UIW Sharp and the Production of Liquid Crystal Displays Paper

Description

Read the Sharp and the production of liquid crystal displays Case study in your text, starting on page 142 .

For this submission, refer to the Case questions on page 142 of your text. Responds to the first and second bulleted questions in one cohesive submission…..make sure you include consideration of the content you have reviewed to date in this course.

Note: Before you start writing, think about the question and organize your thoughts…when you have had time to do so, then begin the writing process!) Please make sure you use APA format and cite your sources. This is a standalone document so if you use your textbook from time to time, cite as you would normally do and write the paper as if you were writing for someone who is not familiar with this course. Include an introduction that states your thesis, a body that speaks to your thesis and provides rationale (cited where necessary) and then conclude. The paper should be no longer than 5 pages in length, double spaced.

Unformatted Attachment Preview

Foundations of Strategy
Second Edition
Robert M. Grant
Judith Jordan
Copyright © 2015, 2012 Robert M. Grant and Judith Jordan
All efforts have been made to trace and acknowledge ownership of copyright. The Publisher would be glad to hear from any copyright
holders whom it has not been possible to contact.
Cover illustration credit: © Valentina Razumova. Used under licence from Shutterstock.com.
Registered office
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, United Kingdom
For details of our global editorial offices, for customer services and for information about how to apply for permission to reuse the
copyright material in this book please see our website at www.wiley.com.
The rights of Robert M. Grant and Judith Jordan to be identified as the authors of this work have been asserted in accordance with the
Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any
means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act
1988, without the prior permission of the publisher.
Wiley publishes in a variety of print and electronic formats and by print-on-demand. Some material included with standard print
versions of this book may not be included in e-books or in print-on-demand. If this book refers to media such as a CD or DVD that is not
included in the version you purchased, you may download this material at http://booksupport.wiley.com. For more information about
Wiley products, visit www.wiley.com.
Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names
used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The publisher is not
associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative
information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering
professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be
sought.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Grant, Robert M., 1948Foundations of strategy / Robert M. Grant & Judith Jordan.—Second Edition.
pages cm
Includes index.
ISBN 978-1-118-91470-0 (pbk.)
1. Strategic planning. 2. Industrial management—Technological innovations.
I. Jordan, Judith. II. Title.
HD30.28.G7214 2015
658.4’012—dc23
2014039505
ISBN: 978-1-118-91470-0 (pbk)
ISBN: 978-1-119-00131-7 (ebk)
ISBN: 978-1-119-00127-0 (ebk)
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Preface to 2nd edition
The second edition retains its aim of providing a concise introduction to the key concepts, frameworks and techniques of
strategy for those who are coming to the subject for the first time. The emphasis remains on practicality and how theory can
be used to gain strategic insight into the challenges facing business organizations. At the same time, the content of the book
has been revised to reflect recent developments in the business environment and in strategy research and to take into
account feedback from instructors.
The distinctive features of the second edition include:

changes and updates to opening and closing cases to reflect the current issues facing decision makers in a broad array of business
organizations (Chapters 1 to 9);
 a more integrated approach to value creation and strategic analysis in not-for-profit contexts (particularly Chapter 1 but
throughout the text);
 a stronger emphasis on strategic change that is structured around the challenges and ways of managing change and highlights the
development of new capabilities and ways in which organizations seek to become more responsive and flexible (Chapter 5);
 a more concise and integrated treatment of strategy implementation; while the book maintains its emphasis on integrating strategy
formulation and integration, Chapters 5 and 9 offer a more accessible and systematic approach to strategy execution;
 updates to the discussion of current trends in strategic management to reflect changes in the business climate and new strands of
research including practice-based approaches (Chapter 10).
Like the first edition, the second edition of Foundations of Strategy draws heavily on the ideas, theories and evidence presented
in Robert Grant’s text Contemporary Strategy Analysis. It has also benefited from the feedback and suggestions of academic
staff and students in the many universities and colleges where Foundations of Strategy has been adopted. We look forward to
broadening and deepening our engagement with users.
We are also grateful for the professionalism and enthusiasm of the editorial, production, and sales and marketing teams at
John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
Preface to 1st edition
Robert Grant’s Contemporary Strategy Analysis is one of the market-leading text books used on MBA and advanced
undergraduate courses around the world. During the continuing development of that text, now in its 8th edition, it has
become apparent that there is also considerable demand for a more accessible and concise version of the text. In response to
this demand, we have developed Foundations of Strategy as a brand new textbook. While maintaining the accessible writing
style, clear approach and sound theoretical depth, this new text is better suited to the needs of both undergraduate students
and Masters’ students requiring a more concise treatment of the subject.
As all those with an interest recognise, the way in which business and management education is delivered continues to evolve
and change over time. Strategy modules remain a key part of business and management programmes but are now delivered
in a wide variety of different formats, to a diverse range of students using a variety of different technologies. Strategy
educators frequently find themselves with the challenge of having to deliver strategy modules in relatively short time frames
to students with limited prior knowledge and experience of business and management practice. This text is designed to assist
educators and students meet this challenge. Our aim has been to cover the key areas of strategy as concisely as possible
without sacrificing intellectual rigour. To that end we have:






Made clear the learning objectives and provided summary tables against these objectives at the start and end of each chapter.
Organised the book on the basis of ten chapters.
Provided a range of short cases that students can read and digest quickly and that can be used as an alternative to, or in
conjunction with, longer cases available on the web.
Included worked examples relating to the opening case of each chapter demonstrating how theory can be applied to practice in
order to gain insight into strategic decision-making.
Highlighted key concepts in the margin.
Provided a glossary of key terms.
Online teaching and learning resources
Visit www.foundationsofstrategy.com to access all the teaching and learning materials that accompany this text.
Instructors will find extensive teaching materials such as an Instructor’s Manual, including Case Teaching Notes, a Test Bank
and PowerPoint Slides. The website also features extra, longer Case Studies written by Robert M. Grant, as well as Case
Video Clips.
Resources for students include Self-Test Quizzes and Glossary Flashcards.
Contents
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Cover
Title page
Copyright page
Preface to 2nd edition
Preface to 1st edition
Online teaching and learning resources
Case List
1: The concept of Strategy
1. Introduction and objectives
2. The role of strategy in success
3. A brief history of strategy
4. Strategy today
5. Strategic management of not-for-profit organizations
6. The approach taken in this book
7. Summary
8. Summary table
9. Further reading
10. Self-study questions
11. Notes
9. 2: Industry analysis
1. Introduction and objectives
2. From environmental analysis to industry analysis
3. The determinants of industry profit: Demand and competition
4. Analysing industry attractiveness
5. Applying industry analysis to forecasting industry profitability
6. Using industry analysis to develop strategy
7. Defining an industry
8. Reviewing the five forces of competition framework
9. Segmentation analysis
10. Dealing with dynamic competition
11. From industry attractiveness to competitive advantage: Identifying key success factors
12. Summary
13. Summary table
14. Further reading
15. Self-study questions
16. Notes
10. 3: Resources and capabilities
1. Introduction and objectives
2. The role of resources and capabilities in strategy formulation
3. Identifying the organization’s resources and capabilities
4. Appraising resources and capabilities
5. Developing strategy implications
6. Summary
7. Summary table
8. Further reading
9. Self-study questions
10. Notes
11. 4: The nature and sources of competitive advantage
1. Introduction and objectives
2. How competitive advantage emerges and is sustained
3. Types of competitive advantage: Cost and differentiation
4. Porter’s generic strategies and being ‘stuck in the middle’
5. Summary
6. Summary table
7. Further reading
8. Self-study questions
9. Notes
12. 5: Industry evolution and strategic change
1. Introduction and objectives
2. The industry lifecycle
3. Managing organizational adaptation and strategic change
4. Managing strategic change
5. Summary
6. Summary table
7. Further reading
8. Self-study questions
9. Notes
13. 6: Technology-based industries and the management of innovation
1. Introduction and objectives
2. Competitive advantage in technology-intensive industries
3. Strategies to exploit innovation: How and when to enter
4. Competing for standards
5. Implementing technology strategies: Creating the conditions for innovation
6. Summary
7. Summary table
8. Further reading
9. Self-study questions
10. Notes
14. 7: Corporate strategy
1. Introduction and objectives
2. The scope of the firm
3. Key concepts for analysing firm scope
4. Diversification
5. Vertical integration
6. Managing the corporate portfolio
7. Summary
8. Summary table
9. Further reading
10. Self-study questions
11. Notes
15. 8: Global strategies and the multinational corporation
1. Introduction and objectives
2. The implications of international competition for industry analysis
3. Analysing competitive advantage in an international context
4. The international location of production
5. How should firms enter foreign markets?
6. Multinational strategies: Global integration vs. national differentiation
7. Strategy and organization within the multinational corporation
8. Summary
9. Summary table
10. Further reading
11. Self-study questions
12. Notes
16. 9: Realizing strategy
1. Introduction and objectives
2. From strategy to execution
3. Organizational design: The fundamentals of organizing
4. Organizational design: Choosing the right structure
5. Organizational culture
6. Summary
7. Summary table
8. Further reading
9. Self-study questions
10. Notes
17. 10: Current trends in strategic management
1. Introduction and objectives
2. The new environment of business
3. New directions in strategic thinking
4. Redesigning organizations
5. The changing role of managers
6. Summary
7. Summary table
8. Further reading
9. Self-study questions
10. Notes
18. Glossary
19. Index
20. End User License Agreement
List of Tables
1. Chapter 1
1. Table 1.1: Applying the concepts and tools of strategic analysis to different types of not-for-profit organization.
2. Chapter 2
1. Table 2.1: The profitability of US industries: 2000–2010.
2. Table 2.2: Identifying key success factors: Steel, fashion clothing and supermarkets.
3. Table 2.3: Private and public health and fitness clubs in the UK: 2011 and 2014.
4. Table 2.4: Leading UK private health and fitness club operators: 2014.
5. Table 2.5: Selected financial data for leading UK private health and fitness club operators (2010–2013).
3. Chapter 3
1. Table 3.1: Indicators of Harley-Davidson performance: 1994–2013.
2. Table 3.2: Large companies with the highest valuation ratios, April 2014.
3. Table 3.3: The world’s most valuable brands, 2013.
4. Table 3.4: A functional classification of organizational capabilities.
5. Table 3.5: Profits, dividends and employee compensation at Goldman Sachs.
6. Table 3.6: Appraising Harley-Davidson’s resources and capabilities.
4. Chapter 4
1. Table 4.1: Costs of available seat kilometres (ASK) between 2001 and 2009 in US cents.
2. Table 4.2: Features of cost leadership and differentiation strategies.
5. Chapter 5
1. Table 5.1: The evolution of industry structure and competition over the lifecycle.
2. Table 5.2: Shaking the foundations.
3. Table 5.3: Distinctive capabilities as a consequence of childhood experiences: The oil majors.
6. Chapter 6
1. Table 6.1: Leaders, followers and winners In emerging Industries.
2. Table 6.2: Examples of companies that own de facto industry standards.
3. Table 6.3: The characteristics of ‘operating’ and ‘innovating’ organizations.
4. Table 6.4: Suppliers of single-serve coffee systems.
7. Chapter 7
1. Table 7.1: Vertical integration (VI) versus outsourcing: Some key considerations.
2. Table 7.2: Key considerations in outsourcing transport for Tesco.
3. Table 7.3: Disney’s revenue 2012/13.
8. Chapter 8
1. Table 8.1: Hourly compensation costs for production workers in manufacturing (US$).
2. Table 8.2: Where does the iPhone come from? The location of iPhone suppliers.
3. Table 8.3: Ghemawat’s CAGE framework for assessing country differences.
9. Chapter 9
1. Table 9.1: Mechanistic versus organic organizational forms.
10. Chapter 10
1. Table 10.1: Emerging-market corporations acquiring Western companies: Some illustrative examples.
List of Illustrations
1. Chapter 1
1. Figure 1.1: Common elements in successful strategies.
2. Figure 1.2: Evolution of strategic management: Dominant themes.
3. Figure 1.3: Some definitions of strategy.
4. Figure 1.4: Corporate versus business strategy.
5. Figure 1.5: Describing a firm’s strategy: Competing in the present, preparing for the future.
6. Figure 1.6: Stakeholder power/interest grid.
7. Figure 1.7: Responses to stakeholders’ positions within the power/interest grid.
8. Figure 1.8: The basic framework: Strategy as a link between the firm and its environment.
9. Figure 1.9: Tough Mudder: Growth 2010–2014.
2. Chapter 2
1. Figure 2.1: From PEST analysis to industry analysis.
2. Figure 2.2: Porter’s five forces of competition framework.
3. Figure 2.3: The structural determinants of the five forces of competition.
4. Figure 2.4: Five forces, or six?
5. Figure 2.5: Identifying key success factors.
3. Chapter 3
1. Figure 3.1: Analysing resources and capabilities: The interface between strategy and the firm.
2. Figure 3.2: The links between resources, capabilities and competitive advantage.
3. Figure 3.3: Porter’s value chain.
4. Figure 3.4: The hierarchy of organizational capabilities at a telecom equipment manufacturer.
5. Figure 3.5: Appraising the strategic importance of resources and capabilities.
6. Figure 3.6: Harley-Davidson’s share price, revenue and net income: 1995–2013.
7. Figure 3.7: The framework for appraising resources and capabilities.
8. Figure 3.8: Summary: A framework for analysing resources and capabilities.
4. Chapter 4
1. Figure 4.1: The emergence of competitive advantage.
2. Figure 4.2: Sustaining competitive advantage: Types of isolating mechanism.
3. Figure 4.3: Sources of competitive advantage.
4. Figure 4.4: The drivers of cost advantage.
5. Figure 4.5: Using the value chain to identify differentiation potential on the supply side.
6. Figure 4.6: Porter’s generic strategies.
5. Chapter 5
1. Figure 5.1: Worldwide shipments of personal computers 1978–2014 (millions of units).
2. Figure 5.2: The industry lifecycle.
3. Figure 5.3: Product and process innovation over time.
4. Figure 5.4: Innovation and renewal in the Industry lifecycle: US retailing.
5. Figure 5.5: Phased development at Hyundai Motor.
6. Chapter 6
1. Figure 6.1: The development of technology: From knowledge creation to diffusion.
2. Figure 6.2: Appropriation of value: Who gets the benefits from innovation?
3. Figure 6.3: Complementary resources.
4. Figure 6.4: Alternative strategies for exploiting innovation.
7. Chapter 7
1. Figure 7.1: The scope of the firm: Specialization versus integration.
2. Figure 7.2: The value chain for steel cans.
3. Figure 7.3: Different types of vertical relationship.
4. Figure 7.4: The GE/McKinsey portfolio planning matrix.
5. Figure 7.5: The BCG growth-share matrix.
6. Figure 7.6: The Heartland Matrix: The potential for parenting advantage.
8. Chapter 8
1. Figure 8.1: Patterns of industry internationalization.
2. Figure 8.2: Competitive advantage in an international context.
3. Figure 8.3: Porter’s national diamond framework.
4. Figure 8.4: Determining the optimal location of value chain activities.
5. Figure 8.5: Alternative modes of overseas market entry.
6. Figure 8.6: Benefits of global integration versus national differentiation.
7. Figure 8.7: The development of the multinational corporation: Alternative parent-subsidiaries relations.
8. Figure 8.8: The transnational corporation.
9. Chapter 9
1. Figure 9.1: The generic annual strategic planning cycle.
2. Figure 9.2: How hierarchy economizes on coordination.
3. Figure 9.4: General Electric: Organizational structure: 2009.
4. Figure 9.5: Royal Dutch Shell Group: Pre-1996 matrix structure.
5. Figure 9.6: Illustrative organization chart for Cisco 2007.
10. Chapter 10
1. Figure 10.1: CEO-to-worker compensation ratios 1965–2012.
1
The concept of strategy
Introduction and objectives
Opening Case: Strategy and success: Lady Gaga and Jeff Bezos
The role of strategy in success
A brief history of strategy
Origins
The evolution of business strategy
Strategy today
What is strategy?
How do we describe a firm’s strategy?
How do we identify a firm’s strategy?
How is strategy made? Design versus emergence
What roles does strategy perform?
Strategy: In whose interest? Shareholders versus stakeholders
Strategy: Whose interests should be prioritized?
Profit and purpose
The debate over corporate social responsibility
Strategic management of not-for-profit organizations
The approach taken in this book
Summary
Further reading
Self-study questions
Closing Case: Tough Mudder LLC: Turning mud runs into a global business
Notes
Introduction and objectives
Strategy is about success. This chapter explains what strategy is and why it is important to individuals and organizations in achieving
their goals. We will distinguish strategy from planning. Strategy is not a detailed plan or programme of instructions; it is a unifying
theme that gives coherence and direction to the actions and decisions of an individual or an organization.
The principal task of this chapter is to introduce the notion of strategy, to make you aware of some of the key debates in strategy and to
present the basic framework for strategy analysis that underlies this book.
By the time you have completed this chapter, you will:






appreciate the contribution that strategy can make to successful performance, both for individuals and for organizations;
be aware of the origins of strategy and how views on strategy have changed over time;
be familiar with some of the key questions and terminology in strategy;
understand the debates that surround corporate values and social responsibility;
gain familiarity with the challenges of strategy making in not-for-profit organizations;
comprehend the basic approach to strategy that underlies this book.
Since the purpose of strategy is to help us to understand success, we start by looking at the role that strategy has played in enabling
individuals to achieve their goals. Our Opening Case provides a brief outline of two different success stories: Lady Gaga’s attainment of
celebrity status and Jeff Bezos’s building of Amazon. These two individuals working in very different fields offer fascinating insights
into the foundations of success and the nature of strategy.
Opening Case
Strategy and success: Lady Gaga and Jeff Bezos
Lady Gaga
Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta, better known as Lady Gaga, is the most successful popular entertainer to emerge in the
21st century. Her three albums, The Fame, released August 2008,Born This Way, released May 2011, and Artpop, released
November 2013, sold a total of 26 million copies by the end of 2013. Her Monster Ball completed a 2009 concert world tour
that grossed $227.4 million (the highest for any debut artist). She has earned five Grammy music awards and 13 MTV video
music awards and places on Forbes’ listings of The World’s 100 Most Powerful Women (though some way behind German
Chancellor Angela Merkel).
Since dropping out of NYU’s Tisch School of the Arts in 2005, she has shown total commitment to advancing her career as an
entertainer and developing her Lady Gaga persona. Gaga’s music is an appealing pastiche of Seventies glam, Eighties disco
and Nineties Europop. One music critic, Simon Reynolds, described it as, ‘ruthlessly catchy, noughties pop glazed with AutoTune and undergirded with R&B-ish beats’.1 Her songs embody themes of stardom, love, religion, money, identity, liberation,
sexuality and individualism.
However, music is only one element in the Lady Gaga phenomenon – her achievement is based less upon her abilities as a
singer or songwriter and more upon her establishing a persona which transcends pop music. Like David Bowie and Madonna
before her, Lady Gaga is famous for being Lady Gaga. The Gaga persona comprises a multimedia, multifaceted offering built
from an integrated array of components that include her music, her stunning visual appearance, newsworthy events,
distinctive social attitudes, her personality and a set of clearly communicated values. Key among these is visual impact and
theatricality. Lady Gaga’s outfits have set new standards in eccentricity and innovation. Her dresses – including her plastic
bubble dress, meat dress and ‘decapitated-corpse dress’ – together with weird hairdos, extravagant hats and extreme
footwear (she met President Obama in 16-inch heels) – are as well-known as her hit songs, and her music is promoted
through visually stunning videos that combine fantasy, sex, sadism and science fiction. The variety of visual images she
projects is such that her every appearance creates a buzz of anticipation as to her latest incarnation.
Lady Gaga has established a business model that recognizes the realities of the post-digital world of entertainment. Like Web
2.0 pioneers such as Facebook and Twitter, Gaga has followed the dictum ‘first build market presence then monetize that
presence’. She builds market presence through a range of online channels: her website, YouTube, Facebook and Twitter.
With 2.8 billion YouTube views, 64 million Facebook fans and 41 million Twitter followers, she is outranked in online
presence only by Justin Bieber and Katy Perry. Her emphasis on visual imagery reflects the ways in which her fame is
converted into revenue. Music royalties are dwarfed by her concert earnings. Her other revenue sources – merchandizing
deals, endorsements and product placements – are also linked to her market presence.
Figure 1.1 Common elements in successful strategies.
3. Objective appraisal of resources.
a. In positioning herself as a celebrity performance artist, Lady Gaga has exploited her talents in relation to design, creativity,
theatricality and self-promotion while astutely augmenting these skills with capabilities she has assembled within her Haus of Gaga.
b. Jeff Bezos’s leadership of Amazon has exploited his talent as a business and technological visionary and his attributes of persistence
and ruthlessness while bringing in the technical, logistical and merchandising know-how that he lacked.
4. Effective implementation.
a. Without effective implementation, even the best-laid strategies are likely to flounder. The ability of Lady Gaga and Amazon to beat
the odds and establish outstanding success owes much to their leaders’ determination and ability to encourage collaboration and
commitment from others.
These observations about the role of strategy in success can be made in relation to most fields of human endeavour. Whether
we look at warfare, chess, politics, sport or business, the success of individuals and organizations is seldom the outcome of a
purely random process. Nor is superiority in initial endowments of skills and resources typically the determining factor.
Strategies that build on the basic four elements almost always play an influential role.
Look at the ‘high achievers’ in any competitive area. Whether we review the world’s political leaders, the CEOs of the Fortune
500 or our own circles of friends and acquaintances, those who have achieved outstanding success in their careers seldom
possessed the greatest innate abilities. Success has gone to those who combine the four strategic factors mentioned above.
They are goal focused; their career goals have taken primacy over the multitude of life’s other goals – friendship, love, leisure,
knowledge, spiritual fulfilment – which the majority of us spend most of our lives juggling and reconciling. They know the
environments within which they play and tend to be fast learners in terms of understanding the keys to advancement. They
know themselves in terms of both strengths and weaknesses. And they implement their career strategies with commitment,
consistency and determination. As the late Peter Drucker observed: ‘We must learn how to be the CEO of our own careers.’ 4
There is a downside, however. Focusing on a single goal may lead to outstanding success but may be matched by dismal
failure in other areas of life.
Many people who have reached the pinnacles of their careers have led lives scarred by poor relationships with friends and
families and stunted personal development. These include Howard Hughes and Steve Jobs in business, Richard Nixon and
Joseph Stalin in politics, Marilyn Monroe and Elvis Presley in entertainment, Joe Louis and O. J. Simpson in sport and
Bobby Fischer in chess. Fulfilment in our personal lives is likely to require broad-based lifetime strategies.5
A brief history of strategy
Origins
Enterprises need business strategies for much the same reasons that armies need military strategies: to give direction and
purpose, to deploy resources in the most effective manner and to coordinate the decisions made by different individuals.
Many of the concepts and theories of business strategy have their antecedents in military strategy. The term ‘strategy’ derives
from the Greek word strategia, meaning ‘generalship’. However, the concept of strategy did not originate with the Greeks. Sun
Tzu’s classic The Art of War, written in about 500 BC, is regarded as the first treatise on strategy.6
Military strategy and business strategy share a number of common concepts and principles, the most basic being the
distinction between strategy and tactics. Strategy is the overall plan for deploying resources to establish a favourable position;
a tactic is a scheme for a specific action. Whereas tactics are concerned with the manoeuvres necessary to win battles, strategy
is concerned with winning the war. Strategic decisions, whether in military or business spheres, share three common
characteristics:



they are important;
they involve a significant commitment of resources;
they are not easily reversible.
Case Insight 1.2
Strategy versus tactics
A key lever for Amazon to drive sales growth was its shipping charges. During the 2000 and 2001 holiday seasons, Amazon began
offering free shipping (initially to customers placing orders of a $100 or more). Such cuts in shipping costs were tactical measures – they
could be introduced and withdrawn at relatively short notice, and while they were effective at boosting sales, they did not necessitate
significant resource commitments. The introduction of Amazon Prime in 2005 was different. In charging a $79 fee to cover 12 months
for free express delivery Amazon was, first, making a commitment for a year, second, it shifted consumers’ behaviour: members of
Prime had a huge incentive to maximize their purchases from Amazon, which then gave Amazon an incentive to broaden its range of
merchandise. Prime was a strategic initiative.
The evolution of business strategy
The evolution of business strategy has been driven more by the practical needs of business than by the development of theory.
During the 1950s and 1960s, senior executives were experiencing increasing difficulty in coordinating decisions and
maintaining control in companies that were growing in size and complexity. Financial budgeting, in the form of annual
financial planning and investment appraisal, provided short-term control and aided project selection but did little to guide
the long-term development of the firm. Corporate planning (also known as long-term planning) was developed during the late
1950s to serve this purpose. Macroeconomic forecasts provided the foundation for the new corporate planning. The typical
format was a five-year corporate planning document that set goals and objectives, forecast key economic trends (including
market demand, market share, revenue, costs and margins), established priorities for different products and business areas
of the firm and allocated capital expenditures. The diffusion of corporate planning was accelerated by a flood of articles and
books addressing this new science.7 The new techniques of corporate planning proved particularly useful for developing and
guiding the diversification strategies that many large companies were pursuing during the 1960s. By the mid-1960s, most
large US and European companies had set up corporate planning departments.
During the 1970s and early 1980s, confidence in corporate planning and infatuation with scientific approaches to
management were severely shaken. Not only did diversification fail to deliver the anticipated synergies but also the oil shocks
of 1974 and 1979 ushered in a new era of macroeconomic instability, combined with increased international competition
from resurgent Japanese, European and Southeast Asian firms. Faced with a more turbulent business environment, firms
could no longer plan their investments, new product introductions and personnel requirements three to five years ahead,
simply because they couldn’t forecast that far.
The result was a shift in emphasis from planning to strategy making, where the focus was less on the detailed management of
companies’ growth paths than on positioning the company in markets and in relation to competitors in order to maximize
the potential for profit. This transition from corporate planning to what became termed strategic management was associated
with increasing focus on competition as the central characteristic of the business environment and competitive advantage as
the primary goal of strategy.
The emphasis on strategic management also directed attention to business performance. During the late 1970s and into the
1980s, attention focused on sources of profit within the industry environment. Michael Porter of Harvard Business School
pioneered the application of industrial organization economics to analysing industry profitability.8 Other studies focused on
how profits were distributed between the different firms in an industry – in particular the impact of market share and
experience upon costs and profits.9
During the 1990s, the focus of strategy analysis shifted from the sources of profit in the external environment to the sources
of profit within the firm. Increasingly, the resources and capabilities of the firm became regarded as the main source of
competitive advantage and the primary basis for formulating strategy.10 This emphasis on what has been called the resourcebased view of the firm (a theoretical perspective that highlights the role of resources and capabilities as the principal basis for
a firm’s strategy) represented a substantial shift in thinking. Rather than firms pursuing similar strategies, as in seeking
attractive markets and favourable competitive positions, emphasis on internal resources and capabilities encouraged firms to
identify how they were different from their competitors and to design strategies that exploited these differences. Michael
Porter’s answer to the question ‘What is strategy?’
Figure 1.2 Evolution of strategic management: Dominant themes.
Strategy today
Having looked at the origins of strategy and how views on strategy have changed over time, we are ready to start our
exploration of strategy today. We do this by posing a series of basic questions. What is strategy? How might we describe
strategy? How do we go about identifying strategies in practice? How is strategy made? What purpose and whose interests
does strategy serve? Can the concepts and tools of strategy be applied to not-for-profit organizations? In providing
preliminary answers to these questions we introduce a number of key concepts and debates that we return to throughout this
book. As you will see when you get further into the subject, strategy is a complex and contested field of study, so answers,
which at first sight seem straightforward, can on deeper inspection raise further questions and force us to reflect on some
things we may have previously taken for granted. For example, when we address the question of whose interests strategy
serves, we find ourselves immediately propelled into considering whose interests strategy should serve. Before we get to that
debate, we need to familiarize ourselves with some basic terminology and concepts and the obvious starting point is with the
definition of the term ‘strategy’ itself.
What is strategy?
In its broadest sense, strategy is the means by which individuals or organizations achieve their objectives. Figure 1.3 presents
a number of definitions of the term strategy. Common to definitions of business strategy is the notion that strategy is focused
on achieving certain goals; that the critical actions which make up a strategy involve allocation of resources; and that strategy
implies consistency, integration or cohesiveness.
Yet, as we have seen, the conception of firm strategy has changed greatly over the past half century. As the business
environment has become more unstable and unpredictable, so strategy has become less concerned with detailed plans and
more about the quest for success. This is consistent with our starting point to the chapter. If we think back to Jeff Bezos and
Lady Gaga, neither wrote detailed strategic plans but both possessed clear ideas of what they wanted to achieve and how they
would achieve it. This shift in emphasis from strategy as plan to strategy as direction does not imply any downgrading of the
role of strategy. Certainly, in a turbulent environment, strategy must embrace flexibility and responsiveness. It is precisely in
these conditions that strategy becomes more rather than less important. In an environment of uncertainty and change, a
clear sense of direction is essential to the pursuit of objectives. When the firm is buffeted by unforeseen threats and when
new opportunities are constantly appearing, strategy becomes a vital tool to navigate the firm through stormy seas.
Figure 1.3 Some definitions of strategy.
Figure 1.4 Corporate versus business strategy.
When discussing strategy a distinction is commonly made between corporate strategy and business strategy (Figure 1.4).


Corporate strategy defines the scope of the firm in terms of the industries and markets in which it competes. Corporate strategy decisions
include investment in diversification, vertical integration, acquisitions and new ventures; the allocation of resources between the different
businesses of the firm; and divestments.
Business strategy is concerned with how the firm competes within a particular industry or market. If the firm is to prosper within an industry,
it must establish a competitive advantage over its rivals. Hence, this area of strategy is also referred to as competitive strategy.
This distinction may be expressed in even simpler terms. The basic question facing the firm is: ‘How do we make money?’
The answer to this question corresponds to the two basic strategic choices we identified above: ‘Where to compete?’ and
‘How to compete?’ The distinction between corporate strategy and business strategy corresponds to the organizational
structure of most large companies. Corporate strategy is typically the responsibility of the top management team and the
corporate strategy staff. Business strategy is primarily the responsibility of divisional management.
Case Insight 1.3
Corporate versus business strategy
Lady Gaga’s extension of her brand from recorded music to live concerts and interactive games illustrates the decisions she has taken at a
corporate strategic level, because they are concerned with where she competes. In contrast her frequent changes in image, her emphasis
on personal interaction with fans using digital media and her focus on theatricality are examples of how she chooses to compete and
constitute decisions about business strategy.
As an integrated approach to firm strategy, this book deals with both business and corporate strategy. Our initial emphasis is
on business strategy. This is because the critical requirement for a company’s success is its ability to establish competitive
advantage. Hence, issues of business strategy precede those of corporate strategy. At the same time, these two dimensions of
strategy are intertwined: the scope of a firm’s business has implications for the sources of competitive advantage; and the
nature of a firm’s competitive advantage determines the range of businesses in which it can be successful.
How do we describe a firm’s strategy?
These same two questions ‘Where is the firm competing?’ and ‘How is it competing?’ also provide the basis upon which we
can describe the strategy that a firm is pursuing. The where question has multiple dimensions. It relates to the industry or
industries in which the firm is located, the products it supplies, the customer groups it targets, the countries and localities in
which it operates and the vertical range of the activities it undertakes.
However, strategy is not simply about competing for today; it is also concerned with competing for tomorrow. This dynamic
concept of strategy involves establishing objectives for the future and determining how they will be achieved. Future
objectives relate to the overall purpose of the firm (mission), what it seeks to become (vision) and specific performance targets
(Figure 1.5).
Figure 1.5 Describing a firm’s strategy: Competing in the present, preparing for the future.
How do we identify a firm’s strategy?
Even if we know how to describe a firm’s strategy, where do we look to find what strategy a firm is pursuing? Where does
information of the type outlined in Figure 1.5 come from? Strategy is located in three places: in the heads of the chief
executive, senior managers and other members of the organization; in the top management team’s articulations of strategy in
speeches and written documents; and in the decisions through which strategy is enacted. Only the last two are observable.
While the most explicit statements of strategy – in board minutes and strategic planning documents – are almost invariably
confidential, most companies, and public companies in particular, see value in communicating their strategy to employees,
customers, investors and business partners and, inevitably, to the public at large. Collis and Rukstad identify a hierarchy of
strategy statements:17




The mission statement is the basic statement of organizational purpose; it addresses ‘Why we exist’.
A statement of principles or values outlines ‘What we believe in and how we will behave’.
The vision statement projects ‘What we want to be’.
The strategy statement articulates ‘What our competitive game plan will be’.
Collis and Rukstad argue that the game plan should comprise three definitive components of strategy: objectives,
scope (where we will compete) and advantage (how we will compete).
A version of some or all of these statements is typically found on the corporate pages of companies’ websites. Featured
Example 1.1 illustrates this point. More detailed statements of strategy, including qualitative and quantitative medium-term
targets, are often found in top management presentations to analysts which are typically included in the ‘For investors’ pages
of company websites. More detailed information on scope (Where?) and advantage (How?) can be found in companies’
annual reports but this kind of information can be difficult to find for privately owned companies.
The usefulness of public statements of strategy is, however, limited by their role as public relations vehicles. This is
particularly evident in vision and mission statements, which are frequently grandiose and cliché
d. Hence, explicit statements
of strategy need to be checked against decisions and actions:



Where is the company investing its money? Notes to financial statements often provide detailed breakdowns of capital expenditure by region
and business segment.
What technologies is the company developing? Identifying the patents that a company has filed (using the online databases of the US and EU
patent offices) indicates the technological trajectory it is pursuing.
What new products have been released, major investment projects initiated and/or top management hires made? A company’s press releases
usually announce these strategic decisions.
Identifying a firm’s strategy requires drawing upon multiple sources of information in order to build an overall picture of
what the company says it is doing and what it is actually doing.
Featured Example 1.1
Statements of company strategy: McDonald’s and the Merck Group
How is strategy made? Design versus emergence
How companies make strategy has been one of the most hotly debated issues in strategic management. Our emphasis on
strategy analysis encourages the view that strategy is the result of managers engaging in deliberate, rational analysis.
However, strategy may also emerge through adaptation to circumstances. In discussing Lady Gaga’s career, we discerned a
consistency and pattern to her career decisions that we described as a strategy, yet there is no evidence that she engaged in
any systematic strategic planning. And this is the same with many successful companies: Walmart’s winning strategy built on
large store formats, hub-and-spoke distribution, small-town locations and employee motivation was not a product of grand
design; it emerged from Sam Walton’s hunches and a series of historical accidents.
Henry Mintzberg is a leading critic of rational approaches to strategy design. He distinguishes intended,
realized and emergent strategies. Intended strategy is strategy as conceived of by the top management team. Even here,
intended strategy is less a product of rational deliberation and more an outcome of negotiation, bargaining and compromise
among the many individuals and groups involved in the process. However, realized strategy– the actual strategy that
is implemented – is only partly related to that which was intended (Mintzberg suggests only 10–30% of intended strategy is
realized). The primary determinant of realized strategy is what Mintzberg terms emergent strategy– the decisions that emerge
from the complex processes in which individual managers interpret the intended strategy and adapt to changing external
circumstances.18 According to Mintzberg, not only is rational design an inaccurate account of how strategies are actually
formulated, it is a poor way of making strategy.
‘The notion that strategy is something that should happen way up there, far removed from the details of running an
organization on a daily basis, is one of the great fallacies of conventional strategic management.’19
Featured Example 1.2
Honda’s entry into the US motorcycle market
Honda’s successful entry into the US motorcycle market has provided a central battleground between those who view strategy making as
primarily a rational, analytical process of deliberate planning (the design school) and those who envisage strategy as emerging from a
complex process of organizational decision making (the emergence or learning school of strategy).20 The Boston Consulting Group
lauded Honda for its single-minded pursuit of a global strategy based on exploiting economies of scale and learning to establish
unassailable cost leadership.21 However, subsequent interviews with the Honda managers in charge of US market entry revealed a
different story: a haphazard entry with little analysis and no clear plan.22 As Mintzberg observes: ‘Brilliant as its strategy may have
looked after the fact, Honda’s managers made almost every conceivable mistake until the market finally hit them over the head with the
right formula.’23
The emergent approaches to strategy making permit adaptation and learning though continuous interaction between
strategy formulation and strategy implementation in which strategy is constantly being adjusted and revised in light of
experience.
In practice, strategy making almost always involves a combination of centrally driven rational design and decentralized
adaptation. The design aspect of strategy comprises a number of organizational processes through which strategy is
deliberated, discussed and decided. In larger companies these include board meetings and a formalized process of strategic
planning supplemented by more broadly participative events such as strategy workshops.
At the same time, strategy is being continually enacted through decisions that are made by every member of the organization,
and by middle management especially. The decentralized, bottom-up strategy emergence may in fact lead to more formalized
strategy formulation. Intel’s historic decision to abandon memory chips and concentrate on microprocessors was initiated by
incremental decisions taken by business unit and plant managers that were subsequently promulgated by top management
into strategy.24
In all the companies we are familiar with, strategic planning combines design and emergence – a process that Grant refers to
as planned emergence.25 The balance between the two depends greatly upon the stability and predictability of a company’s
business environment. The Roman Catholic Church, for example, inhabits a relatively stable environment. For Google, Al
Qaeda and Zimbabwe Banking Corporation, however, strategic planning will inevitably be restricted to a few principles and
guidelines; the rest must emerge as circumstances unfold. As the business environment becomes more turbulent and less
predictable, so strategy making becomes more concerned with guidelines and less with specific decisions. We return to these
issues again throughout the book.
What roles does strategy perform?
The transition from corporate planning to strategic management has involved strategy moving from planning departments to
the centre of corporate leadership. As such, strategy occupies multiple roles within organizations.
STRATEGY AS DECISION SUPPORT We have described strategy as a pattern or theme that gives coherence to the
decisions of an individual or organization. But why can’t individuals or organizations make optimal decisions in the absence
of such a unifying theme? Consider the 1997 ‘man versus computer’ chess epic in which Garry Kasparov was defeated by
IBM’s Deep Blue computer.
Credit: AFP/Getty Images
Deep Blue did not need strategy. Its phenomenal memory and computing power allowed it to identify its optimal moves
based on a huge decision tree.26 Kasparov, although the world’s greatest chess player, was subject to bounded rationality: his
decision analysis was subject to the cognitive limitations that constrain all human beings.27 For chess players, a strategy
offers guidelines and decision criteria that assist positioning and help create opportunities.
Strategy improves decision making in several ways. First, strategy simplifies decision making by constraining the range of
decision alternatives considered and by acting as a heuristic (a rule of thumb) that reduces the search required to find an
acceptable solution to a decision problem. Second, a strategy-making process permits the knowledge of different individuals
to be pooled and integrated. Third, a strategy-making process facilitates the use of analytic tools: the frameworks and
techniques that we will encounter in the ensuing chapters of this book.
STRATEGY AS A COORDINATING DEVICE The greatest challenge of managing an organization is coordinating the
actions of different organizational members. Strategy can promote coordination in several ways. First, it is a communication
device. Statements of strategy are a powerful means through which the CEO can communicate the identity, goals and
positioning of the company to all organizational members. However, communication alone is not enough. For coordination
to be effective, buy-in is essential from the different groups that make up the organization. The strategic planning process can
provide a forum in which views are exchanged and consensus developed. Once formulated, the implementation of strategy
through goals, commitments and performance targets that are monitored over the strategic planning period also provides a
mechanism to ensure that the organization moves forward in a consistent direction.
STRATEGY AS TARGET Strategy is forward looking. It is concerned not only with how the firm will compete now but also
with what the firm will become in the future. A key purpose of a forward-looking strategy is not only to establish a direction
of the firm’s development but also to set aspirations that can motivate and inspire the members of the organization. Gary
Hamel and C. K. Prahalad use the term strategic intent to describe the articulation of a desired leadership position. They argue
that: ‘strategic intent creates an extreme misfit between resources and ambitions. Top management then challenges the
organization to close the gap by building new competitive advantages.’28 The implication they draw is that strategy should be
less about fit and resource allocation and more about stretchand resource leverage.29 The evidence from Toyota, Virgin and
Southwest Airlines is that resource scarcity may engender ambition, innovation and a ‘success against the odds’ culture. Jim
Collins and Jerry Porras make a similar point: US companies that have been sector leaders for 50 years or more – Merck,
Walt Disney, 3M, IBM and Ford – have all generated commitment and drive through setting ‘Big, Hairy, Ambitious Goals’.30
STRATEGY AS ANIMATION AND ORIENTATION Karl Weick popularized the story of a group of soldiers on
reconnaissance in the Alps who, after a snowstorm, lose their way.31 They are feeling cold and despondent until one of the
party discovers a tattered map in a little-used pocket. Finding the map animates the group and gets group members walking
until they are back on a familiar bearing. On reaching shelter they find that the map was of another mountain range, the
Pyrenees. The moral of the story is that the map is like strategy. Often the most important role of strategy is to animate and
orientate individuals within organizations so that they are mobilized, encouraged and work in concert to achieve focus and
direction even if the plan isn’t correct. It helps, of course, to work with a map or a plan that is as accurate as possible.
Strategy: In whose interest? Shareholders versus stakeholders
We have highlighted the multiple roles that strategy plays in organizations and its central role is assisting organizations to
achieve their goals, but while it is easy to comprehend an individual having personal goals, the notion of organizations
having goals is slightly more problematic. Organizations are composed of many different individuals and groups, many of
which may have different agendas. As a consequence, firms are likely to have multiple goals some of which may, at times,
conflict. Nonetheless, at the broadest level, all businesses seek to create value through the activities they undertake. This, of
course, invites the questions about what we mean by value and who benefits from the value businesses create. Defining value
is not straightforward, because it is rarely a matter of objective fact. Perceptions of value arise through the interplay of supply
and demand and through processes of negotiation and argument but, in the business world, value is usually assessed in
monetary terms through customers’ willingness to pay for a good or service. Firms create value for their customers to the
extent that the satisfaction customers gain exceeds the price they pay for the goods or services they purchase.
The ‘value’ created by firms is distributed among different parties: employees (wages and salaries), lenders (interest),
landlords (rent), government (taxes) and owners (profit). Given that the value added by firms is distributed between these
different parties, it is tempting to think of all businesses as operating for the benefit of multiple constituencies. This view of
business organizations as coalitions of interest groups where top management’s role to balance these different, often
conflicting, interests is referred to as the stakeholder approach to the firm.32
Stakeholder analysis is a useful tool for identifying, understanding and prioritizing the needs of key stakeholders. The needs
and goals of stakeholders often conflict, requiring organizations to engage in an ongoing process of balancing and managing
multiple objectives and relationships. Bryson outlines a number of key steps in stakeholder analysis:33


Identification of the list of potential stakeholders – this stage usually involves a brainstorming session between informed parties;
Ranking stakeholders according to their importance and influence on the organization;




For each stakeholder identifying the criteria that stakeholder would use to judge the organization’s performance or the extent to which it is
meeting stakeholders’ expectations;
Deciding how well the organization is doing from its stakeholders’ perspective;
Identifying what can be done to satisfy each stakeholder;
Identifying and recording longer-term issues with individual stakeholders and stakeholders as a group.
To assist with this analysis Eden and Akerman suggest the use of power interest grids (Figure 1.6).34 These grids array
stakeholders in a matrix with stakeholder interest forming one dimension and stakeholder power the other.
Stakeholder interest refers to a particular stakeholder’s political interest in an organization or issue rather than merely their
degree of inquisitiveness. Stakeholder power refers to the stakeholder’s ability to affect the organization’s or the issue’s future.
Four categories of stakeholders result. Players are stakeholders who have both an interest and significant power; subjects are
stakeholders with an interest but little power; context setters are stakeholders with power but little direct interest; and the
crowd make up the final box comprising those with neither interest nor power. The grid is used to identify which stakeholder
interests and power bases should be taken into account, but it also helps identify what coalitions amongst
Figure 1.6 Stakeholder power/interest grid.
Source: C. Eden and F. Ackerman (1998) Making Strategy: The Journey of Strategic Management (London: Sage).
Figure 1.7 Responses to stakeholders’ positions within the power/interest grid.
In contrast, however, in many countries the prime concern of firms is seen as producing profits for shareholders. The
question of whose interests strategy should serve is the subject of much debate, particularly since the 2008 financial crisis
revealed some of the shortcomings of shareholder capitalism so in the next section we review some of the main arguments.
Strategy: Whose interests should be prioritized?
The notion of the corporation balancing the interests of multiple stakeholders has a long tradition, especially in Asia and
continental Europe. By contrast, most English-speaking countries have endorsed shareholder capitalism, where companies’
overriding duty is to produce profits for owners. These differences are reflected in international differences in companies’
legal obligations. In the US, Canada, the UK and Australia, company boards are required to act in the interests of
shareholders. In continental European countries, companies are legally required to take account of the interests of
employees, the state and the enterprise as a whole. Whether companies should operate exclusively in the interests of their
owners or should also pursue the goals of other stakeholders is an ongoing debate.
During the 1990s, Anglo-Saxon shareholder capitalism was in the ascendancy – many continental European and Japanese
companies changed their strategies and corporate governance to increase their responsiveness to shareholder interests.
However, during the 21st century, shareholder value maximization has come to be associated with short-termism, financial
manipulation (Enron, WorldCom), excessive CEO compensation and the failures of risk management that precipitated the
2008/9 financial crisis. The responsibilities of business to employees, customers, society and the natural environment are
central ethical and social issues.
Featured Example 1.3
The Kraft takeover of Cadbury: Shareholders versus stakeholders
Cadbury plc was a globally recognized confectionery company, second only to the Mars-Wrigley group in size worldwide. Its brands
included Crunchie, Flake, Creme Eggs, Roses and Milk Tray, to name but a few. In its long history Cadbury had acquired many other
companies but in February 2010 the company itself became an acquisition target, was taken over by the US food giant Kraft and ceased
to exist as an independent corporate entity.
The business was originally founded in the UK by John Cadbury in 1824 selling tea, coffee and drinking chocolate. The business
flourished and John extended his activities into the production of cocoas and drinking chocolates and formed the partnership Cadbury
Brothers of Birmingham with his brother Benjamin. The business gained particular momentum in the 1850s when a reduction in the high
rate of import tax on cocoa and chocolate meant the Cadbury Brothers’ products, which had hitherto been the preserve of the wealthy
owing to their high cost, became more affordable to the general public. Around this time master confectioner Frederic Kinchelman joined
the business, bringing with him his recipes and production secrets. This allowed Cadbury to move into the chocolate-covered
confectionery products that eventually became the basis of the company’s growth and development.
Credit: AFP/Getty Images
In due course, the business was taken over by John Cadbury’s sons, who decided that they needed larger premises. They acquired land
just outside Birmingham and their new Bournville factory opened in 1879. John’s sons, like their father and uncle, were Quakers, that is
to say members of a Protestant religious group that rejected ritual and formal creed and had a commitment to social reform. Acting in the
Quaker philanthropic tradition, George Cadbury (one of John’s sons) bought land adjacent to the new factory and built a model village
for workers at his own expense in order to ‘alleviate the evils of more cramped living conditions’. His aim was to operate a profitable
company that cared for and nurtured its employees. The company retained its commitment to social philanthropy over time and was
known for its caring attitude to its workers and for its charitable works. The company ethos proved so enduring that in 2010, when
faced with the hostile bid from Kraft, the then chief executive of Cadbury, Todd Stitzer, argued that his firm was the embodiment of a
distinctive style of ‘principled capitalism’ that was ‘woven into its fabric’ by its founders. He saw the Cadbury culture as something
distinctive that contributed to the company’s competitive success and argued that this advantage would be lost if the company were
acquired by Kraft.
Kraft eventually acquired control of Cadbury in February 2010 but the takeover was particularly controversial. Cadbury workers
protested on the streets, the Royal Bank of Scotland was fiercely criticized for lending Kraft the money to close the deal and a few
politicians tried to have the takeover blocked on competition grounds. At the heart of the debate over Cadbury’s future was disagreement
about whose interests were being served. Those who wished to block the bid argued that past history suggested that Kraft would
prioritize shareholders’ interests above those of other stakeholders and in the pursuit of profit would negate everything that Cadbury had
previously stood for. Others saw no such conflict, arguing that doing good is good for business and, anyway, firms that do not pay
attention to shareholders’ interests do not survive.
In practice the extent to which firms take a narrow (shareholder) or broad (stakeholder) view of their purpose is probably
more a matter of pragmatics than arbitrary choice. In a competitive labour market, firms that failed to take their employees
into account would soon find themselves incurring costs of high labour turnover. Similarly, firms that failed to take the
interests of customers or suppliers into account would be at a disadvantage relative to competitors with different policies. In
practice what is important is the priority given to different groups and senior managements’ judgement calls on the tradeoffs required to satisfy important interest groups.
Profit and purpose
As the Cadbury example illustrates, there is more to business than making money. Profit maximization (enterprise value
maximization, to be more precise) provides a convenient foundation for building our tools of strategy analysis, yet it is not
the goal that inspired Henry Ford to build a business that precipitated a social revolution.
‘I will build a motor car for the great multitude … It will be so low in price that no man making good wages will be unable to
own one and to enjoy with his family the blessing of hours of pleasure in God’s great open spaces … When I’m through,
everyone will be able to afford one and everyone will have one.’36
We saw in our Opening Case that Lady Gaga and Jeff Bezos were not so much driven by the desire for riches as the desire to
fulfil a broader vision. Likewise, the world’s most consistently successful companies in terms of profits and shareholder value
tend to be those that are motivated by factors other than profit. A succession of studies point to the role of strategic intent,
vision and ambitious goals in driving sustained corporate success.37 Indeed, the converse may also be true: companies that
are most focused on profitability and the creation of shareholder value are often remarkably unsuccessful at achieving those
goals.
Why does the pursuit of profit so often fail to realize its goal? First, profit will only be an effective guide to management
action if managers know what determines profit. Obsession with profitability can blinker managers’ perception of the real
drivers of superior performance. Conversely, a strategic goal ‘to build a motor car for the great multitude that everyone will
be able to afford’ (Ford) or to ‘build great planes’ (Boeing) or to ‘become the company most known for changing the
worldwide poor quality image associated with Japanese products’ (Sony, 1950s) may lead a company to direct its efforts
towards the sources of competitive advantage within its industry – ultimately leading to superior long-term profitability.
Some companies have kept alive a keen sense of purpose. It is embedded in organizational culture and implicit in strategy
and in the behaviour of corporate leaders. However, sustaining a sense of purpose typically requires articulation in explicit
statements of mission, vision and purpose. For example:




Google’s mission is: ‘to organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful’.
‘The IKEA vision is to create a better everyday life for the many people. They make this possible by offering a wide range of well-designed,
functional home furnishing products at prices so low that as many people as possible will be able to afford them.’
SAP strives to define and establish undisputed leadership in the emerging market for business process platform offerings and accelerate
business innovation powered by IT for companies and industries worldwide.
Oxfam aspires to create lasting solutions to poverty, hunger and social injustice.
The second factor concerns motivation. Success is the result of coordinated effort. The goal of maximizing the return to
stockholders is unlikely to inspire employees and other company stakeholders and it’s unlikely to be especially effective in
inducing cooperation and unity between them. Dennis Bakke, founder of the international power company AES, offers the
following analogy:
Profits are to business as breathing is to life. Breathing is essential to life, but is not the purpose for living. Similarly, profits are essential
for the existence of the corporation, but they are not the reason for its existence.38
A sense of purpose is common to most new, entrepreneurial enterprises and is also very evident in numerous non-privatesector organizations. But what about established companies? What happens to the sense of purpose that was presumably
present at their founding?
Is organizational purpose instilled at birth or can companies choose or adapt their raison d’être during the course of their
lives? Certainly many of the companies that are most
Table 1.1 Applying the concepts and tools of strategic analysis to different types of not-for-profit organization.
In terms of the analysis of the external environment, there is little difference between the techniques of industry analysis
applied to business enterprises and those relevant to not-for-profits that inhabit competitive environments and charge for
their services. In many markets (theatres, sports clubs, vocational training) for-profits and not-for-profits may be in
competition with one another. Indeed, for these types of not-for-profit organizations, the pressing need to break even in
order to survive may mean that their strategies do not differ significantly from those of for-profit firms. In the case of notfor-profits that do not charge users for the services they offer (mostly charities), competition does not really exist at the final
market level: different homeless shelters in San Francisco cannot really be said to be competing for the homeless. However,
these organizations compete for funding: raising donations from individuals, winning grants from foundations or obtaining
contracts from funding agencies. Competing in the market for funding is a key area of strategy for most not-for-profits. The
analysis of resources and capabilities is important to all organizations that inhabit competitive environments and must
deploy their internal resources and capabilities to establish a competitive advantage; however, even for those organizations
that are monopolists – many government departments and other public agencies, for example – performance is enhanced by
aligning strategy with internal strengths in resources and capabilities.
The approach taken in this book
Figure 1.8 shows the basic framework for strategy analysis that we use throughout the book. The four elements of a successful
strategy that we outline at the start of this chapter and illustrate in Figure 1.1are recast into two groups – the firm and the
industry environment – with strategy forming a link between the two. The firm embodies three sets of these elements: goals
and values (‘simple, consistent, long-term goals’), resources and capabilities (‘objective appraisal of resources’) and structure
and systems (‘effective implementation’).
The industry environment (‘profound understanding of the competitive environment’) represents the core of the firm’s
external environment and is defined by the firm’s relationships with customers, competitors and suppliers. Hence, we view
strategy as forming a link between the firm and its external environment.
Fundamental to this view of strategy as a link between the firm and its external environment is the notion of strategic fit. For
a strategy to be successful, it must be consistent with the firm’s external environment and with its internal environment – its
goals and values, resources and capabilities and structure and systems. As we shall see, the failure of many companies is
caused by a lack of consistency with either the internal or external environment. General Motors’ long-term decline is a
consequence of a strategy that has failed to break away from its long-established ideas about multibrand market
segmentation and adapt to the changing market for cars. In other cases, many companies have failed to align their strategies
to their internal resources and capabilities. A critical issue for Nintendo in the coming years will be whether it possesses the
financial and technological resources to continue to compete head-to-head with Sony and Microsoft in the market for video
game consoles. We address the ways in which successful firms achieve fit in the first half of the book, exploring the key tools
of strategic analysis. In Chapters 2, 3 and 4, we focus on business strategy and the quest for competitive advantage before
exploring the ways in which business strategies need to adapt and change in response to different industry contexts
in Chapters 5 and 6. In Chapters 7 and 8, we turn our attention to corporate strategy and the scope of a firm’s activities and
conclude in Chapters 9 and 10 by looking at the challenges of realizing strategy and recent thinking on ways organizations can
adapt their strategies to deal with an ever-changing world.
Figure 1.8 The basic framework: Strategy as a link between the firm and its environment.
Summary
This chapter covers a great deal of ground. If you are feeling a little overwhelmed, not to worry: we shall be returning to the
themes and issues raised in this chapter in subsequent sections of the book. Through the examples provided in our Opening
Case and our subsequent discussion, we have sought to show you the links between strategy and success and to outline the
different ways of thinking about strategy. By posing a series of fundamental questions we have uncovered a number of
central debates. Is strategy about planning or about recognizing patterns? Is strategy formulation the prerogative of the top
management team or something that emerges? Whose interests does strategy serve and, equally importantly, whose
interests should it serve? Can the concepts and tools of corporate and business strategy be applied to not-for-profit
organizations or are they only of value to for-profit firms?
The strategic issues that individuals face in their careers and firms face in their business operations are too complex to lend
themselves to simple solutions, and as we progress through this book and introduce an array of analytical tools and
techniques, you will soon come to appreciate that the purpose of studying strategy is not to provide quick-fix answers (there
aren’t any!) but to understand the issues better. Most of the analytical concepts and techniques we introduce in this and
subsequent chapters are designed to help us identify, classify and understand the principal factors relevant to strategic
decisions. Often one of the most useful contributions strategic analysis makes is to enable us to make a start on unpicking
problems. It helps us to find those initial threads that are the key to untangling complex knots.
We have seen that strategy is about providing common purpose, committing resources and creating value, so inevitably
strategy is bound up with ethical questions. What values and principles should a business organization adopt? What are a
business organization’s broader obligations to society as a whole? As we progress through the illustrative cases and chapters
of this book, we will see that strategic decisions always have an ethical dimension and that the pursuit of shareholder as
opposed to broader stakeholder interests remains a hotly contested debate. We will also see that the pursuit of wider social
and environmental goals does not necessarily have to conflict with shareholder interests. Strategy’s main concern is about
creating value for the future and this requires identifying and exploiting the fundamental drivers of value in a principled way.
Summary table
Further reading
In his 1996 article, Michael Porter provides an excellent discussion on the difference between strategy and operational effectiveness and
in a later article he provides some good insights into current debates about shareholder versus stakeholder values and corporate social
responsibility. Campbell and Yeung’s (1991) article on mission and vision is something of a classic, making clear the distinction between
a firm’s mission and attempts to create a ‘sense of mission’. Henry Mintzberg’s work is the obvious starting point for deeper insight into
the ways in which strategy is made.
Campbell, A. and Yeung, S. (1991). Creating a sense of mission. Long Range Planning, 24(4), 10–20.
Mintzberg, H. (1985). Of strategies: Deliberate and emergent. Strategic Management Journal, 6, 257–72.
Porter, M. E. (1996). What is strategy? Harvard Business Review, 74(6), 61–78.
Porter, M. E. (2006). Strategy and society: The link between competitive advantage and corporate social responsibility. Harvard Business
Review, 84(2), 78–92.
Self-study questions
1. Choose a company that has recently been celebrated in the media for its success and examine its performance in relation to the
four characteristics of successful strategies (clear, consistent, long-term objectives; profound understanding of the environment;
objective appraisal of resources; and effective implementation).
2. The discussion of the evolution of business strategy established that the characteristics of a firm’s strategic plans and its strategic
planning process are strongly influenced by the volatility and unpredictability of its external environment. On this basis, what
differences would you expect in the strategic plans and strategic planning processes of the Coca-Cola Company and Google Inc?
3. Select a firm and use Internet resources to identify and describe its strategy. Use the template provided in Figure 1.5 to structure
your answer.
4. What is your career strategy for the next five years? To what extent does your strategy fit with your long-term goals, the
characteristics of the external environment and your own strengths and weaknesses?
5. ‘Firms abandon shareholder value maximization in favour of some woolly notion of stakeholder satisfaction at their peril.’
Discuss, explaining the benefits and drawback of firms acting primarily in the interests of shareholders.
Closing Case
Tough Mudder LLC: Turning mud runs into a global business
Really tough. But really fun. When I got back to the office on Monday morning, I looked at my colleagues and thought: ‘And what did
you do over the weekend?’
Tough Mudder participant
Introduction
Tough Mudder LLC is a New York-based company that hosts endurance obstacle events – a rapidly growing sport also
known as ‘mud runs’. During 2014, over one million participants will each pay between $100 and $180 to tackle a 10- to 12mile Tough Mudder course featuring 15 to 20 challenging obstacles at 60 different locations in nine different countries. The
obstacles include wading through a dumpster filled with ice (the Arctic Enema), crawling through a series of pipes part-filled
with mud (Boa Constrictor) and dashing through live wires carrying up to 10 000 volts (Electroshock Therapy). Tough
Mudder’s website describes the experience as follows:
Tough Mudder events are hardcore obstacle courses designed to test your all around strength, stamina, mental grit and camaraderie. With
the most innovative courses, over one million inspiring participants worldwide to date, and more than $5 million raised for the Wounded
Warrior Project, Tough Mudder is the premier adventure challenge series in the world. But Tough Mudder is more than an event; it’s a
way of thinking. By running a Tough Mudder challenge, you’ll unlock a true sense of accomplishment, have a great time and discover a
camaraderie with your fellow participants that’s experienced all too rarely these days.45
Tough Mudder was founded in 2010 by former British school pals Will Dean and Guy Livingston. While a Harvard MBA
student, Dean entered Harvard Business School’s annual business plan competition using Tough Guy, a UK obstacle race
based on British Special Forces training, as the basis for his plan.46 On graduating from Harvard, Dean and Livingstone
launched their first Tough Mudder event on 21st May 2010 at Bear Creek Mountain, Pennsylvania attracting 4500
participants.
Growing the company, building the brand
Tough Mudder was targeting the market for endurance sports which comprised traditional endurance sports such as
marathons, triathlons and orienteering and newer activities, including:



Adventure races: off-road, triathlon-based events that typically include trekking/orienteering, mountain biking and paddling.
Obstacle mud runs: cross-country running events with a variety of challenging obstacles.
Novelty events: fun events such as 5 km races in which competitors are doused in paint (Color Run), running with real bulls
(Great Bull Run) and food fights (Tomato Royale).
Figure 1.9 Tough Mudder: Growth 2010–2014.
Case questions
 How would you describe Tough Mudder’s strategy?
 Why has the strategy been successful?
 What do you think is the role of Tough Mudder’s sense of identity (‘We know who we are and what we stand for’) in influencing
the effectiveness with which it implements its strategy?
 Distinguish between the following concepts using examples drawn from the case:
 corporate and competitive strategy;
 strategy and tactics.
 What challenges and opportunities does Tough Mudder currently face and how should it adapt its strategy to meet these
challenges and exploit the opportunities?
 Is Tough Mudder a socially responsible company? To what extent are Tough Mudder’s corporate social responsibility activities a
tool of competitive strategy?
Notes
1 S. Reynolds (2010) The 1980s revival that lasted and entire decade. Guardian 22nd
January, www.theguardian.com/music/musicblog/2010/jan/22/eighties-revival-decade, accessed 29th September 2014.
2 S. Fry (2011) Lady Gaga takes tea with Mr Fry, Financial Times, 28th May.
3 We have drawn extensively on Mauro Sala’s Bocconi University, BSc thesis, Milan, June 2011.
4 P. F. Drucker, ‘Managing oneself’, Harvard Business Review (March–April, 1999): 65–74.
5 S. Covey (The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People, Simon & Schuster, 1989) advises us to start at the end – to visualize our
own funerals and imagine what we would like the funeral speakers to say about us and our lives. On this basis, he
recommends that we develop lifetime mission statements based on the multiple roles that we occupy in life.
6 Sun Tzu, The Art of Strategy: A New Translation of Sun Tzu’s Classic ‘The Art of War’, trans. R. L. Wing (New York: Doubleday,
1988).
7 During the late 1950s, Harvard Business Review featured a number of articles on corporate planning, e.g. D. W. Ewing,
‘Looking around: Long-range business planning’, Harvard Business Review (July–August 1956): 135–46; B. Payne, ‘Steps in
long-range planning’, Harvard Business Review (March–April 1957): 95–101.
8 M. E. Porter, Competitive Strategy (New York: Free Press, 1980).
9 Boston Consulting Group, Perspectives on Experience (Boston: Boston Consulting Group, 1978).
10 R. M. Grant, ‘The resource-based theory of competitive advantage: Implications for strategy formulation’, California
Management Review, 33 (Spring 1991): 114–35; D. J. Collis and C. Montgomery, ‘Competing on resources: Strategy in the
1990s’, Harvard Business Review (July–August 1995): 119–28.
11 M. E. Porter, ‘What is strategy?’ Harvard Business Review (November–December 1996): 64.
12 C. Shapiro and H. R. Varian, Information Rules (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 1998); R. H. Frank and P. J.
Cook, The Winner-Take-All Society (New York: Penguin, 1997).
13 C. Christensen, The Innovator’s Dilemma (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 1997).
14 P. J. Williamson, ‘Strategy as options on the future’, Sloan Management Review, 40(3) (1999): 117–26.
15 C. Markides, ‘Strategic innovation in established companies’, Sloan Management Review (June 1998).
16 W. C. Kim and R. Mauborgne, ‘Creating new market space’, Harvard Business Review (January–February 1999): 83–93.
17 D. J. Collis and M. G. Rukstad, ‘Can you say what your strategy is?’ Harvard Business Review (April 2008): 63–73.
18 See H. Mintzberg, ‘Patterns of strategy formulation’, Management Science, 24 (1978): 934–48; ‘Of strategies: Deliberate
and emergent’, Strategic Management Journal, 6 (1985): 257–72; Mintzberg on Management: Inside our strange world of
organizations (New York: Free Press, 1988).
19 H. Mintzberg, ‘The fall and rise of strategic planning’, Harvard Business Review (January–February 1994): 107–14.
20 The two views of Honda are captured in two Harvard cases: Honda [A] (Boston: Harvard Business School, Case No.
384049, 1989) and Honda [B] (Boston: Harvard Business School, Case No. 384050, 1989).
21 Boston Consulting Group, Strategy Alternatives for the British Motorcycle Industry (London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office,
1975).
22 R. T. Pascale, ‘Perspective on strategy: The real story behind Honda’s success’, California Management Review, 26 (Spring
1984): 47–72.
23 H. Mintzberg, ‘Crafting strategy’, Harvard Business Review, 65 (July–August 1987): 70.
24 R. A. Burgelman and A. Grove, ‘Strategic dissonance’, California Management Review, 38 (Winter 1996): 8–28.
25 R. M. Grant, ‘Strategic planning in a turbulent environment: Evidence from the oil and gas majors’, Strategic Management
Journal 14 (June 2003): 491–517.
26 ‘Strategic intensity: A conversation with Garry Kasparov’, Harvard Business Review (April 2005): 105–13.
27 The concept of bounded rationality was developed by Herbert Simon (‘A behavioral model of rational choice’, Quarterly
Journal of Economics, 69 (1955): 99–118).
28 G. Hamel and C. K. Prahalad, ‘Strategic intent’, Harvard Business Review (May–June 1989): 63–77.
29 G. Hamel and C. K. Prahalad, ‘Strategy as stretch and leverage’, Harvard Business Review (March–April 1993): 75–84.
30 J. C. Collins and J. I. Porras, Built to Last: Successful habits of visionary companies (New York: HarperCollins, 1995).
31 K. E. Weick, Sensemaking in Organizations (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1995): 54.
32 T. Donaldson and L. E. Preston, The stakeholder theory of the corporation, Academy of Management Review, 20 (1995): 65–
91.
33 J. M. Bryson, ‘What to do when stakeholders matter: Stakeholder identification and analysis techniques’, Public
Management Review, 6 (2004): 21–53.
34 F. Akermann and C. Eden, ‘Strategic Management of Stakeholders: Theory and practice’, Long Range Planning, 44 (2011):
179–96.
35 J. M. Bryson, ‘What to do when stakeholders matter: Stakeholder identification and analysis techniques’, Public
Management Review, 6 (2004): 21–53.
36 See www.abelard.org/ford, accessed 29th September 2014.
37 J. Collins and J. Porras, ‘Building your company’s vision’, Harvard Business Review (September–October, 1996): 65–77.
38 Robert Grant’s interview with Dennis Bakke.
39 C. A. Montgomery, ‘Putting leadership back into strategy’, Harvard Business Review (January, 2008): 54–60.
40 M. Friedman, Capitalism and Freedom (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1963). See also: M. Friedman, ‘The social
responsibility of business is to increase its profits’, New York Times Magazine(13th September 1970).
41 J. Helwege, V. Intintoli and A. Zhang, ‘Voting with their feet or activism? Institutional investors’ impact on CEO
turnover’, Journal of Corporate Finance, 18 (2012): 22–37.
42 J. Figuero, S. Greco and M. Ehrgott, Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis: State of the art surveys (Berlin: Springer, 2005).
43 W. T. Allen, ‘Our schizophrenic conception of the business corporation’, Cardozo Law Review, 14 (1992): 261–81.
44 C. Handy, ‘What’s a business for?’ Harvard Business Review (December, 2002): 133–43.
45 http://toughmudder.com/about/, accessed 29th September 2014.
46 http://toughmudder.com/history-of-tough-mudder/, accessed 29th September 2014.
47 J. D. Stein ‘Forging a bond in mud and guts’, New York Times (7th December
2012), http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/09/fashion/extreme-obstacle-course-races-forge-a-bond-in-mud-andguts.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0, accessed 29th September 2014.
48 http://toughmudder.com/about/, accessed 9th September 2014.
49 J. Grose ‘Tough Mudder: There are riches in this mud pit’, New York Magazine (29th September
2013), http://nymag.com/news/business/boom-brands/tough-mudder-2013-10, accessed 29th September 2014.
50 G. Stoddard ‘Tough Mudder’, Financial Times online edition (18th January 2013), http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/7a80e610-603d11e2-b657-00144feab49a.html#ixzz2nFzd1Xx4, accessed 29th September 2014.
51 Issie Lapowsky ‘The Way I Work: Will Dean, Tough Mudder’ Inc Magazine (13th February
2013), http://www.inc.com/magazine/201302/issie-lapowsky/the-way-i-work-will-dean-tough-mudder.html, accessed 29th September
2014.
52 W. Dean ‘On the Streets of SoHo: Tough Mudder’, http://issuu.com/accordion_partners/docs/q_a_will_dean_lite, accessed 29th
September 2014.
2
Industry analysis
Introduction and objectives
Opening Case: Pot of gold? The Colorado marijuana-growing industry
From environmental analysis to industry analysis
The determinants of industry profit: Demand and competition
Analysing industry attractiveness
Porter’s five forces of competition framework
Competition from substitutes
The threat of entry
Rivalry between established competitors
Bargaining power of buyers
Bargaining power of suppliers
Applying industry analysis to forecasting industry profitability
Identifying industry structure
Forecasting industry profitability
Using industry analysis to develop strategy
Strategies to alter industry structure
Positioning the company
Defining an industry
Reviewing the five forces of competition framework
Complements: A missing force in the Porter model?
Segmentation analysis
Dealing with dynamic competition
From industry attractiveness to competitive advantage: Identifying key success factors
Summary
Further reading
Self-study questions
Closing case: Fitness First and the UK health and fitness club industry
Notes
Introduction and objectives
In this chapter, we explore the external environment of the firm. In Chapter 1, we observed that profound understanding of the
competitive environment is a critical ingredient of a successful strategy. We further noted that business strategy is essentially a quest for
profit. The primary task for this chapter is to identify the sources of profit in the external environment. The firm’s proximate environment
is its industry environment, hence the primary focus of this chapter is on industry analysis.
By the time you have completed this chapter, you will:






be familiar with a number of frameworks used to analyse an organization’s external environment and understand how the
structural features of an industry influence competition and profitability;
be able to use evidence on structural trends within industries to forecast changes in competition and profitability and to develop
appropriate strategies for the future;
be able to define the boundaries of the industry within which a firm is located;
be able to recognize the limits of the Porter five forces of competition framework (commonly known as the five forces framework)
and extend the framework to include the role of complements as well as substitutes;
be able to segment an industry into its constituent markets and appraise the relative attractiveness of different segments;
be able to analyse competition and customer requirements in order to identify opportunities for competitive advantage within an
industry (key success factors).
Opening Case
Pot of gold? The Colorado marijuana-growing industry
Legalization of the sale of marijuana by the states of Colorado and Washington in 2014 was a milestone in transition of
America’s marijuana business from a clandestine activity, where growers, dealers and consumers risked fines and jail
sentences, to a legitimate economic activity on a par with tobacco and alcoholic beverages. By the end of 2014, only Colorado
and Washington state allowed the sale of marijuana for recreational use, but 14 other states and the District of Colombia
permitted its sale for medical use. Despite continuing concerns over the physical and psychological risks of marijuana
consumption, several experts predicted that, by 2020, the majority of US states would legalize its recreational sale and use.
It was not only the 7.3% of Americans who were regular consumers of marijuana who welcomed the trend towards legality.
With decriminalization, existing growers of marijuana could emerge from secrecy and newcomers were establishing
cultivation. During 2013, it was estimated that 2000 to 4000 businesses were legally producing marijuana with sales of
about $1.2 billion. New start-ups and the expansion of existing businesses required investment funds. Existing banks and
venture capital funds were unwilling to finance marijuana-related businesses: the growing, sale and possession of marijuana
was still a federal offence.
This created an opportunity for new sources of investment. Among the newly created venture capital funds investing in the
marijuana industry, an early leader was Seattle-based Privateer Holdings. Founded by two investment analysts with Yale
MBAs, Privateer hoped to raise $50 million in 2014 to acquire equity stakes in marijuana-based businesses. Another early
leader was ArcView Group, which acted as an intermediary between businesses seeking investment funds and investors,
mainly wealthy individuals. Investor interest was generated by a growing number of trade conventions and conferences. The
annual CannaBusiness Conference in 2014 in Las Vegas attracted around 1500 industry professionals.
Despite being poised for rapid growth (‘After 3D printing and cloud computing, marijuana is one of the fastest growing
industries in the country’), the industry’s profit prospects were less clear. The Motley Fool suggested that marijuana was a
highly profitable crop: a 10 000-square-foot growing facility with five annual growing cycles could produce 1250 lb a year
with a wholesale value of $2.75 million.1 With production costs of $1.25 million, this implied a net margin of 55%. However,
most Colorado marijuana suppliers reported much more modest margins: La Conte’s Clone Bar & Dispensary earned a
margin of just 6% on revenues of $4.2 million. Future profitability would depend heavily on marijuana prices. In March 2014,
high-quality legal marijuana sold for between $280 and $340 an ounce in Colorado (including state taxes of about 28%); for
medical marijuana, it was closer to $200 an ounce. However, with increasing production capacity, it seemed likely that prices
would fall.
Setting up marijuana cultivation required obtaining a licence, an arduous process involving detailed background checks on
applicants, and capital investment of at least $1 million. Marijuana-growing facilities are capital-intensive: plants are grown
indoors under electric lights under tight security conditions and Colorado regulations require growing plants to be monitored
with security cameras. Facilities tended to be 60 000 square feet or more with capital costs of at least $100 per square foot.
The Colorado regulations favoured vertical integration: the licensed dispensaries that sold medical and recreational
marijuana also grew most of their own supply.
The production process is complex and requires meticulous management. It comprises cloning, growing, flowering, processing and
curing. It is labour-intensive, requires considerable know-how and the risk of crop loss is considerable. Labour and electricity are main
variable costs.
Despite high capital costs and complex regulatory requirements, it looked as though Colorado and Washington would see a continuing
stream of new entrants into the recreational marijuana industry. In each state the number of applications for supplying marijuana
exceeded 2000 at the beginning of March 2014.
As competition in the industry hotted up, some producers hoped to achieve superior profit through differentiating their products on the
basis of quality, service or by offering an array of cannabis-infused products such as cookies and candies. However, one barrier to
branding by producers was that legal protection for trademarks did not extend to products that were illegal under federal law.
The legal marijuana industry was also threatened by competition from other sources. Most significant was competition from illegal
supplies of marijuana. Illicit marijuana had a well-established supply chain with most supply coming from Mexico, where outdoor
production and low-cost labour gave producers a huge cost advantage. Marijuana also competes with a host of other recreational drugs.
These include cocaine, amphetamines, methamphetamine, ecstasy and a range of other ‘designer drugs’.
In seeking to understand how the marijuana industry might evolve and to identify potential sources of its future profitability, several
observers pointed to comparable industries such as tobacco and alcoholic beverages. In the case of tobacco it was noted that, despite
falling consumption, tight regulation and heavy taxation, tobacco remained one of the most profitable industries in the US, with the major
cigarette suppliers (Altria, Reynolds American, BAT and Lorillard) earning an average return on equity of 62% during 2012–2013.
However, there were major differences between the structure of the tobacco and marijuana industries: while the former was highly
concentrated with strongly entrenched brands, the latter was fragmented.
From environmental analysis to industry analysis
The business environment of a firm consists of all the external influences that affect its decisions and performance. Given the
vast number and range of external influences, how can managers hope to monitor, let alone analyse, environmental
conditions? The starting point is some kind of system or framework for organizing information. For example, environmental
influences can be classified by source – e.g. political, economic, social and technological factors (PEST analysis) – or by
proximity – the micro-environment or task environment can be distinguished from the wider influences that form themacroenvironment.
PEST analysis has become popular as an environmental scanning framework because it provides a simple yet systematic
approach to identifying factors that are likely to shape the competitive conditions within an industry.2 Recognizing
these basic forces is important in understanding and predicting how an industry may change and evolve over time and is a
key initial step in thinking about future scenarios and the opportunities and threats that an industry may face. Case Insight
2.1 provides an example of PEST analysis based on the Opening Case.
Case Insight 2.1
An illustration of PEST analysis
Some illustrative examples of the PEST factors affecting firms in the marijuana industry include:
Political
 Licensing: the extent to which other states and other countries follow Colorado’s lead in legalizing marijuana is of paramount
importance to existing and potential marijuana producers, as are the regulations and processes surrounding the issue of licences.
Strict regulatory regimes raise capital requirements, affect the cost structures and profitability of existing producers and influence
the nature and extent of entry into this industry.
 Taxation: it seems likely that marijuana, like tobacco and alcohol, will be subject to heavy taxation and to relatively frequent
changes in tax rates. The extent to which this will affect the industry depends, in large part, on how sensitive consumers are to
changes in price.
 Trademarks and intellectual property: even though the use of marijuana for recreational use is now permitted in Colorado, it still
remains a federal crime to sell ‘pot’. As a consequence it is not currently possible for Colorado marijuana producers to get federal
trademark protection for their brands outside the state. While this is a factor that marijuana producers need to take into
consideration, the larger concern is the uncertainty created by the lack of alignment between state and federal policy. It is possible
to imagine a scenario in which the federal government decides to enforce the federal prohibition on marijuana and shut down
cannabis sellers in Colorado.
Economic
 The costs of labour, capital and energy: the production of marijuana is a labour-, capital- and energy-intensive process hence the
profitability of individual producers, and the industry as a whole, is affected by movements in these cost categories. The overall
impact of cost changes on the profitability of any given producer will, of course, depend on that firm’s cost structure and the
extent to which consumers are prepared to absorb cost increases through price rises.
 The level of economic activity: while it seems likely that the demand for marijuana will be affected by macro-factors such as
levels of employment/unemployment or national income, the nature and extent of any effect is difficult to judge. On the one hand,
it could be expected that as incomes rise consumption of marijuana would, all other things being equal, rise, but this is not
necessarily the case. Marijuana may be viewed as a gateway drug and as incomes rise users may switch to other drugs (e.g.
cocaine), to alcohol or other recreational activities. The hitherto illicit nature of much of this industry means that very little
evidence is available, so it is difficult to judge the impact macro-economic factors have. In addition, there are likely to be
important differences between those who consume marijuana for medical reasons and those who use it for recreational…
Purchase answer to see full
attachment
Explanation & Answer:

4 pages

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool’s honor code & terms of service.

Get 20% Discount on This Paper
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Try it now!

Get 20% Discount on This Paper

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Ace Writing Center has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.

Essays

Essay Writing Services

At Ace Writing Center, Nowadays, students normally have extremely busy schedules. You will note that some of them have to take on some evening or weekend jobs in order to get some income that can help them to sustain in college or in the university. This can deny them a chance to write all the essays given. Others usually get bombarded with a lot of work by their lecturers. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. However, some of them usually try to work on all these essays but end up delivering their work late. This can prevent them from graduating since most lecturers are strict on deadlines. If you want to write a business essay, the wise way is to hire an outstanding essay writing service like us, so that you can get the best results. If you are keen, you will note that many companies usually overcharge their customers. Some of them are there only to make money. And in reality, they really don’t care to build a long term commitment with students. You should not choose such companies. You should take your time and choose a reliable company to work with. Ace Writing Center is the ultimate solution for you. We have been offering our writing service for more than 7 years. This is a clear indication that you will get quality essay writing service. We have a wide range of writers who can work on any business essay that you might have. We believe in doing extensive research so that we can provide quality work to all our clients. .

Admissions

Admission and Business Papers

Have you ever had to write an admission essay for college? The majority of students face the same issues when applying to a university or college and many in such situations decide they need professional help to cope with this matter. They get in a situation when the deadline keeps coming closer but lack motivation to start because they are just not sure if their writing skills are strong enough. We have a solution for you! Ace Writing Center is the best admission essay writing service with a large professional team and years of experience in providing high-quality papers to students of all levels and faculties. The mission of our team is to help students make their dreams of entering a good college come true and that’s what we offer!.

Editing

Editing and Proofreading

Sometimes all the words for your paper just flow out of your mind and into your fingers. You type quickly at your keyboard and there they are, your beautiful words right there on the screen. But you have no idea how to polish it up. You may be wishing there was a paper writing service that offered this type of writing service. Look no more! Here at Ace Writing Center, we offer you an editing and proofreading option that you can't find anywhere else..

Coursework

College Essay Writing

In case you are familiar Ace Writing Center, you know the way to distinguish a better company from a cheap one exactly. First of all, poor service website does not have a sufficient support. We think support team is an essential part of success; it has to answer all clients’ questions and be a connecting link between clients and their writers. On our web-service you will get answers about anything you need and your writer will receive all your instructions, assignments and requirements exactly and swiftly. A writing service that we run has got a flexible pricing system that will save you from senseless wastes and many bonus systems that let you sparing money for something important for you.