Academy of Art University Transformational versus Servant Leadership Critical Review

Description

Make sure you follow the template document attached to this assignment to ensure you are correctly using APA requirements in your document.

Assignment Description:

Review, summarize, analyze, and evaluate a scholarly article based on the concepts and principles covered in this course to compose a Synthesis Paper.

Assignment Instructions:

See specific instructions above in the pdf file.

  • Write a 500-600 word critical review of the attached article: TLSL Article – Stone Russell Patterson 00-292 Revised.pdf.
  • The first portion of your review should consist of a summary of the authors’ main point, or thesis? Look at the author’s points of evidence, organization, and overall method for presenting this information.
  • The second portion of the review should consist of your analysis and evaluation of their argument (Do not begin to analyze and evaluate until you have first summarized their argument and noted their methodology). Did the authors effectively communicate their thesis? Why or why not? You will not be required to include outside sources for this portion of the paper, but you can if you wish.

Unformatted Attachment Preview

Transformational versus Servant Leadership – A Difference in Leader Focus
By
A. Gregory Stone, Ph.D.
Professor
Regent University
School of Business & Leadership
gregsto@regent.edu
Robert F. Russell, Ph.D., CMA, CPA
Associate Professor & Department Chair
Department of Business Administration
Emory & Henry College
rrusse77@gmail.com
Kathleen Patterson, Ph.D.
Professor
Regent University
School of Business & Leadership
kathpat@regent.edu
▪ Stone, A. Gregory, Patterson, Kathleen, Russell, Robert, (2004).
Transformational Versus Servant Leadership – A Difference in Leader
Focus. Leadership and Organization Development Journal, Volume 25
Number 4, 349-364.
2
Abstract
This article examines transformational leadership and servant leadership to
determine what similarities and differences exist between the two leadership
concepts. The authors posit that the primary difference between transformational
leadership and servant leadership is the focus of the leader. The transformational
leader’s focus is directed toward the organization, and his or her behavior builds
follower commitment toward organizational objectives, while the servant leader’s
focus is on the followers, and the achievement of organizational objectives is a
subordinate outcome. The extent to which the leader is able to shift the primary
focus of leadership from the organization to the follower is the distinguishing
factor in classifying leaders as either transformational or servant leaders. This
article also looks at the next stage of developmental issues in servant leadership,
such as the challenges facing empirical investigation and measurement, and the
changes that are occurring in current thinking about the servant leadership
approach. Ultimately, the case is made that although different, both
transformational leadership and servant leadership offer the conceptual
framework for dynamic leadership.
3
Transformational versus Servant Leadership – A Difference in Leader Focus
Transformational leadership, initiated by James MacGregor Burns (1978)
and Bernard M. Bass (1985a), has become a very popular concept in recent
years. Both researchers and practitioners have gravitated to the theory and have
employed it in a variety of organizational settings. Similarly, the concept of
servant leadership, which Robert Greenleaf (1977) formulated in the modern era,
has received substantial attention in the contemporary leadership field. A cursory
glimpse of transformational leadership and servant leadership leaves the
perception that the concepts are rather similar. In fact, some individuals question
whether there is any real difference between the concepts.
This article first examines the theoretical framework, characteristics, and
focus of both transformational leadership and servant leadership to determine
what similarities and differences exist between the two leadership concepts.
Thereafter, the article differentiates the concepts along the dimension of leader
focus. The primary premise of the article is that transformational leaders tend to
focus more on organizational objectives while servant leaders focus more on the
people who are their followers. This tendency of the servant leader to focus on
followers appears to be the primary factor that distinguishes servant leadership
from transformational leadership. Otherwise, there are many similarities between
the two leadership concepts. A clear understanding of both frameworks helps to
understand the many similarities and the aforementioned distinction.
4
Transformational Leadership
Bass and Avolio (Bass, 1985a; Bass & Avolio, 1990) developed Burns’
(1978) ideas and posited the formal concept of transformational leadership. Their
work built not only upon the contribution of Burns but also those made by Bennis
and Nanus (1985), Tichy and Devanna (1986), and others. Bass (1990b)
specified that transformational leadership “occurs when leaders broaden and
elevate the interests of their employees, when they generate awareness and
acceptance of the purposes and mission of the group, and when they stir their
employees to look beyond their own self-interest for the good of the group” (p.
21). Bass (1990a) stipulates that this transcending beyond self-interest is for the
“group, organization, or society” (p. 53). In essence, transformational leadership
is a process of building commitment to organizational objectives and then
empowering followers to accomplish those objectives (Yukl, 1998). The result, at
least in theory, is enhanced follower performance (Burns, 1998; Yukl, 1998).
Burns (1978) considered leaders to be either transformational or
transactional, while others view leadership as a continuum with transactional
leadership at one end and transformational leadership at the other. Bass (1990a)
said that transactional leadership occurs when leaders “exchange promises of
rewards and benefits to subordinates for the subordinates’ fulfillment of
agreements with the leader” (p. 53). The transactional leader, according to Daft
(2002), recognizes followers’ needs and then defines the exchange process for
meeting those needs. Both the leader and the follower benefit from the exchange
transaction. Transactional leadership is based on bureaucratic authority, focuses
5
on task completion, and relies on rewards and punishments (Tracey & Hinkin,
1998).
Transformational leadership differs substantially from transactional
leadership. It is concerned more about progress and development. Furthermore,
transformational leadership enhances the effects of transactional leadership on
followers (Bass, 1985b, 1990a).
Transformational leaders transform the personal values of followers to
support the vision and goals of the organization by fostering an environment
where relationships can be formed and by establishing a climate of trust in which
visions can be shared (Bass, 1985a). Avolio, Waldman, and Yammarino (1991)
established four primary behaviors that constitute transformational leadership:
1) idealized influence (or charismatic influence),
2) inspirational motivation,
3) intellectual stimulation, and
4) individualized consideration.
The following discussion summarizes these areas and identifies the
characteristics that accompany each of them.
Idealized influence. Idealized influence is the charismatic element of
transformational leadership in which leaders become role models who are
admired, respected, and emulated by followers (Avolio & Bass, 2002; Bass,
1998; Bass & Avolio, 1994). Consequently, followers demonstrate a high degree
of trust in such leaders (Bass, 1990b; Jung & Avolio, 2000). Idealized influence in
6
leadership also involves integrity in the form of ethical and moral conduct (Tracey
& Hinkin, 1998).
The development of a shared vision is an integral component of the
idealized, transformational leader’s role (Jung & Avolio, 2000). It helps others to
look at the futuristic state, while inspiring acceptance through the alignment of
personal values and interests to the collective interests of the group’s purposes
(Avolio & Bass, 2002; Bass, 1990b, 1998; Jung & Avolio). Transformational
leaders are also willing to take and share risks with followers (Avolio & Bass,
2002; Bass, 1998).
Inspirational motivation. Transformational leaders inspire and motivate
others by “providing meaning and challenge to their followers’ work” (Avolio &
Bass, 2002, p. 2). The spirit of the team is “aroused” while “enthusiasm and
optimism are displayed” (Bass, 1998, p. 5). The transformational leader builds
relationships with followers through interactive communication, which forms a
cultural bond between the two participants and leads to a shifting of values by
both parties toward common ground. The leader inspires followers to see the
attractive future state, while communicating expectations and demonstrating a
commitment to goals and a shared vision. Idealized influence and inspirational
motivation are usually combined to form charismatic-inspirational leadership
(Bass, 1998).
Intellectual stimulation. Transformational leaders stimulate their followers’
efforts “to be innovative and creative by questioning assumptions, reframing
problems, and approaching old situations in new ways” (Avolio & Bass, 2002, p.
7
2). Followers’ mistakes are not publicly criticized and creativity is openly
encouraged. Transformational leaders solicit their followers’ ideas and creative
solutions to problems, thereby including followers in problem solving. The
intellectually stimulating leader encourages followers to try new approaches but
emphasizes rationality (Bass, 1990b).
Individualized consideration. The transformational leader disburses
personal attention to followers based on the individual follower’s needs for
achievement and growth (Avolio & Bass, 2002). To do this, the leader acts as a
mentor or coach developing followers in a supportive climate to “higher levels of
potential” (Bass, 1998, p. 6). The considerate leader recognizes and
demonstrates acceptance of the followers’ individual differences in terms of
needs and desires. By doing this, the transformational leader fosters two-way
communication through effective listening (Avolio & Bass, 2002; Bass, 1998).
The leader develops followers by delegating tasks and then unobtrusively
monitoring those tasks–checking to see if additional support or direction is
needed. The net effect of individualized consideration and other transformational
leadership behaviors is empowerment of followers (Behling & McFillen, 1996).
Ultimately, transformational leaders can develop a very powerful influence
over followers. For example, several research studies have documented the
power of transformational leadership in establishing value congruency and trust
(Jung & Avolio, 2000; Kirkpatrick & Locke, 1996; Podsakoff, Mackenzie, &
Bommer, 1996; Shamir, 1995). Followers respect and trust transformational
8
leaders, so they conform their values to those of the leaders and yield power to
them.
In summary, the transformational leader articulates the vision in a clear
and appealing manner, explains how to attain the vision, acts confidently and
optimistically, expresses confidence in the followers, emphasizes values with
symbolic actions, leads by example, and empowers followers to achieve the
vision (Yukl, 2002). Table 1 summarizes the four primary or functional areas of
transformational leadership and identifies the attributes that, according to the
literature, accompany these primary characteristics.
Table 1
Transformational Leadership Attributes
FUNCTIONAL ATTRIBUTES
ACCOMPANYING ATTRIBUTES
1) Idealized Influence / Charisma 1) Vision, 2) Trust, 3) Respect,
4) Risk-Sharing, 5) Integrity,
6) Modeling
2) Inspirational Motivation
7) Commitment to Goals, 8) Communication,
9) Enthusiasm
3) Intellectual Stimulation
10) Rationality,
11) Problem Solving
4) Individualized Consideration
12) Personal Attention, 13) Mentoring,
14) Listening, 15) Empowerment
9
Servant Leadership
Robert K. Greenleaf (1904-1990) is credited with initiating the servant
leadership concept among modern organizational theorists (Spears, 1995, 1996).
In Greenleaf’s (1969,1977) opinion, leadership must primarily meet the needs of
others. The focus of servant leadership is on others rather than upon self, and on
an understanding of the role of the leader as a servant (Greenleaf, 1977). Selfinterest should not motivate servant leadership; rather, it should ascend to a
higher plane of motivation (Greenleaf, 1977; Pollard, 1996). The servant leader’s
primary objective is to serve and meet the needs of others, which optimally
should be the prime motivation for leadership (Russell & Stone, 2002). Servant
leaders develop people, helping them to strive and flourish (McMinn, 2001).
Servant leaders provide vision, gain credibility and trust from followers, and
influence others (Farling, Stone, & Winston, 1999).
While servant leadership is an increasingly popular concept, throughout
much of its history the concept has been systematically undefined and lacking in
empirical support (Farling, Stone, & Winston, 1999). In an attempt to give
cohesion to the development of a theory, Russell, and Stone (2002) established
a practical model for servant leadership. They also identified functional and
accompanying attributes of servant leadership (see Table 2). The attributes
identified by Russell and Stone provide a reasonable basis for comparing servant
leadership with transformational leadership.
10
Table 2
Servant Leadership Attributes
FUNCTIONAL ATTRIBUTES
ACCOMPANYING ATTRIBUTES
1) Vision
1) Communication
2) Honesty, 3) Integrity
2) Credibility
4) Trust
3) Competence
5) Service
4) Stewardship
6) Modeling
5) Visibility
7) Pioneering
6) Influence, 7) Persuasion
8) Appreciation of Others
9) Empowerment
8) Listening, 9) Encouragement
10) Teaching, 11) Delegation
Comparative Review of Transformational and Servant Leadership
To help the reader see the similarities and differences between
transformational leadership and servant leadership, all of the elements
referenced thus far are comparatively reviewed in Table 3:
11
Table 3
Comparison of Attributes
TRANSFORMATIONAL
LEADERSHIP ATTRIBUTES
SERVANT LEADERSHIP
ATTRIBUTES
Idealized (Charismatic) Influence
Influence
Vision
Vision
Trust
Trust
Respect
Credibility & Competence
Risk-Sharing
Delegation
Integrity
Honesty & Integrity
Modeling
Modeling & Visibility
Service
Inspirational Motivation
Commitment to Goals
Stewardship
Communication
Communication
Enthusiasm
Intellectual Stimulation
Rationality
Problem Solving
Individualized Consideration
Personal Attention
Mentoring
Listening
Empowerment
Persuasion
Pioneering
Appreciation of Others
Encouragement
Teaching
Listening
Empowerment
(Functional Attributes in Bold Print–Accompanying Attributes in Regular Print)
Similarities and Differences
At this point, one may ask what is the real difference, if any, between
transformational leadership and servant leadership? Is servant leadership just a
subset of transformational leadership or vice versa? Are transformational
leadership and servant leadership the same theory, except for their use of
different names?
The side-by-side comparison in Table 3 reveals that transformational
leadership and servant leadership have relatively analogous characteristics.
12
Perhaps this is because both transformational and servant leadership are
attempts to define and explain people-oriented leadership styles. According to
both concepts, their leadership frameworks incorporate: (a) influence, (b) vision,
(c) trust, (d) respect or credibility, (d) risk-sharing or delegation, (e) integrity, and
(f) modeling. Both transformational leadership and servant leadership emphasize
the importance of appreciating and valuing people, listening, mentoring, or
teaching, and empowering followers. In fact, the theories are probably most
similar in their emphasis upon individualized consideration and appreciation of
followers.
Nevertheless, transformational leadership and servant leadership do have
points of variation. There is a much greater emphasis upon service of followers
and service to followers in the servant leadership paradigm. Furthermore, while
both transformational leaders and servant leaders are influential, servant leaders
gain influence in a nontraditional manner that derives from servanthood itself
(Russell & Stone, 2002). In so doing, they allow extraordinary freedom for
followers to exercise their own abilities. They also place a much higher degree of
trust in their followers than would be the case in any leadership style that
required the leader to be somewhat directive.
The Difference
In response to the questions about whether there are any real differences
between transformational leadership and servant leadership, our position is that
the concepts hold many similarities, and they are complementary theories in
many respects. Nonetheless, they ultimately form a distinctly separate theoretical
13
framework of leadership because of a primary difference. The principal difference
between transformational leadership and servant leadership is the focus of the
leader. While transformational leaders and servant leaders both show concern
for their followers, the overriding focus of the servant leader is upon service to
their followers. The transformational leader has a greater concern for getting
followers to engage in and support organizational objectives. The extent to which
the leader is able to shift the primary focus of his or her leadership from the
organization to the follower is the distinguishing factor in determining whether the
leader may be a transformational or servant leader. Furthermore, we proffer that
this primary distinction influences other characteristics and outcomes, giving rise
to secondary differences between the concepts.
Leader Focus
With transformational leadership, the leader’s focus is directed toward the
organization, and his or her behavior builds follower commitment toward the
organizational objectives through empowering followers to accomplish those
objectives (Yukl, 1998). While transactional leaders focus on exchange relations
with followers, transformational leaders inspire followers to higher levels of
performance for the sake of the organization (Burns, 1998; Yukl). The very
definition of transformational leadership states the building of commitment to the
organizational objectives (Yukl). The primary focus is on the organization, with
follower development and empowerment secondary to accomplishing the
organizational objectives. The result, nonetheless, is enhanced follower
performance (Burns; Yukl).
14
In contrast, the servant leader is one who focuses on his or her followers.
Servant leaders do not have particular affinity for the abstract corporation or
organization; rather, they value the people who constitute the organization. This
is not an emotional endeavor but rather an unconditional concern for the wellbeing of those who form the entity. This relational context is where the servant
leader actually leads. Harvey (2001) states that “…chasing profits is peripheral;
the real point of business is to serve as one of the institutions through which
society develops and exercises the capacity for constructive action” (38-39). The
servant leader does not serve with a focus on results; rather the servant leader
focuses on service itself. Lubin (2001) proffers that the servant leader’s first
responsibilities are relationships and people, and those relationships take
precedence over the task and product. Servant leaders trust their followers to
undertake actions that are in the best interest of the organization, even though
the leaders do not primarily focus on organizational objectives.
According to Bass (2000), servant leadership is “close to the
transformational components of inspiration and individualized consideration” (p.
33). However, the stress of servant leadership is upon the leader’s aim to serve.
This desire to serve people supersedes organizational objectives. Servant
leadership is a belief that organizational goals will be achieved on a long-term
basis only by first facilitating the growth, development, and general well-being of
the individuals who comprise the organization. Conversely, Bass states that
transformational leaders strive to align their own and others’ interests with the
good of the group, organization, or society. The primary aim is organizational
15
conformance and performance more than it is service to and facilitation of
followers. Harvey (2001) contends that the servant leader’s primary objective is
the workers and their growth, then the customer base, and finally the
organizational bottom line.
Historical Context
The differences identified heretofore between transformational leadership
and servant leadership are logical extensions of some of the primary themes in
the leadership literature. Various research studies dating back to the middle part
of the 20th century have identified: (a) a task or production dimension and (b) a
people or relationship dimension to leadership. The Ohio State University
Leadership studies (Stogdill & Coons, 1957) identified two primary elements of
leadership: (a) initiating structure, which deals with task behavior, and (b)
consideration for workers, which concerns relationships. Studies at the University
of Michigan (Likert 1961, 1967) focused on similar concepts. These studies
examined the production orientation and employee orientation of leaders. They
determined that the most effective leaders incorporate both dimensions but pay
the most attention to employees. Blake and Mouton (1964) developed their wellknown Leadership Grid® based on contrasting the two dimensions of: (a)
concern for people and (b) concern for production–again highlighting the
dichotomy between task and relationship responsibilities in leadership. However,
leadership research in the late 1970’s began to concentrate less on a situational
perspective and more on organizational performance (Behling & McFillen, 1996;
Contee-Borders, 2003; Hunt, 1991). Nonetheless, the task (production) and
16
relationship (people) dimensions of leadership have continued in some of the
contemporary leadership literature (Bass, 1990a).
Transformational leadership and servant leadership are both high-order
evolutions in leadership paradigms. Both theoretical frameworks emphasize a
high concern for people and for production. However, transformational leadership
incorporates a greater emphasis upon production because the leader has a
stronger focus on organizational objectives. On the other hand, servant
leadership involves a higher concern for people because the primary focus of the
leader is upon his or her followers.
Transformational leadership and servant leadership are not antithetical,
nor is either paradigm inherently superior to the other. Rather, transformational
leadership and servant leadership are similar, complementary but distinctly
different concepts. The observable differences between transformational
leadership and servant leadership are certainly logical in light of some of the
primary themes that have pervaded the leadership field. The differences between
the theories in practice may be a function of both the organizational context in
which the leaders operate and the personal values of the leaders.
The Emergence of Influence and Motivation
Another area of emerging distinction between transformational leaders
and servant leaders is that of follower influence and motivation resulting from the
focus of the leader. Anecdotal evidence suggests that transformational leaders
rely more on their charismatic attributes to influence followers, whereas servant
leaders significantly influence followers through service itself.
17
The motive of the servant leader’s influence is not to direct others but
rather to motivate and facilitate service and stewardship by the followers
themselves. It is a humble means for affecting follower behavior. Servant leaders
rely upon service to establish the purposes for meaningful work and to provide
needed resources. It is a characteristically unique method for stimulating and
influencing the behavior of others.
Transformational leaders rely upon their charismatic abilities. Bass (1960)
and Etzioni (1961) identified charisma as a form of personal power. Instead of
focusing on service as a means to motivation, transformational leaders rely more
on their charismatic, enthusiastic nature to garner influence and motivate
followers. They seek to get followers to commit to various organizational goals
and facilitate organizational objectives. Bass (1990b) said, “Attaining charisma in
the eyes of one’s employees is central to succeeding as a transformational
leader. Charismatic leaders have great power and influence . . . [they] inspire and
excite employees with the idea that they may be able to accomplish great things”
(p. 21). In essence, transformational leaders develop a type of influence derived
from their expertise, strength of relationships, and charismatic abilities.
Servant leaders, however, derive influence from service itself. They
develop relationships where followers are encouraged to follow their lead of
service. McKenna (1989) notes that servant-power is a category of influence
outside the traditional kinds of power. Real servanthood is a leadership style that
relies upon the influence of self-giving without self-glory.
18
Risks of Manipulation and Corruption. Because leaders garner power, all
forms of leadership carry with them the possibility for manipulation and
corruption. This negative side of leadership is potentially problematic for persons
aspiring to either transformational or servant leadership. The sources of influence
and motivation inherent in the two leadership concepts carry with them certain
distinct possibilities for manipulation.
In transformational leadership, personal power in the form of charisma can
be very influential upon followers. In fact, the strength of the leader’s charisma
may determine his or her overall effectiveness. Strongly charismatic leaders can
develop loyal, enthusiastic followers who may tend to overlook negative traits in
their leaders. Consequently, if the leaders’ motives or ethical standards are poor,
they can manipulate their loyal constituency.
Conger (1990) argued that there can be a dark side to leadership. For
example, leaders who are driven to accomplish their visions may ignore
problems and misrepresent the realism of their visions. Clements and Washbush
(1999) specifically assailed transformational leadership models for having
overlooked potentially negative issues in leader-follower dynamics. Similarly,
Kets de Vries (1993) cited personality problems that can lead to poor leaderfollower relationships. For example, some leaders have narcissistic tendencies-they thrive on power and enjoy manipulation. Some followers have dependent
dispositions and form strong connections to leaders who satisfy their dependency
needs (Kets de Vries, 1989). Such imperfect human tendencies can lead to
problems among charismatic leaders and their followers. History is replete with
19
examples of political, religious, business, and other charismatic leaders who
have manipulated their followers. Charisma may have allowed them to ascend to
leadership positions, but they ultimately used their charisma in oppressive ways.
Of course, such leaders whose standards are poor really function outside the
genre of the ideal transformational leadership paradigm.
Since servant leaders do not rely on charisma, the risk of manipulation in
this form of leadership comes from a different source. Servant leaders rely upon
service, and in so doing, they endear the followers to the leaders in reciprocal
relationships. Cialdini (2001) identified reciprocation as a primary means by
which to influence people. According to the principle of reciprocation, when you
do something for another person, they are psychologically obliged to return the
favor. Optimally, servant leaders have motives that have the best interest of
others in mind. Therefore, they should develop a positive form of reciprocation
whereby they encourage followers to respond not by serving the leader but by
serving others.
Of course, this law of reciprocity can potentially be used negatively.
Persons who seek to be servant leaders, but have poor motives, can take
advantage of others by inducing them to return acts of service. Such selfcentered service can rapidly degenerate into a form of manipulation that can be
more subtly coercive than overt exploitive behavior. However, those who use
service for manipulative purposes abdicate the real responsibility of genuine
servant leadership.
20
Clearly, both transformational leadership and servant leadership, like other
leadership models, have potentially negative aspects. Yet the benefits of the two
concepts far outweigh their negative sides. Additional investigation and field
studies into the role influence and motivation play in transformational and servant
leadership will further distinguish the characteristics of the concepts.
Research on Servant Leadership
There is a long line of research focusing on transformational leadership.
However, academic research on servant leadership is still in its infancy. Thus far,
the research on servant leadership has focused mostly on the comparison of the
servant leadership concept to other leadership methods and the identification of
specific characteristics of servant leadership (see: Farling, Stone, & Winston,
1999; Giampetro-Meyer, Brown, Browne, & Kubasek, 1998; Laub, 1999; Russell,
2000; Tice, 1996).
Farling, Stone, and Winston (1999) presented a concept of leadership
based on the variables of vision, influence, credibility, trust, and service-characteristics of servant leadership frequently noted in the popular press. They
concluded that servant leaders find the source of their values in a spiritual base.
Furthermore, they argued that empowering followers allows the servant leader to
act on his or her embedded values.
James Laub (1999) studied servant leadership in an attempt to define
specific characteristics of the servant leadership concept through a written,
measurable instrument. His research validates the idea of values as a basis for
servant leadership. However, he qualified his conclusions by stating that
21
additional empirical research is necessary to fully understand the relationship
between values and servant leadership. Similarly, Horsman (2001) studied the
idea of servant leadership as an emerging model of leadership and identified a
relationship between servant leadership and the personal aspects of spirit.
Russell (2000, 2001) focused on understanding the values and attributes
of servant leaders. His research hypothesized that servant leaders possess
different personal values than non-servant leaders, and these personal values
are tied to the attributes of leadership. His research provided evidence of a
relationship between values and leadership; however, the results indicated the
need for additional empirical studies to further examine and validate the link.
Academic work in the field of servant leadership is growing. Since the
concept continues to gain attention in practice, we can expect to see additional
research in the area. Further academic studies will help us understand what
leaders are willing to do to establish sustainable success and long-term
productivity using servant leadership. The ability to clearly distinguish servant
leadership from transformational leadership opens the door for clear definitions,
constructs, and instrumentation.
Conclusion
The overviews of transformational leadership and servant leadership
contained herein reveal many basic similarities between the two leadership
theories. Both transformational leaders and servant leaders are visionaries,
generate high levels of trust, serve as role models, show consideration for others,
delegate responsibilities, empower followers, teach, communicate, listen, and
22
influence followers. Certainly, transformational leadership and servant leadership
are not antithetical theories. Rather, they are complementary ideologies because
they both describe excellent forms of leadership. Nonetheless, there are
significant points of variation in the concepts. Most importantly, transformational
leaders tend to focus more on organizational objectives while servant leaders
focus more on the people who are their followers.
The world has become more complicated, and dynamic times require
dynamic, driven leaders (Williams, 1998). Both transformational leadership and
servant leadership offer the conceptual framework for dynamic leadership. While
transformational leadership has been well researched, and has become popular
in practice, servant leadership theory needs further support. Nonetheless,
servant leadership offers great opportunities for leaders.
Like transformational leadership, servant leadership can bring about real
change in organizations, albeit through different means. When followers
recognize that their leaders truly follow the ideals of servant leadership, then the
followers are apparently more likely to become servants themselves, which
decreases customer churn and increases long-term profitability and success
(Braham, 1999). Overall, both servant leadership and transformational leadership
offer valid, yet distinct paradigms for contemporary leadership in all types of
organizations.
23
References
Avolio, B. J., & Bass, B. M. (2002). Developing potential across a full
range of leadership cases on transactional and transformational leadership.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Avolio, B., Waldman, D., & Yammarino, F. (1991). Leading in the 1990’s:
The four I’s of transformational leadership. Journal of European Industrial
Training, 15 (4), 9-16.
Bass, B. M. (1960). Leadership, psychology, and organizational behavior.
New York, NY: Harper.
Bass, B. M. (1985a). Leadership and performance beyond expectations.
New York, NY: The Free Press.
Bass, B. M. (1985b). Leadership: Good, better, best. Organizational
Dynamics, 13, 26-40.
Bass, B. M. (1990a). Bass and Stogdill’s handbook of leadership: Theory,
research, & managerial applications. (3rd ed.). New York: The Free Press.
Bass, B. M. (1990b). From transactional to transformational leadership:
Learning to share the vision. Organizational Dynamics, 18, 19-31.
Bass, B. M. (1998). Transformational leadership: Industrial, military, and
educational impact. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Bass, B. M. (2000). The future of leadership in learning organizations.
Journal of Leadership Studies, 7, 18-40.
Bass, B. M., & Avolio, B. J. (1990). Multifactor leadership questionnaire.
Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologist Press.
24
Bass, B. M., & Avolio, B. J. (1994). Introduction. In B. M. Bass, & B. J.
Avolio (Eds.) Improving organizational effectiveness through transformational
leadership. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Behling, O., & McFillen, J. M. (1996). A syncretical model of
charismatic/transformational leadership. Group & Organizational Management, 2,
163-191.
Bennis, W., & Nanus, B. (1985). Leaders: Strategies for taking charge.
New York: HarperCollins.
Blake, R. R., & Mouton, J. S. (1964). The managerial grid, Houston, TX:
Gulf Publishing.
Braham, J. (1999). The spiritual side. Industry Week, 48-56.
Burns, J. M. (1978). Leadership. New York: Harper & Row, Publishers.
Burns, J. M. (1998). Transactional and transforming leadership. In G. R.
Hickman (Ed.), Leading Organizations. (pp. 133-134). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Publications.
Cialdini, R. B. (2001). Influence: Science and practice. Needham Heights,
MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Clements, C., & Washbush, J. B. (1999). The two faces of leadership:
Considering the dark side of leader-follower dynamics. Journal of Workplace
Learning, 4 (3), 146-148.
Conger, J. A. (1990). The dark side of leadership. Organizational
Dynamics, 19 (2), 44-55.
25
Contee-Borders, A. Karmalita (2002). A case study defining servant
leadership in the workplace. Digital dissertations, 3069348.
Daft, R.L. (2002). The leadership experience. Mason, Ohio: SouthWestern.
Etzioni, A. (1961). A comparative analysis of complex organizations. New
York, NY: Free Press.
Farling, M. L., Stone, A. G., & Winston, B. E. (1999). Servant leadership:
Setting the stage for empirical research. The Journal of Leadership Studies, 6,
49-72.
Giampetro-Meyer, A., Brown, T., Browne, S. J., & Kubasek, N. (1998). Do
we really want more leaders in business? Journal of Business Ethics, 17, 17271736.
Greenleaf, R. K. (1969). Leadership and the individual: The Dartmouth
lectures. In D. M. Frick & L. C. Spears (Eds.). (1996), On becoming a servant
leader (pp. 284-338). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Greenleaf, R. K. (1977). Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of
legitimate power and greatness. New York: Paulist Press.
Harvey, M. (2001). The hidden force: A critique of normative approaches
to business leadership. SAM Advanced Management Journal, 66, 36-48.
Horsman, J. H. (2001). Perspectives of servant leadership and spirit in
organizations. Dissertation Abstracts Online, 8936785.
Hunt, J. G. (1991). Leadership: A new synthesis. Newbury Park, CA: Sage
Publications.
26
Jung, D. I., & Avolio, B. J. (2000). Opening the black box: An experimental
investigation of the mediating effects of trust and value congruence on
transformational and transactional leadership. Journal of Organizational
Behavior, 21, 949-964.
Kets de Vries, M. F. R. (1989). Prisoners of Leadership. New York, NY:
Wiley & Sons.
Kets de Vries, M. F. R. (1993). Leaders, Fools and Imposters: Essays on
the Psychology of Leadership. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Kirkpatrick S., & Locke, E. (1996). Direct and indirect effects of three core
charismatic leadership components on performance and attitudes. Journal of
Applied Psychology, 81, 36-51.
Laub, J. A. (1999). Assessing the servant organization: Development of
the servant organizational leadership assessment (SOLA) instrument.
Dissertations Abstracts Online, 9921922.
Likert, R. (1961). New patterns of management. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Likert, R. (1967). The human organization: Its management and value.
New York: McGraw-Hill.
Lubin, K. A. (2001). Visionary leader behaviors and their congruency with
servant leadership characteristics. Dissertation Abstracts Online, 3022943.
McKenna, D. L. (1989). Power to follow grace to lead: Strategy for the
future of Christian leadership. Dallas, TX: Word Publishing.
27
McMinn, T.F. (2001). The conceptualization and perception of biblical
servant leadership in the southern Baptist convention. Digital dissertations,
3007038.
Podsakoff, P. M., MacKenzie, S., & Bommer, W. H. (1996).
Transformational leader behaviors and substitutes for leadership as determinants
of employee satisfaction, commitment, trust, and organizational citizenship
behaviors. Journal of Management, 22, 259-298.
Pollard, C. W. (1996). The soul of the firm. Grand Rapids, MI:
HarperBusiness and Zondervan Publishing House.
Russell, R. F. (2000). Exploring the values and attributes of servant
leaders. Doctoral dissertation, 5359435.
Russell, R. F. (2001). The role of values in servant leadership. Leadership
& Organization Development Journal, 22 (2), 76-83.
Russell, R. F., & Stone, A. G. (2002). A review of servant leadership
attributes: Developing a practical model. Leadership and Organization
Development Journal, 23, 145-157.
Shamir, B. (1995). Social distance and charisma: Theoretical notes and an
exploratory study. Leadership Quarterly, 6, 19-47.
Spears, L. (1995). Servant-leadership and the Greenleaf legacy. In L.
Spears (Ed.), Reflections on leadership: How Robert K. Greenleaf’s theory of
servant-leadership influenced today’s top management thinkers (pp. 1-14). New
York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
28
Spears, L. (1996). Reflections on Robert K. Greenleaf and servantleadership. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 17, 33-35.
Stogdill, R. M., & Coons, A. E. (Eds.). (1957). Leader behavior: Its
description and measurement. Columbus, OH: The Ohio State University Bureau
of Business Research, 1957.
Tice, L. (1996). Traits of limitless leaders. Association Management, 48,
16.
Tichy, N. M., & Devanna, M. A. (1986). The transformational leader: The
key to global competitiveness. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Tracey, J. B., & Hinkin, T. R. (1998). Transformational leadership or
effective managerial practices? Group & Organization Management, 23, 220236.
Williams, L. E. (1998). Servants of the people: The 1960’s legacy of
African American leadership. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
Yukl, G. (1998). Leadership in organizations (4th ed.). Upper Saddle River,
NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
Yukl, G. (2002). Leadership in organizations. (5th ed.). Upper Saddle
River, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.

Purchase answer to see full
attachment

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool’s honor code & terms of service.

Get 20% Discount on This Paper
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Try it now!

Get 20% Discount on This Paper

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Ace Writing Center has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.

Essays

Essay Writing Services

At Ace Writing Center, Nowadays, students normally have extremely busy schedules. You will note that some of them have to take on some evening or weekend jobs in order to get some income that can help them to sustain in college or in the university. This can deny them a chance to write all the essays given. Others usually get bombarded with a lot of work by their lecturers. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. However, some of them usually try to work on all these essays but end up delivering their work late. This can prevent them from graduating since most lecturers are strict on deadlines. If you want to write a business essay, the wise way is to hire an outstanding essay writing service like us, so that you can get the best results. If you are keen, you will note that many companies usually overcharge their customers. Some of them are there only to make money. And in reality, they really don’t care to build a long term commitment with students. You should not choose such companies. You should take your time and choose a reliable company to work with. Ace Writing Center is the ultimate solution for you. We have been offering our writing service for more than 7 years. This is a clear indication that you will get quality essay writing service. We have a wide range of writers who can work on any business essay that you might have. We believe in doing extensive research so that we can provide quality work to all our clients. .

Admissions

Admission and Business Papers

Have you ever had to write an admission essay for college? The majority of students face the same issues when applying to a university or college and many in such situations decide they need professional help to cope with this matter. They get in a situation when the deadline keeps coming closer but lack motivation to start because they are just not sure if their writing skills are strong enough. We have a solution for you! Ace Writing Center is the best admission essay writing service with a large professional team and years of experience in providing high-quality papers to students of all levels and faculties. The mission of our team is to help students make their dreams of entering a good college come true and that’s what we offer!.

Editing

Editing and Proofreading

Sometimes all the words for your paper just flow out of your mind and into your fingers. You type quickly at your keyboard and there they are, your beautiful words right there on the screen. But you have no idea how to polish it up. You may be wishing there was a paper writing service that offered this type of writing service. Look no more! Here at Ace Writing Center, we offer you an editing and proofreading option that you can't find anywhere else..

Coursework

College Essay Writing

In case you are familiar Ace Writing Center, you know the way to distinguish a better company from a cheap one exactly. First of all, poor service website does not have a sufficient support. We think support team is an essential part of success; it has to answer all clients’ questions and be a connecting link between clients and their writers. On our web-service you will get answers about anything you need and your writer will receive all your instructions, assignments and requirements exactly and swiftly. A writing service that we run has got a flexible pricing system that will save you from senseless wastes and many bonus systems that let you sparing money for something important for you.