In Chapter 8, the case Miranda vs. Arizona is covered. Under the Case Topic: Does the Fifth Amendment apply to custodial interrogations, you will need to read the case, opinion, and dissent and answer the following questions:
Questions
-
According to SCOTUS, what do the words “custody” and “interrogation” mean?
-
Why is custodial interrogation “inherently coercive,” according to the majority?
-
Identify and explain the criteria for waiving the right against self-incrimination in custodial interrogation.
-
On what grounds do the dissenters disagree with the majority’s decision? What interests are in conflict, according to the Court?
-
How do the majority and the dissent explain the balance of interests established by the Constitution?
-
Which is more consistent with the relevant criminal procedures ideals regarding the law of police interrogation, the majority’s bright-line rule, requiring warnings, or the dissent’s due process test, weighing the totality of circumstances on a case-by-case basis? Defend your answer.
