: linked into the global supply chain for a global firm
to supply specific country or regional markets around the world
• Contributor factory: serves a specific country or world region
• Outpost factory: viewed as an intelligence–gathering unit
• Lead factory: creates new processes, products, and technologies
to be used throughout the global firm in all parts of the world
©McGraw-Hill Education
Where to Produce 8
The Hidden Costs of Foreign Locations
• High employee turnover
• Shoddy workmanship
• Poor product quality
• Low productivity
©McGraw-Hill Education
Make-or-Buy Decisions
Make-or-buy decisions
• Decisions about whether to perform a certain value
creation activity in-house or outsource it to another firm
are important to a firm’s manufacturing strategy
• Main factors in the decision are cost and production
capacity
• Other factors include:
• Product success
• Specialized knowledge
• Strategic fit
• Cost and production capacity
• Supplier competencies
• Inventory planning
©McGraw-Hill Education
Figure 15.3
Operationally
Favoring a Make
Decision
Access the text alternative for these images.
©McGraw-Hill Education
Source: C. W. L. Hill and G. T. M. Hult, Global Business Today (New York: McGraw-Hill Education, 2018).
Figure 15.4
Operationally
Favoring a Buy
Decision
©McGraw-Hill Education
Access the text alternative for these images.
Source: C. W. L. Hill and G. T. M. Hult, Global Business Today (New York: McGraw-Hill Education, 2018).
Global Supply Chain Functions 1
Global Logistics
• Core activities
1. Global distribution center
2. Inventory management
3. Packaging and materials handling
4. Transportation
5. Reverse logistics
©McGraw-Hill Education
How Much Relationship Building Do You Really Want to Do?
Like manufacturers, professional service firms have also been learning how to
better manage their delivery on a global basis. For example, some global
services firms are dealing with other global firms in a new way, using one
supplier for all their service- related needs around the world. The traditional
approach involved the development of market-specific relationships, so the
same multinational client would have a number of individual service
relationships, one in each major market for each company division. Under a
global account management approach, one relationship has a global span—
and one contract. Such supply chain practices allow for more effective
relationship management, a better sense of what the client needs, more
product extension opportunities, and better pricing and economies. But
global account management also takes time, energy, and resources. How
many “global accounts” do you think would be ideal for a global company?
What is the minimum and maximum number of global account relationships
a large multinational corporation should have (e.g., Microsoft)?
©McGraw-Hill Education
Global Supply Chain Functions 2
Global Logistics continued
• Global distribution center
• A facility that positions and allows customization of products for
delivery to worldwide wholesalers, retailers, or directly to
consumers anywhere in the world
• The foundation of a global supply network
• Global inventory management
• The decision-making process regarding the raw materials, work-inprocess, and finished goods inventory for an MNC
©McGraw-Hill Education
Global Supply Chain Functions 3
Global Logistics continued
• Packaging: three different categories
• Primary packaging holds the product itself
• Secondary packaging is designed to contain several primary
packages
• Transit packaging is used when primary and secondary packages
are assembled for transportation
• The functions of packaging are to perform, protect, and inform
©McGraw-Hill Education
Global Supply Chain Functions 4
Global Logistics continued
• Transportation
• The movement of raw material, component parts, and finished
goods throughout the global supply chain
• Largest percentage of any logistics budget
• Ocean is the least expensive and air is the most expensive
• Reverse logistics
• The process of moving inventory from the point of consumption to
the point of origin for the purpose of recapturing value or proper
disposal
• The ultimate goal is to optimize the after-market activity or make
it more efficient
©McGraw-Hill Education
Global Supply Chain Functions 5
Global Purchasing
• Five strategic levels
• Level I: domestic purchasing activities only
• Level II: international purchasing only as needed
• Level III: international purchasing as part of firm’s overall supply
chain management strategy
• Level IV: global purchasing activities that are integrated across the
firm’s locations worldwide
• Level V: global purchasing activities that are integrated across
worldwide locations and functional groups
©McGraw-Hill Education
Managing a Global Supply Chain 1
Efficient supply chain management can have a
substantial impact on a firm’s profitability
• Four important areas
1. Just-in-time inventory
2. Information technology
3. Coordination
4. Interorganizational relationships
©McGraw-Hill Education
Managing a Global Supply Chain 2
Role of Just-in-Time Inventory
• Economizes on inventory holding costs by having materials
arrive at a manufacturing plant just in time to enter the
production process, and not before
• Can result in major cost savings from reduced warehousing and
inventory holding costs
• Can help firms spot defective parts, take them out of the
manufacturing process, and boost product quality
• Leaves firms without a buffer stock of inventory, which makes it
difficult for a company to respond quickly to problems
©McGraw-Hill Education
Managing a Global Supply Chain 3
Role of Information Technology
• Information systems allow firms to optimize production
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)
• Less expensive systems now exist, making it easier for
companies of all sizes to access
©McGraw-Hill Education
Managing a Global Supply Chain 4
Coordination in Global Supply Chains
• Global supply chain coordination
• Shared decision-making opportunities and operational
collaboration of key global supply chain activities
• A more integrated, coherent, efficient, and effective supply chain
• Operational objectives
• Responsiveness
• Variance reduction
• Inventory reduction
• Shipment consolidation
• Quality
• Life-cycle support
©McGraw-Hill Education
Managing a Global Supply Chain 5
Interorganizational Relationships
• Trust and commitment between interacting organizations
are important to an efficient and effective global supply
chain
©McGraw-Hill Education
Figure 15.5 Upstream/Inbound Relationships
Access the text alternative for these images.
©McGraw-Hill Education
Source: C. W. L. Hill and G. T. M. Hult, Global Business Today (New York: McGraw-Hill Education, 2018).
Figure 15.6 Downstream/Outbound Relationships
Access the text alternative for these images.
©McGraw-Hill Education
Source: C. W. L. Hill and G. T. M. Hult, Global Business Today (New York: McGraw-Hill Education, 2018).
Summary
In this chapter, we have
•
Explained why global production and supply-chain management
decisions are of central importance to many global companies.
•
Explained how country differences, production technology, and
production factors all affect the choice of where to locate production
activities.
•
Recognized how the role of foreign subsidiaries in production can be
enhanced over time as they accumulate knowledge.
•
Identified the factors that influence a firm’s decision of whether to
source supplies from within the company or from foreign suppliers.
•
Understood the functions of logistics and purchasing (sourcing) within
global supply chains.
•
Described what is required to efficiently manage a global supply
chain.
©McGraw-Hill Education
Purchase answer to see full
attachment