TO: CEO Alexandria Marvel
FROM: Senior Level Leadership Consultant Megan Rodgers
Date: 13 March 2022
Subject: LSN Warehouse Manager Job Announcement
1. The announcement for a new LSN warehouse manager has worked in the past to hire managers with
the ability to make decisions and direct a team. The reason this tactic used to work was based on
leadership models such as “great man theory”, trait theory and autocratic leadership (Daft, R. L.
2010). These styles worked in. business setting where productivity was the main focal point in terms of
success. These traits showcase our leaders as directive in nature, task driven and bossy. These
leadership styles assume people are born with leadership traits, not everyone with certain traits are
good leaders (MALOŞ, R. 2012). Finding the right people for our company is crucial for success. In
recent years studies have shown productivity increases with trust, teamwork, and servant leaders. Our
recent LSN employee survey proves that leadership has been less effective than in previous years. The
job announcement states managers must have “high task focus”, “instruct employees”, be “task
focused” and “personally drive”. It also states managers must be “goal oriented”, “adhere strictly to
policy to succeed”. These leadership styles are not going to connect with our generation of current
employees or new hires. This generation strives for a vision to work toward as a team, communication,
and connection as a unit.
2. Based on today’s leadership styles such as transformational leaders, the leader membership exchange
theory and servant leadership; we must change our requirements of leaders to remain successful and
ensure morale for our team. Our job announcements must read in a way that captures the traits
needed in a leader not a manager (Bass, B. M. 1985). This will ensure we hire the correct team member
that can lead a well-oiled team of followers to a common goal. Specific traits are required to remain
successful based on the contemporary leadership styles previously mentioned. Our leaders must have
charisma, inspirational motivation, individual consideration and enforce contingent rewards. These all
fall under the category of transformational leadership. It is virtually impossible to lead without
followers, charisma will allow team members to follow their newly hired leader (Shamir, B., House, R. J.,
& Arthur, M. B. 1993). An inspirational leader will be able to showcase our LSN mission and create a
vision for team members to work toward. Once you have employee buy-in and a team working toward
a common goal productivity will skyrocket (Gandolfi,2017). Leaders must be able to use individualized
consideration to choose the correct task to achieve the greatest success at each level. Placing the right
people in the right place will increase overall accomplishments within the section. Leaders must be
adaptable and creative this will allow them to incorporate a rewards program to encourage high
performance and build team morale (Dansereau, F., Jr., Graen, G., & Haga, W. J. 1975). Additionally,
employees want to feel empowered, heard and valued. The leader member exchange theory allows the
leader to create a trusting environment that ensures mutual respect at all levels(Dirks, K. T., & Ferrin, D.
L. 2002). The leader can allow for trust, space to complete tasks, and enforce consequences as needed
to ensure the vision is not lost and productivity remains high all while taking care of their employees
(Aldrin & Gayatri, 2014). Finally, servant leaders can develop their team as they work on their personal
and professional goals. This dedication to each member creates an environment where the team wants
to work hard and ensure success for the leader because the leader is invested in them. Employees feel
cared for therefore they want to ensure their leader is cared for in return with productivity, completed
tasks and good attitudes (Liden, R. C., Wayne, S., J., Zhao, H., & Henderson, D. 2008).
3. There is a very clear difference in managing and leading a team. If LSN wants to create a culture of
positivity, ensure longevity of employment, and increase productivity it is critical we focus on leadership
and the positive affect it has on our team and the overall success of our business (Judge, T. A., & Piccolo,
R. F. 2004). An updated announcement for the position has been drafted below for your review.
4. LSN is looking for an experienced, charismatic leader to fulfill the Manager position in our
warehouse. Leaders must be able to create a vision for their team to achieve success. You must be
adaptable, trusting, and able to empower others. Leaders must be able to use creativity to create a
rewards program for their section. Applicants must be able to create an organization of respect and
enforce standards. Managers will be able to support the continued growth of LSN and each individual
employee they lead. This is a fast-paced environment, managers must be able to yield results in
employee satisfaction as well as department success.
4. If you have any questions, comments, or concerns please contact Megan Rodgers at 907-384-3580 or
via email at megan.rodgers@us.af.mil
Megan E. Rodgers
Senior Level Leadership Consultant
References:
GANDOLFI, F., & STONE, S. (2017). The Emergence of Leadership Styles: A Clarified
Categorization. Review of International Comparative Management / Revista de Management Comparat
International, 18(1), 18–30.
Aldrin, A. & Gayatri, R., 2014. Leadership Not A Title Nor A Position. International Journal of Current
Research and Academic Review, 2(8), pp.356–366.
Adapted from Daft, R. L. (2010). The leadership experience (5th ed.). Boston, MA: Cengage Learning
MALOŞ, R. (2012). The Most Important Leadership Theories. Annals of Eftimie Murgu University Resita,
Fascicle II, Economic Studies, 413–420.
Bass, B. M. (1985). Leadership and performance beyond expectations. New York: Free Press.
Shamir, B., House, R. J., & Arthur, M. B. (1993). The motivational effects of charismatic leadership: A selfconcept based theory. Organization Science, 4, 577–594.
Judge, T. A., & Piccolo, R. F. (2004). Transformational and transactional leadership: A meta-analytic test
of their relative validity. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89, 755–768.
Dirks, K. T., & Ferrin, D. L. (2002). Trust in leadership: Meta-analytic findings and implications for
research and practice. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87, 611–628.
Dansereau, F., Jr., Graen, G., & Haga, W. J. (1975). A vertical dyad linkage approach to leadership within
formal organizations: A longitudinal investigation of the role making process. Organizational Behavior &
Human Performance, 13(1), 46–78.
Liden, R. C., Wayne, S., J., Zhao, H., & Henderson, D. (2008). Servant leadership: Development of a
multidimensional measure and multi-level assessment. Leadership Quarterly, 19, 161–177.
To: Marvel, Alexandria
From: Simms, Aliciana
Date: 3/15/2022
Subject: Warehouse Operations Job Description
Good afternoon Ms. Marvel,
In respect to the recent job announcement for the managerial position at Las Vegas and
Miami for Warehouse Operations, it seems to need updating in order to fit more recent
leadership and managerial responsibilities.
It has been observed that the job description would be more efficient if this job was
posted back in the 1990s. Now that technology has advanced and more competitors are
present, a change in job announcement for said managerial position needs to be
modified.
In the 1990s, leadership qualities required more independence than what is necessary
now. In the job description, it mentions that managers need to lead their employees to
certain goals and tasks. Which typically would be necessary for organizations with
horizontal organizational structure, (Morgan 2015b, 2020, p. 1) which were more
common in the 90s. In addition to this, the inclusion of strict adherence to policy would
require sole comprehension and analysis for more unclear and/or loose policies, which
would be made by the manager. Considering that during the 90s the image of a leader
was supposed to represent their company and serve as an example to their employees,
having such the quality to follow strict policy would be vital in a manager.
Leaders today are able to compromise with their employees in order to ensure that they
both have the same vision and goal in mind. The current job announcement fails to
recognize the amount of interpersonal relationship/communication skills that a manager
would need in order to keep their employees satisfied and confident enough to display
high performance within the workplace, (Malo 2012, p. 418). Adding “proficient
interpersonal communication to connect with employees” would be a great modification
to the job announcement. In addition to that, expanding upon results-oriented and
including employee’s wellbeing would be a great addition to the job description.
With that being said, it seems as if the job description describes solely that a manager is
needed instead of a leader. It is vital that a leader is hired for this position because with
poor leadership comes less driven employees and a disconnection with staff members.
With a leader employed, employee concerns are heard, valued, and considered. In
addition to this, leaders motivate staff to get out of their comfort zone to better
themselves or even expand upon their interest. When it comes to managers, they
typically are more focused on the operations and have little regard for staff, (Olojot,
2021, p. 1). With this comes unhappy staff members which decreases productions and
eventually causes a profit-loss. In order for LSN to continue to make a profit, a leader
would need to be elected for this position so that employees have the drive and
willpower to work to their best abilities.
Please feel free to take a look at the references used in regards to managerial and
leadership qualities in the 90s and in present time:
Olojot. (2021, October 29). Differences Between Leading and Managing Retrieved
March 15, from Https://leocontent.umgc.edu/content/scor/uncurated/cst/2215cst640/learning-topic-list/chain-of-custody.html?
Malos, R. (2012). THE MOST IMPORTANT LEADERSHIP THEORIES . Retrieved
March 14, 2022, from https://learn.umuc.edu/content/enforced/347722-001034-012192-OL16381/The%20Relational%20Leadership%20Model.pdf?_&d2lSessionVal=0YKnitbi
vm2p5fhD8dN3HrPYm
Morgan, J. (2015a, July 20). The 5 Types of Organizational Structures: Part 2, ‘Flatter’
Organizations. Retrieved October 24, 2017, from
https://www.forbes.com/sites/jacobmorgan/2015/07/08/the-5-types-of-organizationalstructures-part-2-flatter-organizations/#33fcf6e6dac3
Please feel free to reply if any concerns or questions arise.
V/R,
Aliciana Simms
To: CEO Alexandria Marvel
From: Christopher Puryear
Date: March 17, 2022
Subject: The Critical role of leadership for the future of LSN
This memo addresses Life Science Nutraceuticals, Inc’s current job
announcement and presents recommended adjustments to modernize
and align the announcement with effective hiring strategies of the
current era. These hiring strategies are based on modern developments
in organizational leadership and tie directly into LSN’s employees’
desires for collaborative leadership and decision-making.
The current job announcement for LSN is not suited for recruiting ideal
candidates that will shape the desired culture within the organization.
The current announcement explains that LSN is looking for managers
who will instruct employees and will focus on production speed and
volume (UMGC, n.d.a.). Georgetown University’s professor of
Management Dr. Franco Gandolfi and Youth Research, Inc’s Vice
President of Organizational Development Dr. Seth Stone list five key
attributes of an effective leader: someone who sets the example to
follow, instills passion for a company’s vision into the employees, aims
to reassess and possibly reinvent the organization’s status quo,
encourages employees to think and act autonomously, and truly cares
about the employees and their achievements (Gandolfi & Stone, 2017,
p. 20). The current job announcement is outdated and based on
antiquated theories of leadership from the 1990s and before
(Buchanan, 2013), during which time the prevailing styles of leadership
were to command employees to work, or simply give tasks to
employees and track their progress, as opposed to more modern
approaches of leadership that entail managers connect on a more
personal level with their employees and inspire them to output their
best performances (Gandolfi & Stone, 2017, p. 21). Modern styles of
leadership also require a more personal connection of leader and
follower, rather than manager and employee, and with this personal
connection comes more effective communication that builds lasting
work relationships between leader and follower (Aldrin & Gayatri, 2014,
p. 359).
LSN needs leaders who will change the internal culture of the company
and improve communication so the employees will feel more of a
connection with staff and the company’s vision. Contemporary effective
leadership involves one or more people embodying positive values,
beliefs, and traits which inspire peers and subordinate members of an
organization to align themselves with an organization’s mission and
accomplish their objectives (Aldrin & Gayatri, 2014, p. 356). The current
job announcement includes wording that tunnels would-be new hires
to focus exclusively on high volumes of production, emphasizing
deadlines, and places goals and policies above employees (UMGC,
n.d.a.). Recommended changes to the announcement require
substituting a focus on tasks with a focus on employee satisfaction,
emphasize cohesive relationships between management and
employees, require positive values, traits, and attributes that align with
the company’s vision, and focus on employee engagement in the
decision-making process.
LSN and its leadership must keep in mind that there is a distinct
difference between managing and leading. Leading and managing
draw upon two different sources of authority, with leading being a
more personally merited authority and managing being more of an
assigned authority (UMGC, n.d.b.). A leader often inspires employees
with passion, compassion, understanding, and clear communication,
while a manager is more concerned with employee output, maintaining
a system of rewards and punishment, and does not establish personal
connections with employees (UMGC, n.d.b.). An effective leader often
seeks advice and new ideas from his or her subordinate workforce,
while a manager does not seek advice and ideas from his or her
subordinates (UMGC, n.d.b.). The employees of LSN feel a disconnect
with the current culture in the company (UMGC, n.d.a.) and the only
way to remedy that feeling of disconnect is for LSN to understand what
traits the ideal, modern leader must possess and to seek the most
qualified candidates who match the description.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
References
Aldrin, A., and Gayatri, R. (2014). Leadership Not a Title Nor a
Position. International Journal of Current Research and Academic
Review, 2(8), 356 – 366. Retrieved from http://www.ijcrar.c
Buchanan, L. (2013). Between Venus and Mars: 7 traits of true leaders.
[Online] Retrieved from
http://www.inc.com/magazine/201306/leighbuchanan/traits-of-trueleaders.html.
Gandolfi, F., and Stone, S. (2017). The Emergence of Leadership Styles: A
Clarified Categorization. P. 18-22. Review Of International Comparative
Management / Revista De Management Comparat International, 18(1).
Retrieved from http://rmci.ase.ro/no18vol1/02.pdf
UMGC. (n.d.a.). Week 1 discussion. Case scenario. Retrieved
from https://learn.umgc.edu/d2l/le/625383/discussions/topics/3743773
/View
UMGC. (n.d.b.). Differences between leading and managing. Retrieved
from https://leocontent.umgc.edu/content/scor/uncurated/tlp/2211tlp610/learning-topic-list/differencesbetweenleadingandmanaging.html
Purchase answer to see full
attachment