PU How Six Sigma Was Vital for The Success of The Program Discussion

Description

Case Study Analysis – This case discusses the effectiveness of an effective quality program or effort. Read the attached article.

Discuss how Six Sigma was vital to the success of the program. Could the team have done anything different to achieve the results faster or better? How did the organization facilitate or hinder the team?

Students are expected to carefully read the assignment instructions, then thoroughly and explicitly address each component of the corresponding case study questions. The responses should reflect higher level cognitive processing (analysis, synthesis, and evaluation), which is essential for someone being prepared to serve in an operational capacity within the healthcare and related industry. There is a minimum number of references that need to be utilized to support the completion of this assignment; it is generally understood that any good case study analysis will incorporate the appropriate quality and at minimum four (3) scholarly sources to support any suppositions and recommendations. The submission will not exceed six (6) pages in length, including the title and references pages. The document must adhere to the APA writing style. Finally, the document should be prepared as a Microsoft Word document and uploaded under the correct unit assignment page.

Unformatted Attachment Preview

Making the Case for Quality
February 2016
Using DMAIC to Improve
Nursing Shift-Change Assignments
by Casey Hewes and Nina Costilla BSN, RN
At a Glance . . .
• In this case study involving
an anonymous hospital,
nursing department
leaders sought to improve
efficiency of their staff’s
shift change assignments.
• Upon value stream
mapping the process,
team members identified
the shift nursing report
took 43 minutes on
average to complete.
• Using DMAIC and
other quality tools, team
members improved the
process’ sigma level
from 0.7 to 3.3.
Labor represents the largest expense for large metropolitan hospitals by far. According to Becker’s
Hospital CFO newsletter, labor costs have typically averaged 50 percent of hospitals’ total operating
revenue1 for the past decade. The American Hospital Association also reported in 2012 that growing
labor costs are the most important factor increasing hospital care costs2, and found that wages and benefits accounted for more than 59 percent of hospital costs in 2014 3.
Wasteful practices must be scrutinized and contained to control hospital staffing costs while maximizing operational efficiency. One area of opportunity involves the shift changes for nursing staff, a
process that too frequently results in nurses staying later than their scheduled departure time. In 2010
the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services reported 54 percent of registered nurses surveyed
said they worked more than 39 hours per week 4.
A 600-bed hospital near Dallas, TX, initiated a project to improve its nursing shift change process to
cut labor costs without negatively affecting the quality of patient care. This hospital has a formal operational excellence department that primarily uses Lean Six Sigma methodology, following the define,
measure, analyze, improve, control (DMAIC) approach. The project was approved and facilitated by
this department as well as the service line director of nursing.
Working with Mark J. Davis, a Lean Six Sigma Black Belt as their mentor, the nurse manager and day
nurse supervisor for a medicine and surgery (med-surg) unit led the project. The DMAIC approach
helped the team uncover solutions that would allow nurses to leave work on time and encourage
greater efficiency in the shift-change process.
Define
The shift-change nursing report is the primary tool used to ensure continuity of care as staff change
happens every 12 hours. The report contains pertinent patient information, and is given to the arriving
nurse before the previous nurse on duty leaves at the end of a shift. Nursing assignments are given to
the arriving nurse, and include the list of patients they are to care for.
The charge nurse is responsible for making these assignments, which are typically subjective and based
on many variables (patient acuity, blood sugar levels, and proximity to the nursing station, along with
overall scheduling for the nursing floor, such as number of admissions and discharges, etc.).
ASQ
www.asq.org
Page 1 of 6
The SIPOC map in Figure 1 summarizes the metrics by which nursing
assignments are produced and shift
changes occur.
Supplier
Process
Staff
On this particular med-surg unit, there
are typically five registered nurses
staffing the team. Often the five nurses
from the day shift have to interact with
each of the five nurses on the night
shift as dictated by the patient assignments. If these nurses were to spend
less time working on the shift-change
nursing report, they could use the extra
time to work with their patients, which
would have a more direct impact
on hospital consumer assessment
of healthcare providers and systems
(HCAHPS) scores. One of the key outputs included in Figure 1, HCAHPS, is
the mechanism through which patients
can rate their medical care experience.
Medicare payments to hospitals are,
in part, tied to these scores—making
them very important.
As designated by the hospital’s parent
company, the change of shift report
should take no more than 30 minutes. Any report requiring more than
30 minutes was considered a defect.
During any shift change, five nurses
delivered the report and five received
it. Therefore, each report involved an
opportunity for five defects.
Providers
of the
required
Staff
Customers
Time
Staff
punch in
get report
Get
assignments
get report
get report
get report
get report
Top-level description of the activity
required
by the
process
Employee
Satisfaction
Service Line
Director
Leadership
Staff
Patients
FTEs
Deliverables
from the
process
Anyone who
receives a
deliverable from
the process
day and night shift changes and both took on observation roles for both shifts. Due to the
busyness or distractions of shift changes, they were not exposed because they would time
the nurses from a distance. They were also a routine presence during this time period.
Based on the 30 observations measured, the shift-change nursing report was found to take
an average of 43 minutes to complete.
The next step was to determine of the 43 minutes, how much accounted for nonvalueadded (NVA) steps. The team determined if the nurses were waiting and not delivering
the shift-change report or listening to the report, the time could be categorized as NVA.
The value stream map (VSM) in Figure 2 revealed 23 minutes of the process was nonvalue added and was devoted to completing the shift nursing report as the arriving nurse
waited for the previous shift nurse to depart. The oncoming nurse waited to receive
Figure 2: VSM for shift change reports
Measure
In order to measure improvement, the
team decided to call upon the overall
time it took to produce the nursing
report. Conclusions were drawn from a
total of 30 timed observations. These 30
observations were gathered by the nurse
manager and day nurse supervisor.
The pair discretely timed nurses at shift
changes in the morning and evening
for several weeks. Both observers had
a stopwatch function on their smart
phone and a form to keep observations
accurate and consistent. The observers split the observations evenly for
ASQ
Staff
punch in
CT=10 sec
CVA=0
BNVA=10 sec
NVA=0
Report with
nurse 3
I
10 seconds
(Transaction 1)
I
5 minutes
(Transaction 5)
Put away
belongings
CT=2 min
CVA=0
BNVA=0
NVA=0
Report with
nurse 2
CT=6 min
CVA=6 min
BNVA=0
NVA=0
I
Get
assignment
2 minutes
(Transaction 2)
5 minutes
I
5 minutes
(Transaction 4)
Report with
nurse 1
CT=7 min
CVA=7 min
BNVA=0
NVA=0
Note: Three nurses are
in the value stream map
www.asq.org
Page 2 of 6
reports from an average of three departing nurses before she
could begin her duties.
Analyze
shift-change report is taking so long to complete. Included in the
FMEA is a risk priority number, which suggests the factors that
should take the highest priority in promoting change.
The following are the steps for completing the FMEA:
To begin addressing potential solutions for NVA wait time, the
team completed a failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA)
chart (see Table 1). This analysis is a complete and quantified
cause and effect chart that pinpoints potential reasons why the
1. Analyze what may be causing a long nursing report.
• For example, the number of nurses involved will
influence the length of the report.
Table 1 — FMEA to identify reasons for NVA steps
Staff Nurses Report Disection
Prepared by:
Nina Costilla, Casey Hewes
Responsible:
Project Team
FMEA Date (Orig) 5/16/2015
Process Step/
Input
Potential
Failure Mode
Potential
Failure Effects
Potential Causes
What is the
process step
or input?
In what ways
does the process
step or input
go wrong?
What is the impact?
What causes the
process step or
input to go wrong?
Amount of
nurses
Too many staff
nurses to give
report to
Delay in report
because have to
wait for or find
next staff nurse
8
PCTs in report
Timing of PCT
in report
Distracted PCTs and
staff nurses respond
to call lights
6
Report is given
based on staff
nurse preference
Varied time
of report
Charge in
report
Timing of charge
nurse in report
Distracted charge
nurses and staff
nurses respond
to call lights
Rapport vs.
report
Relationship
development
versus actual
report
Delay in report
Layout –
Hamon vs.
Main
Hamon has
nooks or areas
for nurses to
watch their
pod and more
Medication Pyxis
Less walking
for nurses
CareConnect
inefficient
CareConnect
report not
optimized
Inefficient report
and delay in report
Not enough
WOWs
Each staff nurse
uses WOW
for report
Delay in report
FTE/OT/Salary
Doesn’t directly
measure
report time
Doesn’t directly
measure
report time
Clock in/
clock out
ASQ
7
5
Charge nurse
assignment
Change of
shift design
Different staff nurses
have different skill
levels and areas
of emphasis
Change of
shift design
Occurrence
Current
Controls
3
5
CareConnect
decision
9
720
10
600
8
560
10
500
5
200
None
10
10
Potential to
offput offgoing/
ongoing nurse
None
10
8
Lack of satellite
Medication Pyxis.
Less nooks.
R
P
N
None
10
Nurses choice
5
What are
the existing
controls and
procedures that
prevent either
the cause or the
failure mode?
Potential to
offput offgoing
nurse
None
10
5
Ability to
work around
CareConnect
5
150
5
125
10
120
3
Can’t use
CareConnect
report or unable
to bedside report
4
Does not measure
precisely
2
N/A
1
Don’t utilize
report
1
2
Does not measure
precisely
2
N/A
1
Don’t utilize
report
1
2
www.asq.org
Adequate
amount of
WOWs
Page _1_ of _1_
(Rev)
Actions
Recommended
Detection
Standardization
Severity
Process or
Product Name:
Responsible
What are the
actions for
reducing the
occurrence
of the cause,
or improving
detection?
Territories
Casey/Nina
Stagger
ongoing/
outgoing staff
Casey
Standardization
of report
Laurie
Robbins
Stagger
ongoing/
outgoing staff
Casey
Education on
communication
style
Casey
Build out
615 and
create nook
Casey/Nina
Choice to use
CareConnect
or not
Debbie Van
Sickel/Super
user/Laurie
Robbins
Keep WOWs
operational
Night
charge
nurses
N/A
Casey
N/A
Casey
Page 3 of 6
2. Identify how the step can go wrong.
• Too many nurses may be giving the report to each other
at the same time.
3. Identify what impact the step has on the nursing report.
• The problem is when there are so many nurses they have
to wait for each other.
4. Determine potential causes for the problem.
• The cause of this problem is that the way assignments are
done, nurses must give the report to several other nurses.
5. Assess potential controls that exist for the problem.
• There are no controls in place to manage this problem.
6. Identify how to reduce the likelihood of the problem.
• Create assignments where one nurse can give the report
to only one other nurse.
Improve
Upon observing and analyzing the data, the team identified a
key area for most effectively eliminating waste. It was clear the
most significant and controllable source of unnecessary payroll
expenditures existed in the number of nurses involved in producing the shift-change reports.
Typically, this unit runs over budget by approximately $5,000
per month in payroll expenditures. This process most likely
exists for the majority of hospital units across the United States
because it has always been done this way.
In order to operate more efficiently in the reporting process, the
team redesigned the layout so the nursing assignments are delegated in clusters or by an emphasis on geography. By dividing
assignments by territory, the team was able to maintain flexibility while relegating assignments to a specific area.
Unit staff were presented with two solutions: “territory” or
“pods.” As the force field analysis in Figure 3 illustrates, territory allowed more flexibility, and pods were very simple.
Territories are more flexible because there is a range the nurses
Figure 3: Force field analysis of potential solutions, territory vs. pods
5
Flexibility
Staff
Elevators
Territory
3
Boardroom
625
624
623
622
Stairs
Main 6 West – Geographic Assignment
621
#1 will be the charge assignment
since there are nine rooms.
If night is four nurses, three
rooms from #3 go to #1 and
two rooms from #3 go to #2.
Slower
assignments
2
Med
Room
Nurse’s
Station
619
618
617
616
615
Confusing/
Interpretation
Our own
Waiting
Room
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
Scale importance
– Balanced acuity
– Proximity
– Continuity
– Speed/Ease of
of care
assignments
609
610
1 = Less importance
624
623
Pods
622
612
1
614
3
5 = More importance
Staff
Elevators Boardroom 625
611
2a 2b
5
Easy
608
1a 1b
7
3
620
621
Stairs
2
Offices
Guest
Elevators
Pyxis
Storage
2a 2b
Pod #2 is charge assignment.
If night is four nurses,
will split pod #2.
Inflexibility
2
1
Nurse’s
Station
Med
Room
Pyxis
Storage
Guest
Elevators
Offices
4
Can’t
complain
620
619
618
617
616
615
Charge
2
assignment
will be difficult
Waiting
Room
ASQ
www.asq.org
Page 4 of 6
4
ASQ
1
2
www.asq.org
3
4
Page 5 of 6
can be assigned, but the range is greatly
reduced from the previous scenario.
Pods are more rigid and straightforward
because a nurse has a predetermined
set range, i.e., beds 1-5 with no room
for flexibility. The territory assignment
began January 1 at midnight.
Control
The team tested the territory nursing assignment methodology during
a 30-day trial period for both shifts
on the med-surg unit in question, and
the results were extremely favorable.
Under the territory framework, any
given nurse will average one nurse,
two at the maximum, to whom they
must provide their shift change report.
To deploy the process change, communications were dispersed to all unit
staff through informal discussions,
emails, and in a staff meeting featuring
extensive dialogue. Extra communication and Q&A talking points were
provided for the charge nurses.
Upon implementation of the new
process, the average time it took to
complete the report now stood at 30
minutes, thereby reducing needless
waiting times significantly. Figure 4
illustrates the VSM for the improved
process while Table 2 shows the sigma
level for the process improved from
0.7 to 3.3.
Figure 4: Future state VSM (post-intervention)
Staff
punch in
CT=10 sec
CVA=0
BNVA=10 sec
NVA=0
Put away
belongings
I
Get
assignment
2 minutes
(Transaction 2)
CT=2 min
CVA=0
BNVA=0
NVA=0
(Transaction 1)
I
3 minutes
Report with
nurse 1
Table 2 — Process improvement as measured by sigma level
Pre-Intervention
Post-Intervention
The calculation of a sigma level, is based on the number
of defects per million opportunities (DPMO).
The calculation of a sigma level, is based on the number
of defects per million opportunities (DPMO).
In order to calculate the DPMO, three distinct
pieces of information are required:
In order to calculate the DPMO, three distinct
pieces of information are required:
a) the number of handoffs produced
b) the number of defect opportunities per handoff
c) the number of defects
Opportunity
Defect/Opportunity
Defect
The actual formula is:
DPMO =
a) the number of handoffs produced
b) the number of defect opportunities per handoff
c) the number of defects
The actual formula is:
(Number of defects x 1,000,000)
DPMO =
((Number of defect opportunities/unit) x number of units)
Defects = 24
Opportunities = 30
Defect opportunities per unit = 1
ASQ
Opportunity
Defect/Opportunity
Defect
DPMO = 800,000
Sigma level = 0.7
(Max sigma level = 6.0)
(Number of defects x 1,000,000)
((Number of defect opportunities/unit) x number of units)
Defects = 1
Opportunities = 30
Defect opportunities per unit = 1
www.asq.org
DPMO = 33,333.33
Sigma level = 3.3
(Max sigma level = 6.0)
Page 6 of 6
Med-Surg Unit flex and productive FTE
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May
The goal achievement graph in Figure 5
reflects a greater efficiency and productivity as a result of process change. The
nurses have also had a great experience
and favor the new change, as some have
particularly noted they are walking less
throughout the day and delivering their
reports more quickly.
units to emulate since it could address
an industry-wide problem. If other
med-surg units took this shift-change
project on and it became the norm,
versus an outlier, we could positively
affect healthcare costs.
References
For More Information
The x-axis in Figure 5 represents productivity and is used by the nurse manager
to evaluate labor utilization. The blue
line represents how many employees
the finance department thinks should be
required, given the census, and the red
line is the actual amount used. To date,
the improvement has been in place for
six months and is self-sustaining.
1. Bob Herman, “10 Statistics on
Hospital Labor Costs as a Percentage
of Operating Revenue,” Hospital
CFO, December 10, 2013, www.
beckershospitalreview.com/
finance/10-statistics-on-hospitallabor-costs-as-a-percentage-ofoperating-revenue.html.
•
2. American Hospital Association,
“The Cost of Caring,” AHA.org,
June 2012, www.aha.org/content/12/
CostofCaring2012.pdf.
About the Authors
There have been no interventions by the
nurse manager or day shift supervisor.
There have been discussions rolling this
program out to other med-surg units, but
this has yet to be executed. Currently,
there are no other plans or discussions to
improve this process.
Clearly, there is room for greater efficiency among the majority of hospitals
across the country. This case study
demonstrates an opportunity for similar
ASQ
3. American Hospital Association,
“TrendWatch: Chartbook 2015,”
AHA.org, 2015, www.aha.org/
research/reports/tw/chartbook/
index.shtml.
4. Sung-Heui Bae, “Nursing Overtime:
Why, How Much, and Under What
Working Conditions?,” Nursing
Economics, March-April 2012.
www.asq.org
•
To contact the author of this case
study, email Casey Hewes at
CaseyHewes@Outlook.com.
To view this and other case studies,
visit the ASQ Knowledge Center at
asq.org/knowledge-center/
case-studies.
Casey Hewes has worked in healthcare
for 12 years as a staff nurse and in
management. He has a master’s degree
in business administration with an
emphasis in finance from the University
of Hawaii.
Nina Costilla, a native Texan, received
her bachelor’s degree in nursing from
Texas Tech University. She is currently
working toward a master’s degree in
nursing from Texas Tech.
Page 7 of 6

Purchase answer to see full
attachment
Explanation & Answer:

6 Pages

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool’s honor code & terms of service.

Get 20% Discount on This Paper
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Try it now!

Get 20% Discount on This Paper

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Ace Writing Center has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.

Essays

Essay Writing Services

At Ace Writing Center, Nowadays, students normally have extremely busy schedules. You will note that some of them have to take on some evening or weekend jobs in order to get some income that can help them to sustain in college or in the university. This can deny them a chance to write all the essays given. Others usually get bombarded with a lot of work by their lecturers. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. However, some of them usually try to work on all these essays but end up delivering their work late. This can prevent them from graduating since most lecturers are strict on deadlines. If you want to write a business essay, the wise way is to hire an outstanding essay writing service like us, so that you can get the best results. If you are keen, you will note that many companies usually overcharge their customers. Some of them are there only to make money. And in reality, they really don’t care to build a long term commitment with students. You should not choose such companies. You should take your time and choose a reliable company to work with. Ace Writing Center is the ultimate solution for you. We have been offering our writing service for more than 7 years. This is a clear indication that you will get quality essay writing service. We have a wide range of writers who can work on any business essay that you might have. We believe in doing extensive research so that we can provide quality work to all our clients. .

Admissions

Admission and Business Papers

Have you ever had to write an admission essay for college? The majority of students face the same issues when applying to a university or college and many in such situations decide they need professional help to cope with this matter. They get in a situation when the deadline keeps coming closer but lack motivation to start because they are just not sure if their writing skills are strong enough. We have a solution for you! Ace Writing Center is the best admission essay writing service with a large professional team and years of experience in providing high-quality papers to students of all levels and faculties. The mission of our team is to help students make their dreams of entering a good college come true and that’s what we offer!.

Editing

Editing and Proofreading

Sometimes all the words for your paper just flow out of your mind and into your fingers. You type quickly at your keyboard and there they are, your beautiful words right there on the screen. But you have no idea how to polish it up. You may be wishing there was a paper writing service that offered this type of writing service. Look no more! Here at Ace Writing Center, we offer you an editing and proofreading option that you can't find anywhere else..

Coursework

College Essay Writing

In case you are familiar Ace Writing Center, you know the way to distinguish a better company from a cheap one exactly. First of all, poor service website does not have a sufficient support. We think support team is an essential part of success; it has to answer all clients’ questions and be a connecting link between clients and their writers. On our web-service you will get answers about anything you need and your writer will receive all your instructions, assignments and requirements exactly and swiftly. A writing service that we run has got a flexible pricing system that will save you from senseless wastes and many bonus systems that let you sparing money for something important for you.