GENERAL GUIDELINES for WRITING A PHILOSOPHY PAPER
Format Checklist
Your paper should begin with the following information, either on a separate title page or at the top of the first page:
- the title of the paper,
- the date the paper was completed,
- your student ID (for anonymous grading),
- a word count,
- and the name of the course.
- The title should reflect the thesis and content of the paper. Do not use “First Paper” or “Philosophy Paper: Topic 3.” There should be a list of references following the body of the paper. Sources should be acknowledged and cited properly in the text (see below).
- There are several different formats for citations and reference that you may use (such as APA, Chicago); I only require that you choose one and apply it consistently.
- Format the paper with a normal font (10-12 point), with margins of about 1 inch (3 cm), and double spaced.
Content
1. Topics: If you are writing a paper regarding an assigned topic, be sure you address all parts of the topic. If the prompt includes a yes / no question, you should clearly state and defend your answer. Many assigned topics involve explaining an author’s argument and then critically assessing it. To do this successfully you will need to identify the parts of the text relevant to the topic, and then clarify the author’s position and explore its strengths and weaknesses.
2. Structure: Your paper should present an argument in favor of a precisely formulated thesis. Perhaps the most important part of writing a successful paper is giving it clear structure. You and your reader should both know where the paper is headed and how a particular paragraph fits into the overall argument. Two things are crucial to giving your paper a clear structure. First, you should be able to outline the paper and summarize the key steps in the argument. Often writing an outline is a good first step in working on the paper. Even if you skip this step, if you cannot write a good outline for the finished paper then the structure is not clear enough! Second, you should use various “signposts” to indicate where you are in a particular argument: “I will present two arguments for the claim P … . First, P follows from … The second argument is based on the idea that …” Use language like this to make the structure of the paper clear to the reader. (I have never complained that a paper’s structure is too clear!)
3. Introduction: Do not start with a rambling prologue that gives the history of the topic or too much general background. Sometimes I have gone through an entire page of text without knowing which topic the student had chosen. The introduction should accomplish two things: identify the main claim or thesis that you will be defending, and provide a brief motivation for the topic – indicating why it is interesting and significant. The introduction may also give some indication of how the paper will proceed (although this is usually only necessary for longer papers). Often it is best to rewrite the introduction after you have finished the paper, once you have a better idea of the overall argument and a clearer formulation of your main thesis.
4. Body: In the body of the paper, each paragraph should be devoted to addressing one issue or explaining one further step in the argument. If you are not sure what the point of a particular paragraph is, your reader will certainly not know either! Typically part of the paper will involve explaining the position of one of the authors we have read. Merely summarizing or paraphrasing an author’s position does not qualify as explaining their views. You should explain the author’s ideas in your own words, being as fair to the author as you can. Avoid presenting a “straw man,” which is a misrepresentation that makes an author’s ideas appear particularly weak or stupid. (Politicians often present their opponents’ positions in this way.) You should also avoid summarizing the author’s ideas on issues that are not relevant to your topic. In offering your own arguments or criticisms, be careful to make your point as clear as you possibly can. This includes explaining what you mean very precisely. Many words that have an ordinary meaning have a quite different philosophical meaning (such as “valid”), and you should be careful to use such words correctly. You should also avoid the temptation to use unfamiliar words, as this often leads to imprecise and confusing prose.
5. Conclusion: The conclusion is your final chance to persuade the reader of your argument, and to provoke further reflection about your topic. A good conclusion should complete the main part of the essay by reminding the reader of what has been established. For a short essay, it is not effective to reiterate the argument, but the conclusion should bring a sense of closure. But the conclusion should also convey some sense of the remaining possibilities of the subject or line of argument. This could include, for example: a suggestion about how the line of argument relates to another topic; further questions that have been raised in the course of the paper; or a discussion of the importance of the issue in a broader context.
6. Revision: One of the most important parts of writing well is learning to revise and improve a first draft. Often you will have a much better understanding of the topic after finishing your first draft than you had when you first sat down to write. Give yourself the time to write a first draft of the paper and read it carefully, checking not just for grammatical errors but for more important problems with structure and clarity. You should keep an eye out for gaps in the argument or places where you have not explained yourself fully. You will be graded based on what you have actually written, not what you meant to say or what you expect the reader to understand by “reading between the lines.” On the other hand, you should also look for ways to say what you mean more concisely. You may be able to make a point crisply in a single sentence where the first draft has two or three repetitive sentences. You will discover better ways to formulate your argument on the second (or third …) try.
Plagiarism and the Use of Sources
Plagiarism is the act of presenting another person’s written work as your own. This includes direct quotations that are not acknowledged as such, as well as paraphrasing or slightly rearranging source materials. Do not give in to the temptation to copy text or essays from the web. TurnItIn will compare your paper to an extensive database of other papers and material available online, so it will be very easy for me to detect plagiarized material and find your sources. You are responsible for understanding the difference between plagiarism and the proper use of sources. Ignorance of what constitutes plagiarism is not an acceptable excuse. See the websites below for more detailed advice regarding how to avoid plagiarism.
The guiding principle behind citations is that your reader should be able to find the sources you have used. There are several standard systems for acknowledging sources, including footnotes, endnotes, or parenthetical references included in the text. I prefer that you use parenthetical references, although you can use a different system – as long as you use it correctly.
Here is a brief example of an in-text parenthetical reference (to pages 187-188) and the item as it appears in the bibliography:
Garber (1992, 187-88) rejects the claim that Descartes’ true motivation for introducing the “proper sense” of motion was to avoid the Church’s condemnation of Copernicanism for the following …
Garber, Daniel (1992). Descartes’ Metaphysical Physics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Although the web can be an incredibly useful research tool, sources and texts that appear only online are often unreliable and misleading. With a few exceptions, such as electronic journals and the Stanford on-line philosophy encyclopedia (http://plato.stanford.edu), you should use only published sources for your paper.
More Advice
You should feel free to ask me or the Teaching Assistant for further advice regarding the paper, including looking at early drafts. There are a number of helpful websites that give much more detailed advice regarding the topics discussed above, here are two:
“A Sample Philosophy Paper,” Prezi by Angela Mendelovici (UWO).
Guidelines for proper citations and avoiding plagiarism: www.plagiarism.org/
Philosophy Paper Grading Rubric
(based on rubric created by Mara Harrell, CMU)
|
|
Excellent
|
Good
|
Needs Improvement
|
Unacceptable
|
|
CONTENT (Comments)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Argument
|
|
|
Thesis
|
A clear statement of the main conclusion of the paper.
|
The thesis is obvious, but there is no single clear statement of it.
|
The thesis is present, but must be uncovered or reconstructed from the text of the paper.
|
There is no thesis.
|
|
Premises
|
Each reason for believing the thesis is made clear, and presented in single statements. It is also clear which premises are to be taken as given, and which require further sub-arguments. The premises taken as given are very plausible. The paper provides sub-arguments for any controversial premises, and the structure of the sub-arguments is clear.
|
The premises are all clear, although each may not be presented in a single statement. The premises taken to be given are plausible. The paper provides sub-arguments for controversial premises. If there are sub-arguments, the premises for these are clear.
|
The premises must be reconstructed from the text of the paper. It is not made clear which premises are to be taken as given, and which will be supported by sub-arguments. There are no sub-arguments. The premises taken as given are implausible.
|
There are no premises—the paper merely restates the thesis, or makes assertions without further support.
Or there are premises, but they are implausible and more likely to be false than true.
|
|
Support
|
The premises clearly support the thesis, and the author is aware of exactly the kind of support they provide. The argument is either valid as it stands, or, if invalid, the thesis, based on the premises, is likely to be or plausibly true.
|
The premises support the thesis, and the author is aware of the general kind of support they provide. The argument is either valid as it stands, or, if invalid, the thesis, based on the premises, is likely to be or plausibly true.
|
The premises somewhat support the thesis, but the author is not aware of the kind of support they provide. The argument is invalid, and the thesis, based on the premises, is not likely to be or plausibly true.
|
The premises do not support the thesis.
|
|
Understanding
|
|
|
Exegesis
|
The paper accurately and precisely characterizes the positions in any source text. There is appropriate textual support for attributing the position.
|
The paper develops a plausible reading of the source text, that is fairly accurate and precise. But it is not adequately supported by the text.
|
The paper develops a reading of the source text, that is flawed in some ways (e.g., attributing a “straw man” to the text). There is some textual support for the position.
|
The positions attributed to source texts completely lack textual support, and reflect a failure to understand the source material.
|
|
Ideas
|
The paper contains a highly accurate and precise description of the issue or problem. There is some awareness of different ways to respond to the problem, alternatives to what the author has chosen.
|
The description of the problem or issue is fairly accurate and precise, and an awareness of alternative responses.
|
The description of the problem or issue is limited in both accuracy and precision, and there is little awareness of alternatives.
|
The description of the problem or issue is incorrect, and there is no awareness of alternative solutions.
|
|
Thesis
|
Thesis is original, interesting, and relevant.
|
The thesis is interesting and relevant.
|
The thesis is slightly off-topic, obviously true (or false), or not really worth writing about.
|
The thesis is totally irrelevant.
|
|
STYLE
|
|
|
Grammar and Diction
|
Sentences are grammatical and clearly written. Word choice reflects knowledge of precise meanings. All new or unusual terms are well-defined.
|
All sentences are grammatical. Most words are chosen for their precise meanings. Most new or unusual terms are well-defined.
|
A few sentences are incomplete and/or ungrammatical. Words are not chosen for their precise meanings. New or unusual terms are not well-defined.
|
Grammatical lapses are so great that the paper is hard to follow. The author does not acknowledge that key words have precise meanings.
|
|
Proofreading
|
Information (names, facts, etc.) is accurate. Paper has been spell-checked and proofread, and has almost no errors.
|
Information (names, facts, etc.) is accurate. Paper has been spell-checked and proofread, and has very few errors.
|
Information (names, facts, etc.) is mostly accurate. Paper has several typos and other errors.
|
Information (names, facts, etc.) is inaccurate. Paper has many typos and other errors.
|
|
ORGANIZATION
|
|
|
Introduction
|
Thesis is clear, and contained in the introduction. The introduction effectively motivates interest in the topic.
|
Thesis is contained in the introduction. The introduction motivates interest in the topic.
|
Thesis is not contained in the introduction, and the topic is unclear or unmotivated.
|
No thesis is present, and the topic is also not clear. Introduction is either irrelevant to the topic of the paper, or inaccurate.
|
|
Body
|
The structure of the argument is clear. It is made explicit which claims are being used as premises, and how these premises are supposed to support the thesis. The contribution of sub-arguments supporting specific premises is clear. It is clear how the sub-arguments relate to the overall argument.
|
The structure of the argument is fairly clear. It is clear which claims are being used as premises, and how these premises are supposed to support the thesis. It is fairly easy to determine how sub-arguments contribute, and to distinguish between sub-arguments and the overall argument.
|
The structure of the argument is hard to determine. It is somewhat unclear which claims are being used as premises, and how these premises are supposed to support the thesis. It is often unclear whether a given passage is a sub-argument or part of the main argument, or what it is meant to support.
|
There is no discernible argument. It is difficult or impossible to locate premises or to understand how they contribute. There seem to be many arguments, and it is completely unclear what any given passage contributes.
|
|
Conclusion
|
Completes main part of the essay accurately and succinctly, while also conveying some sense of larger context.
|
Either completes the main part of the essay or suggests larger context, but one is not done effectively.
|
Includes an attempt to complete the essay and suggest larger context, but neither is done effectively.
|
Essay ends without a proper conclusion.
|