University of the Cumberlands Multinational Enterprise Discussion

Description

Part 1

Assigned Readings:

Chapter 10. Global Strategy: Competing Around the World

Initial Postings: Read and reflect on the assigned readings for the week. Then post what you thought was the most important concept(s), method(s), term(s), and/or any other thing that you felt was worthy of your understanding in each assigned textbook chapter.Your initial post should be based upon the assigned reading for the week, so the textbook should be a source listed in your reference section and cited within the body of the text. Other sources are not required but feel free to use them if they aid in your discussion.

Also, provide a graduate-level response to each of the following questions:

  1. The chapter notes that global strategy can change over time for a firm. YouTube is one example in this chapter. Conduct a Web search of a firm you know to be operating internationally and determine its current global strategy position. How long has the firm stayed with this approach? Can you find evidence it had a different global strategy earlier?

[Your post must be substantive and demonstrate insight gained from the course material. Postings must be in the student’s own words – do not provide quotes!]

[Your initial post should be at least 450+ words and in APA format (including Times New Roman with font size 12 and double spaced). Post the actual body of your paper in the discussion thread then attach a Word version of the paper for APA review]

Part 2

Activity

Multinational enterprises (MNEs) have an impact far beyond their firm boundaries. Assume you are working for a small firm that supplies a product or service to an MNE. How might your relationship change as the MNE moves from Globalization 2.0 to Globalization 3.0 operations?

The assignment is to answer the question provided above in essay form. This is to be in narrative form. Bullet points should not to be used. The paper should be at least 1.5 – 2 pages in length, Times New Roman 12-pt font, double-spaced, 1 inch margins and utilizing at least one outside scholarly or professional source related to organizational behavior. This does not mean blogs or websites. This source should be a published article in a scholarly journal. This source should provide substance and not just be mentioned briefly to fulfill this criteria. The textbook should also be utilized. Do not use quotes. Do not insert excess line spacing. APA formatting and citation should be used.

Unformatted Attachment Preview

CHAPTER
10
Global Strategy:
Competing Around
the World
Chapter Outline
10.1 What Is Globalization?
Stages of Globalization
State of Globalization
10.2 Going Global: Why?
Advantages of Going Global
Disadvantages of Going Global
10.3 Going Global: Where and How?
Where in the World to Compete? The CAGE
Distance Framework
How Do MNEs Enter Foreign Markets?
10.4 Cost Reductions vs. Local Responsiveness:
The Integration-Responsiveness Framework
International Strategy
Multidomestic Strategy
Global-Standardization Strategy
Transnational Strategy
10.5 National Competitive Advantage: World
Leadership in Specific Industries
Porter’s Diamond Framework
10.6 Implications for Strategic Leaders
338
Learning Objectives
LO 10-1 Define globalization, multinational
enterprise (MNE), foreign direct
investment (FDI), and global strategy.
LO 10-2 Explain why companies compete abroad,
and evaluate the advantages and
disadvantages of going global.
LO 10-3 Apply the CAGE distance framework to
guide MNE decisions on which countries to
enter.
LO 10-4 Compare and contrast the different options
MNEs have to enter foreign markets.
LO 10-5 Apply the integration-responsiveness
framework to evaluate the four different
strategies MNEs can pursue when
competing globally.
LO 10-6 Apply Porter’s diamond framework to
explain why certain industries are more
competitive in specific nations than in
others.
CHAPTERCASE 10
Sweden’s IKEA: The World’s Most
Profitable Retailer
THE WORLD’S MOST profitable global retailer is not
Walmart or the UK-based Tesco, but IKEA—a privately
owned home-furnishings company hailing from Sweden.
In 2017, IKEA owned more than 400 stores in various formats worldwide in 28 countries, employed over 160,000
people, and earned revenues of more than 35 billion
euros. Exhibit 10.1 shows IKEA’s growth in the number
of stores and revenues worldwide.
Known today for its iconic blue-and-yellow big-box
retail stores, focusing on flat-pack furniture boxes combined with a large do-it-yourself component, IKEA started
as a small retail outlet in 1943 by then-17-year-old Ingvar
Kamprad. Though IKEA has become a global phenomenon, it was initially slow to internationalize. It took 20
years before the company expanded beyond Sweden to
its neighbor Norway. After honing and refining its core
competencies—designing and offering modern, and
Number of Stores
450
400
/
Stores
functional home furnishings in a unique retail experience resulting in a low cost structure—in its home market,
IKEA followed an international strategy, expanding first to
Europe and then beyond. Under this strategy, IKEA can
IKEA Stores and Revenues, 1974–2016
40
Revenues
350
35
30
300
25
250
Revenues (billions euro)
EXHIBIT 10.1
Sweden’s IKEA is growing quickly in both developed countries, such
as the United States and Australia, and also in emerging economies
such as China.
©testing/Shutterstock.com RF
20
200
15
150
10
100
5
50
0
1974 1984 1994 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
0
SOURCE: Depiction of data from IKEA Yearly Summaries (www.ikea.com), various years.
339
sell the same types of home furnishings across the globe with
little adaptation, although it does make some allowances for
country preferences. IKEA is present across all major markets today, having entered India and Serbia in 2017.
In recent years IKEA’s strategy has evolved. To keep
costs low, it shifted from an international strategy to a
global-standardization strategy, in which it attempts to
achieve economies of scale through effectively managing
a global supply chain. Although Asia accounts currently
for only 9 percent of its sales, IKEA sources 35 percent
of its inputs from this region. To pare costs further, IKEA
has begun to implement production techniques from auto
and electronics industries, using cutting-edge technologies
to address complexity while achieving flexibility and low
cost. IKEA’s revenues by geographic region are mainly
from Europe (69 percent), with the rest from North America
(18 percent), Asia and Australia (9 percent), and Russia
(4 percent); see Exhibit 10.2. Although IKEA’s largest market is in Germany (14 percent of total sales), it is seeing
strong growth in China, Canada, Poland, and Australia.
EXHIBIT 10.2
/
The privately held company has also successfully reinvented itself with changing consumer demands: newer formats such as smaller stores in city centers, click-and-collect
locations (small stores for retrieval of online purchases),
and more customized furniture solutions to meet the needs
of an increasingly urban population. In addition, IKEA is
investing heavily in its online presence, enabling consumers
to do all their purchasing online, and then schedule delivery, and even installation of furniture. Busy urban professionals are less inclined to spend the well-known frustrating
and long hours putting IKEA furniture together (“easy
assembly”) with the included low-quality tool and minimal
instructions. IKEA’s functional website (ikea.com) now
garners more than 2 billion hits a year. In the meantime,
IKEA’s big-box stores remain attractive destinations, with
over 1 billion visits a year, up from some 750 million just a
few years earlier.1
You will learn more about IKEA by reading this chapter; related
questions appear in “ChapterCase 10 / Consider This….”
IKEA Sales by Geographic Region (2016)
Asia
& Australia,
9%
Russia,
4%
North America,
18%
Europe,
69%
SOURCE: Depiction of data from IKEA Yearly Summaries (www.ikea.com)
340
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
IT IS SOMEWHAT surprising that a privately held furniture maker from Sweden
is the world’s most profitable retailer and not a behemoth such as the U.S.-based
Walmart or the United Kingdom’s Tesco. IKEA’s success in its international markets is
critical to its competitive advantage. IKEA succeeds in both rich developed countries such
as the United States and Germany, as well as in emerging economies such as China, India,
and Russia. Hailing from a small country in Europe, IKEA earns the vast majority of its
revenues outside of its borders. Moreover, IKEA’s fastest growth is outside Europe.
IKEA intends to reach sales of 50 billion euros by 2020, up from 35 billion euros in
2016, and double its 2011 sales of 25 billion euros. It wants to own 500 profitable stores
globally by 2020, up from some 240 stores in 2006. To accomplish these lofty goals, IKEA
must get its global strategy right, especially in growing markets such as China and India.
Both are countries with more than 1 billion people each and a rapidly expanding middle
class, on which IKEA wants to capitalize.
For more and more U.S. companies, international markets offer the biggest growth
opportunities, just as they do for IKEA. Firms from a wide variety of industries—such as
Apple, Caterpillar, GE, Intel, and IBM—are global enterprises. They have a global work
force and manage global supply chains, and they obtain the majority of their revenues
from outside their home market. Once-unassailable U.S. firms now encounter formidable
foreign competitors such as Brazil’s Embraer (aerospace); China’s Alibaba (ecommerce),
Haier (home appliances), Lenovo (PCs), and Huawei (cell phones); India’s ArcelorMittal (steel), Infosys (IT services), and Reliance Group (conglomerate); Germany’s Siemens
(engineering conglomerate), Daimler, BMW, and VW (vehicles); Japan’s Toyota, Honda,
and Nissan (vehicles); Mexico’s Cemex (cement); Russia’s Gazprom (energy); South
Korea’s LG and Samsung (both in electronics and appliances); and Sweden’s IKEA (home
furnishings), to name just a few. This chapter is about how firms gain and sustain competitive advantage when competing around the world.
The competitive playing field is becoming increasingly global, as the ChapterCase
about the home-furnishings industry indicates. This globalization provides significant
opportunities for individuals, companies, and countries. Indeed, you can probably see
the increase in globalization on your own campus. The number of students enrolled at
universities outside their native countries quadrupled between 1980 and 2014 to over
4 million.2 By 2025, the total number is predicted to double yet again, to 8 million.3
The country of choice for foreign students remains the United States, with more than
1 million international students enrolled per year, followed by the United Kingdom. The
top five countries sending the most students to study abroad are (in rank order): China,
India, Korea, Germany, and Saudi Arabia.4
In Chapter 8, we looked at the first two dimensions of corporate strategy: managing
the degree of vertical integration, and deciding which products and services to offer (the
degree of diversification). Now we turn to the third dimension: competing effectively
around the world. The world’s marketplace—made up of some 200 countries—is a staggering $76 trillion in gross domestic product (GDP), of which the U.S. market is roughly
$18 trillion, or about 24 percent.5
We begin this chapter by defining globalization and presenting stages of globalization.
We then tackle a number of questions that a firm must answer: Why should a company
go global? Where and how should it compete? We present the CAGE6 distance model
to answer the question of where the firm should compete globally and the integrationresponsiveness framework to link a firm’s options of how to compete globally with the different business strategies introduced in Chapter 6 (cost leadership, differentiation, and blue
ocean). We then debate the question of why world leadership in specific industries is often
concentrated in certain geographic areas. We conclude with the practical Implications for
Strategic Leaders.
341
342
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
LO 10-1
Define globalization,
multinational enterprise
(MNE), foreign direct
investment (FDI), and
global strategy.
Globalization The
process of closer integration and exchange
between different countries and peoples worldwide, made possible by
falling trade and investment barriers, advances
in telecommunications,
and reductions in transportation costs.
multinational enterprise
(MNE) A company
that deploys resources
and capabilities in the
procurement, production, and distribution of
goods and services in at
least two countries.
global strategy Part
of a firm’s corporate
strategy to gain and
sustain a competitive
advantage when competing against other foreign
and domestic companies
around the world.
foreign direct
investment (FDI) A
firm’s investments in
value chain activities
abroad.
10.1 What Is Globalization?
Globalization is a process of closer integration and exchange between different countries
and peoples worldwide, made possible by falling trade and investment barriers, advances
in telecommunications, and reductions in transportation costs.7 Combined, these factors
reduce the costs of doing business around the world, opening the doors to a much larger
market than any one home country. Globalization also allows companies to source supplies
at lower costs, to learn new competencies, and to further differentiate products. Consequently, the world’s market economies are becoming more integrated and interdependent.
Globalization has led to significant increases in living standards in many economies
around the world. Germany and Japan, countries that were basically destroyed after
World War II, turned into industrial powerhouses, fueled by export-led growth. The Asian
Tigers—Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan—turned themselves from
underdeveloped countries into advanced economies, enjoying some of the world’s highest
standards of living. China and India continue to offer significant business opportunities.8
Indeed, China, with $11 trillion in GDP, has become the second-largest economy worldwide after the United States (with $18 trillion in GDP) and ahead of Japan in third place
($5 trillion GDP), in absolute terms.9 Adjusting GDP for size of population (per capita)
and adjusting for difference in cost of living (purchasing power parity), the United States
is in 12th place, China comes in at 92nd, and Japan ranks 27th. The three richest countries
in the world by income per person are Qatar, Macao (which is a Special Administrative
Region of China), and Kuwait; all of which are smaller but wealthy countries.
The engine behind globalization is the multinational enterprise (MNE)—a company
that deploys resources and capabilities in the procurement, production, and distribution of
goods and services in at least two countries. MNEs need an effective global strategy that
enables them to gain and sustain a competitive advantage when competing against other
foreign and domestic companies around the world.10 By making investments in value chain
activities abroad, MNEs engage in foreign direct investment (FDI).11
For example, the European aircraft maker Airbus invested $600 million in Mobile,
Alabama, to build jetliners.12 The new Mobile Aeroplex is a 53-acre facility where Airbus
builds the vast majority of its single-aisle A-320 jetliners. Airbus made a significant strategic commitment to the U.S. market, the destination of the majority of its new jetliners; the
A-320 is mainly used in domestic U.S. air travel. Being located in Alabama allows Airbus
to be much closer to its customers and thus to receive and incorporate feedback, as individual airlines request specific customizations. It allows Airbus to take advantage of businessfriendly conditions such as lower taxes, labor cost, and cost of living, plus other incentives
provided by host states in the Southern United States. Making Airbus planes in the United
States also prevents the European company from being forced to accept import restrictions.
U.S. MNEs have a disproportionately positive impact on the U.S. economy.13 Wellknown U.S. multinational enterprises include Boeing, Caterpillar, Coca-Cola, GE, John
Deere, Exxon Mobil, IBM, P&G, and Walmart. U.S. MNEs make up less than 1 percent of
the number of total U.S. companies, but they:
■
■
■
■
■
Account for 11 percent of private-sector employment growth since 1990.
Employ 19 percent of the work force.
Pay 25 percent of the wages.
Provide for 31 percent of the U.S. gross domestic product (GDP).
Make up 74 percent of private-sector R&D spending.
As a business student, you have several reasons to be interested in MNEs. Not only can
these companies provide interesting work assignments in different locations throughout
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
the world, but they also frequently offer the highest-paying jobs for college graduates.
Even if you don’t want to work for an MNE, chances are that the organization you will be
working for will do business with one, so it’s important to understand how they compete
around the globe.
STAGES OF GLOBALIZATION
Since the beginning of the 20th century, globalization has proceeded through three notable
stages.14 Each stage presents a different global strategy pursued by MNEs headquartered
in the United States.
GLOBALIZATION 1.0: 1900–1941. Globalization 1.0 took place from about 1900 through
the early years of World War II. In that period, basically all the important business functions were located in the home country. Typically, only sales and distribution operations
took place overseas—essentially exporting goods to other markets. In some instances,
firms procured raw materials from overseas. Strategy formulation and implementation, as
well as knowledge flows, followed a one-way path—from domestic headquarters to international outposts. This time period saw the blossoming of the idea of MNEs. It ended with
the U.S. entry into World War II.
GLOBALIZATION 2.0: 1945–2000. With the end of World War II came a new focus on
growing business—not only to meet the needs that went unfulfilled during the war years
but also to reconstruct the damage from the war. From 1945 to the end of the 20th century, in the Globalization 2.0 stage, MNEs began to create smaller, self-contained copies
of themselves, with all business functions intact, in a few key countries; notably, Western
European countries, Japan, and Australia.
This strategy required significant amounts of foreign direct investment. Although it was
costly to duplicate business functions in overseas outposts, doing so allowed for greater
local responsiveness to country-specific circumstances. While the U.S. corporate headquarters set overarching strategic goals and allocated resources through the capital budgeting process, local mini-MNE replicas had considerable leeway in day-to-day operations.
Knowledge flow back to U.S. headquarters, however, remained limited in most instances.
GLOBALIZATION 3.0: 21ST CENTURY. Since 2001, we are in the Globalization 3.0 stage.
One watershed event was China’s entry into the World Trade Organization in the same
year. The World Trade Organization (WTO) is a global organization overseeing and administering the rules of trade between nations.15 The goal of the WTO is to help companies
conduct their business across borders based on multinational treaties that are negotiated
and signed by its 164 member nations.
MNEs that had been the vanguard of globalization have since become global collaboration networks (see Exhibit 10.3). Such companies now freely locate business functions
anywhere in the world based on an optimal mix of costs, capabilities, and PESTEL factors.
Huge investments in fiber-optic cable networks around the world have effectively reduced
communication distances, enabling companies to operate 24/7, 365 days a year. When an
engineer in Minneapolis, Minnesota, leaves for the evening, an engineer in Mumbai, India,
begins her workday. In the Globalization 3.0 stage, the MNE’s strategic objective changes.
The MNE reorganizes from a multinational company with self-contained operations in a
few selected countries to a more seamless global enterprise with centers of expertise. Each
of these centers of expertise is a hub within a global network for delivering products and services. Consulting companies, for example, can now tap into a worldwide network of experts
in real time, rather than relying on the limited number of employees in their local offices.
343
344
CHAPTER 10
EXHIBIT 10.3
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
/
Globalization 3.0: 21st
Century
Based on an optimal mix
of costs, skills, and PESTEL
factors, MNEs are organized as global collaboration networks that perform
business functions
throughout the world.
SOURCE: Adapted from “A
Decade of Generating Higher
Value at IBM,” www.ibm.com,
2009.
Creating a global network of local expertise is beneficial not only in service industries,
but also in the industrial sector. To increase the rate of low-cost innovation that can then
be used to disrupt existing markets, GE organizes local growth teams in China, India,
Kenya, and many other emerging countries.16 GE uses the slogan “in country, for country”
to describe the local growth teams’ autonomy in deciding which products and services to
develop, how to make them, and how to shape the business model. Many of these low-cost
innovations, first developed to serve local needs, are later introduced in Western markets
to become disruptive innovations. Examples include the Vscan, a handheld ultrasound
device developed in China; the MAC 400, an ECG device developed in India (details follow later); and the 9100c, an anesthesia system developed in Kenya.17
Some new ventures organize as global collaboration networks from the start. Logitech,
the maker of wireless peripherals such as computer mice, presentation “clickers,” and
video game controllers, started in Switzerland but quickly established offices in Silicon
Valley, California.18 Pursuing a global strategy right from the start allowed Logitech to tap
into the innovation expertise contained in Silicon Valley.19 In 2016, Logitech had sales of
over $2 billion, with offices throughout the Americas, Asia, and Europe. Underlying Logitech’s innovation competence is a network of best-in-class skills around the globe. Based
on its geographic presence, Logitech can organize work continuously because its teams in
different locations around the globe can work 24/7.
Indeed, the trend toward global collaboration networks during the Globalization 3.0
stage raises the interesting question, “What defines a U.S. company?” If it’s the address
of the headquarters, then IBM, GE, and others are U.S. companies—despite the fact that a
majority of their employees work outside the United States. In many instances, the majority of their revenues also come from outside the United States. On the other hand, non-U.S.
companies such as carmakers from Japan (Toyota, Honda, and Nissan) and South Korea
(Hyundai and Kia) and several engineering companies (Siemens from Germany, and ABB,
a Swiss-Swedish MNE) all have made significant investments in the United States and created a large number of well-paying jobs.
STATE OF GLOBALIZATION
Before we delve deeper into the question of why and how firms compete for advantage
globally, a cautionary note concerning globalization is in order. Although many large firms
are more than 50 percent globalized—meaning that more than half of their revenues are
from outside the home country—the world itself is far less global.20 If we look at a number
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
of different indicators, the level of globalization is no more than 10 to 25 percent. For
example, only
■
■
■
■
■
2 percent of all voice-calling minutes are cross-border.21
3 percent of the world’s population are first-generation immigrants.
9 percent of all investments in the economy are foreign direct investments.
15 percent of patents list at least one foreign inventor.
18 percent of internet traffic crosses national borders.
These data indicate that the world is not quite flat yet,22 or fully globalized, but at best
semi-globalized. Pankaj Ghemawat reasons that many more gains in social welfare and
living standards can be had through further globalization if future integration is managed
effectively through coordinated efforts by governments.23
The European Union is an example of coordinated economic and political integration
by 28 countries (reduced to 27 after Brexit negotiations are finalized, expected in 2019), of
which 19 use the euro as a common currency. This coordinated integration took place over
several decades following World War II, precisely to prevent future wars in Europe. The EU
encompasses 500 million people, which makes it one of the largest economic zones in the
world. Indeed its GDP is a little bit larger than the United States, the largest single-country
market in the world. Although the EU has monetary authority administered through the
European Central Bank, it does not have fiscal (i.e., budgetary) authority. This important
responsibility remains with national governments. This separation between monetary and
fiscal authority allowed the sovereign debt crisis during 2009–2015 to emerge.
Continued economic development across the globe has two consequences for MNEs.
First, rising wages and other costs are likely to negate any benefits of access to low-cost
input factors. Second, as the standard of living rises in emerging economies, MNEs are
hoping that increased purchasing power will enable workers to purchase the products they
used to make for export only.24 China’s labor costs, for example, are steadily rising in tandem with an improved standard of living, especially in the coastal regions, where wages
have risen 50 percent since 2005.
Some MNEs have boosted wages an extra 30 percent following labor unrest in recent
years. Many now offer bonuses to blue-collar workers and are taking other measures to
avoid sweatshop allegations that have plagued companies such as Nike, Apple, and Levi
Strauss. Rising wages, fewer workers due to the effects of China’s one-child-per-family
policy, and appreciation of the Chinese currency now combine to lessen the country’s
advantage in low-cost manufacturing.25 This shift is in alignment with the Chinese government’s economic policy, which wants to see a move from “Made in China” to “Designed in
China,” to capture more of the value added.26 For instance, the value added of manufacturing an iPhone by Foxconn in China is only about 5 percent.27
GLOBALIZATION 3.1: RETRENCHMENT? Several black swan events (that is, highly improbable, but high-impact events) have buffeted the world economy in recent years. The global
financial crisis between 2008 and 2010 led to a deep recession and high unemployment
in many parts of the world, including the United States. At the same time, the European
sovereign debt crisis unfolded with several countries teetering on the verge of insolvency,
leading to high unemployment in some countries. For instance, about 50 percent of the
people under 25 were unemployed in Spain and Greece. In the 2010s, the European refugee crisis unfolded with millions of people being displaced. Fleeing civil war zones as well
as territory occupied by the Islamic State, over 1.3 million refugees in 2015 alone streamed
into the European Union. While the crises in the United States and the EU unfolded, China
continued to rise both in economic and political power, establishing itself as a superpower
345
346
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
to be reckoned with, potentially challenging the supremacy of the United States. Other
countries, such as Russia and Turkey, appear to become more autocratic as time unfolds.
All of these macro events contributed to a rise of nationalism in the United States and
Western Europe. In 2016, the British voted to leave the European Union. Right-wing parties registered strong gains in national elections in many European countries. Meanwhile,
in the United States, during his inaugural speech in 2017, President Donald Trump proclaimed an “America first” policy.
As a consequence, globalization is currently undergoing some retrenchment with a
stronger focus on nationalism. Rather than multinational trade deals negotiated by international bodies such as the WTO, bilateral treaties between countries are in vogue. The
future viability of entire economic trading blocs such as the European Union or NAFTA
are being questioned. Any resulting changes would likely affect cross-border trade in a
negative fashion, impacting MNEs the most. It remains to be seen whether such sentiments
will have lasting consequences over the next few years as this process of potential globalization retrenchment unfolds.
10.2 Going Global: Why?
LO 10-2
Explain why companies
compete abroad, and
evaluate the advantages
and disadvantages of
going global.
The decision to pursue international expansion results from the firm’s assessment that
doing so enhances its competitive advantage and that the benefits of globalization exceed
the costs. Simply put, firms expand beyond their domestic borders if they can increase
their economic value creation (V − C) and enhance competitive advantage. As detailed
in Chapter 5, firms enlarge their competitive advantage by increasing a consumer’s willingness to pay through higher perceived value based on differentiation and/or lower production and service delivery costs. Expanding beyond the home market, therefore, should
reinforce a company’s basis of competitive advantage—whether differentiation, low-cost,
or value innovation. Here we consider both the advantages and disadvantages of expanding
beyond the home market (see Exhibit 10.4).
ADVANTAGES OF GOING GLOBAL
Why do firms expand internationally? The main reasons firms expand abroad are to
■
■
■
Gain access to a larger market.
Gain access to low-cost input factors.
Develop new competencies.
GAIN ACCESS TO A LARGER MARKET. Becoming an MNE provides significant opportunities for companies, given economies of scale and scope that can be reaped by participating
EXHIBIT 10.4
Advantages and
Disadvantages
of International
Expansion
/
International
Expansion
Advantages
Disadvantages
• Access new markets
• Liability of foreignness
• Access lower-cost inputs
• Loss of reputation
• Develop new competencies
• Loss of intellectual property
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
347
Strategy Highlight 10.1
The Gulf Airlines Are Landing in the
United States
The Gulf airlines bring back some of the service and glamour that used to be associated with air travel. They offer
amenities such as higher-quality complimentary meals and
Fasten your seat belts, Delta, American, and United. Severe
hot towels in economy, in addition, to an open bar in business
turbulence may be ahead.
class, and private suites with showers in first class. Their
New entrants into both the domestic and international
ratio of flight attendants to passengers is also greater, includroutes are increasing the competitive pressure on U.S. legacy
ing offering flying nannies to keep kids occupied, happy, and
air carriers. Three airlines—Emirates, Etihad Airways, and Qatar
most importantly not crying. In their home base, they build
Airways—all from the Persian Gulf, are using a blue ocean strategy
airports reminiscent of luxury hotels with swimming pools
to attract new customers. The Gulf carriers offer higher quality
above the concourse for laps during layovers, high-speed
at lower cost to break into international routes, the last remainWi-Fi, high-end conference rooms with the latest audiovisual
ing profit sanctuary of U.S. carriers. The legacy carriers have
equipment, plush lounges, and many other amenities.
long been squeezed domestically by low-cost competitors such
Given their location on the Persian peninsula, the Gulf airlines
as Southwest, Fronoffer direct flights to
tier, Spirit, and others
major hubs in Europe,
(see Strategy Highlight
Asia, and the United
3.2). Although most of
States, using the newthe future growth is in
est and most modern
Asia, the United States
aircraft. Their reach via
remains the world’s largdirect flights extends
est air traffic market,
to about 80 percent of
still holding on to onethe world’s population.
third of all business.
In particular, the Gulf
But look at the latcarriers are already
est U.S. competitors.
connecting Europe and
The Gulf carriers make
Asia, having taken away
flying enjoyable again,
major business from
getting away from the
European airlines such
Greyhound bus feel
as Lufthansa of Germany
adopted by U.S. carAn Emirates A-380 superjumbo jet takes off en route to the United States, flying past the famous
and British Airways.
riers to drive down Burj Al Arab hotel in Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
These so-called supercosts. At many U.S.
©Balkis Press/ABACAUSA.COM/Newscom
connectors already domairlines, service has
inate the long-distance
deteriorated as air travel has become a commodity, and price
route between Europe and Asia, growing its passengers threefold
has become the main competitive weapon. A high-profile inciover the past decade. Moreover, traditional international airport
dent in 2017, as an already seated United Airlines passenger
hubs such as London, Frankfurt, and Amsterdam all have lost a
was removed by force to make room for late-arriving crew
large share of their business to the new luxury hubs in Dubai,
members hitching a ride, epitomized the service crisis in U.S.
Abu Dhabi, and Doha. The Gulf carriers are now attempting to
air travel. Caught on video by smartphones, the incident went
repeat this feat in the United States, offering direct flights to many
viral, receiving global attention. Qatar Airways, one of the
U.S. cities including Atlanta, Boston, Chicago, Dallas, Houston, Los
Gulf carriers, was quick to update its smartphone app to say
Angeles, Miami, New York, Philadelphia, San Francisco, Seattle,
that it “doesn’t support drag and drop of passengers.”
Orlando, and Washington, D.C.
(continued)
348
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
U.S. carriers have complained that the Persian Gulf airlines receive unfair subsidies. CEOs of U.S. carriers have
turned to politicians in Washington to stem the onslaught of
the Gulf carriers. Customers, however, are voting with their
wallets by flocking to the Gulf carriers, enjoying competitive
prices and a better service experience. Moreover, the Gulf
carriers counter that U.S. airlines have long enjoyed tightly
regulated markets, restricting foreign competition. Moreover,
they also remind the public that each of the U.S. legacy carriers has used bankruptcy filings to obtain debt relief, and
that some legacy carriers received government bailouts. They
suggest that the investments made by the government owners
of the Persian Gulf carriers are merely equity investments as
done by other stockholders.
Yet even the Gulf carriers are experiencing headwinds lately.
Given the 50 percent decline in oil prices since 2014, other
international airlines have become more cost-competitive.
In addition, economic performance in the Gulf region is tightly
linked to the price of oil. With falling oil prices, the spending
power of companies in the region drops, and with it demand
for business travel, the most profitable segment for airlines.
A series of terrorist attacks at airports in the Middle East as
well as the downing of a Russian passenger jet by a bomb in
the region have contributed to a sharp decline in air travel
to and from the Middle East, including to the super-connector
hubs. Finally, restrictions imposed by the American government on airlines flying from the region directly into the
United States, such as a laptop ban on board, have redirected
demand for air travel to European carriers, departing from
Frankfurt, Amsterdam, London, or Paris.
One thing seems clear, however; the competitive pressure
by the Gulf carriers on U.S. legacy carriers is likely to get
stronger. The Persian Gulf states have decided that international air travel is a strategic future industry for the region.
To back up their intent, the carriers made strong strategic
commitments, not only by building the most modern and luxurious airports in the world, but also by locking up about half
of the airframe makers’ future production capacity. In particular, they ordered new super-modern, long-range airplanes
made by Boeing (such as the new 787 Dreamliner) and Airbus
(such as the A-380, the superjumbo). The Gulf carriers are
already the fastest-growing airlines globally, yet they continue to push into larger markets and more attractive routes.
In the meantime, consumers enjoy the benefits of globalization: more choice, more routes, better service and amenities,
as well as lower prices.28
in a much larger market. Companies that base their competitive advantage on economies
of scale and economies of scope have an incentive to gain access to larger markets because
this can reinforce the basis of their competitive advantage. This in turn allows MNEs to
out-compete local rivals. In Strategy Highlight 6.1, we detailed how Narayana Health, a
specialty hospital chain in India, founded and led by Dr. Devi Shetty, obtained a low-cost
competitive advantage in complex procedures such as open-heart surgery. Narayana Health
is now leveraging its low-cost, high-quality position by opening specialty hospitals in the
Cayman Islands (to serve U.S. patients) and Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
At the same time, some countries with relatively weak domestic demand, such as China,
Germany, South Korea, and Japan, focus on export-led economic growth, which drives
many of their domestic businesses to become MNEs. For companies based in smaller
economies, becoming an MNE may be necessary to achieve growth or to gain and sustain competitive advantage. Examples include Acer (Taiwan), Casella Wines (Australia),
IKEA (featured in the ChapterCase), Nestlé (Switzerland), LEGO (Denmark), Philips
(Netherlands), Samsung (South Korea), and Zara (Spain). Unless companies in smaller
economies expand internationally, their domestic markets are often too small for them to
reach significant economies of scale to compete effectively against other MNEs. Strategy
Highlight 10.1 shows how the Persian Gulf airlines (all coming from small countries) are
entering the much larger U.S. and international markets, competing directly with legacy
carriers such as American, Delta, and United.
GAIN ACCESS TO LOW-COST INPUT FACTORS. MNEs that base their competitive advantage on a low-cost leadership strategy are particularly attracted to go overseas to gain
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
349
access to low-cost input factors. Access to low-cost raw materials such as lumber, iron
ore, oil, and coal was a key driver behind Globalization 1.0 and 2.0. During Globalization
3.0, firms have expanded globally to benefit from lower labor costs in manufacturing and
services. India carved out a competitive advantage in business process outsourcing (BPO),
not only because of low-cost labor but also because of an abundance of well-educated,
English-speaking young people. Infosys, TCS, and Wipro are some of the more wellknown Indian IT service companies. Taken together, these companies employ more than
250,000 people and provide services to many of the Global Fortune 500 companies. Many
MNEs have close business ties with Indian IT firms. Some, such as IBM, are engaged in
foreign direct investment through equity alliances or building their own IT and customer
service centers in India. More than a quarter of Accenture’s work force, a consultancy specializing in technology and outsourcing, is now in Bangalore, India.29 Both the CEOs of
Google (Sundar Pichai) and Microsoft (Satya Nadella) hail from India.
Likewise, China has emerged as a manufacturing powerhouse because of low labor
costs and an efficient infrastructure. An American manufacturing worker costs about
20 times more in wages alone than a similarly skilled worker in China.30 A significant
cost differential exists not only for low-skilled labor, but for high-skilled labor as well.
A Chinese engineer trained at Purdue University, for example, works for only a quarter of
the salary in his native country compared with an engineer working in the United States.31
Of course, this absolute wage disparity also reflects the relative difference in the two countries’ cost of living.
DEVELOP NEW COMPETENCIES. Some MNEs pursue a global strategy in order to develop
new competencies.32 This motivation is particularly attractive for firms that base their competitive advantage on a differentiation strategy. These companies are making foreign direct
investments to be part of communities of learning, which are often contained in specific
geographic regions.33 AstraZeneca, a Swiss-based pharmaceutical company, relocated its
research facility to Cambridge, Massachusetts, to be part of the Boston biotech cluster,
in hopes of developing new R&D competencies in biotechnology.34 Cisco invested more
than $1.6 billion to create an Asian headquarters in Bangalore and support other locations
in India, in order to be in the middle of India’s top IT location.35 Likewise, Microsoft, the
third-largest tech company globally (after Apple and Alphabet, Google’s parent), has a key
research center in Bangalore, India. Unilever’s new-concept center is located in downtown
Shanghai, China, attracting hundreds of eager volunteers to test the firm’s latest product innovations on-site, while Unilever researchers monitor consumer reactions. In these
examples, AstraZeneca, Cisco, Microsoft, and Unilever all reap location economies—
benefits from locating value chain activities in optimal geographies for a specific activity,
wherever that may be.36
Many MNEs now are replacing the one-way innovation flow from Western economies
to developing markets with a polycentric innovation strategy—a strategy in which MNEs
now draw on multiple, equally important innovation hubs throughout the world characteristic of Globalization 3.0; see Exhibit 10.3. GE Global Research, for example, orchestrates a “network of excellence” with facilities in Niskayuna, New York (United States);
Bangalore (India); Shanghai (China); and Munich (Germany). Indeed, emerging economies are becoming hotbeds for low-cost innovations that find their way back to developed
markets.37 In Bangalore, GE researchers developed the MAC 400, a handheld electrocardiogram (ECG).38 The device is small, portable, and runs on batteries. Although a conventional ECG machine costs $2,000, this handheld version costs $800 and enables doctors to
do an ECG test at a cost of only $1 per patient. The MAC 400 is now entering the United
States and other Western markets as a disruptive innovation, with anticipated widespread
use in the offices of general practitioners and emergency ambulances.
location economies
Benefits from locating
value chain activities
in the world’s optimal
geographies for a specific activity, wherever
that may be.
350
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
DISADVANTAGES OF GOING GLOBAL
Companies expanding internationally must carefully weigh the
benefits and costs of doing so. If the cost of going global as
captured by the following disadvantages exceeds the expected
benefits in terms of value added (C > V), that is, if the economic value creation is negative, then firms are better off by
not expanding internationally. Disadvantages to going global
include
■
■
■
A GE team in China
developed the Vscan,
an inexpensive,
portable ultrasound
device, costing some
$5,000— rather than
the $250,000 cost
of a traditional ultrasound machine used in
Western hospitals. The
Vscan is now widely
used in rural areas of
developing countries
(as shown here in Vietnam) and has made its
entry as a disruptive
innovation in the United
States and other rich
countries.
©Thierry Falise/LightRocket
via Getty Images
liability of foreignness
Additional costs of
doing business in an
unfamiliar cultural and
economic environment,
and of coordinating
across geographic
distances.
Liability of foreignness.
Loss of reputation.
Loss of intellectual property.
LIABILITY OF FOREIGNNESS. In international expansion,
firms face risks. In particular, MNEs doing business abroad
also must overcome the liability of foreignness. This liability consists of the additional
costs of doing business in an unfamiliar cultural and economic environment, and of coordinating across geographic distances.39
For instance, Walmart’s problems in several international markets are in large part
because of the liability of foreignness. In particular, Walmart failed in Germany and experienced a similar fate in South Korea, where it also exited in 2006. In addition, Walmart
has tried for many years to successfully enter the fast-growing markets in Russia and India,
but with little or no success. Walmart’s success recipe that worked so well domestically
didn’t work in Germany, South Korea, Russia, or India. Strategy Highlight 10.2 illustrates
how Walmart underestimated its liability of foreignness when entering and competing in
Germany, and how it is now facing the German grocery industry disruptors, Aldi and Lidl,
on its home turf.
LOSS OF REPUTATION. One of the most valuable resources that a firm may possess is
its reputation. A firm’s reputation can have several dimensions, including a reputation for
innovation, customer service, or brand reputation. Apple’s brand, for example, stands for
innovation and superior customer experience. Apple’s reputation is also one of its most
important resources. Apple’s brand is valued at $230 billion, making it (with Google’s)
one of the two most valuable brands in the world.40 We detailed in Chapter 4 that a brand
can be the basis for a competitive advantage if it is valuable, rare, and difficult to imitate.
While cost savings can generally be achieved, globalizing a supply chain can also have
unintended side effects. These can lead to a loss of reputation and diminish the MNE’s
competitiveness. A possible loss in reputation can be a considerable risk and cost for doing
business abroad. Because Apple’s stellar consumer reputation is critical to its competitive
advantage, it should be concerned about any potential negative exposure from its global
activities. Problems at Apple’s main supplier, Foxconn, brought this concern to the fore.
Low wages, long hours, and poor working and living conditions contributed to a spate
of suicides in 2010 at Foxconn, Apple’s main supplier in China.41 The Taiwanese company, which employs more than a million people, manufactures computers, tablets, smartphones, and other consumer electronics for Apple and other leading consumer electronics
companies. The backlash against alleged sweatshop conditions in Foxconn prompted
Apple to work with its main supplier to improve working conditions and wages. Tim Cook,
Apple’s CEO, visited Foxconn in China to personally inspect its manufacturing facility
and workers’ living conditions. Although conditions at Foxconn have been improving,42
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
351
Strategy Highlight 10.2
Walmart Retreats from Germany, and Lidl
Invades the United States
In 2006 and after spending billions of dollars, Walmart
exited Germany in defeat. The eight-year failure shocked an
otherwise successful company, and ghosts from the debacle
now haunt Walmart on its native shores. What went wrong?
In 1998, Walmart faced a saturated U.S. market, and Germany, then the third-largest economy in the world, looked
appealing. Walmart was already active in six foreign countries, with some 500 stores. Leadership decided the company’s superior U.S. strategy—as the low-cost leader—would
travel well one more time.
Walmart acquired Germany’s 21-store Wertkauf chain and
74 hypermarkets from German retailer Spar Handels AG. And
it followed the U.S. playbook: Walmart cheer, a door greeter,
associates always available to customers, smiling and offering
help, bagging groceries at the checkout, and so on. German
employees, however, declined the transfusion of American values. No door greeters. Employees upheld the usual gruff standard of retail customer service found throughout Germany.
Worse, the first Walmart boss in Germany—installed directly
from the Arkansas headquarters—spoke no German. He
decreed that English would be the official in-house language.
Cultural differences aside, Walmart also failed to keep
prices down. The retailer lacked its domestic economies of
scale and efficient distribution centers. Moreover, German
labor laws—more protective than in the United States—drove
up costs. The prices at Walmart in Germany were not “always
low” despite the company slogan, but fell in the medium range.
Lastly, Walmart faced serious competition. Germany was
already home to retail discount powerhouses such as Aldi
and Lidl, with thousands of smaller outlets offering higher
convenience combined with lower prices. Then it faced
Metro, a large-box retailer, which started a price war when
Walmart entered Germany. In the end, a defeated Walmart
sold its stores to—guess who?—Metro!
One useful definition of strategy is to answer the question of how to deal with competition.43 Walmart did not find
a good strategy for competing with Aldi and Lidl in Germany.
Now, Walmart is worried that Aldi and Lidl will challenge the
world’s largest retailer on its home turf. Aldi has been competing in the United States since the 1970s with its own Aldi
stores (and its Trader Joe’s brand). In 2017, Lidl also entered
the United States.
Lidl, a German discounter, entered the United States in 2017. Together with
Aldi, Lidl disrupted the grocery market in the United Kingdom. Walmart executives are concerned about a repeat in the United States.
©AP Images/Steve Helber
Why does Walmart worry about Lidl’s entry into the U.S.
grocery business? Aldi has been highly successful with its
over 2,000 stores (and another 400-plus Trader Joe’s stores)
in the United States. Rather than focusing on large big-box
outlets, Aldi stores are small, near urban centers with high
foot traffic and easy access to public transportation or major
roads to suburbia. Moreover, Trader Joe’s, as a neighborhood grocery store, has a loyal fan base. It offers mainly its
own brand-name products such as organic, vegetarian, or
imported foods at much lower prices than Whole Foods and
elsewhere. Trader Joe’s generates twice as much revenue per
square foot of retail space as Whole Foods.
Lidl is joining the fray. It already has a few dozen
stores on the U.S. East Coast, with hundreds more planned.
Similarly to Aldi, Lidl also competes on price and offers
mainly its own store brands. Another advantage: These
competitors typically offer 2,000 products rather than the
standard 40,000 or so of large supermarkets. For example,
many grocery stores sell 30 types of mustard. These German
disruptors carry only two. Products arrive shelf-ready,
minimizing stocking and inventory costs, albeit often with
a wholesale feel. All products are sold at ultra-low prices.
There are no daily or weekly specials.
Indeed, the entry of the German discounters was so successful in the United Kingdom that Tesco, Britain’s leading
supermarket chain, had to close dozens of stores, with largescale layoffs. Its market cap fell almost 80 percent, from
$80 billion in 2007 to as low as $17 billion in 2017.
(continued)
352
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
Meanwhile, Walmart prepares. With online sales, Walmart
leads the German discounters, although it trails Amazon.
Walmart’s online sales grew by more than 50 percent in
2017. This growth comes in part from a new “order online,
pick up in store” concept, with dedicated parking bays for
drive-by customers to pick up online purchases. And it
successfully improved Walmart.com, offering free, two-day
delivery for orders over $35.
Walmart is also working the basics to speed up checkout
times and lower some prices even more. And it continues to
pressure suppliers so that its prices will be 15 percent lower
than the competition’s 80 percent of the time. With Amazon
on one side (especially after its acquisition of Whole Foods
Market) and industry disruptors such as Aldi and Lidl on the
other, Walmart is sharpening its strategic position as a lowcost leader. This competitive battle is crucial for Walmart
because groceries make up some 60 percent of its annual
revenues of $500 billion, making it the largest grocery chain
in the United States.44
Apple started to diversify its supplier base by adding Pegatron, another Taiwanese original
equipment manufacturer (OEM).45
MNEs’ search for low-cost labor has had tragic effects where local governments are
corrupt and unwilling or unable to enforce a minimum of safety standards. The textile
industry is notorious for sweatshop conditions, and many Western companies such as the
Gap (United States), H&M (Sweden), and Carrefour (France) have taken a big hit to their
reputations in factory accidents in Bangladesh and elsewhere in Southeast Asia. Hundreds
of factory workers were killed when a textile factory collapsed in Rana Plaza in 2013 on
the outskirts of Dhaka, Bangladesh.46 Although much of the blame lies with the often corrupt host governments not enforcing laws, regulations, and building codes, the MNEs that
source their textiles in these factories also receive some of the blame with negative consequences for their reputation. The MNEs are accused of exploiting workers and being indifferent to their working conditions and safety, all in an unending quest to drive down costs.
This challenge directly concerns the MNEs’ corporate social responsibility (CSR), discussed in Chapter 2. Since some host governments are either unwilling or unable to enforce
regulation and safety codes, MNEs need to rise to the challenge.47 Walmart responded by
posting a public list of “banned suppliers” on its website. These are suppliers that do not
meet adequate safety standards and working conditions. Before the Rana Plaza accident,
Walmart had already launched a working and fire-safety academy in Bangladesh to train
textile workers.
Given the regulatory and legal void that local governments often leave, several Western
MNEs have proposed a concerted action to finance safety efforts and worker training as
well as structural upgrades to factory buildings. After earlier revelations about the frequent
practice of child labor in many developing countries, Western MNEs in the textile industry
worked together to ban their suppliers from using child labor. Ensuring ethical sourcing of
raw materials and supplies is becoming ever more important. Besides a moral responsibility, MNEs have a market incentive to protect their reputations given the public backlash in
the wake of factory accidents, child labor, worker suicides, and other horrific externalities.
LOSS OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY. Finally, the issue of protecting intellectual property
in foreign markets also looms large. The software, movie, and music industries have long
lamented large-scale copyright infringements in many foreign markets. In addition, when
required to partner with a foreign host firm, companies may find their intellectual property
being siphoned off and reverse-engineered.
Japanese and European engineering companies entered China to participate in building
the world’s largest network of high-speed trains worth billions of dollars.48 Companies
such as Kawasaki Heavy Industries (Japan), Siemens (Germany), and Alstom (France)
were joint venture partners with domestic Chinese companies. These firms now allege that
the Chinese partners built on the Japanese and European partners’ advanced technology
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
353
to create their own, next-generation high-speed trains. To make matters worse, they also
claim that the Chinese companies now compete against them in other lucrative markets,
such as Saudi Arabia, Brazil, and even California, with trains of equal or better capabilities but offered at much lower prices. This example highlights the intellectual property
exposure that firms can face when expanding overseas.
10.3 Going Global: Where and How?
After discussing why companies expand internationally, we now turn to the question of
how to guide MNE decisions on which countries to enter and how to then enter those
countries.
LO 10-3
Apply the CAGE distance
framework to guide
MNE decisions on which
countries to enter.
WHERE IN THE WORLD TO COMPETE?
THE CAGE DISTANCE FRAMEWORK
The question of where to compete geographically is, following vertical integration and
diversification, the third dimension of determining a firm’s corporate strategy. The primary driver behind firms expanding beyond their domestic market is to strengthen their
competitive position by gaining access to larger markets and low-cost input factors and to
develop new competencies. So wouldn’t companies choose new markets solely based on
measures such as per capita consumption of the product and per capita income?
Yes and no. Consider that several countries and locations can score similarly on such
absolute metrics of attractiveness. Ireland and Portugal, for example, have similar cost
structures, and both provide access to some 500 million customers in the European Union.
Both countries use the euro as a common currency, and both have a similarly educated
work force and infrastructure. Given these similarities, how does an MNE decide? Rather
than looking at absolute measures, MNEs need to consider relative distance in the CAGE
model.
To aid MNEs in deciding where in the world to compete, Pankaj Ghemawat introduced
the CAGE distance framework. CAGE is an acronym for different kinds of distance:
■
■
■
■
Cultural.
Administrative and political.
Geographic.
Economic.49
Most of the costs and risks involved in expanding beyond the domestic market are created by distance. Distance not only denotes geographic distance (in miles or kilometers), but
also includes, as the CAGE acronym points out, cultural distance, administrative and political distance, and economic distance. The CAGE distance framework breaks distance into
different relative components between any two country pairs that affect the success of FDI.
Although absolute metrics such as country wealth or market size matter to some
extent—as we know, for example, that a 1 percent increase in country wealth leads to a
0.8 percent increase in international trade—the relative factors captured by the CAGE distance model matter more. For instance, countries that are 5,000 miles apart trade only 20
percent of the amount traded among countries that are 1,000 miles apart. Cultural distance
matters even more. A common language increases trade between two countries by 200
percent over country pairs without one. Thus, in the earlier example regarding which EU
country to select for FDI, a U.S. MNE should pick Ireland, while a Brazilian MNE should
select Portugal. In the latter case, Brazil and Portugal also share a historic colony–colonizer
CAGE distance
framework A decision
framework based on
the relative distance
between home and a
foreign target country
along four dimensions:
cultural distance, administrative and political
distance, geographic
distance, and economic
distance.
354
CHAPTER 10
EXHIBIT 10.5
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
/
The CAGE Distance Framework
C
Distance
Between two
countries increases
with . . .
Cultural
• Different languages,
ethnicities,
religions, social
norms, and
dispositions
• Lack of connective
ethnic or social
networks
• Lack of trust and
mutual respect
Most affects
industries or
products . . .
• With high linguistic
content (TV)
• Related to national
and/or religious
identity (foods)
• Carrying countryspecific quality
associations
(wines)
A
Administrative and
Political
• Absence of trading
bloc
• Absence of shared
currency, monetary
or political
association
• Absence of colonial
ties
• Political hostilities
• Weak legal and
financial institutions
• That a foreign
government views as
staples (electricity),
as building national
reputations
(aerospace),
or as vital to
national security
(telecommunications)
G
E
Geographic
Economic
• Lack of common
border, waterway
access, adequate
transportation, or
communication
links
• Physical
remoteness
• Different
consumer incomes
• Different costs
and quality of
natural, financial,
and human
resources
• Different climates
and time zones
• Different
information or
knowledge
• With low valueto-weight ratio
(cement)
• For which demand
varies by income
(cars)
• That are fragile
or perishable
(glass, meats)
• In which labor
and other cost
differences matter
(textiles)
• In which
communications
are vital (financial
services)
SOURCE: Adapted from P. Ghemawat (2001), “Distance still matters: The hard reality of global expansion,” Harvard Business Review, September: 137–147.
relationship. This link increases the expected trade intensity between these two countries
by yet another 900 percent in comparison to country pairs where absent.
Other CAGE distance factors are significant in predicting the amount of trade between
two countries. If the countries belong to the same regional trading bloc, they can expect
another 330 percent in trade intensity. Examples include the United States, Canada, and
Mexico in NAFTA, or the member states of the European Union. If the two countries use
the same currency it increases trade intensity by 340 percent. An example is use of the euro
as the common currency in 19 EU countries.50
Exhibit 10.5 presents the CAGE distance model. In particular, it details factors that
increase the overall distance between the two countries and how distance affects different
industries or products along the CAGE dimensions.51 Next, we briefly discuss each of the
CAGE distance dimensions.52
national culture The
collective mental and
emotional “programming
of the mind” that differentiates human groups.
CULTURAL DISTANCE. In his seminal research, Geert Hofstede defined and measured
national culture, the collective mental and emotional “programming of the mind” that
differentiates human groups.53 Culture is made up of a collection of social norms and
mores, beliefs, and values. Culture captures the often unwritten and implicitly understood
rules of the game.
Although there is no one-size-fits-all culture that accurately describes any nation,
Hofstede’s work provides a useful tool to proxy cultural distance. Based on data analysis
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
from more than 100,000 individuals from many different countries, four main dimensions
of culture emerged: Power distance, individualism, masculinity–femininity, and uncertainty avoidance.54 Hofstede’s data analysis yielded scores for the different countries, for
each dimension, on a range of zero to 100, with 100 as the high end. More recently, Hofstede added two additional cultural dimensions: long-term orientation and indulgence.55
Cultural differences find their expression in language, ethnicity, religion, and social
norms. They directly affect customer preferences (see Exhibit 10.5). Because of religious
beliefs, for example, Hindus do not eat beef, while Muslims do not eat pork. In terms
of content-intensive service, cultural and language differences are also the reason global
internet companies such as Amazon or Google offer country-specific variations of their
sites. Despite these best efforts, they are often outflanked by native providers because of
their deeper cultural understanding. For example, in China the leading websites are domestic ones: Alibaba in ecommerce, and Baidu in online search. In Russia, the leading ecommerce site is Ozon, while the leading search engine is Yandex.
Hofstede’s national-culture research becomes even more useful for managers by combining the distinct dimensions of culture into an aggregate measure for each country.
MNEs then can compare the national-culture
measures for any two country pairings to
inform their entry decisions.56 The difference
between scores indicates cultural distance,
the cultural disparity between the internationally expanding firm’s home country and
its targeted host country. A firm’s decision to
enter certain international markets is influenced by cultural differences. A greater cultural distance can increase the cost and
uncertainty of conducting business abroad.
In short, greater cultural distance increases
the liability of foreignness.
If we calculate the cultural distance from
the United States to various countries, for
example, we find that some countries are
culturally very close to the United States.
Australia, for example, has an overall cultural
distance score of 0.02. Others are culturally
quite distant. Russia has an overall cultural
distance score of 4.42. As can be expected,
English-speaking countries such as Canada (0.12), Ireland (0.35), New Zealand (0.26), and
the United Kingdom (0.09) all exhibit a low cultural distance to the United States. Since
culture is embedded in language, it comes as no surprise that cultural and linguistic differences are highly correlated.
Culture even matters in the age of Facebook with its global reach of 2 billion users.
Most Facebook friends are local rather than across borders. This makes sense when one
considers that the online social graph that Facebook users develop in their network of
friends is actually a virtual network laid above a (pre)existing social network, rather than
forming one anew.57
ADMINISTRATIVE AND POLITICAL DISTANCE. Administrative and political distances
are captured in factors such as the absence or presence of shared monetary or political
associations, political hostilities, and weak or strong legal and financial institutions.59
355
cultural distance
Cultural disparity
between an internationally expanding firm’s
home country and its
targeted host country.
In 2000 when Starbucks
entered the Chinese market,
it moved fast to overcome
cultural barriers by handing out key chains to help
new customers order!
Now it leverages Chinese
approaches to social media
(WeChat, Weibo, and Jiepang)
and fine-tunes its own mobile
apps and loyalty programs to
lure China’s growing middle
class. The result? Today
China is its second-largest
market and growing.58
Courtesy of Resonance China
356
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
The 19 European countries in the eurozone, for example, not only share the same currency
but also integrate politically to some extent. It should come as no surprise then that most
cross-border trade between European countries takes place within the EU. Germany, one
of the world’s largest exporters, conducts roughly 75 percent of its cross-border business
within the EU.60 Similarly, Canada and Mexico partner with the United States in the North
American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), increasing trade in goods and services between
the three countries. As a result, United States is the largest trading partner for both Canada and Mexico. After China, Canada and Mexico are the largest trading partners for the
United States. Colony–colonizer relationships also have a strong positive effect on bilateral
trade between countries. British companies continue to trade heavily with businesses from
its former colonies in the commonwealth; Spanish companies trade heavily with Latin
American countries; and French businesses trade with the franc zone of West Africa.
Many foreign (target) countries also erect other political and administrative barriers,
such as tariffs, trade quotas, FDI restrictions, and so forth, to protect domestic competitors. In many instances, China, for example, requests the sharing of technology in a joint
venture when entering the country. This was the case in the high-speed train developments
discussed earlier. Other countries, including the United States and EU members, protect
national champions such as Boeing or Airbus from foreign competition. Industries that
are considered critical to national security—domestic airlines or telecommunications—
are often protected. Finally, strong legal and ethical pillars as well as well-functioning
economic institutions such as capital markets and an independent central bank reduce distance. Strong institutions, both formal and informal, reduce uncertainty and thus reduce
transaction costs.61
GEOGRAPHIC DISTANCE. The costs to cross-border trade rise with geographic distance.
It is important to note, however, that geographic distance does not simply capture how far
two countries are from each other but also includes additional attributes, such as the country’s physical size (Canada versus Singapore), the within-country distances to its borders,
the country’s topography, its time zones, and whether the countries are contiguous to one
another or have access to waterways and the ocean. The country’s infrastructure, including road, power, and telecommunications networks, also plays a role in determining geographic distance. Geographic distance is particularly relevant when trading products with
low value-to-weight ratios, such as steel, cement, or other bulk products, and fragile and
perishable products, such as glass or fresh meats and fruits.
ECONOMIC DISTANCE. The wealth and per capita income of consumers is the most
important determinant of economic distance. Wealthy countries engage in relatively more
cross-border trade than poorer ones. Rich countries tend to trade with other rich countries;
in addition, poor countries also trade more frequently with rich countries than with other
poor countries. Companies from wealthy countries benefit in cross-border trade with other
wealthy countries when their competitive advantage is based on economies of experience,
scale, scope, and standardization. This is because replication of an existing business model
is much easier in a country where the incomes are relatively similar and resources, complements, and infrastructure are of roughly equal quality. Although Walmart in Canada is a virtual carbon copy of the Walmart in the United States, Walmart in China is quite different.62
Companies from wealthy countries also trade with companies from poor countries to
benefit from economic arbitrage. The textile industry (discussed earlier) is a prime example. We also highlighted economic arbitrage as one of the main benefits of going global:
access to low-cost input factors.
In conclusion, although the CAGE distance framework helps determine the attractiveness of foreign target markets in a more fine-grained manner based on relative differences,
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
357
it is necessarily only a first step. A deeper analysis requires looking inside the firm (as done
in Chapter 4) to see how a firm’s strengths and weaknesses work to increase or reduce
distance from specific foreign markets. A company with a large cadre of cosmopolitan
managers and a diverse work force will be much less affected by cultural differences, for
example, than a company with a more insular and less diverse culture with all managers
from the home country. Although technology may make the world seem smaller, the costs
of distance along all its dimensions are real. The costs of distance in expanding internationally are often very high. Ignoring these costs can be expensive (see Walmart’s adventure in
Germany, discussed in Strategy Highlight 10.2) and can lead to a competitive disadvantage.
HOW DO MNES ENTER FOREIGN MARKETS?
Assuming an MNE has decided why and where to enter a foreign market, the remaining
decision is how to do so. Exhibit 10.6 displays the different options managers have when
entering foreign markets, along with the required investments necessary and the control
they can exert. On the left end of the continuum in Exhibit 10.6 are vehicles of foreign
expansion that require low investments but also allow for a low level of control. On the right
are foreign-entry modes that require a high level of investments in terms of capital and other
resources, but also allow for a high level of control. Foreign-entry modes with a high level
of control such as foreign acquisitions or greenfield plants reduce the firm’s exposure to two
particular downsides of global business: loss of reputation and loss of intellectual property.
Exporting—producing goods in one country to sell in another—is one of the oldest
forms of internationalization (part of Globalization 1.0). It is often used to test whether
a foreign market is ready for a firm’s products. When studying vertical integration and
diversification (in Chapter 8), we discussed in detail different forms along the make-or-buy
continuum. As discussed in Chapter 9, strategic alliances (including licensing, franchising,
and joint ventures) and acquisitions are popular vehicles for entry into foreign markets.
Since we discussed these organizational arrangements in detail in previous chapters, we
therefore keep this section on foreign-entry modes brief.
The framework illustrated in Exhibit 10.6, moving from left to right, has been suggested
as a stage model of sequential commitment to a foreign market over time.63 Though it
does not apply to globally born companies, it is relevant for manufacturing companies that
are just now expanding into global operations. In some instances, companies are required
by the host country to form joint ventures in order to conduct business there, while some
MNEs prefer greenfield operations—building new, fully owned plants and facilities from
scratch, as Motorola did when it entered China in the 1990s.64
LO 10-4
Compare and contrast the
different options MNEs
have to enter foreign
markets.
EXHIBIT 10.6
Contract-Based
Exporting
Subsidiary
Strategic Alliances
Long-term contracts
• Licensing
• Franchising
Equity
Alliances
Modes of ForeignMarket Entry along
the Investment and
Control Continuum
Joint
Ventures
• Acquisition
• Greenfield
Investment and Control
LESS
MORE
/
358
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
LO 10-5
Apply the integrationresponsiveness
framework to evaluate the
four different strategies
MNEs can pursue when
competing globally.
globalization hypothesis
Assumption that
consumer needs and
preferences throughout the world are
converging and thus
becoming increasingly
homogenous.
local responsiveness
The need to tailor
product and service
offerings to fit local
consumer preferences
and host-country
requirements.
integration-responsiveness framework Strategy framework that
juxtaposes the pressures an MNE faces
for cost reductions and
local responsiveness
to derive four different
strategies to gain and
sustain competitive
advantage when competing globally.
10.4 Cost Reductions vs. Local Responsiveness:
The Integration-Responsiveness Framework
MNEs face two opposing forces when competing around the globe: cost reductions
versus local responsiveness. Indeed, cost reductions achieved through a globalstandardization strategy often reinforce a cost-leadership strategy at the business level.
Similarly, local responsiveness increases the differentiation of products and services,
reinforcing a differentiation strategy at the business level. Taken together, however, cost
reductions and local responsiveness present strategic trade-offs because higher local
responsiveness frequently goes along with higher costs. Conversely, a focus on cost reductions does not allow for much local responsiveness. Just like low cost and differentiation
at the business strategy level, cost reductions and local responsiveness are trade-offs when
competing globally.
One of the core drivers for globalization is to expand the total market of firms in order
to achieve economies of scale and drive down costs. For many business executives, the
move toward globalization is based on the globalization hypothesis, which states that
consumer needs and preferences throughout the world are converging and thus becoming
increasingly homogenous. Theodore Levitt stated: “Nothing confirms [the globalization
hypothesis] as much as the success of McDonald’s from [the] Champs-Élysées to Ginza, of
Coca-Cola in Bahrain and Pepsi-Cola in Moscow, and of rock music, Greek salad, Hollywood movies, Revlon cosmetics, Sony televisions, and Levi jeans everywhere.”65 In support of the globalization hypothesis, IKEA, as featured in the ChapterCase, sells its home
furnishings successfully in over 40 countries. Toyota is selling its hybrid Prius vehicle in
80 countries. Most vehicles today are built on global platforms and modified (sometimes
only cosmetically) to meet local tastes and standards.
The strategic foundations of the globalization hypothesis are based primarily on cost
reduction. Lower cost is a key competitive weapon, and MNEs attempt to reap significant
cost reductions by leveraging economies of scale and by managing global supply chains to
access the lowest-cost input factors.
Although there seems to be some convergence of consumer preferences across the
globe, national differences remain, due to distinct institutions and cultures. For example, in
the 1990s, Ford Motor Co. followed this one-size-fits-all strategy by offering a more or
less identical car throughout the world: the Ford Mondeo, sold as the Ford Contour and the
Mercury Mystique in North America. Ford learned the hard way, by lack of sales, that
consumers did not subscribe to the globalization hypothesis at the same level as the Ford
executives and were not yet prepared to ignore regional differences.66 In some instances,
MNEs experience pressure for local responsiveness—the need to tailor product and service offerings to fit local consumer preferences and host-country requirements; it generally
entails higher costs. Walmart sells live animals (snakes, eels, toads, etc.) for food preparation in China. IKEA sells kimchi refrigerators and metal chopsticks in South Korea.
McDonald’s uses chicken and fish instead of beef in India and offers a teriyaki burger in
Japan, even though its basic business model of offering fast food remains the same the
world over. Local responsiveness generally entails higher cost, and sometimes even outweighs cost advantages from economies of scale and lower-cost input factors.
Given the two opposing pressures of cost reductions versus local responsiveness, scholars have advanced the integration-responsiveness framework, shown in Exhibit 10.7.67
This framework juxtaposes the opposing pressures for cost reductions and local responsiveness to derive four different strategic positions to gain and sustain competitive advantage when competing globally. The four strategic positions, which we will discuss in the
following sections, are
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
EXHIBIT 10.7
Pressure for Local
Responsiveness
Pressure for Cost Reductions
High
GLOBALSTANDARDIZATION
TRANSNATIONAL
Infosys
Lenovo
Siemens Energy
ABB
Bertelsmann
P&G
INTERNATIONAL
MULTIDOMESTIC
Harley-Davidson
Rolex
Starbucks
Bridgestone
Nestlé
Philips
/
The IntegrationResponsiveness
Framework: Global
Strategy Positions and
Representative MNEs
High
Low
359
SOURCES: C.K. Prahalad
and Y.L. Doz (1987), The
Multinational Mission (New
York: Free Press); and K. Roth
and A.J. Morrison (1991),
“An empirical analysis of the
integration-responsiveness
framework in global industries,”
Journal of International
Business Studies 21:
541–564.
Low
■
■
■
■
International
Multidomestic
Global-standardization
Transnational68
At the end of that discussion, Exhibit 10.9 summarizes each global strategy.
INTERNATIONAL STRATEGY
An international strategy is essentially a strategy in which a company sells the same
products or services in both domestic and foreign markets. It enables MNEs to leverage
their home-based core competencies in foreign markets. An international strategy is one
of the oldest types of global strategies (Globalization 1.0) and is frequently the first step
companies take when beginning to conduct business abroad. As shown in the integrationresponsiveness framework, it is advantageous when the MNE faces low pressures for both
local responsiveness and cost reductions.
An international strategy is often used successfully by MNEs with relatively large
domestic markets and with strong reputations and brand names. These MNEs, capitalizing
on the fact that foreign customers want to buy the original product, tend to use differentiation as their preferred business strategy. For example, bikers in Shanghai, China, like their
Harley-Davidson motorcycles to roar just like the ones ridden by the Hells Angels in the
United States. Similarly, a Brazilian entrepreneur importing machine tools from Germany
expects superior engineering and quality. Finally, Apple’s latest iPhone model is a desired
luxury product and status symbol the world over. An international strategy tends to rely
international strategy
Strategy that involves
leveraging home-based
core competencies by
selling the same products or services in both
domestic and foreign
markets.
360
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
on exporting or the licensing of products and franchising of services to reap economies of
scale by accessing a larger market.
A strength of the international strategy—its limited local responsiveness—is also a
weakness in many industries. For example, when an MNE sells its products in foreign markets with little or no change, it leaves itself open to the expropriation of intellectual property (IP). Looking at the MNE’s products and services, pirates can reverse-engineer the
products to discover the intellectual property embedded in them. In Thailand, for example,
a flourishing market for knockoff luxury sports cars (e.g., Ferraris, Lamborghinis, and
Porsches) has sprung up.69 Besides the risk of exposing IP, MNEs following an international strategy are highly affected by exchange-rate fluctuations. Given increasing globalization, however, fewer and fewer markets correspond to this situation—low pressures for
local responsiveness and cost reductions—that gives rise to the international strategy.
MULTIDOMESTIC STRATEGY
multidomestic strategy
Strategy pursued by
MNEs that attempts to
maximize local responsiveness, with the intent
that local consumers
will perceive them to be
domestic companies.
MNEs pursuing a multidomestic strategy attempt to maximize local responsiveness,
hoping that local consumers will perceive their products or services as local ones. This
strategy arises out of the combination of high pressure for local responsiveness and low
pressure for cost reductions. MNEs frequently use a multidomestic strategy when entering
host countries with large and/or idiosyncratic domestic markets, such as Japan or Saudi
Arabia. This is one of the main strategies MNEs pursued in the Globalization 2.0 stage.
A multidomestic strategy is common in the consumer products and food industries. For
example, Swiss-based Nestlé, the largest food company in the world, is known for customizing its product offerings to suit local preferences, tastes, and requirements. Given the strong
brand names and core competencies in R&D, and the quality in their consumer products
and food industries, it is not surprising that these MNEs generally pursue a differentiation
strategy at the business level. An MNE following a multidomestic strategy, in contrast with
an international strategy, faces reduced exchange-rate exposure because the majority of the
value creation takes place in the host-country business units, which tend to span all functions.
On the downside, a multidomestic strategy is costly and inefficient because it requires
the duplication of key business functions across multiple countries. Each country unit
tends to be highly autonomous, and the MNE is unable to reap economies of scale or
learning across regions. The risk of IP appropriation increases when companies follow a
multidomestic strategy. Besides exposing codified knowledge embedded in products, as
is the case with an international strategy, a multidomestic strategy also requires exposing
tacit knowledge because products are manufactured locally. Tacit knowledge that is at risk
of appropriation may include, for example, the process of how to create consumer products
of higher perceived quality.
GLOBAL-STANDARDIZATION STRATEGY
global-standardization
strategy Strategy
attempting to reap
significant economies
of scale and location
economies by pursuing a global division of
labor based on wherever
best-of-class capabilities reside at the lowest
cost.
MNEs following a global-standardization strategy attempt to reap significant economies
of scale and location economies by pursuing a global division of labor based on wherever
best-of-class capabilities reside at the lowest cost. The global-standardization strategy arises
out of the combination of high pressure for cost reductions and low pressure for local responsiveness. MNEs using this strategy are often organized as networks (Globalization 3.0).
This lets them strive for the lowest-cost position possible. Their business-level strategy
tends to be cost leadership. Because there is little or no differentiation or local responsiveness because products are standardized, price becomes the main competitive weapon. To
be price competitive, the MNE must maintain a minimum efficient scale (see Chapter 6).
MNEs that manufacture commodity products such as computer hardware or offer
services such as business process outsourcing generally pursue a global-standardization
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
361
strategy. Lenovo, the Chinese computer manufacturer, is the maker of the ThinkPad line
of laptops, which it acquired from IBM in 2005. To keep track of the latest developments
in computing, Lenovo’s research centers are located in Beijing and Shanghai in China, in
Raleigh, North Carolina (in the Research Triangle Park), and in Japan.70 To benefit from
low-cost labor and to be close to its main markets to reduce shipping costs, Lenovo’s manufacturing facilities are in Mexico, India, and China. The company describes the benefits
of its global-standardization strategy insightfully: “Lenovo organizes its worldwide operations with the view that a truly global company must be able to quickly capitalize on new
ideas and opportunities from anywhere. By forgoing a traditional headquarters model and
focusing on centers of excellence around the world, Lenovo makes the maximum use of
its resources to create the best products in the most efficient and effective way possible.”71
One of the advantages of the global-standardization strategy—obtaining the lowest cost
point possible by minimizing local adaptations—is also one of its key weaknesses. The American MTV network cable channel started out with a global-standardization strategy.72 The
main inputs—music videos by vocal artists—were sourced more or less globally based on
the prevailing music hits. MTV reasoned that music videos were a commodity product that
would attract worldwide audiences. MTV was wrong! As indicated by the CAGE distance
model, cultural distance most affects products with high linguistic content such as TV. Even
in a music video channel, audiences have a distinct preference for at least some local content.
Keep in mind that strategic positions are not constant; they can change over time.
Consider how MTV changed its strategic positions as it attempted to respond to the pressures for both cost reduction and local responsiveness. At first, MTV followed a globalstandardization strategy. To be more responsive to local audiences, MTV then implemented
a multidomestic strategy to meet the need for local responsiveness. This led to a loss of
scale effects, especially rolling out expensive content over a large installed base of viewers.
In a move a few years later, MTV shifted its strategic position away from a multidomestic strategy and is now pursuing a transnational strategy. Exhibit 10.8 tracks how MTV
changed strategic positions in its quest for competitive advantage.
TRANSNATIONAL STRATEGY
MNEs pursuing a transnational strategy attempt to combine the benefits of a localization
strategy (high local responsiveness) with those of a global-standardization strategy (lowestcost position attainable). This strategy arises out of the combination of high pressure for
local responsiveness and high pressure for cost reductions. A transnational strategy is generally used by MNEs that pursue a blue ocean strategy at the business level by attempting
to reconcile product and/or service differentiations at low cost.
Besides harnessing economies of scale and location, a transnational strategy also aims to
benefit from global learning. MNEs typically implement a transnational strategy through a
global matrix structure. This organizational structure combines economies of scale along specific product divisions with economies of learning attainable in specific geographic regions.
The idea is that best practices, ideas, and innovations will be diffused throughout the world,
regardless of their origination. The managers’ mantra is to think globally, but act locally.
Although a transnational strategy is quite appealing, the required matrix structure is
rather difficult to implement because of the organizational complexities involved. High
local responsiveness typically requires that key business functions are frequently duplicated in each host country, leading to higher costs. Further compounding the organizational complexities is the challenge of finding managers who can dexterously work across
cultures in the ways required by a transnational strategy. We’ll discuss organizational
structure in more depth in the next chapter.
The German multimedia conglomerate Bertelsmann attempts to follow a transnational
strategy. Bertelsmann employs over 100,000 people, with two-thirds of that work force
transnational strategy
Strategy that attempts
to combine the benefits
of a localization strategy
(high local responsiveness) with those of a
global-standardization
strategy (lowest-cost
position attainable).
362
CHAPTER 10
EXHIBIT 10.8
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
/
Pressure for Cost Reductions
Dynamic Strategic
Positioning: The MTV
Music Channel
Pressure for Local
Responsiveness
High
(1)
MTV starts
by pursuing a
(3)
Today, MTV
pursues a
GLOBALSTANDARDIZATION
STRATEGY
TRANSNATIONAL
STRATEGY
Low
High
(2)
MTV then
implements a
INTERNATIONAL
STRATEGY
MULTIDOMESTIC
STRATEGY
Low
outside its home country. Bertelsmann operates in more than 60 countries throughout
the world and owns many regional leaders in their specific product categories, including
Random House Publishing in the United States and RTL Group, Europe’s second-largest
TV, radio, and production company (after the BBC). Bertelsmann operates its over 500
regional media divisions as more or less autonomous profit-and-loss centers but attempts
to share best practices across units; global learning and human resource strategies for executives are coordinated at the network level.73
As a summary, Exhibit 10.9 provides a detailed description of each of the four global
strategies in the integration-responsiveness framework.
10.5 National Competitive Advantage: World
Leadership in Specific Industries
death-of-distance
hypothesis Assumption
that geographic location
alone should not lead to
firm-level competitive
advantage because firms
are now, more than ever,
able to source inputs
globally.
Globalization, the prevalence of the internet with other advances in communications technology, and transportation logistics can lead us to believe that firm location is
becoming increasingly less important.74 Because firms can now, more than ever, source inputs
globally, many believe that location must be diminishing in importance as an explanation of
firm-level competitive advantage. This idea is called the death-of-distance hypothesis.75
Despite an increasingly globalized world, however, it turns out that high-performing
firms in certain industries are concentrated in specific countries.76 For example, the leading
biotechnology, software, and internet companies are headquartered in the United States.
Some of the world’s best computer manufacturers are in China and Taiwan. Many of the
leading consumer electronics companies are in South Korea and Japan. The top mining
companies are in Australia. The leading business process outsourcing (BPO) companies are
in India. Some of the best engineering and car companies are in Germany. The world’s top
fashion designers are in Italy. The best wineries are in France. The list goes on. Although
CHAPTER 10
EXHIBIT 10.9
/
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
363
International, Multidomestic, Global-Standardization, and Transnational Strategies: Characteristics,
Benefits, and Risks
Strategy
Characteristics
Benefits
Risks
International
Often the first step in internationalizing.
Leveraging core
competencies.
No or limited local
responsiveness.
Economies of scale.
Highly affected by exchangerate fluctuations.
Used by MNEs with relatively large
domestic markets or strong exporters
(e.g., MNEs from the United States,
Germany, Japan, South Korea).
Well-suited for high-end products with
high value-to-weight ratios such as
machine tools and luxury goods that can
be shipped across the globe.
Products and services tend to have
strong brands.
Low-cost implementation
through:
• Exporting or licensing (for
products)
IP embedded in product or
service could be expropriated.
• Franchising (for services)
• Licensing (for trademarks)
Main business-level strategy tends to
be differentiation because exporting,
licensing, and franchising add additional
costs.
Multidomestic
Used by MNEs to compete in host
countries with large and/or lucrative
but idiosyncratic domestic markets (e.g.,
Germany, Japan, Saudi Arabia).
Often used in consumer products and
food industries.
Highest-possible local
responsiveness.
Increased differentiation.
Reduced exchange-rate
exposure.
Main business-level strategy is
differentiation.
Used by MNEs that are offering
standardized products and services (e.g.,
computer hardware or business process
outsourcing).
Main business-level strategy is cost
leadership.
Little or no economies of scale.
Little or no learning across
different regions.
Higher risk of IP expropriation.
MNE wants to be perceived as local
company.
GlobalStandardization
Duplication of key business
functions in multiple
countries leads to high cost of
implementation.
Location economies: global
division of labor based
on wherever best-of-class
capabilities reside at lowest
cost.
No local responsiveness.
Economies of scale and
standardization.
“Race to the bottom” as wages
increase.
Little or no product
differentiation.
Some exchange-rate exposure.
Some risk of IP expropriation.
Transnational
Used by MNEs that pursue a blue
ocean strategy at the business level
by simultaneously focusing on product
differentiation and low cost.
Mantra: Think globally, act locally.
Attempts to combine
benefits of localization and
standardization strategies
simultaneously by creating a
global matrix structure.
Global matrix structure
is costly and difficult to
implement, leading to high
failure rate.
Economies of scale, location,
experience, and learning.
Higher risk of IP expropriation.
Some exchange-rate exposure.
globalization lowers the barriers to trade and investments and increases human capital
mobility, one key question remains: Why are certain industries more competitive in some
countries than in others? This question goes to the heart of the issue of national competitive advantage, a consideration of world leadership in specific industries. That issue, in
national competitive
advantage World
leadership in specific
industries.
364
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
turn, has a direct effect on firm-level competitive advantage. Companies from home countries that are world leaders in specific industries tend to be the strongest competitors
globally.
PORTER’S DIAMOND FRAMEWORK
Michael Porter advanced a framework to explain national competitive advantage—why
some nations outperform others in specific industries. This framework is called Porter’s
diamond of national competitive advantage. As shown in Exhibit 10.10, it consists of four
interrelated factors:
LO 10-6
Apply Porter’s diamond
framework to explain
why certain industries
are more competitive in
specific nations than in
others.
■
■
■
■
Factor conditions.
Demand conditions.
Competitive intensity in focal industry.
Related and supporting industries/complementors.
FACTOR CONDITIONS. Factor conditions describe a country’s endowments in terms of
natural, human, and other resources. Other important factors include capital markets, a
supportive institutional framework, research universities, and public infrastructure (airports, roads, schools, health care system), among others.
Interestingly, natural resources are often not needed to generate world-leading companies, because competitive advantage is often based on other factor endowments such as
human capital and know-how. Several of the world’s most resource-rich countries (such
as Afghanistan,77 Iran, Iraq, Russia, Saudi Arabia, and Venezuela) are not home to any
of the world’s leading companies, even though some (though not all) do have in place
EXHIBIT 10.10
/
Competitive
Intensity in
Focal Industry
Porter’s Diamond of
National Competitive
Advantage
SOURCE: Adapted from
M.E. Porter (19901), “The
competitive advantage of
nations,” Harvard Business
Review, March–April: 78.
Factor
Conditions
NATIONAL
COMPETITIVE
ADVANTAGE
Related and
Supporting
Industries/
Complementors
Demand
Conditions
CHAPTER 10
Global Strategy: Competing Around the World
institutional frameworks allowing them to be a productive member of world commerce.
In contrast, countries that lack natural resources (e.g., Denmark, Finland, Israel, Japan,
Singapore, South Korea, Switzerland, Taiwan, and the Netherlands) often develop worldclass human capital to compensate.78
DEMAND CONDITIONS. Demand conditions are the specific characteristics of demand
in a firm’s domestic market. A home market made up of sophisticated customers who
hold companies to a high standard of value creation and cost containment contributes to
national competitive advantage. Moreover, demanding customers may also clue firms into
the latest developments in specific fields and may push firms to move research from basic
findings to commercial applications for the marketplace.
For example, due to dense urban living conditions, hot and humid summers, and high
energy costs, it is not surprising that Japanese customers demand small, quiet, and energyefficient air conditioners. In contrast to the Japanese, Finns have a sparse population living
in a more remote countryside. A lack of landlines for telephone service has resulted in the
Finnish demand for high-quality wireless services, combined with reliable handsets (and
long-life batteries) that can be operated in remote, often hostile, environments. Cell phones
have long been a necessity for survival in rural areas of Finland. This situation enabled
Nokia to become an early leader in cell phones.79
COMPETITIVE INTENSITY IN A FOCAL INDUSTRY. Companies that face a highly competitive environment at home tend to outperform global competitors that lack such intense
domestic competition. Fierce domestic competition in Germany, for example, combined
with demanding customers and the no-speed-limit autobahn make a tough environment for
any car company. Success requires top-notch engineering of chassis and engines, as well
as keeping costs and fuel consumption ($6-per-gallon gas) in check. This extremely tough
home environment amply prepared German car companies such as Volkswagen (which
also owns Audi and Porsche), BMW, and Daimler for global competition.
RELATED AND SUPPORTING INDUSTRIES/COMPLEMENTORS. Leadership in related and
supporting industries can also foster world-class competitors in downstream industries.
The availability of top-notch complementors—firms that provide a good or service that
leads customers to value the focal firm’s offering more when the two are combined—
further strengthens national competitive advantage. Switzerland, for example, leveraged
its early lead in industrial chemicals into pharmaceuticals.80 A sophisticated health care
service industry sprang up alongside as an important complementor, to provide further
stimulus for growth and continuous improvement and innovation.
The effects of sophisticated customers and highly competitive industries ripple through
the industry value chain to create top-notch suppliers and complementors. Toyota’s global
success in the 1990s and early 2000s was based to a large extent on a network of worldclass suppliers in Japan.81 This tightly knit network allowed for fast two-way knowledge
sharing—this in turn improved Toyota’s quality and lowered its cost, which it leveraged
into a successful blue ocean strategy at the business level.
It is also interesting to note that by 2010, Toyota’s supplier advantage had disappeared.82
It was unable to solve the trade-off between drastic…
Purchase answer to see full
attachment

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool’s honor code & terms of service.

Get 20% Discount on This Paper
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Try it now!

Get 20% Discount on This Paper

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Ace Writing Center has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.

Essays

Essay Writing Services

At Ace Writing Center, Nowadays, students normally have extremely busy schedules. You will note that some of them have to take on some evening or weekend jobs in order to get some income that can help them to sustain in college or in the university. This can deny them a chance to write all the essays given. Others usually get bombarded with a lot of work by their lecturers. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. However, some of them usually try to work on all these essays but end up delivering their work late. This can prevent them from graduating since most lecturers are strict on deadlines. If you want to write a business essay, the wise way is to hire an outstanding essay writing service like us, so that you can get the best results. If you are keen, you will note that many companies usually overcharge their customers. Some of them are there only to make money. And in reality, they really don’t care to build a long term commitment with students. You should not choose such companies. You should take your time and choose a reliable company to work with. Ace Writing Center is the ultimate solution for you. We have been offering our writing service for more than 7 years. This is a clear indication that you will get quality essay writing service. We have a wide range of writers who can work on any business essay that you might have. We believe in doing extensive research so that we can provide quality work to all our clients. .

Admissions

Admission and Business Papers

Have you ever had to write an admission essay for college? The majority of students face the same issues when applying to a university or college and many in such situations decide they need professional help to cope with this matter. They get in a situation when the deadline keeps coming closer but lack motivation to start because they are just not sure if their writing skills are strong enough. We have a solution for you! Ace Writing Center is the best admission essay writing service with a large professional team and years of experience in providing high-quality papers to students of all levels and faculties. The mission of our team is to help students make their dreams of entering a good college come true and that’s what we offer!.

Editing

Editing and Proofreading

Sometimes all the words for your paper just flow out of your mind and into your fingers. You type quickly at your keyboard and there they are, your beautiful words right there on the screen. But you have no idea how to polish it up. You may be wishing there was a paper writing service that offered this type of writing service. Look no more! Here at Ace Writing Center, we offer you an editing and proofreading option that you can't find anywhere else..

Coursework

College Essay Writing

In case you are familiar Ace Writing Center, you know the way to distinguish a better company from a cheap one exactly. First of all, poor service website does not have a sufficient support. We think support team is an essential part of success; it has to answer all clients’ questions and be a connecting link between clients and their writers. On our web-service you will get answers about anything you need and your writer will receive all your instructions, assignments and requirements exactly and swiftly. A writing service that we run has got a flexible pricing system that will save you from senseless wastes and many bonus systems that let you sparing money for something important for you.