Economic “Reality” and the Myth of theBottom Line
Louella Moore
INTRODUCTION
Why do accounting practitioners, users, and standard setters continue to pursue a mythi-cal, determinate “bottom line” in spite of the known limitations of accounting mea-sures? Accounting standard-setting bodies espouse the usefulness of a consistent con-
ceptual framework, and have derived multiple frameworks in the last century. Yet none of themseem to last. Emerson �1841� notes:
a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophersand divines. With consistency a great soul has simply nothing to do.
Ironically, accounting standard setters manage to have plenty to do by simply changing fromone consistent, but problematic, framework to another. American standard setters adopted a set ofhistorical cost principles for a time, attempted to switch to fair value until they were faced with apractitioner backlash, then allowed a mix of historical and other valuations, and are now on atrajectory toward fair value. Similar to prior attempts, the new asset/liability-based fair valueapproach espoused by the International Accounting Standards Board �IASB� and the FinancialAccounting Standards Board �FASB� is getting a lukewarm reception �Benston 2008; Kvifte2008�. It seems the accounting profession simply cannot settle on a logical, consistent frameworkfor long. This paper argues that the inability to maintain agreement may be tied to the starkcontrast between the inherent paradoxes of accounting and the profession’s insistence on pursuingthe myth of a determinate bottom line. If basic elements of the economic “reality” are in factindeterminate and paradoxical in nature, perhaps it is understandable that a consistent theoreticalframework is elusive.
This paper begins with a brief summary of some previously iterated limitations or problems inaccounting measurement. The main section of the paper then draws on recent discussions betweenphysicists and Buddhist philosophers exploring the nature of real-world phenomena. The physicsand philosophy dialogs to date have focused on inherent problems in the objective measurement ofphenomena and suggest that similar challenges exist in the accounting profession’s efforts tomeasure economic “reality.” The discussion on the indeterminate nature of phenomenal reality is
Louella Moore is a Professor at Arkansas State University.
Accounting HorizonsVol. 23, No. 3 American Accounting Association2009 DOI: 10.2308/acch.2009.23.3.327pp. 327–340
COMMENTARY
Submitted: September 2008Accepted: April 2009
Published Online: August 2009Corresponding author: Louella Moore
Email: lmoore@astate.edu327
followed by conjectures as to what may be causing the accounting profession to cling so tightly tothe prevailing myth of the bottom line. The paper ends with implications for standard setting,practice, education, and research.
PROBLEMS WITH ACCOUNTING MEASURESTable 1 lists significant problems with accounting measures that have been previously iden-
tified in the accounting literature and business press. The list is not intended to be exhaustive, butto be indicative of broad problem areas in accounting.
Limitations of Numeric Scales and Measurement ApproachesThe first limitation is the mix of numeric scales found in accounting reports. Stevens �1946�
argued that most measurements can be classified as nominal, ordinal, interval, or ratio. In account-ing practice, classifying an object under a specific account title is a nominal measurement process,while numbers on the financial statements may be ordinal, interval, or ratio in scale. Stevens sawthe inherent properties of the scales as a constraint on the types of valid comparisons that can bemade using financial data. According to Bierman �1969, 141�:
TABLE 1
Problems with Accounting Measures
Problem Short Description of Problem
�1� Measurement Scales:�Bierman 1969�
Nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio scales: Prevalence ofnonratio scales in practice limits the ability to assessdistances between measures.
�2� Measurement Approaches:�Edwards and Bell 1961;Chambers 1966; Sweeney1930�
No agreement on available approaches: �a� cost, with orwithout price-level adjustments and �b� value; �1�replacement value; �2� realizable value; �3� net realizablevalue; �4� discounted cash flows; and �5� value of similarproductive capacity.
�3� Traditional TransactionsIncome versus EconomicIncome: �Hicks 1939;Mitchell 1967; Revsine1970�
Transaction approach is a weak substitute for the opportunitycosts hypothesized in pure economic theory.
�4� Incorrigibility ofAllocations: �Thomas1969; Devine 1985�
It is impossible to derive a single defensible basis for allocatingcosts.
�5� Transfer pricing: �TheEconomist 2007�
Transfer prices can move income from department todepartment—distorts tax and responsibility accountingsystems.
�6� Market adjustments areoften counterintuitive:�Brubaker 2008; Katz andReason 2008�
Market adjustments for liabilities in companies with decliningcredit worthiness defy economic common sense.
�7� Circular effect and inabilityto audit instruments basedon future market conditions:�Benston 2006�
Many types of financial instruments cannot be objectivelyvalued on an ongoing basis; reported values may causemarket changes.
�8� Management incentives forincome manipulation: �Coreet al. 2003�
Reward systems based on market or accounting performanceare associated with opportunistic choice of accountingprocedures.
328 Moore
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
If accounting limited itself to presenting the amount of cash in the bank, a true measurement mightbe attainable, but when the scope of accounting is broadened … the possibility of finding a truemeasure falls out of reach.
Readers of financial statements can reach inappropriate decisions from accounting data whenthey fail to consider the type of number scale they are using. In publicly available accountingreports it is often unclear what numbers are on an ordinal, interval, or ratio scale. Becausedifferent companies may use different methods of measuring assets, numbers that in a perfectworld would be comparable on a percentage basis, as in the ratio scale, may be capable of givingonly interval or even ordinal level comparisons in practice. Krantz et al. �1971� expanded onStevens’s �1946� classification to consider nonlinear structures, while Sarle �1995� demonstratedthat measures can have properties that lie somewhere between the four classical scales and thatdata sets may measure different attributes at different times for different purposes.
A second problem is that while most conceptual frameworks are built on a framework ofdecision usefulness, accountants do not agree on what kind of data is most useful. Cost and valueapproaches are most common. The cost approach is usually viewed as more objective or reliablethan a value approach, but even cost-based approaches can contain many subjective elements.Value measurements may take many forms such as replacement value, realizable value, discountedcash flow, value of similar productive capacity, or opportunity costs, while initial outlay costs canbe adjusted for changes in general price levels �Sweeney 1930; Chambers 1966; Edwards and Bell1961�. Which cost or value measure is preferred depends on which limits one can accept for agiven decision; yet financial statements are intended to be helpful in a variety of decisions.
The replacement value approach is usually more subjective than historical cost, particularly ifthe product has to be replaced through internal manufacture or through development such as foroil or mineral exploration. Another criticism of replacement cost is that for buildings and othertypes of long-lived assets it would be unreasonable to replace the asset without upgrades; there-fore, the replacement value of the same equipment may be just as irrelevant as historical cost.Realizable and net realizable values represent an attempt to measure how much cash would bereceived if an asset were sold. A distinct criticism of this approach is that while realizable or netrealizable value might give an approximation of the value of assets in an orderly liquidation, thisis irrelevant data if the company plans to continue using the asset. Discounted cash flow �DCF�uses a discount rate to determine the present value of expected future cash flows. The DCFtechnique attempts to measure the value in use rather than the value to purchase another asset orthe flows from disposal. Still, management has incentives to make opportunistic future cash flowestimates, and these flows often cannot be estimated on an asset-by-asset basis. The cost of similarproductive capacity approach modifies replacement cost to recognize that asset replacement usu-ally involves purchasing updated models with improved technology. This approach will typicallyuse the opportunity cost of buying new equipment in the income statement. Yet the company is infact still using the low-tech model rather than an improved model. Does it really make sense toreport income statement costs or balance sheet values for updated equipment the company doesnot yet own or use?
Difficulties in Measuring IncomeA third problem is that the accounting profession has not really reached closure on what we
mean by income. One approach is to assume that accounting is attempting to operationalizeeconomic concepts of wealth on a continuous basis. Another approach is that accounting shouldreflect the effect of transactions between the firm and other entities. Hicks �1939� sees economicincome as the amount an individual could consume during a week and still be as well off at theend of the week as at the beginning. The Hicksian or economic approach to income is broader in
Economic “Reality” and the Myth of the Bottom Line 329
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
scope and more subjective than the transaction-based approach. The Hicksian economic or wealth-based approach suggests that increases or decreases in income can arise from changes in theunderlying value of one’s assets or liabilities even in the absence of an exchange transaction.According to Hicks, even psychological assessments that the market is about to take a downturnmight cause one to feel less wealthy. Thus economic measurements are not separate from thepsyche of the owner, accountant, or other market players.
Transaction- and wealth-based approaches affect the income statement and the balance sheetvery differently. The Hicksian approach assumes that changes in the underlying perceptions ofasset and liability values are part of income. The transaction-based approach to accounting waitsfor a subsequent exchange event to provide confirming evidence of value changes before they areadmitted to income.
On its surface, the recent FASB and IASB evolution to an asset/liability approach seems tomove the accounting profession closer to economic theory. However, the asset/liability model failsto capture the essence of economic income because fair values are not always the same asopportunity costs �Mitchell 1967; Revsine 1970�. Accounting practice ignores the implicationfrom economic theory that if markets were completely efficient there would be no sustainableeconomic profits as competition would quickly drive all firms to a common level. Beaver andDemski �1979� as well as Bromwich et al. �2008� note that if markets were truly perfect, account-ing measures would be redundant.
The Problems of Allocation and Transfer PricingThomas’s �1969� analysis of joint product and other allocation schemes found that all attempts
to allocate or apportion costs to multiple periods, departments, or other cost objects are “incorri-gible.” Thomas concluded that it is impossible to derive a single noncontroversial approach toaccounting allocations and that the potential variations in practice can cause such significantdistortions that they should be discontinued. In an American Accounting Association study, Devine�1985� also concluded that all accounting allocations are arbitrary or impossible. Still, Thomas andDevine’s conclusions have not hindered the development of expensive activity-based costingsystems built on the idea of making overhead allocations more and more detailed. Althoughactivity-based costing can provide some benefits if it better identifies fixed versus variable costs,fixed and variable classifications are based on subjective views of the length of the typical decisionhorizon. Likewise, it is well-known that if there are no externally imposed limits on the type oftransfer prices used between organizational departments or between related companies, manage-ment has incentives to park income in fortuitous tax venues �The Economist 2007�.
Counter-Intuitive, Unauditable, and Opportunistic Accounting MeasuresThe FASB has gone back and forth on whether gains and losses on advance refundings of debt
should be treated as extraordinary, apparently because these adjustments are counter to common-sense impressions of economic reality. When a company’s credit worthiness declines, its interestrates rise. Under the asset/liability approach, as market values decline the company can book again. Thus, companies are in effect rewarded for their declining ability to pay their debts�Brubaker 2008; Katz and Reason 2008�. In addition, Enron clearly demonstrated that manycompanies today are buying and selling financial instruments with values contingent on futureevents that cannot be reliably measured on an ongoing basis �Benston 2006�. Yet being required toreport all instruments at some version of current value provides incentive to select measuresbecause of their potential to influence future values. Furthermore, the agency theory literatureprovides convincing evidence that use of reward systems that rely on accounting or market mea-sures tend to result in opportunistic selection of accounting techniques �Core et al. 2003�.
330 Moore
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
PERSPECTIVES ON “REALITY” FROM PHYSICS AND BUDDHIST PHILOSOPHY
Accountants are faced with significant challenges in their attempt to provide true and fairmeasures of economic reality. Physicists commonly deal with problems inherent in moving frompure theory to the practical measurement of physical phenomena. Buddhist philosophers likewisehave a longstanding tradition of applying rigorous logic to identify what is “real” and the limits ofwhat can be deduced about so-called “real” phenomena. Insights from quantum mechanics andBuddhist philosophy may give a new perspective on some of the underlying issues inherent inaccounting measurement problems.
The Quantum View of Phenomena
Prior to the last century, physicists hoped that explanations of the workings of all naturalphenomena could be reduced to deterministic mathematical formulas. After all, Newtonian for-mulas had been very useful in calculating trajectories, speeds, thrust, and other data useful increating the machines used by the emerging industrial complex. Toward the end of the 19th andthe beginning of the 20th century, physicists came to realize that in many cases the old formulaswere unacceptably imprecise.
The old theories of physics assumed that the world was made up of phenomena that couldalways be measured precisely, if the proper tools could only be devised. Although some objectsmight be very small, it was thought that all measurable phenomena could be conceptualized asdistinct units. The term quantum mechanics is attributed to Max Born �Bernstein 2005; Heisenberg1927�, but Max Planck, Albert Einstein, Neils Bohr, and many other physicists also contributed tothe development of an understanding that phenomena act very differently at the quantum, thesubatomic, level compared with what one would expect from larger objects �Einstein 1934; Bohr1958; De Broglie 1953; Beller 2001�. One basic idea from quantum theory is that subatomicphenomena can act as either waves or particles depending on the measurement technique. Accord-ing to Werner Heisenberg’s �1970� uncertainty principle, it is impossible to know precisely boththe position and momentum of a quantum object. The act of observing actually changes themomentum. Furthermore, although the changes in momentum can be estimated probabilistically, aportion of the change is inherently random.
Physics models are coming to be widely used as tools for valuing financial instruments onWall Street �Derman 2004; Ouellette 1999�, and Demski et al. �2006� have suggested possibleapplications of physics to accounting. Palmrose �2008� predicts that insights from physics mayprovide the next major research paradigm for financial accounting. Still, Bernstein �2005� noteswith some irony that Scholes of Black-Scholes fame and his colleagues relied on their physics-based theoretical models to create a $3.65 billion real-world crisis for the Long Term CapitalManagement Fund because they forgot a basic tenet of quantum mechanics—they treated proba-bilistic investor behavior as if it were deterministic.
A second tenet of quantum mechanics is that at the subatomic level discrete objects do notexist. This parallels the problem of establishing objective boundaries in accounting. Accountingmay attempt to measure the behavior of a single manager, a legally defined corporation, or aconsolidated entity, but external effects always remain. While agency theorists define a firm as anexus of contracts for research purposes, that definition is of little help in measuring financialstatement items. In practice, financial accountants must posit some form of arbitrary reportingentity even though firms are inherently interconnected with other economic interests.
Economic “Reality” and the Myth of the Bottom Line 331
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
The Nature of Phenomena in Buddhist PhilosophyBuddhist philosophers and physicists have recently entered into formal dialogs to explore the
parallels between quantum mechanics and Buddhist philosophy �Hayward and Varela 1992; DalaiLama 2005; Mansfield 2008�.1 In particular this paper considers the Buddhist concepts of empti-ness �shunyata�, signlessness �animitta�, and aimlessness �apranihita� �Hanh 1998, 146–155; Rab-jam 2007, 99� to explore how these ideas may mirror problems in accounting measurement.2
The concept of emptiness �shunyata� is central to Buddhist thought. The term is used tosignify that all phenomena are interdependent. For example, humans cannot exist without air,which comes from plants, which in turn depend on soil, sunshine, insects for pollination, and soon, ad infinitum. Emptiness does not mean that objects of measurement are nonexistent, but that itis impossible to understand fully any phenomena independent of other entities that form a web ofcausal streams. This mirrors the physics and accounting problems of boundaries. The boundariesof presumed objects of accounting measurement are not as fixed as they might first appear.Traditional financial reports rarely distinguish an organization’s current performance from thestructural benefits or burdens resulting from prior management action or the state of the overalleconomy. Some have proposed expansion of accounting to include more social and environmentalissues �Bowen 1953; Goyder 1961; Belkaoui 1984; Tinker 1985; Mathews 1997; Quarter et al.2002�. Yet how can we resolve the conundrum that at some point accounting for anything becomesaccounting for everything?
The Buddhist concept of signlessness �animitta� focuses on the idea that no description ofcharacteristics can ever fully describe anything. The map can never completely replicate theterritory. While we can call an object a chair, or a collection of boards, plastic, and fabric, the veryact of describing will in some way either omit some of the object’s potentialities or influence thelistener as to the capabilities of the object. Solomons’ �1978� description of accounting as financialcartography gets at these same limitations. The idea of signlessness coupled with emptiness en-compasses the basic philosophical problem of nonduality �Loy 1988�, which is the impossibility ofdistinctly separating subjects and objects. Accounting measures are inherently understood in asocial context, with the measures influencing and being influenced by the surrounding society. It isimpossible to make a perfect separation between the object being measured and the influence ofthe accounting measures.
The third Buddhist concept of aimlessness runs counter to popular business culture. Aimless-ness implies that setting and running after goals is overrated in the long term. Yet modern corpo-rate management and corporate accountability is firmly based on the idea of setting goals andmeasuring the results against those goals. Still, the concept of aimlessness mirrors conclusions inpure economic theory that eventually all businesses should devolve to a state of no true economicgain after other entities have studied and appropriated the techniques of corporate best practice.
Taking emptiness, signlessness, and aimlessness to their logical conclusion for social account-ability, if a positive income persists long term it suggests the market allows externalities andexploitation of workers, while a loss might be equivalent to a charitable contribution to the overallsociety. Thus, it is unclear that traditional accounting measures are a proper measure of value to
1 Buddhism is commonly associated with religious debates on theism versus atheism, the soul versus no soul, andconcepts such as nirvana and how it might be attained, if at all. This paper focuses not on religious elements but onsecular, philosophical inquiry concerning the nature of phenomena using concepts that happen to have been derivedfrom Buddhist scholarship.
2 In the original Buddhist texts these concepts were never applied to accounting issues. The Hanh text, though not anoriginal Buddhist scripture or sutra, is the most accessible English explanation of the secular aspects of these threeconcepts. These three themes run through classic works such as the Lotus Sutra �Saddharma Pundarīka Sutra�, theHeart or Perfection of Wisdom Sutra �Prajñāpāramitā Hrdaya Sutra�, and the Diamond Sutra�Vajracchedikā-prajñāpāramitā-sutra�.
332 Moore
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
society. From a moral standpoint, running after gain and worrying about loss is the Buddhistequivalent of a deadly sin in the Christian tradition. Still, achieving a profit and avoiding a loss iswidely accepted as the business raison d’etre in the West and the East alike even though inperfectly efficient markets real profits should quickly devolve to zero.
So how can these two approaches be reconciled? Physicists have concluded that the rulesdiffer for larger phenomenon compared with the activities of their subatomic components. Incontrast, Buddhist philosophers suggest their conclusions apply to larger phenomena as well, butthey attempt to reconcile the counterintuitive ideas of emptiness, signlessness, and aimlessness bydistinguishing between relative and ultimate truths. At the ultimate level Buddhist philosophyimplies that �1� accountants have nothing to measure �emptiness�; �2� what we are measuringcannot be fully described �signlessness�; and �3� too much focus on individual profit maximizationmay run counter to general social welfare �aimlessness�. At the relative level, society accepts someartificial boundaries for firms, using certain measurement conventions of positive cash flow orincome as indicators of firm performance, even though they may be measured only imprecisely byoperational rules that reflect the conventions of social value �Beaver and Demski 1979; Demskiand Sappington 1990�. The concepts of emptiness, signlessness, and aimlessness taken togethersuggest that the popular call for true, fair, and fully transparent accounting systems can beachieved in a relative but not an absolute sense.
Buddhist ethics have had less influence on accounting than those of Abrahamic origin �Liya-narachchi 2008, 121; Jayasinghe and Soobaroyen 2007�. One aspect of Buddhist and other Easternethical views is that the public good should take precedence over individual interest because ofemptiness; that is, mutual interdependence. Although the assumption that individuals work towardtheir own self-interest has been inherent in classical economics, Eastern ethical concepts of inter-dependence are not at odds with modern game theory, which has shown that the group realizes thehighest good when individuals choose to override mundane self-interest and work toward mutualsocial goals �Fernandez and Bierman 1998; Gintis 2000�.
The Prevailing Myth of a Bottom LineHaving discussed the known problems or limitations in accounting and two bodies of work
that suggest that the interdependent nature of phenomena precludes perfect measurement, it isimportant to ask why the myth of the “bottom line” is so persistent. This section posits fourpossible explanations: �1� Western cultural bias in accounting; �2� innumeracy and ritual; �3�artifacts of a weak credentialization movement; and �4� inordinate faith in market equilibrium asa basis for social justice.
Cultural BiasThe concept of shunyata �emptiness�, or interdependence, appears in various Eastern tradi-
tions such as Hinduism and Taoism, but less commonly in Western cultures. The Western culturalbias is that things should have an answer. Westerners think the accountant should be able to saywhether product A is making or losing money and how much. Westerners want puzzles to have asolution. Riddles that go round and round are unacceptable. Readers of financial statements do notwant to hear that the profit for the year was somewhere between a negative $5 million and apositive $30 million. Furthermore, it is not uncommon in Western society for members of the pressand the general public to work to place specific blame on someone. They just want to hear howmuch money the company made; they do not want to hear that it was the fault of the overalleconomy, or a weather event beyond the company’s control. If there is a financial reporting crisis,someone needs to be blamed, be it the CEO, the CFO, or the auditor. The mindset that a single,noncontroversial bottom line exists is common among the functionally innumerate. It is no less
Economic “Reality” and the Myth of the Bottom Line 333
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
common among the financial elite who use the very myth of a determinate bottom line as the basisfor lawsuits to recoup stock market losses.
Even though Eastern cultures generally tolerate the notion of interdependence better than thepopular Western mindset, the Western accounting bias has extended to Eastern countries as well.Recent efforts at accounting standard setting in China and Japan are not significantly differentfrom those of the FASB and IASB �Deloitte 2006; Study Group 2004�. The Western bias thataccounting reports represent the bottom line cuts both ways. If the public chooses to believe thatthe bottom line is precise and noncontroversial in spite of considerable evidence to the contrary,this enhances the reputation of accountants as answer machines �Burchell et al. 1980� in the shortterm. But if accountants are unable to provide determinate answers because of the inherent natureof economic phenomena, this might explain recurring crises of confidence.
Innumeracy and RitualInnumeracy has been defined as “an inability to deal comfortably with the fundamental
notions of number and chance” �Paulos 1988, 3�. This bias against numeric information preventsusers from looking too closely at the techniques behind accounting numbers. Not only is thegeneral public biased against numeric information, but even accounting practitioners seem to havelittle interest in the conclusions from accounting academic research when it is based on high-levelmathematical models �Elliot 1991; Bricker and Previtts 1990�. Paulos �1988� posits that mostpeople really do not like numbers, do not care to delve into how the numbers were calculated, andare not interested in debating the deficiencies of numeric measures. It is simply easier to acceptaccounting numbers as a definitive bottom line. Feldman and March �1981� maintain that account-ing’s role as information for decision-making purposes is not nearly as important as its function asa symbolic ritual. Cleverly �1973� suggests the act of drawing up a set of elaborate financialstatements accompanied by a detailed audit is not meant to serve the purpose of providing data fordecision making but rather to serve the purpose of providing a symbolic sense of appeasement.Porter �1995� maintains that passive acceptance of results stated in numbers is a significant socialand moral issue that has not been adequately addressed.
Artifacts of a Weak Credentialization MovementOne way to ward off potential criticism of a given occupation is for practitioners to band
together to set certain standards of practice. This typically involves mandatory training and certi-fication while seeking government sanction to exclude others from the field. Paper-and-pencilcredentialization exams measure the level of expertise and signal that exclusion is only for justcause. It is interesting that accountants, lawyers, and doctors all take certification exams with apreponderance of objective questions. Yet in practice, accountants are expected to be right the firsttime, whereas medical and legal clients routinely seek second opinions in hopes of a differentanswer. Porter �1995, 96� notes:
willingness to insist on standardizability, even where it violates the best judgment of expert prac-titioners, will rarely be found except in fields that are highly vulnerable to criticism from outsiders.The reluctance of accountants in many situations to admit the exercise of personal discretion isevidence of their public exposure, and in this sense their weakness.
Thus, accountants may be aware of the limitations of their measures, but are so enmeshed ina politically weak credentialization movement that they feel compelled to promise an inordinatedegree of accounting precision.
Inordinate Faith in Market ProcessesAccounting’s capital markets literature recognizes that accounting has measurement prob-
lems, but the changes in the accounting frameworks are seen as the manifestation of the ebb and
334 Moore
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
flow in a natural adjustment process. Accounting measurement problems are viewed as insignifi-cant noise in what is an otherwise very useful information system. Capital markets researchassumes that markets are sufficiently efficient that players can either override inappropriate signalsfrom accounting measures or lobby for changes in accounting rules that assure an efficient marketover time. This paper does not argue that accounting’s limitations prevent it from having anydecision usefulness, but the question rises, “Does inordinate faith in equilibrium processes leaveunexamined certain social justice issues that cannot be resolved by market mechanisms?”
Public interest researchers have suggested that capital markets equilibrium models oversim-plify economic phenomena, and the profession should not rely on them as the only version ofeconomic truth. Ketz and Wyatt �1983� note that the world is far more complex and diverse thancaptured by the efficient markets paradigm, cautioning the FASB not to place undue emphasis onthese studies. After reviewing more than 150 papers based on the capital markets and informationusefulness model, Wolk et al. �2008, 251� conclude that unexpected accounting earnings explainonly a small percentage of security price changes, and there are credible challenges to the assump-tion of market efficiency. Furthermore, capital markets research rarely provides unequivocal evi-dence that one accounting method is preferable to another, leading Watts and Zimmerman �1979�to conclude that standard setting has devolved to a search for excuses.
Other detractors of capital markets research argue that positive accounting research modelsare flawed by tautological reasoning �Williams 1995; Boer and Moseley 1995�. Is there not a basicproblem with assuming markets are efficient, then using that assumption to isolate cases wherecertain accounting rules appear to be associated with abnormal returns; that is, market ineffi-ciency? Economic theory posits that markets reach a natural equilibrium �Arrow and Debreu 1954;McKenzie 1981�. Yet even though computing advances allow increasingly precise general equi-librium solutions �Mitra-Kahn 2008�, there continues to be criticism of general equilibrium modelsas resolving to illogical answers, unstable results, or requiring excessively stringent assumptions�Petri 2004; Mandler 1999�. Furthermore, Arrow’s �1950� impossibility theorem suggests that ifmarket players have different ideas about what is important, there is no reason to assume that theequilibrium price necessarily results in a common sense solution for maximum social welfare.Equilibrium depends in part on utility functions, which may change over time in ways not speci-fied by most economic models. Lehman �1992, 32–35� claims that the Pareto optimal criterion ofneoclassical economics ignores the role of social structure in creating unequal distribution ofwealth even when the economy is in equilibrium.
Posner �1974� and Stigler �1971� suggest that it is common for regulatory bodies such asaccounting standard setters to become captured by those in positions of professional or politicalpower. Zeff’s �1978� work on economic consequences gives evidence that powerful players do notpassively rely on an invisible hand to establish market equilibria but work for changes in account-ing standards that favor their private objectives. Public interest researchers would suggest a caveatthat processes can remain captured even when conducted in public forums when the economicinterests of the relatively few who find it feasible to respond are not representative of the moredispersed interests of the broader public.
Lehman �1992� is particularly critical of capital markets research because it focuses on theinformation value of accounting, while ignoring the ways in which accounting measures areaffected by social power structures. Capital markets researchers tend to ignore the public interestchallenges, treating problems in accounting measures as insignificant noise. This failure to engagein meaningful dialog between capital markets and public interest researchers may derive fromharsh public interest rhetoric that labels traditional accounting and standard-setting processes as“bullshit” �Macintosh 2006� and the “hunting of snarks” �Page 2005�, or an unwillingness torevamp the techniques and infrastructure dedicated to the dominant capital markets paradigm�Puxty and Tinker 1995, 243–270�. Westerners with little interest in numeric models rarely chal-
Economic “Reality” and the Myth of the Bottom Line 335
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
lenge the complex mathematics of capital markets research. Could the dominance of mathematicalmodels rather than philosophical concepts of public welfare in accounting research be tied to aweak professionalization movement that seeks to preclude public discussion of areas in whichaccounting cannot provide a definitive “bottom line”?
Implications of the Inherent Paradoxes of AccountingUnderstanding and admitting the interdependence between accounting measures and the so-
cial environment can provide a framework for understanding why some reforms cannot work. Thecurrent movement of the FASB toward principles-based and away from rules-based accountingfails to recognize the interdependence of accounting measures and ethical expectations of thesociety. Rules proliferate in societies where individuals are not committed to policing themselvesagainst strong social and ethical principles that place more emphasis on the community good thanpersonal gain. Rules-based systems evolve when principles-based approaches are not working. Aswitch from rules- to principles-based accounting while the society at large still seeks to assignpraise or blame to individual firms or players within those firms will provide only more latitude toexploit the limitations of incorrigible allocations and indistinct accounting boundaries for personalgain.
Education is one area where public recognition of problems of accounting measurementapparently increases the visibility and perceived value of an accounting degree. American under-graduate accounting programs saw enrollment increases after Enron and similar scandals �Hohman2002; Wan 2003; Giegerich 2005�. After the dramatic effects of the Enron and WorldCom melt-downs, students who previously thought that accounting was all about following noncontroversialrules saw accounting as more exciting and socially relevant. Prior to these notorious cases, ac-counting classroom materials had become highly structured, using lists of learning objectives andpractice multiple-choice questions from credentialing exams. Conversely, accounting curriculahave de-emphasized basic problems like the incorrigibility of allocations and the known counter-intuitive nature of some fair market valuations. Rather than making students lose faith in thedecision usefulness of accounting, accounting’s dark side apparently increases interest. Studyingboth the inherent limitations and the potential for ethical failures arising from improper uses ofaccounting rules and principles has the potential to make today’s students more sophisticated usersof accounting data, perhaps even increasing market efficiency or moving markets to an equilib-rium that is more socially just. Focusing on the inherent controversies in accounting could serve asan organizing principle for accounting curricula interested in moving from mindless memorizationof rules toward the higher order skills of critical thinking and synthesis.
The techniques used by capital markets and public interest researchers differ widely in theirbasic assumptions and conclusions. Most capital markets research assumes that self-interest isparamount. Yet recent perspectives from physics and Buddhist philosophy that emphasize theconnections between phenomena mirror work in modern game theory that indicates the bestresults accrue from aligning self-interest with social goals. In focusing on market equilibrium,public interest researchers argue that capital markets researchers do not pay adequate attention tothe possibility of resetting equilibrium points by modifying collective social values and structures.On the other hand, the economic model of the prisoner’s dilemma �Pounder 1992� emphasizes thedifficulties in maintaining a commitment to joint rather than individual goals. Even if capitalmarkets and public interest researchers never integrate their research methodologies, an under-standing of the reasons why economic “reality” can never be fully explained by a single paradigmshould encourage the accounting profession to value a variety of research models.
The subprime mortgage and related financial crises of 2008 and beyond suggest the generalpublic might be well served to know more about the inherent limitations of complex financial
336 Moore
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
contracts. How can the accounting profession pride itself on providing a genuine service to thepublic if its members are not committed to specific initiatives aimed at consumer education? Whilethe American Institute of CPA’s 360 Degrees of Literacy program is a modest start, recent eventssuggest the profession should be doing more to help consumers be less gullible and more focusedon asking the right questions about financial products.
Not all accounting issues can be solved with better rules and more consistent conceptualframeworks. Allocation and boundary problems can be alleviated only by having users who aresophisticated enough to understand and distinguish between those elements of accounting reportsthat are objective and those that are arbitrary by their very nature. The accounting profession needsto consider why we feel compelled to change our rules and frameworks in response to each andevery criticism while attorneys and doctors do not. Physicians and hospitals are not shy aboutmaking patients sign waivers of responsibility that specifically list all kinds of risks and negativeoutcomes. And the courts assume that legal clients not only can but should assist their attorneys inmaking decisions on legal strategy. In contrast, tax franchises run advertisements promising theycan find “errors” that other accountants missed, reinforcing the popular idea that there is only oneright answer. The accounting profession seems trapped in a cycle of constantly revising their rulesand concepts. We go from method A, to method B, and eventually back to method A in reaction toa constant barrage of political crises. Perhaps it is time we seriously asked ourselves, “Does theaccounting profession project an image of having correct answers because it is a weak profession,or do accountants have weak professional standing because they do not have the courage to admitpublicly the inherent paradoxes and limitations of their craft?”
REFERENCES
Arrow, K. J. 1950. A difficulty in the concept of social welfare. The Journal of Political Economy 58 �4�:328–346.
——–, and G. Debreu. 1954. The existence of an equilibrium for a competitive economy. Econometrica 22:265–290.
Beaver, W., and J. Demski. 1979. The nature of income measurement. The Accounting Review �January�:38–46.
Belkaoui, A. 1984. Socio-Economic Accounting. Westport, CT: Quorum.Beller, M. 2001. Quantum Dialogue: The Making of a Revolution. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Benston, G. J. 2006. Fair-value accounting: A cautionary tale from Enron. Journal of Accounting and Public
Policy 25 �July/August�: 465–484.——–. 2008. The shortcomings of fair-value accounting described in SFAS157. Journal of Accounting and
Public Policy 27 �March/April�: 101–114.Bernstein, J. 2005. Max Born and the quantum theory. American Journal of Physics 73 �November�: 999–
1008.Bierman, H., Jr. 1969. Measurement and accounting. In Contemporary Accounting and Its Environment,
edited by J. W. Buckley. Belmont, CA: Dickenson.Boer, G., and O. Moseley. 1995. Some comments on logical reasoning and “the market for excuses.” In
Policing Accounting Knowledge: The Market for Excuses Affair, edited by T. Tinker and A. Puxty,92–107. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener.
Bohr, N. 1958. Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge. New York, NY: John Wiley.Bowen, H. R. 1953. Social Responsibilities of the Businessman. New York, NY: Harper.Bricker, J. R., and G. J. Previtts. 1990. The sociology of accountancy: A study of academic and practice
community schisms. Accounting Horizons 4 �1�: 1–14.Bromwich, M., R. Macve, and S. Sunder. 2008. Conceptual framework: Revisiting the basics—A comment
on Hicks and the concept of “income” in the conceptual framework. Paper presented at AmericanAccounting Association Annual Meeting, Session 6.1, Anaheim, CA, August 5.
Brubaker, H. 2008. New rules can turn a loss into a gain. Philadelphia Inquirer �May 18�.
Economic “Reality” and the Myth of the Bottom Line 337
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
Burchell, S., C. Clubb, A. Hopwood, J. Hughes, and J. Nahapiet. 1980. The roles of accounting in organi-zations and society. Accounting, Organizations and Society 5 �1�: 5–27.
Chambers, R. J. 1966. Accounting, Evaluation and Economic Behavior. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.Cleverly, G. 1973. Managers and Magic. London, U.K.: Longman.Core, J. E., W. R. Guay, and D. F. Larcker. 2003. Executive equity compensation and incentives: A survey.
Economic Policy Review 9 �April 1�: 27–50.Dalai Lama. 2005. The Universe in a Single Atom: The Convergence of Science and Spirituality. New York,
NY: Morgan.De Broglie, L. 1953. The Revolution in Physics. New York, NY: Noonday.Deloitte. 2006. China’s new accounting standards: A comparison with current PRC GAAP and IFRS. Avail-
able at: http://www.iasplus.com/dttpubs/0607prcifrsenglish.pdf.Demski, J., and D. E. M. Sappington. 1990. Fully revealing income. The Accounting Review 65 �2�: 363–
383.——–, S. FitzGerald, Y. Ijiri, Y. Ijiri, and H. Lin. 2006. Quantum information and accounting information:
Their salient features and conceptual applications. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 25 �4�:435–464.
Derman, E. 2004. A Geek’s Walk on Wall Street. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.Devine, C. T., ed. 1985. Some impossibilities—including allocations. In Essays in Accounting Theory, Vol. 5,
79–91. Sarasota, FL: American Accounting Association.Economist, The. 2007. Moving pieces. U.S. Ed. 382 �February 24�: 9.Edwards, E. O., and P. W. Bell. 1961. The Theory and Measurement of Business Income. Berkeley, CA:
University of California Press.Einstein, A. 1934. Essays in Science. New York, NY: Philosophical Library.Elliot, R. K. 1991. Accounting education and research at the crossroad. Issues in Accounting Education 6 �1�:
1–8.Emerson, R. W., ed. 1841. Self-reliance. In Essays. Boston, MA: James Munroe and Company. Republished
in 1995 by The Classics of Liberty Library, New York, NY.Feldman, M. S., and J. G. March. 1981. Information in organizations as signal and symbol. Administrative
Science Quarterly 26 �June�: 171–186.Fernandez, L. F., and H. S. Bierman. 1998. Game Theory with Economic Applications. Reading, MA:
Addison-Wesley.Giegerich, A. 2005. Enron gives boost to accounting field. Portland Business Journal �July 29�. Available at:
http://portland.bizjournals.com/portland/stories/2005/08/01/story2.html.Gintis, H. 2000. Game Theory Evolving: A Problem-Centered Introduction to Modeling Strategic Behavior.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Goyder, G. 1961. The Responsible Company. Oxford, U.K.: Basil Blackwell.Hanh, T. N., ed. 1998. The three doors of liberation. In The Heart of the Buddha’s Teaching, 146–155. New
York, NY: Broadway Books.Hayward, J., and F. Varela. 1992. Gentle Bridges: Conversations with the Dalai Lama on the Science of
Mind. Boston. MA: Shambhala.Heisenberg, W. 1927. Quantum mechanics 1925–1927. Sound bites. Available at: http://www.aip.org/history/
heisenberg/voice1.htm.——–. 1970. Natural Law and the Structure of Matter. London, U.K.: Rebel Press.Hicks, J. R. 1939. Value and Capital. Oxford, U.K.: Oxford University Press.Hohman, G. 2002. Accounting enrollment on rise despite streak of corporate scandals. Charleston Daily Mail
�September 16�. Available at: http://accounting.smartpros.com/x35312.xml.Jayasinghe, K., and T. Soobaroyen. 2007. “Spirit” of religion and peoples; Perceptions of accountability in
Buddhist and Hindu religious organisations: A story from non-Western societies. Research paper2007–4, School of Management and Business, The University of Wales. Available at: http://www.aber.ac.uk/smba/en/Research/Research/20Papers%2007/07-4%20’Spirit’%20of%20Religion.pdf.
Katz, D. M., and T. Reason. 2008. How fair value rewards deadbeats. CFO.com, July 9. http://www.cfo.com/article.cfm/11706587/c_2984368.
338 Moore
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
Ketz, J. E., and A. Wyatt. 1983. The FASB in a world with partially efficient markets. Journal of Accounting,Auditing & Finance �Fall�: 29–43.
Krantz, D. H., R. D. Luce, P. Suppes, and A. Tversky. 1971. Foundations of Measurement. Vol. I. New York,NY: Academic Press.
Kvifte, S. 2008. Revisiting the concepts: Time to challenge the asset-liability view. Australian AccountingReview 18 �March�: 81–92.
Lehman, C. R. 1992. Accounting’s Changing Role in Social Conflict. New York, NY: Markus Wiener.Liyanarachchi, G. A. 2008. Ethics in accounting: Exploring the relevance of a Buddhist perspective. Accoun-
tancy, Business, and the Public Interest 7 �2�: 118–148.Loy, D. 1988. Nonduality: A Study in Comparative Philosophy. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Macintosh, N. B. 2006. Accounting—Truth, lies, or “bullshit”? A philosophical investigation. Accounting and
the Public Interest 6: 22–36.Mandler, M. 1999. Dilemmas in Economic Theory: Persisting Foundational Problems of Microeconomics.
Oxford, U.K.: Oxford University Press.Mansfield, V. 2008. Tibetan Buddhism & Modern Physics. West Conshohocken, PA: Templeton Foundation.Mathews, M. R. 1997. Twenty-five years of social and environmental accounting research: Is there a silver
jubilee to celebrate? Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 10 �4�: 481–531.McKenzie, L. W. 1981. The classical theorem on existence of competitive equilibrium. Econometrica 49:
819–841.Mitchell, B. 1967. A comparison of accounting and economic concepts of business income. New York
Certified Public Accountant 37 �October�: 762–772.Mitra-Kahn, B. H. 2008. Debunking the myths of computable general equilibrium models, Working Paper
10–2008, Schwartz Center for Economic Policy Analysis �SCEPA�.Ouellette, J. 1999. Physicists graduate from Wall Street. The Industrial Physicist 5 �6�: 9–13.Page, M. 2005. The search for a conceptual framework: Quest for a holy grail, or hunting a snark? Account-
ing, Auditing & Accountability Journal 18 �4�: 565–576.Palmrose, Z.-V. 2008. Science, politics, the media, and accounting: Perspectives from the Potomac. Plenary
speech at the 2008 American Accounting Association Annual Meeting, Anaheim, CA, August 5.Paulos, J. A. 1988. Innumeracy: Mathematical Illiteracy and Its Consequences. New York, NY: Hill and
Wang.Petri, F. 2004. General Equilibrium, Capital and Macroeconomics: A Key to Recent Controversies in Equi-
librium Theory. Cheltenham, U.K.: Edward Elgar.Porter, T. M. 1995. Trust in Numbers: The Pursuit of Objectivity in Science and Public Life. Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.Posner, R. A. 1974. Theories of economic regulation. Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 5:
335–358.Pounder, W. 1992. Prisoner’s Dilemma. New York, NY: Doubleday.Puxty, T., and T. Tinker, eds. 1995. Policing accounting: The sociology of knowledge as praxis. In Policing
Accounting Knowledge: The Market for Excuses Affair, 243–270. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener.Quarter, J., L. Mook, and B. Richmond. 2002. What Counts: Social Accounting for Nonprofits and Coop-
eratives. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.Rabjam, S. 2007. The Great Medicine that Conquers Clinging to the Notion of Reality. Boston, MA: Sham-
bhala.Revsine, L. 1970. On the correspondence between replacement cost income and economic income. The
Accounting Review 45 �July�: 513–523.Sarle, W. S. 1995. Measurement theory: Frequently asked questions. In Disseminations of the International
Statistical Applications Institute, 4th ed., Wichita, KS: ACG Press. Available at: ftp://ftp.sas.com/pub/neural/measurement.html.
Solomons, D. 1978. The politicization of accounting. Journal of Accountancy 146 �November�: 65–72.Stevens, S. S. 1946. On the theory of scales of measurement. Science 103: 677–680.Stigler, G. J. 1971. The theory of economic regulation. Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science
2 �1�: 3–21.
Economic “Reality” and the Myth of the Bottom Line 339
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
Study Group on the Internationalization of Business Accounting, Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry�Study Group�. 2004. Report on the Internationalization of Business Accounting in Japan, June. Avail-able at: http://www.iasplus.com/resource/0406ifrsjapangaap.pdf.
Sweeney, H. W. 1930. Stabilized Accounting. New York, NY: Harper & Brothers.Thomas, A. L. 1969. Studies in Accounting Research # 3; The Allocation Problem in Financial Accounting
Theory. Sarasota, FL: American Accounting Association.Tinker, T. 1985. Paper Prophets: A Social Critique of Accounting. New York, NY: Praeger.Wan, W. 2003. Corporate scandals add up to money, interest in suddenly “sexy” accounting. Capital News
Service �January 31�.Watts, R. L., and J. L. Zimmerman. 1979. The demand for and supply of accounting theories: The market for
excuses. The Accounting Review �April�: 273–305.Williams, P. 1995. The logic of positive accounting theory. In Policing Accounting Knowledge: The Market
for Excuses Affair, edited by T. Tinker and A. Puxty, 217–233. Princeton, NJ: Markus Wiener.Wolk, H. I., J. L. Dodd, and J. J. Rozycki, eds. 2008. Usefulness of accounting information to investors and
creditors. In Accounting Theory: Conceptual Issues in a Political and Economic Environment, 217–267. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
Zeff, S. 1978. The rise of “economic consequences.” Journal of Accountancy 3 �December�: 56–63.
340 Moore
Accounting Horizons September 2009American Accounting Association
The phrase “the bottom line” has become a shorthand for the value of a company. But what is the bottom line, really? Is it the end of the story? And if so, how much can we trust it?
The bottom line is not the end of the story. It’s only one metric for economic health, and it can be misleading if you’re looking at them in isolation from other key indicators like revenue growth and profit margin. The best business leaders know that there are many ways to measure success, not just one.
In the 1930s, the economy was more homogeneous and less complex. It was a time when most Americans were employed in manufacturing and agriculture, and there was little international trade. The world’s population was roughly half its current size–about 6 billion people at that time compared to over 7 billion today–and most people lived on farms where they produced their own food rather than relying on stores or supermarkets for basic needs like milk and bread (or cheese).
Today, however, almost half of us don’t work in those traditional occupations; we’re not farmers anymore but instead professionals who make our living using technologies developed over many decades by other people working together across national borders. The global nature of today’s economy means that workers must often move around from country to country seeking employment; this creates new opportunities for innovation as well as new challenges such as discrimination based on race or gender identity.*
The bottom line is a myth.
It’s not the end of the story, and it doesn’t tell you what makes a company valuable in its entirety–or even just one part of it. In fact, it’s extremely conservative metric for economic health.
You can get much more information about value from looking at things like cash flow and profits (revenue minus expenses), which will tell you whether or not a company is actually making money; they’re much more telling than just focusing on how much money it has in its bank account!
The bottom line is actually an extremely conservative metric for economic health.
The bottom line is the most conservative metric for economic health, because it doesn’t take into account any spending on research and development or other capital investments that might be needed to enable a company to create new products or services. It also doesn’t include employees’ wages, which are paid out of profits–something that would be reflected in higher profits if those wages were included in the equation. The bottom line may seem like an easy way to measure how well a company does financially, but it’s actually not very accurate at all.
The value of a company is not just about its stock price. Stock market data can be misleading, especially when it comes to assessing the future of a company. The price of your stock reflects market sentiment at any given time and doesn’t necessarily reflect economic reality or even the past performance of that specific business unit within an enterprise. For example: if you own 100 shares of XYZ Company’s common stock but only 20% ownership in total shares outstanding (including restricted shares), then even though your investment in XYZ Company has increased by 10% since last month, you don’t really have any say in how much profit this company makes because only 50% goes toward shareholders’ dividends/distributions anyway!
The bottom line is a myth. It’s time we start treating companies as people and stop treating them as if they were just a collection of numbers on a page. We need to stop thinking about our economy in this way because it’s actually very damaging to the future of our world. If we continue down this path, there will be no more jobs or money left for anyone; only corporations who can afford to pay their workers less than minimum wage while they make billions off their workers’ labor! This is why investing ethically and taking care of your employees should be part of everyones’ plan over the long term but not just because it’s good for business – it’s also good for society as well.”
Try it now!
How it works?
Follow these simple steps to get your paper done
Place your order
Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.
Proceed with the payment
Choose the payment system that suits you most.
Receive the final file
Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.
Our Services
Ace Writing Center has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.
Essays
At Ace Writing Center, Nowadays, students normally have extremely busy schedules. You will note that some of them have to take on some evening or weekend jobs in order to get some income that can help them to sustain in college or in the university. This can deny them a chance to write all the essays given. Others usually get bombarded with a lot of work by their lecturers. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. However, some of them usually try to work on all these essays but end up delivering their work late. This can prevent them from graduating since most lecturers are strict on deadlines. If you want to write a business essay, the wise way is to hire an outstanding essay writing service like us, so that you can get the best results. If you are keen, you will note that many companies usually overcharge their customers. Some of them are there only to make money. And in reality, they really don’t care to build a long term commitment with students. You should not choose such companies. You should take your time and choose a reliable company to work with. Ace Writing Center is the ultimate solution for you. We have been offering our writing service for more than 7 years. This is a clear indication that you will get quality essay writing service. We have a wide range of writers who can work on any business essay that you might have. We believe in doing extensive research so that we can provide quality work to all our clients. .
Admissions
Admission and Business Papers
Have you ever had to write an admission essay for college? The majority of students face the same issues when applying to a university or college and many in such situations decide they need professional help to cope with this matter. They get in a situation when the deadline keeps coming closer but lack motivation to start because they are just not sure if their writing skills are strong enough. We have a solution for you! Ace Writing Center is the best admission essay writing service with a large professional team and years of experience in providing high-quality papers to students of all levels and faculties. The mission of our team is to help students make their dreams of entering a good college come true and that’s what we offer!.
Editing
Editing and Proofreading
Sometimes all the words for your paper just flow out of your mind and into your fingers. You type quickly at your keyboard and there they are, your beautiful words right there on the screen. But you have no idea how to polish it up. You may be wishing there was a paper writing service that offered this type of writing service. Look no more! Here at Ace Writing Center, we offer you an editing and proofreading option that you can't find anywhere else..
Coursework
College Essay Writing
In case you are familiar Ace Writing Center, you know the way to distinguish a better company from a cheap one exactly. First of all, poor service website does not have a sufficient support. We think support team is an essential part of success; it has to answer all clients’ questions and be a connecting link between clients and their writers. On our web-service you will get answers about anything you need and your writer will receive all your instructions, assignments and requirements exactly and swiftly. A writing service that we run has got a flexible pricing system that will save you from senseless wastes and many bonus systems that let you sparing money for something important for you.