SJSU Hierarchy and Job Titles Have No Meaning in Creative Inspiration Chapter Summary

Description

https://www.theinvestorspodcast.com/billionaire-bo… click this link you can find the summary for each chapter

Summarize the assigned chapters in sufficient details. You need to cover main themes, arguments, and stories in each of the assigned chapters. (The suggested length for this section is about one and a half single-spaced pages.)

Personal reflections. What are the major insights that you get from reading the chapters? Which stories in the chapters do you like the most? How are they related to your personal experiences? (The suggested length of this section is about half a page up to one single-spaced page.)

Theory and Concept applications. Which theories and concepts that we have learned in this class can be applied to explain the experience of the author and his firm? 

Unformatted Attachment Preview

C R E AT I V I T Y, I N C .
O V E R C O M I N G T H E U N S E E N F O R C E S T H AT
S T A N D I N T H E W AY O F T R U E I N S P I R A T I O N
ED CATMULL
with Amy Wallace
d
RANDOM HOUSE
NEW YORK
Copyright © 2014 by Edwin Catmull
All rights reserved.
Published in the United States by Random House,
an imprint and division of Random House LLC,
a Penguin Random House Company, New York.
Random House and the House colophon are registered
trademarks of Random House LLC.
library of congress cataloging-in-publication data
Catmull, Edwin E.
Creativity, Inc. : overcoming the unseen forces that stand in the way of
true inspiration / Ed Catmull with Amy Wallace.
pages cm
ISBN 978-0-8129-9301-1
eBook ISBN 978-0-679-64450-7
1. Creative ability in business. 2. Corporate culture. 3. Organizational
effectiveness. 4. Pixar (Firm) I. Wallace, Amy. II. Title.
HD53.C394 2014
658.4’0714—dc23 2013036026
Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
www.atrandom.com
246897531
first edition
Book design by Diane Hobbing
INTRODUCTION: LOST AND FOUND
Every morning, as I walk into Pixar Animation Studios—past the
twenty-foot-high sculpture of Luxo Jr., our friendly desk lamp
mascot, through the double doors and into a spectacular glassceilinged atrium where a man-sized Buzz Lightyear and Woody,
made entirely of Lego bricks, stand at attention, up the stairs past
sketches and paintings of the characters that have populated our
fourteen films—I am struck by the unique culture that defines this
place. Although I’ve made this walk thousands of times, it never
gets old.
Built on the site of a former cannery, Pixar’s fifteen-acre campus, just over the Bay Bridge from San Francisco, was designed,
inside and out, by Steve Jobs. (Its name, in fact, is The Steve Jobs
Building.) It has well-thought-out patterns of entry and egress that
encourage people to mingle, meet, and communicate. Outside,
there is a soccer field, a volleyball court, a swimming pool, and a
six-hundred-seat amphitheater. Sometimes visitors misunderstand
the place, thinking it’s fancy for fancy’s sake. What they miss is
that the unifying idea for this building isn’t luxury but community.
Steve wanted the building to support our work by enhancing our
ability to collaborate.
x
|
INTRODUCTION: LOST AND FOUND
The animators who work here are free to—no, encouraged
to—decorate their work spaces in whatever style they wish. They
spend their days inside pink dollhouses whose ceilings are hung
with miniature chandeliers, tiki huts made of real bamboo, and
castles whose meticulously painted, fifteen-foot-high styrofoam
turrets appear to be carved from stone. Annual company traditions
include “Pixarpalooza,” where our in-house rock bands battle for
dominance, shredding their hearts out on stages we erect on our
front lawn.
The point is, we value self-expression here. This tends to make
a big impression on visitors, who often tell me that the experience
of walking into Pixar leaves them feeling a little wistful, like something is missing in their work lives—a palpable energy, a feeling of
collaboration and unfettered creativity, a sense, not to be corny, of
possibility. I respond by telling them that the feeling they are picking up on—call it exuberance or irreverence, even whimsy—is integral to our success.
But it’s not what makes Pixar special.
What makes Pixar special is that we acknowledge we will always have problems, many of them hidden from our view; that we
work hard to uncover these problems, even if doing so means making ourselves uncomfortable; and that, when we come across a
problem, we marshal all of our energies to solve it. This, more than
any elaborate party or turreted workstation, is why I love coming
to work in the morning. It is what motivates me and gives me a
definite sense of mission.
There was a time, however, when my purpose here felt a lot less
clear to me. And it might surprise you when I tell you when.
On November 22, 1995, Toy Story debuted in America’s theaters
and became the largest Thanksgiving opening in history. Critics
heralded it as “inventive” (Time), “brilliant” and “exultantly witty”
(The New York Times), and “visionary” (Chicago Sun-Times). To
INTRODUCTION: LOST AND FOUND
|
xi
find a movie worthy of comparison, wrote The Washington Post,
one had to go back to 1939, to The Wizard of Oz.
The making of Toy Story—the first feature film to be animated
entirely on a computer—had required every ounce of our tenacity,
artistry, technical wizardry, and endurance. The hundred or so men
and women who produced it had weathered countless ups and
downs as well as the ever-present, hair-raising knowledge that our
survival depended on this 80-minute experiment. For five straight
years, we’d fought to do Toy Story our way. We’d resisted the advice
of Disney executives who believed that since they’d had such success with musicals, we too should fill our movie with songs. We’d
rebooted the story completely, more than once, to make sure it rang
true. We’d worked nights, weekends, and holidays—mostly without complaint. Despite being novice filmmakers at a fledgling studio in dire financial straits, we had put our faith in a simple idea: If
we made something that we wanted to see, others would want to
see it, too. For so long, it felt like we had been pushing that rock up
the hill, trying to do the impossible. There were plenty of moments
when the future of Pixar was in doubt. Now, we were suddenly
being held up as an example of what could happen when artists
trusted their guts.
Toy Story went on to become the top-grossing film of the year
and would earn $358 million worldwide. But it wasn’t just the numbers that made us proud; money, after all, is just one measure of a
thriving company and usually not the most meaningful one. No,
what I found gratifying was what we’d created. Review after review
focused on the film’s moving plotline and its rich, three-dimensional
characters—only briefly mentioning, almost as an aside, that it had
been made on a computer. While there was much innovation that
enabled our work, we had not let the technology overwhelm our
real purpose: making a great film.
On a personal level, Toy Story represented the fulfillment of a
goal I had pursued for more than two decades and had dreamed
about since I was a boy. Growing up in the 1950s, I had yearned to
xii
|
INTRODUCTION: LOST AND FOUND
be a Disney animator but had no idea how to go about it. Instinctively, I realize now, I embraced computer graphics—then a new
field—as a means of pursuing that dream. If I couldn’t animate by
hand, there had to be another way. In graduate school, I’d quietly
set a goal of making the first computer-animated feature film, and
I’d worked tirelessly for twenty years to accomplish it.
Now, the goal that had been a driving force in my life had been
reached, and there was an enormous sense of relief and exhilaration—at least at first. In the wake of Toy Story’s release, we took
the company public, raising the kind of money that would ensure
our future as an independent production house, and began work
on two new feature-length projects, A Bug’s Life and Toy Story 2.
Everything was going our way, and yet I felt adrift. In fulfilling a
goal, I had lost some essential framework. Is this really what I want
to do? I began asking myself. The doubts surprised and confused
me, and I kept them to myself. I had served as Pixar’s president for
most of the company’s existence. I loved the place and everything
that it stood for. Still, I couldn’t deny that achieving the goal that
had defined my professional life had left me without one. Is this all
there is? I wondered. Is it time for a new challenge?
It wasn’t that I thought Pixar had “arrived” or that my work
was done. I knew there were major obstacles in front of us. The
company was growing quickly, with lots of shareholders to please,
and we were racing to put two new films into production. There
was, in short, plenty to occupy my working hours. But my internal
sense of purpose—the thing that had led me to sleep on the floor of
the computer lab in graduate school just to get more hours on the
mainframe, that kept me awake at night, as a kid, solving puzzles
in my head, that fueled my every workday—had gone missing. I’d
spent two decades building a train and laying its track. Now, the
thought of merely driving it struck me as a far less interesting task.
Was making one film after another enough to engage me? I wondered. What would be my organizing principle now?
It would take a full year for the answer to emerge.
INTRODUCTION: LOST AND FOUND
|
xiii
From the start, my professional life seemed destined to have one
foot in Silicon Valley and the other in Hollywood. I first got into
the film business in 1979 when, flush from the success of Star Wars,
George Lucas hired me to help him bring high technology into the
film industry. But he wasn’t based in Los Angeles. Instead, he’d
founded his company, Lucasfilm, at the north end of the San Francisco Bay. Our offices were located in San Rafael, about an hour’s
drive from Palo Alto, the heart of Silicon Valley—a moniker that
was just gaining traction then, as the semiconductor and computer industries took off. That proximity gave me a front-row
seat from which to observe the many emerging hardware and software companies—not to mention the growing venture capital
industry—that, in the course of a few years, would come to dominate Silicon Valley from its perch on Sand Hill Road.
I couldn’t have arrived at a more dynamic and volatile time. I
watched as many startups burned bright with success—and then
flamed out. My mandate at Lucasfilm—to merge moviemaking
with technology—meant that I rubbed shoulders with the leaders
of places like Sun Microsystems and Silicon Graphics and Cray
Computer, several of whom I came to know well. I was first and
foremost a scientist then, not a manager, so I watched these guys
closely, hoping to learn from the trajectories their companies followed. Gradually, a pattern began to emerge: Someone had a creative idea, obtained funding, brought on a lot of smart people, and
developed and sold a product that got a boatload of attention. That
initial success begat more success, luring the best engineers and attracting customers who had interesting and high-profile problems
to solve. As these companies grew, much was written about their
paradigm-shifting approaches, and when their CEOs inevitably
landed on the cover of Fortune magazine, they were heralded as
“Titans of the New.” I especially remember the confidence. The
leaders of these companies radiated supreme confidence. Surely,
they could only have reached this apex by being very, very good.
xiv
|
INTRODUCTION: LOST AND FOUND
But then those companies did something stupid—not just
stupid-in-retrospect, but obvious-at-the-time stupid. I wanted to
understand why. What was causing smart people to make decisions
that sent their companies off the rails? I didn’t doubt that they believed they were doing the right thing, but something was blinding
them—and keeping them from seeing the problems that threatened
to upend them. As a result, their companies expanded like bubbles,
then burst. What interested me was not that companies rose and
fell or that the landscape continually shifted as technology changed
but that the leaders of these companies seemed so focused on the
competition that they never developed any deep introspection
about other destructive forces that were at work.
Over the years, as Pixar struggled to find its way—first selling
hardware, then software, then making animated short films and
advertisements—I asked myself: If Pixar is ever successful, will we
do something stupid, too? Can paying careful attention to the missteps of others help us be more alert to our own? Or is there something about becoming a leader that makes you blind to the things
that threaten the well-being of your enterprise? Clearly, something
was causing a dangerous disconnect at many smart, creative companies. What, exactly, was a mystery—and one I was determined to
figure out.
In the difficult year after Toy Story’s debut, I came to realize
that trying to solve this mystery would be my next challenge. My
desire to protect Pixar from the forces that ruin so many businesses
gave me renewed focus. I began to see my role as a leader more
clearly. I would devote myself to learning how to build not just a
successful company but a sustainable creative culture. As I turned
my attention from solving technical problems to engaging with the
philosophy of sound management, I was excited once again—and
sure that our second act could be as exhilarating as our first.
INTRODUCTION: LOST AND FOUND
|
xv
It has always been my goal to create a culture at Pixar that will
outlast its founding leaders—Steve, John Lasseter, and me. But it is
also my goal to share our underlying philosophies with other leaders and, frankly, with anyone who wrestles with the competing—
but necessarily complementary—forces of art and commerce. What
you’re holding in your hands, then, is an attempt to put down on
paper my best ideas about how we built the culture that is the bedrock of this place.
This book isn’t just for Pixar people, entertainment executives,
or animators. It is for anyone who wants to work in an environment that fosters creativity and problem solving. My belief is that
good leadership can help creative people stay on the path to excellence no matter what business they’re in. My aim at Pixar—and at
Disney Animation, which my longtime partner John Lasseter and I
have also led since the Walt Disney Company acquired Pixar in
2006—has been to enable our people to do their best work. We
start from the presumption that our people are talented and want
to contribute. We accept that, without meaning to, our company is
stifling that talent in myriad unseen ways. Finally, we try to identify
those impediments and fix them.
I’ve spent nearly forty years thinking about how to help smart,
ambitious people work effectively with one another. The way I see
it, my job as a manager is to create a fertile environment, keep it
healthy, and watch for the things that undermine it. I believe, to my
core, that everybody has the potential to be creative—whatever
form that creativity takes—and that to encourage such development is a noble thing. More interesting to me, though, are the
blocks that get in the way, often without us noticing, and hinder the
creativity that resides within any thriving company.
The thesis of this book is that there are many blocks to creativity, but there are active steps we can take to protect the creative
process. In the coming pages, I will discuss many of the steps we
follow at Pixar, but the most compelling mechanisms to me are
xvi
|
INTRODUCTION: LOST AND FOUND
those that deal with uncertainty, instability, lack of candor, and the
things we cannot see. I believe the best managers acknowledge and
make room for what they do not know—not just because humility
is a virtue but because until one adopts that mindset, the most
striking breakthroughs cannot occur. I believe that managers must
loosen the controls, not tighten them. They must accept risk; they
must trust the people they work with and strive to clear the path for
them; and always, they must pay attention to and engage with anything that creates fear. Moreover, successful leaders embrace the
reality that their models may be wrong or incomplete. Only when
we admit what we don’t know can we ever hope to learn it.
This book is organized into four sections—Getting Started,
Protecting the New, Building and Sustaining, and Testing What We
Know. It is no memoir, but in order to understand the mistakes we
made, the lessons we learned, and the ways we learned from them,
it necessarily delves at times into my own history and that of Pixar.
I have much to say about enabling groups to create something
meaningful together and then protecting them from the destructive
forces that loom even in the strongest companies. My hope is that
by relating my search for the sources of confusion and delusion
within Pixar and Disney Animation, I can help others avoid the
pitfalls that impede and sometimes ruin businesses of all kinds.
The key for me—what has kept me motivated in the nineteen years
since Toy Story debuted—has been the realization that identifying
these destructive forces isn’t merely a philosophical exercise. It is a
crucial, central mission. In the wake of our earliest success, Pixar
needed its leaders to sit up and pay attention. And that need for
vigilance never goes away. This book, then, is about the ongoing
work of paying attention—of leading by being self-aware, as managers and as companies. It is an expression of the ideas that I believe make the best in us possible.
PART I
GETTING STARTED
CHAPTER 1
ANIMATED
For thirteen years we had a table in the large conference room at
Pixar that we call West One. Though it was beautiful, I grew to
hate this table. It was long and skinny, like one of those things
you’d see in a comedy sketch about an old wealthy couple that sits
down for dinner—one person at either end, a candelabra in the
middle—and has to shout to make conversation. The table had
been chosen by a designer Steve Jobs liked, and it was elegant, all
right—but it impeded our work.
We’d hold regular meetings about our movies around that
table—thirty of us facing off in two long lines, often with more
people seated along the walls—and everyone was so spread out
that it was difficult to communicate. For those unlucky enough to
be seated at the far ends, ideas didn’t flow because it was nearly
impossible to make eye contact without craning your neck. Moreover, because it was important that the director and producer of
the film in question be able to hear what everyone was saying, they
had to be placed at the center of the table. So did Pixar’s creative
4
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
leaders: John Lasseter, Pixar’s creative officer, and me, and a handful of our most experienced directors, producers, and writers. To
ensure that these people were always seated together, someone
began making place cards. We might as well have been at a formal
dinner party.
When it comes to creative inspiration, job titles and hierarchy
are meaningless. That’s what I believe. But unwittingly, we were allowing this table—and the resulting place card ritual—to send a
different message. The closer you were seated to the middle of the
table, it implied, the more important—the more central—you must
be. And the farther away, the less likely you were to speak up—your
distance from the heart of the conversation made participating feel
intrusive. If the table was crowded, as it often was, still more people
would sit in chairs around the edges of the room, creating yet a
third tier of participants (those at the center of the table, those at
the ends, and those not at the table at all). Without intending to,
we’d created an obstacle that discouraged people from jumping in.
Over the course of a decade, we held countless meetings around
this table in this way—completely unaware of how doing so undermined our own core principles. Why were we blind to this? Because
the seating arrangements and place cards were designed for the
convenience of the leaders, including me. Sincerely believing that
we were in an inclusive meeting, we saw nothing amiss because we
didn’t feel excluded. Those not sitting at the center of the table,
meanwhile, saw quite clearly how it established a pecking order but
presumed that we—the leaders—had intended that outcome. Who
were they, then, to complain?
It wasn’t until we happened to have a meeting in a smaller room
with a square table that John and I realized what was wrong. Sitting around that table, the interplay was better, the exchange of
ideas more free-flowing, the eye contact automatic. Every person
there, no matter their job title, felt free to speak up. This was not
only what we wanted, it was a fundamental Pixar belief: Unhindered communication was key, no matter what your position. At
A N I M AT E D
|
5
our long, skinny table, comfortable in our middle seats, we had
utterly failed to recognize that we were behaving contrary to that
basic tenet. Over time, we’d fallen into a trap. Even though we were
conscious that a room’s dynamics are critical to any good discussion, even though we believed that we were constantly on the lookout for problems, our vantage point blinded us to what was right
before our eyes.
Emboldened by this new insight, I went to our facilities department. “Please,” I said, “I don’t care how you do it, but get that table
out of there.” I wanted something that could be arranged into a
more intimate square, so people could address each other directly
and not feel like they didn’t matter. A few days later, as a critical
meeting on an upcoming movie approached, our new table was installed, solving the problem.
Still, interestingly, there were remnants of that problem that
did not immediately vanish just because we’d solved it. For example, the next time I walked into West One, I saw the brand-new
table, arranged—as requested—in a more intimate square that
made it possible for more people to interact at once. But the table
was adorned with the same old place cards! While we’d fixed the
key problem that had made place cards seem necessary, the cards
themselves had become a tradition that would continue until we
specifically dismantled it. This wasn’t as troubling an issue as the
table itself, but it was something we had to address because cards
implied hierarchy, and that was precisely what we were trying to
avoid. When Andrew Stanton, one of our directors, entered the
meeting room that morning, he grabbed several place cards and
began randomly moving them around, narrating as he went. “We
don’t need these anymore!” he said in a way that everyone in the
room grasped. Only then did we succeed in eliminating this ancillary problem.
This is the nature of management. Decisions are made, usually
for good reasons, which in turn prompt other decisions. So when
problems arise—and they always do—disentangling them is not as
6
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
simple as correcting the original error. Often, finding a solution is
a multi-step endeavor. There is the problem you know you are trying to solve—think of that as an oak tree—and then there are all
the other problems—think of these as saplings—that sprouted
from the acorns that fell around it. And these problems remain
after you cut the oak tree down.
Even after all these years, I’m often surprised to find problems
that have existed right in front of me, in plain sight. For me, the key
to solving these problems is finding ways to see what’s working and
what isn’t, which sounds a lot simpler than it is. Pixar today is managed according to this principle, but in a way I’ve been searching all
my life for better ways of seeing. It began decades before Pixar even
existed.
When I was a kid, I used to plunk myself down on the living room
floor of my family’s modest Salt Lake City home a few minutes
before 7 p.m. every Sunday and wait for Walt Disney. Specifically, I’d
wait for him to appear on our black-and-white RCA with its tiny
12-inch screen. Even from a dozen feet away—the accepted wisdom
at the time was that viewers should put one foot between them and
the TV for every inch of screen—I was transfixed by what I saw.
Each week, Walt Disney himself opened the broadcast of The
Wonderful World of Disney. Standing before me in suit and tie, like
a kindly neighbor, he would demystify the Disney magic. He’d explain the use of synchronized sound in Steamboat Willie or talk
about the importance of music in Fantasia. He always went out of
his way to give credit to his forebears, the men—and, at this point,
they were all men—who’d done the pioneering work upon which
he was building his empire. He’d introduce the television audience
to trailblazers such as Max Fleischer, of Koko the Clown and Betty
Boop fame, and Winsor McCay, who made Gertie the Dinosaur—
the first animated film to feature a character that expressed
emotion—in 1914. He’d gather a group of his animators, colorists,
A N I M AT E D
|
7
and storyboard artists to explain how they made Mickey Mouse
and Donald Duck come to life. Each week, Disney created a madeup world, used cutting-edge technology to enable it, and then told
us how he’d done it.
Walt Disney was one of my two boyhood idols. The other was
Albert Einstein. To me, even at a young age, they represented the
two poles of creativity. Disney was all about inventing the new. He
brought things into being—both artistically and technologically—
that did not exist before. Einstein, by contrast, was a master of
explaining that which already was. I read every Einstein biography
I could get my hands on as well as a little book he wrote on his
theory of relativity. I loved how the concepts he developed forced
people to change their approach to physics and matter, to view the
universe from a different perspective. Wild-haired and iconic, Einstein dared to bend the implications of what we thought we knew.
He solved the biggest puzzles of all and, in doing so, changed our
understanding of reality.
Both Einstein and Disney inspired me, but Disney affected me
more because of his weekly visits to my family’s living room.
“When you wish upon a star, makes no difference who you are,” his
TV show’s theme song would announce as a baritone-voiced narrator promised: “Each week, as you enter this timeless land, one of
these many worlds will open to you . . . .” Then the narrator would
tick them off: Frontierland (“tall tales and true from the legendary
past”), Tomorrowland (“the promise of things to come”), Adventureland (“the wonder world of nature’s own realm”), and Fantasyland (“the happiest kingdom of them all”). I loved the idea that
animation could take me places I’d never been. But the land I most
wanted to learn about was the one occupied by the innovators at
Disney who made these animated films.
Between 1950 and 1955, Disney made three movies we consider
classics today: Cinderella, Peter Pan, and Lady and the Tramp.
More than half a century later, we all remember the glass slipper,
the Island of Lost Boys, and that scene where the cocker spaniel
8
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
and the mutt slurp spaghetti. But few grasp how technically sophisticated these movies were. Disney’s animators were at the forefront
of applied technology; instead of merely using existing methods,
they were inventing ones of their own. They had to develop the
tools to perfect sound and color, to use blue screen matting and
multi-plane cameras and xerography. Every time some technological breakthrough occurred, Walt Disney incorporated it and then
talked about it on his show in a way that highlighted the relationship between technology and art. I was too young to realize such a
synergy was groundbreaking. To me, it just made sense that they
belonged together.
Watching Disney one Sunday evening in April of 1956, I experienced something that would define my professional life. What
exactly it was is difficult to describe except to say that I felt something fall into place inside my head. That night’s episode was called
“Where Do the Stories Come From?” and Disney kicked it off by
praising his animators’ knack for turning everyday occurrences
into cartoons. That night, though, it wasn’t Disney’s explanation
that pulled me in but what was happening on the screen as he
spoke. An artist was drawing Donald Duck, giving him a jaunty
costume and a bouquet of flowers and a box of candy with which
to woo Daisy. Then, as the artist’s pencil moved around the page,
Donald came to life, putting up his dukes to square off with the
pencil lead, then raising his chin to allow the artist to give him a
bow tie.
The definition of superb animation is that each character on
the screen makes you believe it is a thinking being. Whether it’s a
T-Rex or a slinky dog or a desk lamp, if viewers sense not just
movement but intention—or, put another way, emotion—then the
animator has done his or her job. It’s not just lines on paper anymore; it’s a living, feeling entity. This is what I experienced that
night, for the first time, as I watched Donald leap off the page. The
transformation from a static line drawing to a fully dimensional,
animated image was sleight of hand, nothing more, but the mys-
A N I M AT E D
|
9
tery of how it was done—not just the technical process but the way
the art was imbued with such emotion—was the most interesting
problem I’d ever considered. I wanted to climb through the TV
screen and be part of this world.
The mid-1950s and early 1960s were, of course, a time of great
prosperity and industry in the United States. Growing up in Utah in
a tight-knit Mormon community, my four younger brothers and
sisters and I felt that anything was possible. Because the adults we
knew had all lived through the Depression, World War II, and then
the Korean War, this period felt to them like the calm after a thunderstorm.
I remember the optimistic energy—an eagerness to move forward that was enabled and supported by a wealth of emerging
technologies. It was boom time in America, with manufacturing
and home construction at an all-time high. Banks were offering
loans and credit, which meant more and more people could own a
new TV, house, or Cadillac. There were amazing new appliances
like disposals that ate your garbage and machines that washed your
dishes, although I certainly did my share of cleaning them by hand.
The first organ transplants were performed in 1954; the first polio
vaccine came a year later; in 1956, the term artificial intelligence
entered the lexicon. The future, it seemed, was already here.
Then, when I was twelve, the Soviets launched the first artificial
satellite—Sputnik 1—into earth’s orbit. This was huge news, not
just in the scientific and political realms but in my sixth grade classroom at school, where the morning routine was interrupted by a
visit from the principal, whose grim expression told us that our
lives had changed forever. Since we’d been taught that the Communists were the enemy and that nuclear war could be waged at the
touch of a button, the fact that they’d beaten us into space seemed
pretty scary—proof that they had the upper hand.
The United States government’s response to being bested was
10
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
to create something called ARPA, or the Advanced Research Projects Agency. Though it was housed within the Defense Department, its mission was ostensibly peaceful: to support scientific
researchers in America’s universities in the hopes of preventing
what it termed “technological surprise.” By sponsoring our best
minds, the architects of ARPA believed, we’d come up with better
answers. Looking back, I still admire that enlightened reaction to a
serious threat: We’ll just have to get smarter. ARPA would have a
profound effect on America, leading directly to the computer revolution and the Internet, among countless other innovations. There
was a sense that big things were happening in America, with much
more to come. Life was full of possibility.
Still, while my family was middle-class, our outlook was shaped
by my father’s upbringing. Not that he talked about it much. Earl
Catmull, the son of an Idaho dirt farmer, was one of fourteen kids,
five of whom had died as infants. His mother, raised by Mormon
pioneers who made a meager living panning for gold in the Snake
River in Idaho, didn’t attend school until she was eleven. My father was the first in his family ever to go to college, paying his own
way by working several jobs. During my childhood, he taught
math during the school year and built houses during the summers.
He built our house from the ground up. While he never explicitly
said that education was paramount, my siblings and I all knew we
were expected to study hard and go to college.
I was a quiet, focused student in high school. An art teacher
once told my parents I would often become so lost in my work that
I wouldn’t hear the bell ring at the end of class; I’d be sitting there,
at my desk, staring at an object—a vase, say, or a chair. Something
about the act of committing that object to paper was completely
engrossing—the way it necessitated seeing only what was there and
shutting out the distraction of my ideas about chairs or vases and
what they were supposed to look like. At home, I sent away for Jon
Gnagy’s Learn to Draw art kits—which were advertised in the
back of comic books—and the 1948 classic Animation, written and
A N I M AT E D
|
11
drawn by Preston Blair, the animator of the dancing hippos in Disney’s Fantasia. I bought a platen—the flat metal plate artists use to
press paper against ink—and even built a plywood animation stand
with a light under it. I made flipbooks—one was of a man whose
legs turned into a unicycle—while nursing my first crush, Tinker
Bell, who had won my heart in Peter Pan.
Nevertheless, it soon became clear to me that I would never be
talented enough to join Disney Animation’s vaunted ranks. What’s
more, I had no idea how one actually became an animator. There
was no school for it that I knew of. As I finished high school, I realized I had a far better understanding of how one became a scientist. The route seemed easier to discern. Throughout my life, people
have always smiled when I told them I switched from art to physics
because it seems, to them, like such an incongruous leap. But my
decision to pursue physics, and not art, would lead me, indirectly,
to my true calling.
Four years later, in 1969, I graduated from the University of Utah
with two degrees, one in physics and the other in the emerging field
of computer science. Applying to graduate school, my intention
was to learn how to design computer languages. But soon after I
matriculated, also at the U of U, I met a man who would encourage
me to change course: one of the pioneers of interactive computer
graphics, Ivan Sutherland.
The field of computer graphics—in essence, the making of digital pictures out of numbers, or data, that can be manipulated by a
machine—was in its infancy then, but Professor Sutherland was
already a legend. Early in his career, he had devised something
called Sketchpad, an ingenious computer program that allowed figures to be drawn, copied, moved, rotated, or resized, all while retaining their basic properties. In 1968, he’d co-created what is
widely believed to be the first virtual reality head-mounted display
system. (The device was named The Sword of Damocles, after the
12
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
Greek myth, because it was so heavy that in order to be worn by the
person using it, it had to be suspended from a mechanical arm
bolted to the ceiling.) Sutherland and Dave Evans, who was chair
of the university’s computer science department, were magnets for
bright students with diverse interests, and they led us with a light
touch. Basically, they welcomed us to the program, gave us workspace and access to computers, and then let us pursue whatever
turned us on. The result was a collaborative, supportive community so inspiring that I would later seek to replicate it at Pixar.
One of my classmates, Jim Clark, would go on to found Silicon
Graphics and Netscape. Another, John Warnock, would co-found
Adobe, known for Photoshop and the PDF file format, among
other things. Still another, Alan Kay, would lead on a number of
fronts, from object-oriented programming to “windowing” graphical user interfaces. In many respects, my fellow students were the
most inspirational part of my university experience; this collegial,
collaborative atmosphere was vital not just to my enjoyment of the
program but also to the quality of the work that I did.
This tension between the individual’s personal creative contribution and the leverage of the group is a dynamic that exists in all
creative environments, but this would be my first taste of it. On one
end of the spectrum, I noticed, we had the genius who seemed to
do amazing work on his or her own; on the other end, we had the
group that excelled precisely because of its multiplicity of views.
How, then, should we balance these two extremes, I wondered. I
didn’t yet have a good mental model that would help me answer
that, but I was developing a fierce desire to find one.
Much of the research being done at the U of U’s computer science department was funded by ARPA. As I’ve said, ARPA had
been created in response to Sputnik, and one of its key organizing
principles was that collaboration could lead to excellence. In fact,
one of ARPA’s proudest achievements was linking universities
with something they called “ARPANET,” which would eventually
evolve into the Internet. The first four nodes on the ARPANET
A N I M AT E D
|
13
were at the Stanford Research Institute, UCLA, UC Santa Barbara,
and the U of U, so I had a ringside seat from which to observe
this grand experiment, and what I saw influenced me profoundly.
ARPA’s mandate—to support smart people in a variety of areas—
was carried out based on the unwavering presumption that researchers would try to do the right thing and, in ARPA’s view,
overmanaging them was counterproductive. ARPA’s administrators did not hover over the shoulders of those of us working on the
projects they funded, nor did they demand that our work have direct military applications. They simply trusted us to innovate.
This kind of trust gave me the freedom to tackle all sorts of
complex problems, and I did so with gusto. Not only did I often
sleep on the floor of the computer rooms to maximize time on the
computer, but so did many of my fellow graduate students. We
were young, driven by the sense that we were inventing the field
from scratch—and that was exciting beyond words. For the first
time, I saw a way to simultaneously create art and develop a technical understanding of how to create a new kind of imagery. Making
pictures with a computer spoke to both sides of my brain. To be
sure, the pictures that could be rendered on a computer were very
crude in 1969, but the act of inventing new algorithms and seeing
better pictures as a result was thrilling to me. In its own way, my
childhood dream was reasserting itself.
At the age of twenty-six, I set a new goal: to develop a way to
animate, not with a pencil but with a computer, and to make the
images compelling and beautiful enough to use in the movies. Perhaps, I thought, I could become an animator after all.
In the spring of 1972, I spent ten weeks making my first short animated film—a digitized model of my left hand. My process combined old and new; again, like everyone in this fast-changing field,
I was helping to invent the language. First I plunged my hand into
a tub of plaster of Paris (forgetting, unfortunately, to coat it in
14
|
CREATIVITY, INC.
Vaseline first, which meant I had to yank out every tiny hair on the
back of my hand to get it free); then, once I had the mold, I filled it
with more plaster to make a model of my hand; then, I took that
model and covered it with 350 tiny interlocking triangles and polygons to create what looked like a net of black lines on its “skin.”
You may not think that a curved surface could be built out of such
flat, angular elements, but when you make them small enough, you
can get pretty close.
I’d chosen this project because I was interested in rendering
complex objects and curved surfaces—and I was looking for a challenge. At that time, computers weren’t great at showing flat objects, let alone curved ones. The mathematics of curved surfaces
was not well developed, and computers had limited memory capability. At the U of U’s computer graphics department, where every
one of us yearned to make computer-generated images look as if
they were photographs of real objects, we had three driving goals:
speed, realism, and the ability to depict curved surfaces. My film
sought to address the latter two.
The human hand doesn’t have a single flat plane. And unlike a
simpler curved surface—a ball, for example—it has many parts
that act in opposition to one another, with a seemingly infinite
ANIMATED
|
15
number of resulting movements. The hand is an incredibly complex “object” to try to capture and translate into arrays of numbers. Given that most computer animation at the time consisted of
rendering simple polygonal objects (cubes, pyramids), I had my
work cut out for me.
Once I had drawn the triangles and polygons on my model, I
measured the coordinates of each of their corners, then entered
that data into a 3D animation program I’d written. That enabled
me to display the many triangles and polygons that made up my
virtual hand on a monitor. In its first incarnation, sharp edges
could be seen at the seams where the polygons joined together. But
later, thanks to “smooth shading”—a technique, developed by another graduate student, that diminished the appearance of those
edges—the hand became more lifelike. The real challenge, though,
was making it move.
16
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
Hand, which debuted at a computer science conference in
1973, caused a bit of a stir because no one had ever seen anything
like it before. In it, my hand, which appears at first to be covered in
a white net of polygons, begins to open and close, as if trying to
make a fist. Then my hand’s surface becomes smoother, more like
the real thing. There is a moment when my hand points directly at
the viewer as if to say, “Yes, I’m talking to you.” Then, the camera
goes inside the hand and takes a look around, aiming its lens inside
the palm and up into each finger, a tricky bit of perspective that I
liked because it could be depicted only via computer. Those four
minutes of film had taken me more than sixty thousand minutes to
complete.
Together with a digitized film that my friend Fred Parke made
of his wife’s face around the same time, Hand represented the
state-of-the-art in computer animation for years after it was made.
Snippets of both Fred’s and my films would be featured in the 1976
movie Futureworld, which—though mostly forgotten by moviegoers today—is still remembered by aficionados as the first full-length
feature to use computer-generated animation.
Professor Sutherland used to say that he loved his graduate students at Utah because we didn’t know what was impossible. Neither, apparently, did he: He was among the first to believe that
Hollywood movie execs would care a fig about what was happening in academia. To that end, he sought to create a formal exchange
program with Disney, wherein the studio would send one of its
animators to Utah to learn about new technologies in computer
rendering, and the university would send a student to Disney Animation to learn more about how to tell stories.
In the spring of 1973, he sent me to Burbank to try to sell this
idea to the Disney executives. It was a thrill for me to drive through
the red brick gates and onto the Disney lot on my way to the original Animation Building, built in 1940 with a “Double H” floor plan
A N I M AT E D
|
17
personally supervised by Walt himself to ensure that as many
rooms as possible had windows to let in natural light. While I’d
studied this place—or what I could glimpse of it on our 12-inch
RCA—walking into it was a little like stepping into the Parthenon
for the first time. There, I met Frank Thomas and Ollie Johnston,
two of Walt’s “Nine Old Men,” the group of legendary animators
who had created so many of the characters in the Disney movies I
loved, from Pinocchio to Peter Pan. At one point I was taken into
the archives where all the original paper drawings from all the animated films were kept, with rack after rack after rack of the images
that had fueled my imagination. I’d entered the Promised Land.
One thing was immediately clear. The people I met at Disney—
one of whom, I swear, was named Donald Duckwall—had zero
interest in Sutherland’s exchange program. The technically adventuresome Walt Disney was long gone. My enthusiastic descriptions
were met with blank stares. To them, computers and animation
simply didn’t mix. How did they know this? Because the one time
they had turned to computers for help—to render images of millions of bubbles in their 1971 live-action movie Bedknobs and
Broomsticks—the computers had apparently let them down. The
state of the technology at the time was so poor, particularly for
curved images, that bubbles were beyond the computers’ reach. Unfortunately, this didn’t help my cause. “Well,” more than one Disney executive told me that day, “until computer animation can do
bubbles, then it will not have arrived.”
Instead, they tried to tempt me into taking a job with what is
now called Disney Imagineering, the division that designs the
theme parks. It may sound odd, given how large Walt Disney had
always loomed in my life, but I turned the offer down without hesitation. The theme park job felt like a diversion that would lead me
down a path I didn’t want to be on. I didn’t want to design rides for
a living. I wanted to animate with a computer.
18
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
Just as Walt Disney and the pioneers of hand-drawn animation
had done decades before, those of us who sought to make pictures
with computers were trying to create something new. When one of
my colleagues at the U of U invented something, the rest of us
would immediately piggyback on it, pushing that new idea forward. There were setbacks, too, of course. But the overriding feeling was one of progress, of moving steadily toward a distant goal.
Long before I’d heard about Disney’s bubble problem, what
kept me and many of my fellow graduate students up at night was
the need to continue to hone our methods for creating smoothly
curved surfaces with the computer—as well as to figure out how to
add richness and complexity to the images we were creating. My
dissertation, “A Subdivision Algorithm for Computer Display of
Curved Surfaces,” offered a solution to that problem.
Much of what I spent every waking moment thinking about
then was extremely technical and difficult to explain, but I’ll give it
a try. The idea behind what I called “subdivision surfaces” was that
instead of setting out to depict the whole surface of a shiny, red
bottle, for example, we could divide that surface into many smaller
pieces. It was easier to figure out how to color and display each tiny
piece—which we could then put together to create our shiny, red
bottle. (As I’ve noted, computer memory capacity was quite small
in those days, so we put a lot of energy into developing tricks to
overcome that limitation. This was one of those tricks.) But what if
you wanted that shiny, red bottle to be zebra-striped? In my dissertation, I figured out a way that I could take a zebra-print or woodgrain pattern, say, and wrap it around any object.
“Texture mapping,” as I called it, was like having stretchable
wrapping paper that you could apply to a curved surface so that it
fit snugly. The first texture map I made involved projecting an image
of Mickey Mouse onto an undulating surface.
I also used Winnie the Pooh and Tigger to illustrate my points.
I may not have been ready to work at Disney, but their characters
were still the touchstones I referenced.
A N I M AT E D
|
19
At the U of U, we were inventing a new language. One of us
would contribute a verb, another a noun, then a third person would
figure out ways to string the elements together to actually say something. My invention of something called the “Z-buffer” was a good
example of this, in that it built on others’ work. The Z-buffer was
designed to address the problem of what happens when one
computer-animated object is hidden, or partially hidden, behind
another one. Even though the data that describes every aspect of
the hidden object is in the computer’s memory (meaning that you
could see it, if need be), the desired spatial relationships mean that
it should not be fully seen. The challenge was to figure out a way to
tell the computer to meet that goal. For example, if a sphere were
in front of a cube, partially blocking it, the sphere’s surface should
be visible on the screen, as should the parts of the cube that are not
blocked by the sphere. The Z-buffer accomplished that by assigning a depth to every object in three-dimensional space, then telling
the computer to match each of the screen’s pixels to whatever object was the closest. Computer memory was so limited—as I’ve
said—that this wasn’t a practical solution, but I had found a new
way of solving the problem. Although it sounds simple, it is anything but. Today, there is a Z-buffer in every game and PC chip
manufactured on earth.
After receiving my Ph.D. in 1974, I left Utah with a nice little
list of innovations under my belt, but I was keenly aware that I’d
only done all this in the service of a larger mutual goal. Like my
classmates, the work I’d championed had taken hold largely because of the protective, eclectic, intensely challenging environment
I’d been in. The leaders of my department understood that to create a fertile laboratory, they had to assemble different kinds of
thinkers and then encourage their autonomy. They had to offer
feedback when needed but also had to be willing to stand back and
give us room. I felt instinctively that this kind of environment was
rare and worth reaching for. I knew that the most valuable thing I
was taking away from the U of U was the model my teachers had
20
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
provided for how to lead and inspire other creative thinkers. The
question for me, then, was how to get myself into another environment like this—or how to build one of my own.
I walked away from Utah with a clearer sense of my goal, and I
was prepared to devote my life to it: making the first computeranimated film. But getting to that point would not be easy. There
were, I guessed, at least another ten years of development needed
to figure out how to model and animate characters and render them
in complex environments before we could even begin to conceive of
making a short—let alone a feature—film. I also didn’t yet know
that my self-assigned mission was about much more than technology. To pull it off, we’d have to be creative not only technically but
also in the ways that we worked together.
Back then, no other company or university shared my goal of
making a computer-generated film; in fact, each time I expressed
that goal in job interviews at universities, it seemed to cast a pall
over the room. “But we want you to teach computer science,” my
interviewers would say. What I was proposing to do looked, to most
academics, like a pipe dream, an expensive fantasy.
Then, in November 1974, I received a mysterious call from a
woman who said she worked at something called the New York
Institute of Technology. She said she was the secretary to the institute’s president, and she was calling to book my airplane ticket. I
didn’t know what she was talking about, and I told her so. What
was the name of the institute again? I asked. Why did she want me
to fly to New York? There was an awkward silence. “I’m sorry,” she
said. “Someone else was supposed to call you before I did.”
And with that, she hung up. The next phone call I received
would change my life.
CHAPTER 2
PIXAR IS BORN
What does it mean to manage well?
As a young man, I certainly had no idea, but I was about to
begin figuring it out by taking a series of jobs—working for three
iconoclastic men with very different styles—that would provide me
with a crash course in leadership. In the next decade, I would learn
much about what managers should and shouldn’t do, about vision
and delusion, about confidence and arrogance, about what encourages creativity and what snuffs it out. As I gained experience, I was
asking questions that intrigued me even as they confused me. Even
now, forty years later, I’ve never stopped questioning.
I want to start with my first boss, Alex Schure—the man whose
secretary called me out of the blue that day in 1974 to book me an
airplane ticket and then, realizing her mistake, slammed down the
receiver. When the phone rang again, a few minutes later, an unfamiliar voice—this time, a man who said he worked for Alex—filled
me in: Alex was starting a research lab on Long Island’s North
Shore whose mission was to bring computers into the animation
22
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
process. Money was not a problem, he assured me—Alex was a
multimillionaire. What they needed was someone to run the place.
Was I interested in talking?
Within weeks I was moving into my new office at the New York
Institute of Technology.
Alex, a former college chancellor, had zero expertise in the field
of computer science. At the time, that wasn’t unusual, but Alex
himself certainly was. He naïvely thought that computers would
soon replace people, and leading that charge was what excited him.
(We knew this was a misconception, if a common one at that point,
but we were grateful for his eagerness to fund our work.) He had a
bizarre way of speaking that mixed bluster, non sequiturs, and even
snippets of rhyming verse into a sort of Mad Hatter–ish patois—or
“word salad,” as one of my colleagues called it. (“Our vision will
speed up time,” he would say, “eventually deleting it.”) Those of us
who worked with him often had trouble understanding what he
meant. Alex had a secret ambition—well, not so secret. He said
almost every day that he didn’t want to be the next Walt Disney,
which only made us all think that he did. When I arrived, he was in
the process of directing a hand-drawn animated movie called
Tubby the Tuba. Really, the thing never had a chance—no one at
NYIT had the training or the story sensibility to make a film, and
when it was finally released, it vanished without a trace.
Deluded though he may have been about his own skills, Alex
was a visionary. He was incredibly prescient about the role computers would someday play in animation, and he was willing to spend
a lot of his own money to push that vision forward. His unwavering
commitment to what many labeled a pipe dream—the melding of
technology and this hand-drawn art form—enabled much groundbreaking work to be done.
Once Alex brought me in, he left it to me to assemble a team. I
have to give that to him: He had total confidence in the people he
hired. This was something I admired and, later, sought to do myself. One of the first people I interviewed was Alvy Ray Smith, a
PIXAR IS BORN
|
23
charismatic Texan with a Ph.D. in computer science and a sparkling resume that included teaching stints at New York University
and UC Berkeley and a gig at Xerox PARC, the distinguished R&D
lab in Palo Alto. I had conflicting feelings when I met Alvy because,
frankly, he seemed more qualified to lead the lab than I was. I can
still remember the uneasiness in my gut, that instinctual twinge
spurred by a potential threat: This, I thought, could be the guy who
takes my job one day. I hired him anyway.
Some might have seen hiring Alvy as a confident move. The
truth is, as a twenty-nine-year-old who’d been focused on research
for four years and had never had an assistant, let alone hired and
managed a staff, I was feeling anything but confident. I could see,
however, that NYIT was a place where I could explore what I’d set
out to do as a graduate student. To ensure that it succeeded, I
needed to attract the sharpest minds; to attract the sharpest minds,
I needed to put my own insecurities away. The lesson of ARPA had
lodged in my brain: When faced with a challenge, get smarter.
So we did. Alvy would become one of my closest friends and
most trusted collaborators. And ever since, I’ve made a policy of
trying to hire people who are smarter than I am. The obvious payoffs of exceptional people are that they innovate, excel, and generally make your company—and, by extension, you—look good. But
there is another, less obvious, payoff that only occurred to me in
retrospect. The act of hiring Alvy changed me as a manager: By
ignoring my fear, I learned that the fear was groundless. Over the
years, I have met people who took what seemed the safer path and
were the lesser for it. By hiring Alvy, I had taken a risk, and that risk
yielded the highest reward—a brilliant, committed teammate. I
had wondered in graduate school how I could ever replicate the
singular environment of the U of U. Now, suddenly, I saw the way.
Always take a chance on better, even if it seems threatening.
At NYIT, we focused on a single goal: pushing the boundaries
of what computers could do in animation and graphics. And as
word of our mission spread, we began to attract the top people in
24
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
the field. The bigger my staff became, the more urgent it was that
I figure out how to manage them. I created a flat organizational
structure, much like I’d experienced in academia, largely because I
naïvely thought that if I put together a hierarchical structure—
assigning a bunch of managers to report to me—I would have to
spend too much time managing and not enough time on my own
work. This structure—in which I entrusted everybody to drive their
own projects forward, at their own pace—had its limits, but the
fact is, giving a ton of freedom to highly self-motivated people enabled us to make some significant technological leaps in a short
time. Together, we did groundbreaking work, much of which was
aimed at figuring out how to integrate the computer with handdrawn animation.
In 1977, for example, I wrote a 2D animation program
called Tween, which performed what’s known as “automatic inbetweening”—filling in frames of motion between key shots, an
otherwise expensive and labor-intensive process. Another technical
challenge that occupied us was the need for something called “motion blur.” With animation in general and computer animation in
particular, the images created are in perfect focus. That may sound
like a good thing, but in fact, human beings react negatively to it.
When moving objects are in perfect focus, theatergoers experience
an unpleasant, strobe-like sensation, which they describe as “jerky.”
When watching live-action movies, we don’t perceive this problem
because traditional film cameras capture a slight blur in the direction an object is moving. The blur keeps our brains from noticing
the sharp edges, and our brains regard this blur as natural. Without
motion blur, our brains think something is wrong. So the question
for us was how to simulate the blur for animation. If the human eye
couldn’t accept computer animation, the field would have no future.
Among the handful of companies that were trying to solve
these problems, most embraced a culture of strictly enforced, even
CIA-like secrecy. We were in a race, after all, to be the first to make
PIXAR IS BORN
|
25
a computer-animated feature film, so many who were pursuing this
technology held their discoveries close to their vests. After talking
about it, however, Alvy and I decided to do the opposite—to share
our work with the outside world. My view was that we were all so
far from achieving our goal that to hoard ideas only impeded our
ability to get to the finish line. Instead, NYIT engaged with the
computer graphics community, publishing everything we discovered, participating in committees to review papers written by all
manner of researchers, and taking active roles at all the major academic conferences. The benefit of this transparency was not immediately felt (and, notably, when we decided upon it, we weren’t
even counting on a payoff; it just seemed like the right thing to do).
But the relationships and connections we formed, over time, proved
far more valuable than we could have imagined, fueling our technical innovation and our understanding of creativity in general.
For all the good work we were doing, however, I found myself
in a quandary at NYIT. Thanks to Alex, we were fortunate to have
the funds to buy the equipment and hire the people necessary to
innovate in the world of computer animation, but we didn’t have
anyone who knew anything about filmmaking. As we developed
the ability to tell a story with a computer, we still didn’t have storytellers among us, and we were the poorer for it. So aware were
Alvy and I of this limitation that we began making quiet overtures
to Disney and other studios, trying to gauge their interest in investing in our tools. If we found an interested suitor, Alvy and I were
prepared to leave NYIT and move our team to Los Angeles to
partner with proven filmmakers and storytellers. But it was not to
be. One by one, they demurred. It’s hard to imagine now, but in
1976, the idea of incorporating high technology into Hollywood
filmmaking wasn’t just a low priority; it wasn’t even on the radar.
But one man was about to change that, with a movie called Star
Wars.
26
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
On May 25, 1977, Star Wars opened in theaters across America.
The film’s mastery of visual effects—and its record-shattering popularity at the box office—would change the industry forever. And
thirty-two-year-old writer-director George Lucas was only getting
started. His company, Lucasfilm, and its ascendant Industrial Light
& Magic studio had already taken the lead developing new tools in
visual effects and sound design. Now, while no one else in the movie
industry evinced even the slightest desire to invest in such things,
George resolved in July 1979 to launch a computer division. Thanks
to Luke Skywalker, he had the resources to do it right.
To run this division, he wanted someone who not only knew
computers; he wanted someone who loved film and believed that
the two could not only coexist but enhance one another. Eventually, that led George to me. One of his key people, Richard Edlund,
who was a pioneer of special effects, came to see me one afternoon
in my office at NYIT wearing a belt with an enormous buckle that
read, in huge letters, “Star Wars.” This was worrisome, given that I
was trying to keep his visit a secret from Alex Schure. Somehow,
though, Alex didn’t catch on. George’s emissary was apparently
pleased with what I showed him, because a few weeks after he left,
I was on my way to Lucasfilm in California for a formal interview.
My first meeting there was with a man named Bob Gindy, who
ran George’s personal construction projects—not exactly the qualifications you’d expect for a guy spearheading the search for a new
computer executive. The first thing he asked me was, “Who else
should Lucasfilm be considering for this job?” Meaning, the job I
was there to interview for. Without hesitation, I rattled off the
names of several people who were doing impressive work in a variety of technical areas. My willingness to do this reflected my worldview, forged in academia, that any hard problem should have many
good minds simultaneously trying to solve it. Not to acknowledge
that seemed silly. Only later would I learn that the guys at Lucasfilm had already interviewed all the people I listed and had asked
them, in turn, to make similar recommendations—and not one of
PIXAR IS BORN
|
27
them had suggested any other names! To be sure, working for
George Lucas was a plum job that you’d have to be crazy not to
want. But to go mute, as my rivals did, when asked to evaluate the
field signaled not just intense competitiveness but also lack of confidence. Soon I’d landed an interview with George himself.
On my way to meet him, I remember feeling nervous in a way I
rarely had before. Even before Star Wars, George had proved himself as a successful writer-director-producer with American Graffiti. I was a computer guy with an expensive dream. Still, when I
arrived at the shooting stage in Los Angeles where he was working,
he and I seemed pretty similar: Skinny and bearded, in our early
thirties, we both wore glasses, worked with a blinders-on intensity,
and had a tendency to talk only when we had something to say. But
what struck me immediately was George’s relentless practicality.
He wasn’t some hobbyist trying to bring technology into filmmaking for the heck of it. His interest in computers began and ended
with their potential to add value to the filmmaking process—be it
through digital optical printing, digital audio, digital non-linear
editing, or computer graphics. I was certain that they could, and I
told him so.
In the intervening years, George has said that he hired me because of my honesty, my “clarity of vision,” and my steadfast belief in what computers could do. Not long after we met, he offered
me the job.
By the time I moved into the two-story building in San Anselmo
that would serve as the temporary headquarters of Lucasfilm’s new
computer division, I had given myself an assignment: to rethink
how I managed people. What George wanted to create was a far
more ambitious enterprise than the one I oversaw at NYIT, with a
higher profile, a bigger budget, and, given his ambitions in Hollywood, the promise of much greater impact. I wanted to make sure
that I was enabling my team to make the most of that. At NYIT, I’d
created a flat structure much like I’d seen at the U of U, giving my
colleagues a lot of running room and little oversight, and I’d been
28
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
relatively pleased with the results. But now I had to admit that our
team there behaved a lot like a collection of grad students—
independent thinkers with individual projects—rather than a team
with a common goal. A research lab is not a university, and the
structure didn’t scale well. At Lucasfilm, then, I decided to hire
managers to run the graphics, video, and audio groups; they would
then report to me. I knew I had to put some sort of hierarchy in
place, but I also worried that hierarchy would lead to problems. So
I edged in slowly, feeling suspicious of it at first, yet knowing that
some part of it was necessary.
The Bay Area in 1979 could not have provided a more fertile
environment for our work. In Silicon Valley, the number of computer companies was growing so fast that no one’s Rolodex (yes,
we had Rolodexes back then) was ever up to date. Also growing
exponentially were the number of tasks that computers were being
assigned to tackle. Not long after I got to California, Microsoft’s
Bill Gates agreed to create an operating system for the new IBM
personal computer—which would, of course, go on to transform
the way Americans worked. One year later, Atari released the first
in-home game console, meaning that its popular arcade games like
Space Invaders and Pac-Man could be played in living rooms across
America, opening up a market that now accounts for more than
$65 billion in global sales.
To get a sense of how quickly things were changing, consider
that when I was a graduate student, in 1970, we’d used huge computers made by IBM and seven other mainframe companies (a
group that was nicknamed “IBM and the Seven Dwarves”). Picture
a room filled with racks and racks of equipment measuring six feet
tall, two feet wide, and 30 inches deep. Five years later, when I
arrived at NYIT, the minicomputer—which was about the size of
an armoire—was on the rise, with Digital Equipment in Massachusetts being the most significant player. By the time I got to
Lucasfilm in 1979, the momentum was swinging to workstation
PIXAR IS BORN
|
29
computers such as those made by Silicon Valley upstarts Sun Microsystems and Silicon Graphics, as well as IBM, but by that time,
everyone could see that workstations were only another stop on the
way to PCs and, eventually, personal desktop computers. The swiftness of this evolution created seemingly endless opportunities for
those who were willing and able to innovate. The allure of getting
rich was a magnet for bright, ambitious people, and the resulting
competition was intense—as were the risks. The old business models were undergoing continual disruptive change.
Lucasfilm was based in Marin County, one hour north of Silicon Valley by car and one hour from Hollywood by plane. This
was no accident. George saw himself, first and foremost, as a filmmaker, so Silicon Valley wasn’t for him. But he also had no desire
to be too close to Los Angeles, because he thought there was something a bit unseemly and inbred about it. Thus, he created his own
island, a community that embraced films and computers but
pledged allegiance to neither of the prevailing cultures that defined
those businesses. The resulting environment felt as protected as an
academic institution—an idea that would stay with me and help
shape what I would later try to build at Pixar. Experimentation was
highly valued, but the urgency of a for-profit enterprise was definitely in the air. In other words, we felt like we were solving problems for a reason.
I put Alvy in charge of our graphics group, which was dedicated
initially to creating a digital approach to blue-screen matting—the
process by which one image (say, a man on a surfboard) can be
dropped into a separate image (say, a 100-foot wave). Before digital,
this effect was accomplished on film with the use of sophisticated
optical devices, and the special effects wizards at the time had no
interest in leaving that painstaking method behind. Our job was to
convince them otherwise. Alvy’s team set out to design a highly
specialized standalone computer that had the resolution and processing power to scan film, combine special-effects images with
30
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
live-action footage, and then record the final result back onto film.
It took us roughly four years, but our engineers built just such a
device, which we named the Pixar Image Computer.
Why “Pixar”? The name emerged from a back-and-forth between Alvy and another of our colleagues, Loren Carpenter. Alvy,
who spent much of his childhood in Texas and New Mexico, had a
fondness for the Spanish language, and he was intrigued by how
certain nouns in English looked like Spanish verbs—words like
“laser,” for example. So Alvy lobbied for “Pixer,” which he imagined to be a (fake) Spanish verb meaning “to make pictures.” Loren
countered with “Radar,” which he thought sounded more hightech. That’s when it hit them: Pixer + radar = Pixar! It stuck.
Within Lucasfilm, the special effects experts were relatively indifferent to our computer graphics technology. Their film editor
colleagues, however, were outright opposed. This was driven home
when, at George’s request, we developed a video-editing system
that would enable editors to do their work on the computer. George
envisioned a program that would allow shots to be banked and
filed easily and cuts to be made far more quickly than they were on
film. Ralph Guggenheim, a computer programmer (with a degree
in filmmaking from Carnegie Mellon as well) I’d lured away from
NYIT, took the lead on this project, which was so ahead of its time
that the hardware needed to support it didn’t even exist yet. (In
order to approximate it, Ralph had to mock up an elaborate makeshift system using laser disks). But as challenging as that problem
proved to be, it paled in comparison to the bigger, and eternal, impediment to our progress: the human resistance to change.
While George wanted this new video-editing system in place,
the film editors at Lucasfilm did not. They were perfectly happy
with the system they had already mastered, which involved actually
cutting film into snippets with razor blades and then pasting them
back together. They couldn’t have been less interested in making
changes that would slow them down in the short term. They took
comfort in their familiar ways, and change meant being uncom-
PIXAR IS BORN
|
31
fortable. So when it came time to test our work, the editors refused
to participate. Our certainty that video editing would revolutionize
the process didn’t matter, and neither did George’s backing. Because the people our new system was intended to serve were resistant to it, progress screeched to a halt.
What to do?
If left up to the editors, no new tool would ever be designed and
no improvements would be possible. They saw no advantage to
change and couldn’t imagine how using a computer would make
their work easier or better. But if we designed the new system in a
vacuum, moving ahead without the editors’ input, we would end
up with a tool that didn’t address their needs. Being confident
about the value of our innovation was not enough. We needed buyin from the community we were trying to serve. Without it, we were
forced to abandon our plans.
Clearly, it wasn’t enough for managers to have good ideas—
they had to be able to engender support for those ideas among the
people who’d be charged with employing them. I took that lesson
to heart.
During the Lucasfilm years, I definitely had my periods of feeling overwhelmed as a manager, periods when I wondered about my
own abilities and asked myself if I should try to adopt a more
forceful, alpha male management style. I’d put my version of hierarchy in place by delegating to other managers, but I was also part
of a chain of command in the greater Lucasfilm empire. I remember going home at night, exhausted, feeling like I was balancing on
the backs of a herd of horses—only some of the horses were thoroughbreds, some were completely wild, and some were ponies who
were struggling to keep up. I found it hard enough to hold on, let
alone steer.
Simply put, managing was hard. No one took me aside to give
me tips. The books I read that promised insight on the topic were
mostly devoid of content. So I looked to George to see how he did
it. I saw that his way seemed to reflect some of the philosophy he
32
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
had put into Yoda. Just as Yoda said things like, “Do, or do not.
There is no try,” George had a fondness for folksy analogies that
sought to describe, neatly, the mess of life. He would compare the
often arduous process of developing his 4,700-acre Skywalker
Ranch compound (a minicity of residences and production facilities) to a ship going down river . . . that had been cut in half . . .
and whose captain had been thrown overboard. “We’re still going
to get there,” he would say. “Grab the paddles and let’s keep going!”
Another of his favorite analogies was that building a company
was like being on a wagon train headed west. On the long journey
to the land of plenty, the pioneers would be full of purpose and
united by the goal of reaching their destination. Once they arrived,
he’d say, people would come and go, and that was as it should be.
But the process of moving toward something—of having not yet
arrived—was what he idealized.
Whether evoking wagons or ships, George thought in terms of
a long view; he believed in the future and his ability to shape it. The
story has been told and retold about how, as a young filmmaker, in
the wake of American Graffiti’s success, he was advised to demand
a higher salary on his next movie, Star Wars. That would be the
expected move in Hollywood: Bump up your quote. Not for George,
though. He skipped the raise altogether and asked instead to retain
ownership of licensing and merchandising rights to Star Wars. The
studio that was distributing the film, 20th Century Fox, readily
agreed to his request, thinking it was not giving up much. George
would prove them wrong, setting the stage for major changes in the
industry he loved. He bet on himself—and won.
Lucasfilm, in those post–Star Wars days, was a magnet for big
names. Famous directors, from Steven Spielberg to Martin Scorsese, were always stopping by to see what we were working on and
what new effects or innovations they might use in their films. But
more than the drop-ins from A-listers, the visit that would stick
PIXAR IS BORN
|
33
with me most was the group of Disney animators who came for a
tour just after Valentine’s Day, 1983. As I showed them around, I
noted that one of them—a kid in baggy jeans named John—seemed
particularly excited about what we were up to. In fact, the first
thing I noticed was his curiosity. When I showed everyone a
computer-animated image that we were so proud of we’d given it a
name—“The Road to Point Reyes”—he just stood there, transfixed. I told him we’d developed the image of a gently curving road
overlooking the Pacific Ocean using a software program we’d developed called Reyes (for Renders Everything You Ever Saw), and
the pun was intended: Point Reyes, California, is a seaside village
on Route 1, not far from Lucasfilm. Reyes represented the cutting
edge of computer graphics at the time. And it bowled this John guy
over.
Soon, I learned why. He had an idea, he told me, for a film
called The Brave Little Toaster about a toaster, a blanket, a lamp, a
radio, and a vacuum cleaner who journey to the city to find their
master after being abandoned in their cabin in the woods. He told
me that his film, which he was about to pitch to his bosses at Disney Animation, would be the first to place hand-drawn characters
inside computer-generated backgrounds, much like the one I’d just
shown him. He wanted to know if we could work together to make
this happen.
That animator was John Lasseter. Unbeknownst to me, soon
after our meeting at Lucasfilm, he would lose his job at Disney. Apparently, his supervisors felt that The Brave Little Toaster was—
like him—a little too avant-garde. They listened to his pitch and,
immediately afterward, fired him. A few months later, I ran into
John again on the Queen Mary, of all places. The historic Long
Beach hotel, which also happens to be a docked ocean liner, was the
site of the annual Pratt Institute Symposium on Computer Graphics. Not knowing of his newly unemployed status, I asked if there
was any way he could come up to Lucasfilm and help us make our
first short film. He said yes without hesitation. I remember think-
34
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
ing it was almost as if Professor Sutherland’s exchange program
idea was finally getting its moment. To have a Disney animator on
our team, even temporarily, would be a huge leap forward. For the
first time, a true storyteller would be joining our ranks.
John was a born dreamer. As a boy, he lived mostly in his head
and in the tree houses and tunnels and spaceships he drew in his
sketchbook. His dad was the parts manager at the local Chevrolet
dealership in Whittier, California—instilling in John a lifelong obsession with cars—and his mom was a high school art teacher. Like
me, John remembers discovering that there were people who made
animation for a living and thinking he’d found his place in the
world. For him, as for me, that realization was Disney-related; it
came when he stumbled upon a well-worn copy of The Art of Animation, Bob Thomas’s history of the Disney Studios, in his high
school library. By the time I met John, he was as connected to Walt
Disney as any twenty-six-year-old on earth. He had graduated
from CalArts, the legendary art school founded by Walt, where
he’d learned from some of the greatest artists of Disney’s Golden
Age; he’d worked as a river guide on the Jungle Cruise at Disneyland; and he’d won a Student Academy Award in 1979 for his short
film The Lady and the Lamp—an homage to Disney’s Lady and the
Tramp—whose main character, a white desk lamp, would later
evolve into our Pixar logo.
What John hadn’t realized when he joined Disney Animation,
however, was that the studio was going through a rough, fallow
period. The animation there had plateaued much earlier—no significant technical advances had been made since 1961’s 101 Dalmatians, and many of its young, talented animators had left the studio,
reacting in part to an increasingly hierarchical culture that didn’t
value their ideas. When John arrived in 1979, Frank Thomas, Ollie
Johnston, and the rest of the Nine Old Men were getting up in
years—the youngest was 65—and had stepped away from the dayto-day business of moviemaking, leaving the studio in the hands of
a group of lesser artists who had been waiting in the wings for de-
PIXAR IS BORN
|
35
cades. These men felt that it was their turn to be in charge but were
so insecure about their standing within the company that they
clung to their newfound status by stifling—not encouraging—
younger talents. Not only were they not interested in the ideas of
their fledgling animators, they exercised a sort of punitive power.
They were seemingly determined that those beneath them not rise
in the ranks any faster than they already had. John was almost immediately unhappy in this noncollaborative environment, though it
was still a shock when he got fired. No wonder he was so eager to
join us at Lucasfilm.
The project we enlisted John’s help on was originally going to
be called My Breakfast with André, an homage of sorts to a 1981
movie we all loved called My Dinner with André. The idea was
simple: an android named André was supposed to wake up, yawn,
and stretch as the sun rose, revealing a lush, computer-rendered
world. Alvy had drawn the first storyboards and was taking the
lead on the project, which was a way for us to test some of the new
animation technology we’d developed, and he was thrilled that
John was coming aboard to help. John was an effusive presence
with a knack for bringing out the best in others. His energy would
enliven the film.
“Do you mind if I say a couple of things?” John asked Alvy
after being shown the early storyboards.
“Of course not,” Alvy responded. “That’s why you’re here.”
As Alvy tells it, John then “proceeded to save the piece. I’d foolishly thought I’d be the animator, but frankly, I didn’t have the
magic. I could make things move very nicely, but not think, emote
and have consciousness. That’s John.” John made some suggestions about the look of the main character, a simple, human-like
figure with a sphere for a head and another sphere for a nose. But
his most brilliant stroke was adding a second character, a bumblebee named Wally for André to interact with. (And who, by the way,
was named for Wallace Shawn, who’d starred in the movie our
short was inspired by.) The film was renamed The Adventures of
36
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
André and Wally B., and it opened with André on his back, asleep
in the forest, waking to find Wally B. hovering just above his face.
Frightened, he flees as Wally B. gives chase, buzzing right behind
him. That is the entire plot, if you can call it that—frankly, we
weren’t as focused on story as we were on showing what was possible to render with a computer. John’s genius was in creating an
emotional tension, even in this briefest of formats.
The movie was designed to run two minutes, but we were still
racing against time to complete it. It wasn’t just that the animation
process was labor-intensive, though it surely was; it was that we
were inventing the animation process as we went along. Adding to
the stress was the fact that we’d left ourselves so little time to get it
all done. We had a self-imposed deadline of July 1984—just eight
months after John came aboard—because that was when the annual SIGGRAPH Conference would be held in Minneapolis. This
week-long computer graphics summit was a great place to find out
what everyone in the field was up to, the one time every year that
academics, educators, artists, hardware salesmen, graduate students, and programmers all came together under one roof. According to tradition, the Tuesday of conference week was reserved for
“movie night,” with a showing of the most exciting visual work
produced in the field that year. Up until then, that had meant mostly
15-second snippets of flying network news logos (think spinning
globes and rippling American flags) and scientific visualization (everything from the NASA’s Voyager 2 fly-by of Saturn to illustrations of Contac time-release cold capsules). Wally B. would be the
first computerized character animation ever shown at SIGGRAPH.
As the deadline approached, however, we realized that we
weren’t going to make it. We’d worked so hard to create images
that were better and clearer and, to make things really hard, we’d
set the movie in a forest (whose foliage tested the limits of our animation chops at the time). But we hadn’t accounted for how much
computer power those images would require to render and how
PIXAR IS BORN
|
37
long that process would take. We could complete a rough version
of the film in time, but portions of it would be unfinished, appearing as wire frame images—mock-ups, made from grid polygons, of
the finished characters—instead of fully colored images. The night
of our premiere, we watched, mortified, as these segments appeared on the screen, but something surprising happened. Despite
our worries, the majority of the people I talked to after the screening said that they hadn’t even noticed that the movie had switched
from full color to black and white wireframes! They were so caught
up in the emotion of the story that they hadn’t noticed its flaws.
This was my first encounter with a phenomenon I would notice
again and again, throughout my career: For all the care you put
into artistry, visual polish frequently doesn’t matter if you are getting the story right.
In 1983, George and his wife Marcia split up, and the settlement
would significantly affect the cash position of Lucasfilm. George
hadn’t lost an ounce of his ambition, but the new financial realities
meant that he had to streamline his business. At the same time, I
was coming to realize that while we in the computer division
wanted more than anything to make an animated feature film,
George didn’t share our dream. He had always been most interested in what computers could do to enhance live-action films. For
a while our goals, though disparate, had overlapped and pushed
each other forward. But now, under pressure to consolidate his investments, George decided to sell us. The computer division’s primary asset was the business we’d created around the Pixar Image
Computer. Although we originally designed it to handle frames of
film, it had proven to have multiple applications, including everything from medical imaging to design prototyping to image processing for the many three-letter agencies around Washington,
D.C.
38
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
The next year would be one of the most stressful of my life.
A management team brought in by George to restructure Lucasfilm seemed concerned mostly with cash flow, and as time went
on, they became openly skeptical that our division would ever attract a buyer. This team was headed by two men with the same first
name, whom Alvy and I nicknamed “the Dweebs” because they
didn’t understand a thing about the business we were in. Those two
guys threw around management consulting terms (they loved to
tout their “corporate intuition” and constantly urged us to make
“strategic alliances”), but they didn’t seem at all insightful about
how to make us attractive to buyers or about which buyers to pursue. At one point, they called us into an office, sat us down, and
said that to cut costs, we should lay off all our employees until after
our division was sold—at which point we could discuss rehiring
them. In addition to the emotional toll we knew this would take,
what bugged us about this suggestion was that our real selling
point—the thing that had attracted potential suitors thus far—was
the talent we’d gathered. Without that, we had nothing.
So, when our two like-minded overlords demanded a list of
names of people to lay off, Alvy and I gave them two: his and mine.
That temporarily halted that plan, but as we headed into 1985, I
was keenly aware that if we weren’t sold off, and fast, we could be
shut down at any moment.
Lucasfilm wanted to walk away from the deal with $15 million
in cash, but there was a hitch: Our computer division came with a
business plan that required an additional infusion of $15 million to
take us from prototype to product and ensure that we’d be able to
stand on our own. This structure did not sit well with the venture
capitalists they hoped would buy us, who didn’t typically make
such significant cash commitments when they acquired companies.
We were shopped to twenty prospective buyers, none of whom bit.
When that list was exhausted, a string of manufacturing companies stopped in to kick our tires. Again, no luck.
PIXAR IS BORN
|
39
At long last, our group reached an agreement with General
Motors and Philips, the Dutch electronics and engineering conglomerate. Philips was interested because, with our Pixar Image
Computer, we had developed the foundational technology for rendering volumes of data, such as you get from CT scans or MRIs.
General Motors was intrigued because we were leading the way in
the modeling of objects, which they felt could be used in car design.
We were within one week of signing the deal when it fell apart.
At this point, I remember feeling a mixture of despair and relief. We’d known from the outset that entering into a relationship
with GM and Philips would likely put an end to our dream of making the first animated feature film, but that was a risk no matter
who we joined up with: Each investor was going to have its own
agenda, and that was the price of our survival. To this day, I am
thankful that the deal went south. Because it paved the way for
Steve Jobs.
I first met Steve in February of 1985, when he was the director
of Apple Computer, Inc. Our meeting had been arranged by Apple’s chief scientist, Alan Kay, who knew that Alvy and I were looking for investors to take our graphics division off George’s hands.
Alan had been at the U of U with me and at Xerox PARC with Alvy,
and he told Steve that he should visit us if he wanted to see the cutting edge in computer graphics. We met in a conference room with
a white board and a large table surrounded by chairs—not that
Steve stayed seated for very long. Within minutes, he was standing
at the white board, drawing us a chart of Apple’s revenues.
I remember his assertiveness. There was no small talk. Instead,
there were questions. Lots of questions. What do you want? Steve
asked. Where are you heading? What are your long-term goals? He
used the phrase “insanely great products” to explain what he believed in. Clearly, he was the sort of person who didn’t let presentations happen to him, and it wasn’t long before he was talking about
making a deal.
40
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
To be honest, I was uneasy about Steve. He had a forceful personality, whereas I do not, and I felt threatened by him. For all of
my talk about the importance of surrounding myself with people
smarter than myself, his intensity was at such a different level, I
didn’t know how to interpret it. It put me in the mind of an ad
campaign that the Maxell cassette tape company released around
this time, featuring what would become an iconic image: a guy sitting low in a leather-and-chrome Le Corbusier chair, his long hair
being literally blown back by the sound from the stereophonic
speaker in front of him. That’s what it was like to be with Steve. He
was the speaker. Everyone else was the guy.
For nearly two months after that initial meeting, we heard
nothing. Total silence.
We were perplexed, given how intent Steve had been in our
meetings. We finally learned why when, in late May, we read in the
papers of Steve’s blowup with Apple CEO John Sculley. Sculley had
persuaded Apple’s board of directors to remove Steve from his duties as head of the company’s Macintosh division after rumors surfaced that Steve was trying to stage a boardroom coup.
When the dust settled, Steve sought us out again. He wanted a
new challenge and thought maybe we were it.
He came to Lucasfilm one afternoon for a tour of our hardware
lab. Again, he pushed and prodded and poked. What can the Pixar
Image Computer do that other machines on the market can’t? Who
do you envision using it? What’s your long-term plan? His aim
didn’t seem to be to absorb the intricacies of our technology as
much as to hone his own argument, to temper it by sparring with
us. Steve’s domineering nature could take one’s breath away. At one
point he turned to me and calmly explained that he wanted my job.
Once he took my place at the helm, he said, I would learn so much
from him that in just two years I would be able to run the enterprise
all by myself. I was, of course, already running the enterprise by
myself, but I marveled at his chutzpah. He not only planned to dis-
PIXAR IS BORN
|
41
place me in the day-to-day management of the company, he expected me to think it was a great idea!
Steve was hard-charging—relentless, even—but a conversation
with him took you places you didn’t expect. It forced you not just
to defend but also to engage. And that in itself, I came to believe,
had value.
The next day, several of us drove out to meet with Steve at his
place in Woodside, a lovely neighborhood near Menlo Park. The
house was almost empty but for a motorcycle, a grand piano, and
two personal chefs who had once worked at Chez Panisse. Sitting
on the grass looking out over his seven-acre lawn, he formally proposed that he buy the graphics group from Lucasfilm and showed
us a proposed organizational chart for the new company. As he
spoke, it became clear to us that his goal was not to build an animation studio; his goal was to build the next generation of home computers to compete with Apple.
This wasn’t merely a deviation from our vision, it was the total
abandonment of it, so we politely declined. We returned to the task
of trying to find a buyer. Time was running out.
Months passed. As we approached the one-year anniversary of our
unveiling of The Adventures of André and Wally B., our anxiety—
the kind that builds when survival is at stake and saviors are in
short supply—was showing on our faces. Still, we had fortune on
our side—or, at least, geography. The 1985 SIGGRAPH conference
was being held in San Francisco, right up the 101 freeway from Silicon Valley. We had a booth on the trade show floor where we showcased our Pixar Image Computer. Steve Jobs dropped by on the
first afternoon.
Immediately, I sensed a change. Since I’d last seen him, Steve
had founded a personal computer company, NeXT. I think that
gave him the ability to approach us with a different mindset. He
42
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
had less to prove. Now, he looked around our booth and proclaimed
our machine the most interesting thing in the room. “Let’s go for a
walk,” he said, and we set off on a stroll around the hall. “How are
things going?”
“Not great,” I confessed. We were still hoping to find an outside investor, but we were nearly out of options. It was then that
Steve raised the idea of resuming our talks. “Maybe we can work
something out,” he said.
As we talked, we came upon Bill Joy, one of the founders of Sun
Computer. Bill, like Steve, was an extraordinarily bright, competitive, articulate, and opinionated person. I don’t remember what
they talked about as we stood there, but I’ll never forget the way
they talked: standing nose to nose, their arms behind their backs,
swaying from side to side—in perfect sync—completely oblivious
to anything going on around them. This went on for quite a while,
until Steve had to break off to go meet someone.
After Steve left, Bill turned to me and said, “Boy, is he arrogant.”
When Steve came by our booth again later, he walked up to me
and said of Bill: “Boy, is he arrogant.”
I remember being struck by this clash-of-the-titans moment. I
was amused by the fact that each man could see ego in the other but
not in himself.
It took another few months, but on the third day of January,
1986, Steve said he was ready to make a deal and addressed, right
off, the issue that had concerned me most—his previous insistence
on controlling and running the company. He was willing to back
off on that, he said, and not only that, he was open to letting us
explore making a business out of the nexus of computers and
graphics. By the end of the meeting, Alvy and I felt comfortable
with his proposal—and his intentions. The only wild card was
what he was going to be like as a partner. We were well aware of his
reputation for being difficult. Only time would tell whether he
would live up to it.
PIXAR IS BORN
|
43
At one point in this period, I met with Steve and gently asked
him how things got resolved when people disagree with him. He
seemed unaware that what I was really asking him was how things
would get resolved if we worked together and I disagreed with him,
for he gave a more general answer.
He said, “When I don’t see eye to eye with somebody, I just take
the time to explain it better, so they understand the way it should
be.”
Later, when I relayed this to my colleagues at Lucasfilm, they
laughed. Nervously. I remember one of Steve’s attorneys telling us
that if we were acquired by his client, we had better be ready to
“get on the Steve Jobs roller coaster.” Given our dire straits, this
was a ride Alvy and I were ready to board.
The acquisition process was complicated by the fact that the
negotiators for Lucasfilm weren’t very good. The chief financial
officer, in particular, underestimated Steve, assuming he was just
another rich kid in over his head. This CFO told me that the way to
establish his authority in the room was to arrive last. His thinking,
which he articulated out loud to me, was that this would establish
him as the “most powerful player,” since he and only he could afford to keep everyone else waiting.
All that it ended up establishing, however, was that he’d never
met anyone like Steve Jobs.
The morning of the big negotiating session, all of us but the
CFO were on time—Steve and his attorney; me, Alvy, and our attorney; Lucasfilm’s attorneys; and an investment banker. At precisely 10 a.m., Steve looked around and, finding the CFO missing,
started the meeting without him! In one swift move, Steve had not
only foiled the CFO’s attempt to place himself atop the pecking
order, but he had grabbed control of the meeting. This would be
the kind of strategic, aggressive play that would define Steve’s stewardship of Pixar for years to come—once we joined forces, he became our protector, as fierce on our behalf as he was on his own. In
the end, Steve paid $5 million to spin Pixar off of Lucasfilm—and
44
|
C R E A T I V I T Y, I N C .
then, after the sale, he agreed to pay another $5 million to fund the
company, with 70 percent of the stock going to Steve and 30 percent to the employees.
The closing took place on a Monday morning in February
1986, and the moo…
Purchase answer to see full
attachment

User generated content is uploaded by users for the purposes of learning and should be used following Studypool’s honor code & terms of service.

Get 20% Discount on This Paper
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Try it now!

Get 20% Discount on This Paper

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Ace Writing Center has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.

Essays

Essay Writing Services

At Ace Writing Center, Nowadays, students normally have extremely busy schedules. You will note that some of them have to take on some evening or weekend jobs in order to get some income that can help them to sustain in college or in the university. This can deny them a chance to write all the essays given. Others usually get bombarded with a lot of work by their lecturers. This can still delay such students from working on all their essays. However, some of them usually try to work on all these essays but end up delivering their work late. This can prevent them from graduating since most lecturers are strict on deadlines. If you want to write a business essay, the wise way is to hire an outstanding essay writing service like us, so that you can get the best results. If you are keen, you will note that many companies usually overcharge their customers. Some of them are there only to make money. And in reality, they really don’t care to build a long term commitment with students. You should not choose such companies. You should take your time and choose a reliable company to work with. Ace Writing Center is the ultimate solution for you. We have been offering our writing service for more than 7 years. This is a clear indication that you will get quality essay writing service. We have a wide range of writers who can work on any business essay that you might have. We believe in doing extensive research so that we can provide quality work to all our clients. .

Admissions

Admission and Business Papers

Have you ever had to write an admission essay for college? The majority of students face the same issues when applying to a university or college and many in such situations decide they need professional help to cope with this matter. They get in a situation when the deadline keeps coming closer but lack motivation to start because they are just not sure if their writing skills are strong enough. We have a solution for you! Ace Writing Center is the best admission essay writing service with a large professional team and years of experience in providing high-quality papers to students of all levels and faculties. The mission of our team is to help students make their dreams of entering a good college come true and that’s what we offer!.

Editing

Editing and Proofreading

Sometimes all the words for your paper just flow out of your mind and into your fingers. You type quickly at your keyboard and there they are, your beautiful words right there on the screen. But you have no idea how to polish it up. You may be wishing there was a paper writing service that offered this type of writing service. Look no more! Here at Ace Writing Center, we offer you an editing and proofreading option that you can't find anywhere else..

Coursework

College Essay Writing

In case you are familiar Ace Writing Center, you know the way to distinguish a better company from a cheap one exactly. First of all, poor service website does not have a sufficient support. We think support team is an essential part of success; it has to answer all clients’ questions and be a connecting link between clients and their writers. On our web-service you will get answers about anything you need and your writer will receive all your instructions, assignments and requirements exactly and swiftly. A writing service that we run has got a flexible pricing system that will save you from senseless wastes and many bonus systems that let you sparing money for something important for you.